Parallax

13 March, 1905

A Dutch divorcee becomes Mata Hari

In a museum library dressed up as a Hindu temple, a hatter’s daughter from Friesland danced before the Paris elite as an Indian temple priestess. The invention made her famous for twelve years and helped to get her shot.

Musee Guimet, Paris, France

The industrialist Emile Guimet had filled a building near the Trocadero with the religious art he had collected in Asia. For the evening of 13 March 1905 he had its circular library transformed. The columns were wound with flowers, candles burned on the floor, and a bronze of the dancing, four-armed Shiva from southern India stood at the back as an altar. A small orchestra played behind a screen. The invited guests included ambassadors, scholars and the more adventurous hostesses.

The dancer was announced under a name nobody in Paris had heard before: Mata Hari, a Malay phrase meaning ‘eye of the day’, the sun. She came out wrapped in veils, wearing a jewelled metal breastplate and a headdress, and performed what the programme described as sacred dances of the temple. Before each she explained in French, English or German the rite she was about to offer the god. One by one the veils came off, until she sank before the statue in very little but the breastplate and her bracelets. The audience was assured that it was watching religion, and applauded.

The newspapers were ecstatic, and she fed them. She was, she said, the daughter of a Brahmin and a temple dancer who had died giving birth to her, raised in a temple on the Malabar coast and dedicated to Shiva. On other days she was Javanese, or the child of a British lord. In truth she was Margaretha Geertruida Zelle, born in Leeuwarden in the Netherlands in 1876, the daughter of a hatter who went bankrupt. At eighteen she had answered a newspaper advertisement placed on behalf of Rudolph MacLeod, an army captain twenty years her senior home on leave from the Dutch East Indies.

She spent five years with him in garrisons on Java and Sumatra. The marriage was wretched: he drank and was violent, both were unfaithful, and in 1899 their small son died, apparently poisoned, in circumstances never cleared up. She had seen local dancing there and learned some Malay, and that was the extent of her training. Back in Europe she left MacLeod, lost custody of their daughter, and arrived in Paris in 1903 with no money. She tried modelling for painters and riding in a circus before a patron suggested she dance in private salons. Guimet saw her at one of them.

Within a year of that night she was appearing at the Olympia in Paris for ten thousand francs an engagement, then in Madrid, Monte Carlo, Vienna and at La Scala in Milan. She was already nearly thirty, and by 1912 younger imitators and the Ballets Russes had overtaken her. She lived thereafter mainly as the mistress of wealthy men and officers of several nations, which, when war came, was a dangerous way to live.

How it came to this

Paris in 1905 had an appetite for the East that reached well beyond scholarship. The universal exhibitions of 1889 and 1900 had brought Javanese court dancers and Cambodian musicians to the city as living exhibits from the colonies, and composers and painters had been fascinated by them. Translations of Sanskrit texts, Theosophy and the new museums of Asian art had given educated people a vague idea of Hindu ritual and a strong idea that the East was sensual and mysterious.

The stage was changing too. Loie Fuller and Isadora Duncan had shown that a woman could dance alone, barefoot and uncorseted, and call it art. Nudity was still liable to prosecution, but could be presented if it was framed as classical, ethnographic or sacred. Zelle understood that frame precisely. Most of her audience had never seen India or Java and could not check a word of what she told them; the Dutch had ruled the East Indies for three centuries, and her years there gave her just enough vocabulary, costume and gesture to be plausible.

How each side saw it

Mata Hari herself

Her letters, many of them published from Dutch archives in 2017, show a woman who knew exactly what she was doing and saw it as the only capital she had. She had been left without income or child by a husband the courts favoured. She never claimed in private that her dances were authentic, and told one interviewer that she had never been able to dance well: people came because she was the first to dare to show herself naked. At her interrogation in 1917 she is recorded as saying that she was a courtesan, admittedly, but never a spy.

Java and India

No Javanese or Indian reaction to her performances was recorded at the time, and that silence is part of the story: the people whose religion and art she claimed to represent had no say in Paris. Later scholars of performance, Matthew Isaac Cohen among them, treat her as a leading example of how colonial Europe consumed an invented East, in which Hindu temple ritual and Javanese court dance were blended into a striptease. Real practitioners were beginning to arrive. The Indian musician Inayat Khan, who accompanied her at one Paris appearance in 1912, was in Europe to present Indian music and Sufi teaching on their own terms.

The French prosecution, 1917

Captain Pierre Bouchardon, the examining magistrate who interrogated her for months in Saint-Lazare prison, wrote in his memoirs that she was a born spy, a woman without scruple who was used to living off men. The prosecutor Andre Mornet told the court martial that the harm she had done was beyond calculation, and the figure of 50,000 French soldiers’ lives was put about. The case rested on intercepted German radio messages from Madrid identifying agent H21, on money she admitted taking from a German consul, and on her way of life. For the army, in the year of the mutinies, a guilty foreign seductress was a useful explanation for failure.

What is disputed

Her guilt is the lasting argument. She did accept 20,000 francs from a German diplomat in the Netherlands, and later agreed to work for the French officer Georges Ladoux as well. Sam Waagenaar, Russell Warren Howe and Pat Shipman conclude that she passed nothing of value to anyone and was sacrificed; Howe argued the Germans exposed her deliberately by using a code they knew was broken. Julie Wheelwright reads the trial as a judgement on female independence. French officers of the time never wavered. Mornet is reported to have said years later that there was not enough evidence to whip a cat. Stories of her blowing kisses to the firing squad come from journalists who were not there.

