Parallax

14 March, 1757

Admiral Byng is shot on his own quarterdeck

Acquitted of cowardice, recommended to mercy by the very court that sentenced him, a British admiral was executed for failing to do his utmost. Whether he died for his own fault or his government’s has been argued ever since.

HMS Monarch, Portsmouth harbour, England

A little before noon on 14 March 1757, in a hard wind and rain, Admiral John Byng came out of the great cabin of the Monarch on to the quarterdeck. He was fifty-two, the son of a famous admiral, and wore a plain grey coat. A cushion had been laid on the planking, with a heap of sawdust beside it. Boats crowded with spectators lay all around the ship, and the crews of the fleet had been ordered into the rigging to watch.

Byng had intended to face the firing party with his eyes open. His friends persuaded him that the sight of his face might unsteady the marines, and he agreed to a blindfold for their sake. He knelt, tied the handkerchief himself, and held a second one in his hand as the signal. When he dropped it the marines fired a single volley and he fell dead on his side. Those present, including officers who had no love for him, recorded that he showed no trace of fear.

His offence dated from the previous spring. In April 1756, with war against France imminent, he had been sent from England with ten ships of the line, short of men and in poor repair, to protect the British island base of Minorca. He arrived to find a French army of 15,000 already ashore and the garrison shut up in Fort St Philip. On 20 May he fought the French fleet under the Marquis de La Galissoniere. His leading ships closed and were badly knocked about; the rear, where Byng was, became tangled behind a disabled vessel and scarcely engaged. The French drew off. Four days later a council of his captains agreed unanimously that the fleet could do nothing more for the fort and should fall back to cover Gibraltar. Minorca surrendered at the end of June.

The news caused an uproar in Britain. Byng was burned in effigy in dozens of towns, and the Duke of Newcastle’s ministry, which had sent him out late and weak, was glad to see the anger aimed at him. His dispatch was printed with the passages explaining his reasons cut out. He was brought home under arrest.

The court martial sat for a month at Portsmouth. It cleared him of cowardice and of disaffection, but found that he had not done his utmost to relieve the fort or destroy the enemy. Under the twelfth Article of War, as tightened in 1749, that finding carried death with no alternative. The thirteen officers passed the sentence and in the same breath begged the Admiralty to obtain the king’s mercy. William Pitt pleaded for him; the Commons passed a bill to let the judges explain themselves, and the Lords threw it out. George II would not pardon him.

How it came to this

Britain and France had been fighting undeclared in North America and at sea since 1754, and the conflict that became the Seven Years’ War was formally declared in May 1756, days before Byng’s battle. Minorca, taken from Spain in 1708, gave the Royal Navy its only deep-water harbour in the western Mediterranean. The ministry had ample warning that the French were preparing an expedition at Toulon but, fearing an invasion of England, kept its best ships in the Channel and sent Byng with what was left.

The law that killed him was itself a reaction to failure. After the indecisive battle off Toulon in 1744, a series of courts martial had let hesitant officers off lightly, and Parliament was scandalised. The revised Articles of War of 1749 removed the courts’ discretion: an officer who through cowardice, negligence or disaffection failed to do his utmost in action was to die. Byng had himself sat on one of the Toulon courts. Nobody had expected the clause to be applied to an error of judgement by a commander-in-chief.

How each side saw it

Byng and his family

Byng’s last written statement, handed to the marshal on the morning of his death, said that he was a victim, that his enemies themselves now thought him innocent, and that he had done his duty to the best of his judgement. His sister-in-law and nephews campaigned for him to the end. They buried him in the family vault at Southill in Bedfordshire under an inscription that begins ‘To the perpetual disgrace of public justice’ and describes him as a martyr to political persecution, at a time ‘when bravery and loyalty were insufficient securities for the life and honour of a naval officer’. Descendants petitioned for a posthumous pardon as recently as 2007, and were refused.

The French

His opponents thought the sentence absurd. The Duc de Richelieu, who had commanded the army on Minorca, wrote a letter stating that Byng had done all that could be expected and that the French fleet had simply been the stronger on the day. Voltaire, who had met Byng in England years before, forwarded it to him for use at the trial. It did no good and may have done harm. Two years later Voltaire had the hero of Candide witness the execution of an admiral at Portsmouth and be told that in this country it is thought good to kill an admiral from time to time, to encourage the others.

The Navy’s defenders of the sentence

A different reading comes from within naval history. N. A. M. Rodger argues that Byng’s conduct, whatever the ministry’s faults, was feeble: he made one half-hearted attempt and then gave up an island he had been sent to save, on the opinion of a council he had steered. On this view the execution, harsh as it was, taught every later British captain that the one unforgivable course was not to fight, and so helped to create the aggressive habit that marked the navy of Hawke and Nelson. Voltaire’s joke, Rodger suggests, was no more than the truth.

