Parallax

12 March, 1938

German troops cross into Austria

Austria ceased to exist as a state in a single weekend, without a shot fired and to the sound of cheering. Who was the victim of that weekend, and who the accomplice, took Austrians half a century to argue out.

Braunau am Inn, Linz and Vienna, Austria

On the evening of Wednesday 9 March 1938 the Austrian chancellor, Kurt Schuschnigg, announced in Innsbruck that the country would vote in four days’ time on whether it wished to remain ‘free and German, independent and social, Christian and united’. It was a gamble by a cornered man. A month earlier, at Berchtesgaden, Hitler had shouted him into taking Austrian Nazis into his government. A plebiscite, with the voting age set at twenty-four to exclude the most Nazified of the young, was his attempt to show the world that Austrians did not want to be absorbed.

Hitler could not risk the vote being held. On Friday 11 March, Hermann Goering spent the day on the telephone to Vienna issuing one ultimatum after another: cancel the plebiscite; then, Schuschnigg must resign; then, the Nazi lawyer Arthur Seyss-Inquart must be made chancellor. Schuschnigg found that neither Italy, nor Britain, nor France would act. That evening he went on the radio, said that he was yielding to force and had ordered the army not to resist so that no German blood should be shed, and ended, ‘God protect Austria.’ President Wilhelm Miklas held out against appointing Seyss-Inquart until nearly midnight. By then Austrian Nazis had taken over the streets and public buildings of most provincial capitals.

German troops crossed the frontier at dawn on Saturday 12 March. They met flowers and flags, not opposition, though a good many of their vehicles broke down on the road. Heinrich Himmler had flown into Vienna before first light to begin the arrests. That afternoon, shortly before four, Hitler himself drove over the bridge at Braunau am Inn, the border town where he had been born forty-eight years earlier, and went on through cheering villages to Linz, where he had been a schoolboy. The crowd in the main square was so large and so loud that he was visibly moved.

He seems until then to have had in mind a union of two states under his own leadership. In Linz, on the strength of that welcome, he decided on outright annexation. A law making Austria ‘a land of the German Reich’ was signed the next day. On 15 March he addressed some 200,000 people from the balcony of the Hofburg on Vienna’s Heldenplatz and reported to history, as he put it, the entry of his homeland into the German Reich.

In the same streets, from the Friday night onwards, Vienna’s Jews were being dragged from their homes and shops and set to scrubbing Schuschnigg’s plebiscite slogans off the pavements on their hands and knees, while crowds of their neighbours watched and jeered. Tens of thousands of people were arrested in the first weeks. The first trainload of prisoners left for Dachau on 1 April.

How it came to this

The Austria of 1938 was the German-speaking remnant of the Habsburg empire, a country of under seven million people that few of its citizens had wanted in that form. In 1918 its own provisional assembly had declared it part of the German republic, and the victorious Allies forbade the union in the peace treaties. The wish for it was strong on the left as well as the right until Hitler came to power in Germany in 1933.

By then Austria was no longer a democracy. Chancellor Engelbert Dollfuss suspended parliament in 1933, crushed the Social Democrats in a brief civil war in February 1934, and set up an authoritarian Catholic state. Austrian Nazis murdered him in a failed coup that July. His successor Schuschnigg ruled with the same narrow base, having banned both the Nazis and the socialists, and relied on Mussolini’s protection. When Italy moved into alliance with Germany after 1936 that protection disappeared. In March 1938 he turned at the last moment to the outlawed labour movement for support, and its leaders agreed to back him, but there were only days left.

How each side saw it

Vienna’s Jews

About 190,000 Jews lived in Austria, nearly all in Vienna. Their accounts describe not an orderly German takeover but an eruption from below. The playwright Carl Zuckmayer, who was there, wrote in his memoirs that the city turned overnight into a nightmare painting, with envy, spite and the lust for revenge let loose. George Clare’s Last Waltz in Vienna and the dispatches of the British correspondent G. E. R. Gedye record the looting of flats and the ‘scrubbing parties’. German officials were themselves surprised by the scale of the freelance plunder. Some 65,000 Austrian Jews were murdered in the years that followed; most of the rest escaped abroad, stripped of what they owned.

Austrians who welcomed it

For a large part of the population the union was the fulfilment of a wish denied since 1918, and the promise of work after years of depression. This was not confined to Nazis. Cardinal Theodor Innitzer, Archbishop of Vienna, had church bells rung for Hitler’s arrival and signed a declaration of the bishops recommending a yes vote, adding ‘Heil Hitler’ in his own hand. Karl Renner, the Social Democrat who had been the republic’s first chancellor, said publicly that he would vote yes. Both later explained themselves as having tried to protect their followers; Innitzer fell out with the regime within months and his palace was sacked by Hitler Youth.

Schuschnigg and the old regime

In his memoir Austrian Requiem, Schuschnigg presented himself as a patriot abandoned by the powers and unwilling to order a hopeless fight between Germans. He spent the war in German custody, latterly in concentration camps, and later taught in the United States. His critics on the Austrian left replied that the regime he led had destroyed democracy and the workers’ movement four years earlier and so had nobody left to defend it. His defenders point out that his was the only European government Hitler removed that had been trying, however late, to put the question to a vote.

The other governments

Britain’s Lord Halifax had told Hitler in November 1937 that London would not oppose changes in Austria if they came peacefully. Neville Chamberlain told the Commons on 14 March that nothing short of force could have stopped it. France was between governments that weekend. Mussolini, who had moved troops to the Brenner in 1934, sent word that he accepted the outcome, and Hitler replied that he would never forget it. The only formal protest lodged at the League of Nations came from Mexico, an act still commemorated by the name of the Mexikoplatz in Vienna.

