Parallax

16 March, AD 37

The death of Tiberius

Rome’s second emperor died at seventy-seven in a villa on the Bay of Naples, either of old age or under a pile of bedclothes. The city he had not entered for eleven years celebrated.

Misenum, Bay of Naples, Italy

In the early spring of AD 37 the emperor Tiberius was travelling slowly along the coast of Campania, as he had many times before, approaching Rome and then turning away. He was seventy-seven, tall, stooped and bald, and he had ruled for twenty-two years. At a military festival at Circeii he insisted on throwing javelins at a boar in the arena, wrenched his side and caught a chill. He went on regardless, dining as usual, and reached the villa at Misenum that had once belonged to the millionaire general Lucullus. There his strength gave out.

With him were the two men who stood to gain most from his death: Gaius, his twenty-four-year-old great-nephew and heir, known as Caligula, and Macro, the commander of the Praetorian Guard. According to Tacitus, a doctor named Charicles took the old man’s hand on the pretext of saying goodbye, felt his pulse, and told Macro that he would not last two days.

What happened on 16 March is told in several ways. In Tacitus’s version, Tiberius stopped breathing and was taken for dead. Caligula was already receiving congratulations when word came that the emperor had revived and was asking for food. The courtiers scattered in terror; Caligula stood speechless; and Macro, unperturbed, ordered the old man to be smothered under a heap of blankets. Suetonius collects other versions: slow poison, starvation, a pillow. He also quotes the elder Seneca, a contemporary, for a quieter scene, in which Tiberius, feeling faint, took off his signet ring as if to hand it to someone, held it a while, put it back on his finger, called for attendants, and on getting no answer rose and fell dead beside the bed.

In Rome, Suetonius says, people ran through the streets shouting ‘To the Tiber with Tiberius!’ There was a proposal to deny him burial. In the event Caligula brought the body to the city with an escort of soldiers, delivered a tearful eulogy and gave it a public funeral. The Senate then set aside the will, which had named Caligula joint heir with the emperor’s own teenage grandson Gemellus, and gave everything to Caligula. Gemellus was dead within the year.

Tiberius left behind a full treasury, quiet frontiers and a reputation in ruins. For his last decade he had lived on Capri, governing by letter, while in Rome senators denounced each other for treason. The historians who wrote of him a lifetime later filled that island with stories of cruelty and elaborate debauchery. He was not, unlike his predecessor, declared a god.

How it came to this

Tiberius Claudius Nero was born in 42 BC into one of Rome’s oldest aristocratic families. When he was three his mother Livia divorced his father to marry the future emperor Augustus. He grew into the regime’s most reliable general, campaigning for years in the Alps, the Balkans and Germany. Augustus never warmed to him and preferred a series of other heirs. In 11 BC he compelled Tiberius to divorce a wife he loved, Vipsania, and marry Augustus’s daughter Julia. The marriage failed, and in 6 BC Tiberius abruptly withdrew to Rhodes for eight years. Only after the deaths of Augustus’s grandsons was he adopted, in AD 4, and he succeeded in AD 14 at the age of fifty-four.

He began cautiously, deferring to the Senate and refusing extravagant honours. Then came the death in AD 19 of his popular nephew Germanicus, for which many blamed him, and in 23 of his own son Drusus. He came to rely on the Praetorian prefect Sejanus, and in 26 he left Rome for good. In 31, warned that Sejanus was aiming at the throne, he destroyed him by a letter read out in the Senate. The purge that followed, and the discovery that Sejanus had probably poisoned Drusus, darkened his last years.

How each side saw it

The senatorial historians

Tacitus, writing about eighty years afterwards, made Tiberius the centre of the first six books of his Annals. His emperor is a hypocrite of great ability who concealed his nature while others restrained him and revealed it by stages as they died, until at last he gave way to crime and vice alike. Tacitus was a senator, and the treason trials, in which senators informed on senators and suicide was the usual way out, are his real subject. Suetonius, a palace official, supplies the anecdotes: the victims thrown from the cliffs of Capri, the troupes of young people kept for the emperor’s pleasure. Cassius Dio follows the same tradition.

Contemporaries and provincials

Those who wrote in his lifetime, or from outside Rome, tell it differently. Velleius Paterculus, an officer who had served under him for eight years, published a history in AD 30 that praises his justice, economy and care for the provinces; it is usually dismissed as flattery but it is a first-hand account. Philo of Alexandria, a Jewish philosopher writing a few years after the emperor’s death, looked back on the reign as a time of peace and good government across the empire. Tiberius is credited with telling a governor who wanted to raise taxes that a good shepherd shears his sheep and does not skin them.

The Jews of Rome and Judaea

For Jews the record was mixed, and comes mainly through Josephus and Philo. In AD 19 Tiberius expelled the Jewish community from Rome after a fraud scandal and had 4,000 men of military age sent to fight bandits in Sardinia, where, Tacitus remarks, their loss to the climate would be cheap. Philo blames the hostility on Sejanus and says the emperor reversed it after Sejanus fell. It was Tiberius who kept Pontius Pilate as prefect of Judaea for ten years, and who, by Philo’s account, rebuked him for offending Jewish law. The crucifixion of Jesus of Nazareth took place in his reign and went unnoticed in Rome.

