In the first days of March 1265 an assembly unlike any England had seen was nearing the end of its business in the palace of Westminster. It had been called in the name of King Henry III, who attended it and sealed what it decided. He did so as a captive. Ten months earlier, at Lewes in Sussex, he and his son Edward had been beaten in battle by an army of rebel barons, and since then the kingdom had been governed by their leader, the king’s own brother-in-law, Simon de Montfort, Earl of Leicester.
The writs had gone out in December, summoning the parliament for 20 January. The list shows how narrow Montfort’s footing was. Only five earls and eighteen barons were called, the men he could count on, when a full gathering would have had several times that number. To fill the gap he summoned about 120 bishops, abbots and priors, among whom his cause was popular, and two knights from every shire. Then came the novelty. York, Lincoln and other chosen towns were each told to send two of their citizens, and the Cinque Ports four apiece.
Knights of the shire had been called to parliaments before, at least since 1254, usually to agree a tax. Townsmen had not been summoned in this way. Nor were they asked for money. The business was political: on what terms Edward, held as a hostage for his father’s good conduct, could be released, and how the new government was to be made permanent.
The settlement was sealed in the second week of March. In Westminster Hall the king and his son swore to uphold the new order and to take no revenge. Edward was freed from custody in name and remained under guard; as the price he made over the earldom of Chester and other lands to Montfort. Nine bishops in full vestments pronounced excommunication on anyone who broke the peace, and the terms were ordered to be read out in every county court.
It was already coming apart. Gilbert de Clare, the young Earl of Gloucester and the most powerful of Montfort’s allies, had quarrelled with him during the session over the castles, ransoms and offices piling up in the hands of Montfort’s sons, and withdrew to his lands on the Welsh border. In May Edward rode away from his guards at Hereford on a borrowed horse and joined him. On 4 August they trapped Montfort at Evesham. He was killed with one of his sons and most of his household knights, and his body was cut to pieces.
How it came to this
Henry III had been king since childhood and had never managed the great men of his realm. He spent heavily on his wife’s Savoyard relatives and his own Poitevin half-brothers, and in the 1250s he promised the pope an enormous sum to buy the crown of Sicily for his younger son. In 1258, with the harvest failed and the debt unpayable, the barons came armed to a parliament and forced on him the Provisions of Oxford, which put government in the hands of a council of fifteen and required parliaments three times a year.
Montfort, a Frenchman by birth who had married the king’s sister, emerged as the one magnate who would not compromise on the Provisions when others drifted back to the court. Both sides asked Louis IX of France to arbitrate, and in January 1264 he ruled entirely for Henry. The reformers refused the verdict and war followed. Montfort’s victory at Lewes that May left him holding the king, the heir and the machinery of government, with most of the great lords either hostile or in exile and a papal legate waiting across the Channel to excommunicate him.