Parallax

14 July, 1789

Paris takes the Bastille

The crowd came for gunpowder, not prisoners, and found only seven of those. By nightfall the governor’s head was on a pike and a half-empty fortress had become the symbol of everything the old order was.

Paris, France

On the morning of Tuesday 14 July 1789 a crowd forced its way into the Invalides, the military hospital on the left bank, and carried off some thirty thousand muskets. There was no powder to go with them. The powder, 250 barrels of it, had been moved a few days earlier to the Bastille, the fourteenth-century fortress whose eight towers stood over the working-class faubourg Saint-Antoine at the eastern edge of the city.

Its governor, Bernard-Rene de Launay, had a garrison of eighty-two pensioned veterans and thirty-two Swiss soldiers sent as reinforcements, and food for two days. Through the morning he received delegations from the electors sitting at the city hall, gave one of them lunch, agreed to pull his cannon back from the embrasures and promised not to fire unless attacked. He would not hand over the powder or the fortress without orders.

At about half past one, men climbed from the roof of a perfume shop on to the wall of the outer courtyard and cut the chains of a drawbridge, which crashed down and killed one of the crowd. People poured into the court. Someone fired; each side said the other. The defenders shot down from the towers into a packed yard for the next two hours, and the besiegers, who believed they had been lured in and betrayed, set fire to carts of straw for cover.

The balance changed at around three, when companies of the French Guards, a royal regiment that had gone over to the city, arrived with five cannon and were placed opposite the main gate by two former soldiers, Pierre-Augustin Hulin and Jacob Elie. De Launay wrote a note threatening to blow up the magazine, and the district with it, unless he was granted terms. His own veterans begged him not to. Around five o’clock he had the inner drawbridge lowered.

Close to a hundred of the attackers were dead and one of the defenders. Hulin and Elie tried to bring de Launay alive to the city hall, but on the Place de Greve the crowd closed in. He was stabbed and shot, and an unemployed cook named Desnot cut off his head with a pocket knife. The chief magistrate of the city, Jacques de Flesselles, accused of having misled the people about where arms were kept, was shot on the steps. Both heads were paraded on pikes.

Inside the towers the victors found seven prisoners: four forgers, two men who were insane, and a nobleman confined at his family’s request. At Versailles, Louis XVI had spent the day without hunting, and the entry in his diary for 14 July reads ‘Rien’, nothing.

How it came to this

France was close to bankruptcy, and the Estates General, summoned in May 1789 for the first time since 1614 to approve new taxes, had turned itself into a National Assembly claiming to speak for the nation. The king appeared to give way and at the same time moved troops, many of them foreign regiments, towards Paris and Versailles. On 11 July he dismissed Jacques Necker, the finance minister whom Parisians trusted to keep bread and credit flowing. The news reached the city on Sunday 12 July. In the gardens of the Palais-Royal a young journalist, Camille Desmoulins, climbed on a table and called people to arms.

Bread was dearer that week than at any time in the century, after a failed harvest and a savage winter. For two days crowds burned the customs posts that taxed food entering the city, sacked a monastery for grain and searched for weapons, while the electors of Paris formed a committee and a citizen militia to keep order and to resist the army. The Bastille mattered to them first as an arsenal and a gun platform. Its reputation as a prison for men held without trial on the king’s sealed letter, built by generations of pamphlets and by the memoirs of former inmates, did the rest.

How each side saw it

The besiegers

The men afterwards awarded the title of Conquerors of the Bastille numbered about 950. The lists show cabinet-makers, joiners, locksmiths, shoemakers, wine sellers and a good many soldiers, most of them living within a short walk of the fortress, and one laundress. In their own depositions they had gone to disarm a threat pointed at their homes and had been fired on under a flag of truce. They believed, wrongly but sincerely, that de Launay had lowered the bridge on purpose to trap them, and that belief is what made the killing afterwards seem like justice to those who did it.

The garrison

Lieutenant Ludwig von Flue, who commanded the Swiss detachment, wrote a report soon afterwards that is the fullest account from inside. He describes a governor who was anxious and indecisive, a fortress never provisioned for a siege, and veterans who had no wish to fire on their neighbours. He maintains that the garrison shot only after the outer court was invaded and that the capitulation was accepted before the gates were opened. He blamed de Launay for surrendering at all, since the walls could not have been taken. Several of the veterans were killed after they had laid down their arms.

The court and the counter-revolution

At Versailles the fall of a royal fortress to a mob, with the help of mutinous royal troops, showed that the army could not be relied on. The king’s brother Artois and the leading courtiers left France within days, the first of the emigres. Edmund Burke, writing the following year, and Hippolyte Taine a century later, saw 14 July as the day lawful government gave way to the rule of the street, and dwelt on the heads on pikes. In this tradition the Bastille was a nearly empty building defended by old men, and its capture was a lynching dressed up as a liberation.

