Parallax

8 March, 1265

Simon de Montfort’s parliament sits at Westminster with townsmen in it

A rebel earl holding the king prisoner needed more support than the barons would give him, so he sent for knights from the shires and citizens from the towns. Whether that makes him the father of the House of Commons has been argued ever since.

Westminster, England

In the first days of March 1265 an assembly unlike any England had seen was nearing the end of its business in the palace of Westminster. It had been called in the name of King Henry III, who attended it and sealed what it decided. He did so as a captive. Ten months earlier, at Lewes in Sussex, he and his son Edward had been beaten in battle by an army of rebel barons, and since then the kingdom had been governed by their leader, the king’s own brother-in-law, Simon de Montfort, Earl of Leicester.

The writs had gone out in December, summoning the parliament for 20 January. The list shows how narrow Montfort’s footing was. Only five earls and eighteen barons were called, the men he could count on, when a full gathering would have had several times that number. To fill the gap he summoned about 120 bishops, abbots and priors, among whom his cause was popular, and two knights from every shire. Then came the novelty. York, Lincoln and other chosen towns were each told to send two of their citizens, and the Cinque Ports four apiece.

Knights of the shire had been called to parliaments before, at least since 1254, usually to agree a tax. Townsmen had not been summoned in this way. Nor were they asked for money. The business was political: on what terms Edward, held as a hostage for his father’s good conduct, could be released, and how the new government was to be made permanent.

The settlement was sealed in the second week of March. In Westminster Hall the king and his son swore to uphold the new order and to take no revenge. Edward was freed from custody in name and remained under guard; as the price he made over the earldom of Chester and other lands to Montfort. Nine bishops in full vestments pronounced excommunication on anyone who broke the peace, and the terms were ordered to be read out in every county court.

It was already coming apart. Gilbert de Clare, the young Earl of Gloucester and the most powerful of Montfort’s allies, had quarrelled with him during the session over the castles, ransoms and offices piling up in the hands of Montfort’s sons, and withdrew to his lands on the Welsh border. In May Edward rode away from his guards at Hereford on a borrowed horse and joined him. On 4 August they trapped Montfort at Evesham. He was killed with one of his sons and most of his household knights, and his body was cut to pieces.

How it came to this

Henry III had been king since childhood and had never managed the great men of his realm. He spent heavily on his wife’s Savoyard relatives and his own Poitevin half-brothers, and in the 1250s he promised the pope an enormous sum to buy the crown of Sicily for his younger son. In 1258, with the harvest failed and the debt unpayable, the barons came armed to a parliament and forced on him the Provisions of Oxford, which put government in the hands of a council of fifteen and required parliaments three times a year.

Montfort, a Frenchman by birth who had married the king’s sister, emerged as the one magnate who would not compromise on the Provisions when others drifted back to the court. Both sides asked Louis IX of France to arbitrate, and in January 1264 he ruled entirely for Henry. The reformers refused the verdict and war followed. Montfort’s victory at Lewes that May left him holding the king, the heir and the machinery of government, with most of the great lords either hostile or in exile and a papal legate waiting across the Channel to excommunicate him.

How each side saw it

Montfort’s supporters

The case for the earl was set out in a long Latin poem, the Song of Lewes, probably by a Franciscan in his circle. It argues that a king is bound by law, that he should rule with the counsel of the community of the realm, and that those who know the country’s customs are better advisers than foreigners. Friars, many bishops, Londoners and lesser knights saw him as a man of conscience who kept his oath when greater men broke theirs. After Evesham people reported miracles at his grave, and the crown had to forbid anyone to call him a saint.

The royalists

To the king’s party he was a perjured subject who had imprisoned his lord and ruled through a puppet. The chronicler Thomas Wykes, the most articulate royalist voice, describes a government that spoke of the common good while Montfort’s family gathered up castles and ransoms, and that packed its parliament with partisans. The pope’s legate, Guy Foulquois, who became Pope Clement IV that February, excommunicated the earl and his followers. On this view the townsmen at Westminster were not a principle but an audience, brought in because the men who ordinarily counselled the king would not come.

England’s Jews

The reform movement drew much of its support from knights in debt to Jewish lenders, and it turned on them. Montfort had expelled the Jews from his town of Leicester as early as 1231. In April 1264 his allies in London killed several hundred Jews in a single outbreak, and there were attacks at Canterbury, Worcester and elsewhere, with the bonds recording debts seized or burned. His government then cancelled many such debts. Jewish testimony survives mainly in royal financial records and in a few Hebrew laments. For this community the champion of the realm’s liberties was the leader of the party that murdered them.

Later tradition and modern historians

Victorian writers, above all Bishop Stubbs, made Montfort the founder of the House of Commons, and Parliament marked the 750th anniversary in 2015. Historians now put it more carefully. J. R. Maddicott, his modern biographer, sees real religious conviction joined to family greed, and a summons to the towns that was both expedient and important. Others note that Edward I, Montfort’s destroyer, was the one who made the practice regular from 1275. England was not first, either: townsmen sat in the Cortes of Leon in 1188, and Iceland’s Althing dates from about 930.