What is disputed

That Byng was a scapegoat for ministers is the older view, set out by Brian Tunstall and Dudley Pope, and it is supported by the doctoring of his dispatch. Rodger and others reply that scapegoat and failure are not exclusive. George II’s reasons are unclear: he disliked Byng, distrusted Pitt, and may have feared the mob. A remark attributed to Newcastle, promising a City deputation that Byng would be tried and hanged directly, rests on hearsay. Whether Byng’s tactics were timid or merely correct under the Fighting Instructions is still debated, as is whether Minorca could have been saved by any admiral with that fleet.

What followed

Newcastle’s ministry had already fallen; he returned within months in coalition with Pitt, and the war that began with the loss of Minorca ended with Britain supreme in North America and India. Minorca was handed back in 1763 in exchange for other conquests. The mandatory death penalty in the twelfth Article was removed in 1779, when courts were allowed to impose lesser punishments. No British admiral has been executed since. Byng survives chiefly in a phrase: ‘pour encourager les autres’ has been used ever since of any exemplary punishment that falls on a man for the benefit of his colleagues.

Read further

  • Dudley Pope, At 12 Mr Byng Was Shot (1962)
  • N. A. M. Rodger, The Command of the Ocean: A Naval History of Britain, 1649-1815 (2004)
  • Brian Tunstall, Admiral Byng and the Loss of Minorca (1928)
  • Horace Walpole, Memoirs of King George II
  • Voltaire, Candide (1759)

Same day, other years

1794

Eli Whitney patents the cotton gin

Philadelphia, United StatesThe Americas

Eli Whitney, a Yale graduate from Massachusetts, was staying on a Georgia plantation in 1793 when he built a hand-cranked machine whose wire teeth pulled the fibre of short-staple cotton through a grid too fine for the seeds. One person could now clean in a day what had taken many days by hand. The patent was granted on 14 March 1794. Upland cotton became hugely profitable across the American South. The crop grew from a few thousand bales a year to some four million by 1860, and the enslaved population of the United States from about 700,000 to nearly four million, around a million of them sold and marched from the older states to the new cotton lands.

Seen from elsewhere. Whitney earned little, since planters simply copied the machine. Angela Lakwete has shown that roller gins had been used in India and elsewhere for centuries and that his was one improvement among many. Claims that the idea came from his hostess Catharine Greene, or from an enslaved worker, cannot be proved. Whether slavery was declining before the gin is itself disputed.

1883

Karl Marx dies in his armchair

London, EnglandEurope

Marx had lived in London as a stateless exile for thirty-four years, supported for much of the time by Friedrich Engels. His wife Jenny had died fifteen months earlier and his eldest daughter in January. Ill with bronchitis and a lung abscess, he died in his armchair at home in north London on the afternoon of 14 March, aged sixty-four, in the few minutes he had been left alone. Only the first volume of Capital had been published. About a dozen people attended the burial at Highgate cemetery three days later, where Engels compared his friend’s discovery of the law of human history to Darwin’s of organic nature and said that his name would endure through the ages.

Seen from elsewhere. His rival Mikhail Bakunin had warned a decade earlier that a state run in the name of the workers would become the rule of a new privileged minority. Marx’s admirers hold that the regimes later built on his name betrayed a critic of all domination; his critics that the doctrine itself led there. The large bronze head on his grave was added by the British Communist Party in 1956.

1931

Indian cinema finds its voice

Bombay, IndiaAsia

Alam Ara, ‘Ornament of the World’, opened at the Majestic cinema in Bombay on 14 March 1931, the first feature-length sound film made in India. Its director, Ardeshir Irani, had raced rival studios to finish it, recording at night because the studio stood beside a railway line and the microphones picked up every train. The story was a costume romance from the Parsi stage, in Hindustani, with seven songs. Crowds besieged the cinema, police were called to control them, and tickets changed hands at many times their price. The first of the songs, sung on screen by Wazir Mohammed Khan as a street beggar, set the pattern for a cinema built around music.

Seen from elsewhere. Sound divided what had been a single silent market into separate language cinemas, and it ended the careers of many silent stars, including Anglo-Indian and Jewish actresses who did not speak Hindustani. No print of Alam Ara is known to survive; it is the best-known casualty of a period from which most Indian films have been lost.

1978

Israel invades southern Lebanon

Southern LebanonMiddle East

On 11 March 1978 a Fatah squad landed by sea, seized a bus on the coastal road north of Tel Aviv, and thirty-eight Israeli civilians, thirteen of them children, died in the hijacking and the gun battle that ended it. On the night of 14 March some 25,000 Israeli troops crossed into Lebanon in what was called Operation Litani, with the stated aim of clearing Palestinian guerrilla bases from the border zone. Within a week they held nearly everything south of the Litani river. Between 1,000 and 2,000 Lebanese and Palestinians were killed, most of them civilians, and well over 100,000 people fled north. The UN Security Council called for withdrawal and created a peacekeeping force, UNIFIL.

Seen from elsewhere. Most PLO fighters had pulled back before the advance, so the cost fell on Shia villagers who had already resented the guerrillas’ presence. Israel withdrew in June but handed the border strip to an allied Lebanese militia. Many Lebanese date from 1978 the occupation and the resistance movements that later produced Hezbollah. UNIFIL, meant to be temporary, is still there.

Also on 14 March