Historians

Jules Michelet made the day the act of a whole people rising by instinct. George Rude’s study of the police and pension records replaced the people with identifiable craftsmen and shopkeepers, and Jacques Godechot reconstructed the day hour by hour, stressing how little was planned. Simon Schama argued that the violence was no accident of the day but was built into the Revolution from its first hours. Hans-Jurgen Lusebrink and Rolf Reichardt have traced how a prison holding seven men was made, before and after, into the emblem of despotism.

What is disputed

Who fired first was contested within hours and cannot be resolved. The dead among the attackers are usually given as 98, a figure derived from the lists of 1789-90. The exchange in which the Duke of La Rochefoucauld-Liancourt tells the king ‘No, Sire, it is a revolution’ rests on later family tradition, and the king’s ‘Rien’ is a hunting record, not a comment on events. Accounts differ on the identity of some prisoners. Historians also disagree on how much the day itself achieved, since the Assembly had already defied the king in June and the withdrawal of troops owed as much to the army’s unreliability.

What followed

The king recalled Necker, sent the troops away, and on 17 July came to Paris and pinned the new tricolour cockade to his hat. A contractor named Palloy began demolishing the fortress the next morning and sold its stones as souvenirs; Lafayette sent one of its keys to George Washington, and it is still at Mount Vernon. Towns across France set up their own committees and militias. The date became the national holiday only in 1880, by a law that left unstated whether it honoured 1789 or the peaceful Festival of the Federation held on the first anniversary.

Read further

  • Jacques Godechot, The Taking of the Bastille: July 14th, 1789 (1970)
  • George Rude, The Crowd in the French Revolution (1959)
  • Simon Schama, Citizens: A Chronicle of the French Revolution (1989)
  • Hans-Jurgen Lusebrink and Rolf Reichardt, The Bastille: A History of a Symbol of Despotism and Freedom (1997)
  • Georges Lefebvre, The Coming of the French Revolution (1947)

Same day, other years

1933

Germany legislates compulsory sterilisation

Berlin, GermanyEurope

On 14 July 1933, the same day it made the Nazi party the only legal one, Hitler’s cabinet approved the Law for the Prevention of Hereditarily Diseased Offspring. From January 1934 special hereditary health courts, each of two doctors and a judge, could order the sterilisation of anyone judged to suffer from ‘congenital feeble-mindedness’, schizophrenia, manic depression, hereditary epilepsy, blindness or deafness, Huntington’s chorea, severe deformity or chronic alcoholism. Doctors, teachers and asylum directors were required to report candidates. Around 400,000 people were sterilised by 1945, and several thousand, most of them women, died of the operation. The law was not a killing programme; the murder of asylum patients began separately in 1939, and drew on the same doctors and the same reasoning.

Seen from elsewhere. Its authors pointed out, correctly, that they were following others: some thirty American states had sterilisation laws, upheld by the Supreme Court in 1927, and Sweden and Denmark passed their own. The Catholic Church objected on doctrinal grounds. West Germany long refused the victims recognition as persecuted persons; the Bundestag annulled the courts’ rulings only in 1998.

1958

Army officers destroy the Iraqi monarchy

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Two brigades ordered to Jordan had to pass through Baghdad on the night of 13 July 1958, and for once they had been issued with ammunition. Their commanders, Brigadier Abd al-Karim Qasim and Colonel Abd al-Salam Arif, belonged to a secret group of Free Officers modelled on Nasser’s in Egypt. At dawn Arif’s troops seized the radio station and surrounded the Rihab palace. King Faisal II, aged twenty-three, his uncle the former regent Abd al-Ilah, and several women of the family came out into the courtyard and were shot. The veteran prime minister Nuri al-Said was caught the next day disguised in a woman’s cloak and killed. Crowds dragged the bodies through the streets. Iraq was declared a republic.

Seen from elsewhere. For many Iraqis the day ended a regime installed by Britain and tied to it by bases, oil and the Baghdad Pact, and it was the national day for decades. Others date from it a cycle of coups and killings that led to the Baath party’s rule. Whether the officers ordered the family’s deaths or a captain acted on impulse is still argued.

1969

El Salvador and Honduras go to war after a football tie

Honduras-El Salvador borderThe Americas

Some 300,000 Salvadorans, squeezed out of the most crowded country on the American mainland, were farming land in emptier Honduras. In 1969 the Honduran government began enforcing a land reform law that reserved plots for the native-born, and tens of thousands of Salvadorans were expelled or fled, many of them after beatings. That June the two countries met in three ill-tempered World Cup qualifying matches, with riots at each. On the evening of 14 July Salvadoran aircraft bombed Honduran airfields and the army crossed the border. A ceasefire arranged by the Organization of American States took hold four days later. Between two and three thousand people had died, most of them Honduran civilians.

Seen from elsewhere. El Salvador said it acted to protect its nationals from persecution, Honduras that it was invaded. The Polish reporter Ryszard Kapuscinski gave the war its name, but historians such as Thomas Anderson and William Durham trace it to land and the power of landowners in both countries. The returning refugees deepened the crisis that became El Salvador’s civil war.

Also on 14 July