What is disputed

The central dispute is the ‘first victim’ thesis. The Allies’ Moscow Declaration of 1943 called Austria the first free country to fall to Hitler’s aggression, and the post-war republic built its identity on that phrase. Historians such as Gerhard Botz and Evan Burr Bukey have shown how broad the enthusiasm and participation were. The plebiscite of 10 April 1938 returned 99.7 per cent in favour, but Jews and known opponents were excluded and the ballot was hardly secret; Bukey nonetheless judges that a real majority approved. What Schuschnigg’s own vote would have shown is unknowable. Estimates of the first arrests range from about 20,000 to over 70,000.

What followed

The Anschluss gave Germany Austria’s gold reserves, iron ore and manpower and surrounded Czechoslovakia on three sides; Munich followed six months later. Vienna became the testing ground for the forced emigration of Jews under Adolf Eichmann. Austrians served throughout the German army and were over-represented, on several historians’ reckoning, among the staff of the camps. The republic restored in 1945 long avoided the subject. It was forced open by the dispute over President Kurt Waldheim’s war record in 1986, and in 1991 Chancellor Franz Vranitzky acknowledged before parliament that Austrians shared responsibility for the suffering the regime had caused.

Read further

  • Evan Burr Bukey, Hitler’s Austria: Popular Sentiment in the Nazi Era, 1938-1945 (2000)
  • G. E. R. Gedye, Fallen Bastions: The Central European Tragedy (1939)
  • Kurt von Schuschnigg, Austrian Requiem (1946)
  • George Clare, Last Waltz in Vienna (1981)
  • Ian Kershaw, Hitler, 1936-1945: Nemesis (2000)

Same day, other years

1930

Gandhi sets out for the sea to make salt

Sabarmati ashram, Ahmedabad, IndiaAsia

At half past six in the morning Mohandas Gandhi, aged sixty, walked out of his ashram with seventy-eight chosen followers and headed south. His target was the government’s monopoly on salt and the tax that went with it, which touched every household in India, however poor. Over twenty-four days the column covered some 240 miles through the villages of Gujarat, gathering crowds and the world’s press. On 6 April, on the beach at Dandi, he picked up a lump of natural salt and so broke the law. Millions followed his example. Around 60,000 people were jailed that year, Gandhi among them, before the Viceroy agreed to negotiate with him.

Seen from elsewhere. The Viceroy, Lord Irwin, first thought the idea too trivial to bother with, and officials insisted the tax was light. Within India, Muslim participation was limited outside the North-West Frontier, and B. R. Ambedkar kept the Dalit movement apart. Gandhi included no women among the marchers; Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay and others pressed him until women were admitted to the campaign. The salt tax itself survived until 1947.

1947

Truman asks Congress to hold the line in Greece and Turkey

Washington, DC, United StatesWorldwide

Three weeks earlier Britain had told Washington that it could no longer afford to support the Greek government in its civil war against communist-led guerrillas, or to subsidise Turkey against Soviet pressure. On 12 March President Harry Truman went before a joint session of Congress and asked for 400 million dollars for the two countries. He put the request in universal terms: it must be the policy of the United States, he said, ‘to support free peoples who are resisting attempted subjugation by armed minorities or by outside pressures’. Congress agreed in May. The principle, soon known as the Truman Doctrine, shaped American foreign policy for the next forty years.

Seen from elsewhere. The Greek left saw a royalist government staffed in part by wartime collaborators being rescued by a new foreign patron. Stalin was in fact giving the Greek communists little help, having conceded Greece to the British sphere in 1944; their supplies came mainly from Tito’s Yugoslavia. George Kennan, the architect of containment, thought the speech’s open-ended language unwise.

1967

Suharto replaces Sukarno

Jakarta, IndonesiaAsia

Indonesia’s provisional consultative assembly stripped Sukarno, the country’s founding president, of his powers and named General Suharto acting president. It was the last step in a slow takeover that began on 1 October 1965, when a group of junior officers killed six generals and Suharto, commanding the strategic reserve, put the movement down within a day. The army blamed the Indonesian Communist Party, then the largest outside the communist states. In the months that followed, soldiers and allied civilian militias killed an estimated half a million to a million alleged party members and sympathisers, and detained hundreds of thousands more without trial. Suharto ruled until 1998.

Seen from elsewhere. The official version under Suharto was that the army saved the nation from a communist coup and that the killing was spontaneous popular anger. Historians including John Roosa, Robert Cribb and Geoffrey Robinson describe a campaign organised by the army, with American and British encouragement that declassified files confirm. Survivors remained under legal disabilities for decades. No one has been tried.

1993

A dozen bombs across Bombay

Bombay (Mumbai), IndiaAsia

At half past one in the afternoon a car bomb exploded in the basement of the Bombay Stock Exchange. Over the next two hours a further eleven blasts hit banks, hotels, a passport office, markets and the Air India building. The official toll was 257 dead and more than 700 injured. Investigators traced the plot to the smuggling syndicate of Dawood Ibrahim and to Tiger Memon, both of whom fled abroad. It was presented by its organisers as revenge for the demolition of the Babri mosque at Ayodhya in December 1992 and for the riots that followed in Bombay, in which some 900 people, most of them Muslims, had died.

Seen from elsewhere. India holds that Pakistan’s intelligence service trained the bombers and shelters the planners, which Pakistan denies. The Srikrishna Commission found that the riots and the bombings were cause and effect and blamed the Shiv Sena and sections of the police for the riots. Muslim organisations and civil liberties groups point out that the bombers were tried and one hanged, while those named for the riots largely went unpunished.

Also on 12 March