What is disputed

The date needs care. Some popular calendars give 8 March as the day this parliament gathered. The writs summoned it for 20 January 1265, and it sat for some seven weeks; this entry is placed on 8 March because the assembly was then in session and concluding its business, not because it opened that day. Its claim to be the ‘first parliament’ also fails on the facts: the word had been used for English assemblies since the 1230s, and knights were summoned in 1254. What was new was the presence of burgesses. Whether Montfort acted from principle or necessity is the standing argument, and the evidence supports both.

What followed

The war dragged on for two years after Evesham until the Dictum of Kenilworth allowed the defeated to buy back their lands. Henry III died in 1272. Edward I, who had learned from his enemy, summoned knights and burgesses together in 1275 and frequently afterwards, mainly because their consent made taxes easier to collect. By the fourteenth century the two groups sat as a separate house. Montfort is commemorated in a relief on the wall of the United States House of Representatives and in the name of a university in Leicester, which has faced calls to change it because of his treatment of the Jews.

Read further

  • J. R. Maddicott, Simon de Montfort (1994)
  • J. R. Maddicott, The Origins of the English Parliament, 924-1327 (2010)
  • David Carpenter, The Struggle for Mastery: Britain 1066-1284 (2003)
  • The Song of Lewes, edited by C. L. Kingsford (1890)
  • R. F. Treharne, The Baronial Plan of Reform, 1258-1263 (1932)

Same day, other years

1782

Militiamen kill ninety-six Christian Delawares at Gnadenhutten

Gnadenhutten, OhioThe Americas

The Delaware and Mohican converts of the Moravian mission villages on the Tuscarawas River were pacifists in the middle of a frontier war, distrusted by the British and by the Americans alike. Removed by force the previous autumn to the Sandusky, where they went hungry, about a hundred and fifty came back in late winter to gather the corn left standing in their fields. A force of some 160 Pennsylvania militia under David Williamson found them, disarmed them with promises of protection, and then accused them of sheltering raiders. The militia voted to kill them. The prisoners spent the night praying and singing hymns. In the morning 28 men, 29 women and 39 children were clubbed to death with mallets and scalped.

Seen from elsewhere. The militiamen said they had found goods taken from murdered settlers, and frontier opinion largely approved; a minority of them refused to take part. No one was tried. The record comes from the missionaries Zeisberger and Heckewelder and from two boys who survived. Delaware warriors burned an American colonel alive that June in reprisal.

1917

Women textile workers start the Russian Revolution

Petrograd, RussiaEurope

It was 23 February by the Russian calendar and International Women’s Day in the socialist one. In the Vyborg district of Petrograd, women from the cotton mills, many of them soldiers’ wives who had been queueing through the night for bread, walked out and went from factory to factory calling the men to join them, by some accounts throwing snowballs at the windows of the metalworks. By evening about ninety thousand people were on strike and crowds were crossing the frozen river into the centre shouting for bread. Within three days the strike was general. On the fifth day the garrison mutinied, and a week after the women walked out Nicholas II abdicated.

Seen from elsewhere. The revolutionary parties had advised against a strike that day; the Bolshevik organiser Vasily Kayurov recalled his annoyance at being ignored. The Empress wrote to her husband that it was a hooligan movement of young people shouting that they had no bread. Historians differ on how spontaneous it was, but agree that no party leadership planned it.

1942

The Dutch surrender Java to Japan

Kalijati, Java, IndonesiaAsia

One week after Japanese troops landed on Java, the Dutch governor-general and his army commander, General Hein ter Poorten, drove to the airfield at Kalijati to meet General Hitoshi Imamura. They hoped to yield the city of Bandung alone. Imamura demanded the unconditional surrender of all forces in the Netherlands East Indies and threatened to bomb Bandung if refused. Ter Poorten agreed, and the order was broadcast the next morning. Dutch rule in the archipelago, which had begun with trading posts at the start of the seventeenth century, was over in practice. Tens of thousands of soldiers, among them British, Australian and American troops, went into prison camps, followed by about a hundred thousand Dutch civilians.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Indonesians cheered the Japanese as liberators, and nationalists including Sukarno worked with them. The welcome did not last: millions were conscripted as forced labourers, rice was requisitioned, and wartime deaths from hunger and labour ran into the millions. The occupation nonetheless destroyed Dutch prestige and trained the men who declared independence in August 1945.

1979

Iranian women march against compulsory veiling

Tehran, IranMiddle East

Less than a month after the fall of the Shah, Ayatollah Khomeini said that women working in government ministries should not come to work ‘naked’, meaning without the Islamic head covering. The next day was International Women’s Day. Tens of thousands of women, students, nurses, lawyers and office workers, many of whom had demonstrated for the revolution, marched through the snow in Tehran to the prime minister’s office and the palace of justice, chanting that they had not made a revolution to go backwards. Men attacked the marchers with stones, knives and insults and the marchers had little protection. The protests continued for several days, and the government announced that the remark had been only a recommendation.

Seen from elsewhere. Supporters of the veil, many women among them, saw it as dignity regained after the Pahlavi state had forcibly unveiled women in 1936 and as a rejection of Western cultural dominance. Most left-wing parties declined to back the marchers, calling the issue a distraction. Veiling was imposed in offices in 1980 and on all women by law in 1983.

Also on 8 March