What followed

She was arrested in a Paris hotel on 13 February 1917, tried in closed session in July, and shot by a squad of twelve soldiers at Vincennes at dawn on 15 October, aged forty-one. Reliable witnesses agree that she refused a blindfold. Nobody claimed her body, which went to a medical school. Ladoux, who had recruited her, was himself arrested days later on suspicion of spying and eventually cleared. Her daughter died in 1919. The trial file was sealed for a century and opened in 2017. Her stage name long ago passed into several languages as the word for a woman who uses seduction to obtain secrets.

Read further

  • Pat Shipman, Femme Fatale: Love, Lies, and the Unknown Life of Mata Hari (2007)
  • Julie Wheelwright, The Fatal Lover: Mata Hari and the Myth of Women in Espionage (1992)
  • Sam Waagenaar, The Murder of Mata Hari (1964)
  • Russell Warren Howe, Mata Hari: The True Story (1986)

Same day, other years

1591

Moroccan guns break the Songhai empire at Tondibi

Tondibi, near Gao, present-day MaliAfrica

Sultan Ahmad al-Mansur of Morocco wanted the gold of the western Sudan and sent an army of about 4,000 across the Sahara to take it. Its commander, Judar Pasha, was a Spanish-born convert, and many of his men were Andalusian exiles and European renegades armed with arquebuses and a few cannon. The crossing took some four months and killed a large part of the force. North of Gao the survivors met the far larger army of Askia Ishaq II, which had no firearms. The Songhai drove a herd of cattle at the Moroccan line; the gunfire turned the animals back into their own ranks. Gao and Timbuktu fell, and the largest state in West African history broke apart.

Seen from elsewhere. The Timbuktu chronicles, the Tarikh al-Sudan and Tarikh al-Fattash, describe what followed as ruin: security replaced by fear and plenty by want. The city’s leading scholar, Ahmad Baba, was deported in chains to Marrakesh and argued there that enslaving free Muslims was unlawful. Morocco gained little; the gold trade dwindled and the garrison went its own way. Some sources date the battle 12 March.

1881

The Tsar Liberator is killed by a bomb

St Petersburg, RussiaEurope

By the Russian calendar it was 1 March. Alexander II, who had freed the serfs in 1861, was driving back along the Catherine Canal from a Sunday parade when a member of the revolutionary group People’s Will threw a bomb under his carriage. It killed a Cossack and a passing boy. The emperor, unhurt, got out to see the wounded and the prisoner, and a second man, Ignacy Hryniewiecki, threw another bomb at his feet. Alexander died at the Winter Palace an hour or so later. That morning he had approved a plan to bring elected representatives into the drafting of laws. His son Alexander III shelved it.

Seen from elsewhere. People’s Will held that the emancipation had cheated the peasants with decades of redemption payments, and wrote to the new tsar offering to end terror in return for an amnesty and a freely elected assembly. Five conspirators were hanged, among them Sofia Perovskaya. Whether the shelved plan amounted to a constitution is disputed. The murder was followed by a wave of pogroms against Jews.

1940

Udham Singh shoots Sir Michael O’Dwyer

Caxton Hall, Westminster, LondonEurope

At the close of a public meeting on Afghanistan, a Punjabi man in his early forties walked to the front of the hall and fired six shots from a revolver. Sir Michael O’Dwyer, aged seventy-five, died at once. He had been Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab in April 1919, when troops under Brigadier-General Dyer fired on an unarmed crowd in the Jallianwala Bagh at Amritsar, and he had approved Dyer’s action. Three other former imperial officials were wounded, among them the Secretary of State for India. The gunman, Udham Singh, made no attempt to escape and gave his name as Mohammad Singh Azad, combining Muslim and Sikh names with the word for ‘free’. He was hanged at Pentonville on 31 July.

Seen from elsewhere. At the time Gandhi called the shooting an act of insanity and Nehru regretted it. Independent India came to honour Udham Singh as a martyr, and his remains were brought home with state ceremony in 1974. The official death toll at Amritsar was 379; Indian estimates run to about a thousand. Whether he was present at the massacre, as tradition holds, cannot be proved.

1954

The guns open on Dien Bien Phu

Dien Bien Phu, north-western VietnamAsia

The French command had planted a fortified camp in a remote valley near the Laotian border, supplied by air, to draw the Viet Minh into a set battle. They assumed that their enemy could not bring heavy guns through the mountains. At about five in the afternoon of 13 March, artillery that General Vo Nguyen Giap’s men had hauled up by hand and dug into the hillsides opened fire, and the outlying strongpoint Beatrice fell that night. The airstrip was soon unusable. The French artillery commander, Colonel Charles Piroth, who had promised to silence any enemy guns, killed himself two days later. The garrison held for fifty-six days and surrendered on 7 May.

Seen from elsewhere. For Vietnam it is the victory that ended colonial rule, won as much by a quarter of a million porters as by soldiers. Vietnamese accounts say little about the Chinese guns, lorries and advisers, which Chinese accounts stress. Much of the ‘French’ garrison was Legionnaire, North African, West African, Tai or Vietnamese. Of roughly 11,000 men taken prisoner, only about a third came back.

Also on 13 March