Modern historians

Since the nineteenth century scholars have tried to get behind Tacitus. Ronald Syme showed how much of the portrait is shaped by literary design and by Tacitus’s experience of a later tyrant, Domitian. Robin Seager and Barbara Levick, in the standard modern biographies, describe a capable, conservative and embittered man, temperamentally unfit for a position that required charm, who presided over real judicial killings but far fewer than the tone of the Annals suggests. Most now treat the sexual stories from Capri as the kind of rumour that gathered around any ruler who shut himself away, impossible to prove or to refute.

What is disputed

The manner of death is the first problem: murder by Macro, murder by Caligula, or natural collapse, each with ancient authority. Seneca’s undramatic version is the earliest, and many historians prefer it, noting that a man of seventy-seven needed no help. The date of 16 March comes from Tacitus and Suetonius; Dio gives 26 March. The Capri stories rest on Suetonius and on hints in Tacitus. An inscribed decree of the Senate about the trial of Piso, found in Spain in the late 1980s, confirms Tacitus’s outline of that affair while showing how he rearranged it. Sayings attributed to Augustus about his successor’s ‘slow jaws’ are of uncertain worth.

What followed

Caligula was welcomed with joy, spent the treasury within about a year and was murdered by his own guards in 41. The system Tiberius had inherited outlasted them both. His reign had shown that the arrangement Augustus built around his own personality could be handed on, that the Senate would not recover its power, and that the Praetorian Guard, which he concentrated in a single camp in Rome on Sejanus’s advice, could make and unmake emperors. The treason law he allowed to grow became a standing weapon of later rulers. His name survives on the Sea of Galilee, where Herod Antipas founded the city of Tiberias in his honour.

Read further

  • Tacitus, Annals (Books 1-6)
  • Suetonius, The Twelve Caesars (Life of Tiberius)
  • Velleius Paterculus, Roman History
  • Robin Seager, Tiberius (1972)
  • Barbara Levick, Tiberius the Politician (1976)

Same day, other years

1190

The Jews of York die in the royal castle

York, EnglandEurope

Attacks on Jews had spread through England since riots at Richard I’s coronation the previous autumn, fanned by preaching for the crusade. In York a mob led by local landowners who owed money to Jewish lenders, Richard Malebisse foremost among them, plundered Jewish houses, and about 150 people took refuge in the wooden keep of the royal castle, where Clifford’s Tower now stands. They were besieged for days. On the night of 16 March, the eve of the Sabbath before Passover, Rabbi Yom Tov of Joigny urged them to die by their own hands sooner than be killed or forcibly baptised, and most did, the fathers killing their families first. Those who came out at dawn asking for baptism were murdered.

Seen from elsewhere. The fullest account is by a Christian, the canon William of Newburgh, who condemned the killers as driven by greed. The mob went straight to the Minster and burned the records of debts kept there. The Crown treated the affair as damage to royal property and fined the city; nobody was executed. Hebrew elegies preserve the Jewish memory of the dead as martyrs.

1521

Magellan’s ships sight the Philippines

Samar and Homonhon, PhilippinesAsia

After more than three months crossing an ocean far wider than anyone had guessed, with crews dying of scurvy and eating leather and rats, the three surviving ships of Ferdinand Magellan’s Spanish expedition raised the mountains of Samar on 16 March 1521. They anchored the next day at the small island of Homonhon to rest the sick. The first islanders they met brought fish, palm wine and coconuts. Magellan moved on to Cebu, where its ruler Humabon accepted baptism and an alliance. On 27 April Magellan was killed on the shore of nearby Mactan, attacking a chief named Lapulapu who had refused to submit. One ship eventually completed the voyage round the world.

Seen from elsewhere. No local account exists; the story depends on the Venetian passenger Antonio Pigafetta. Filipino memory has reversed its emphasis: Lapulapu is honoured as the first to resist foreign rule, and the official 500th anniversary in 2021 commemorated the ‘Victory at Mactan’ and the islanders’ hospitality, and avoided the word discovery. Spanish colonisation followed in 1565.

1968

The My Lai massacre

Son My, Quang Ngai province, South VietnamAsia

Soldiers of Charlie Company, 11th Brigade of the US Army’s Americal Division, were flown into the hamlet they called My Lai 4 expecting to meet a Viet Cong battalion. They met no resistance. Over about four hours they shot old men, women, children and babies, in their homes, on paths and in an irrigation ditch, and raped a number of women and girls. A helicopter pilot, Hugh Thompson, landed between the troops and a group of villagers and told his gunners to fire on the Americans if they went on. The army recorded a victory. The truth emerged in 1969 through a veteran’s letters and the reporter Seymour Hersh. One officer, Lieutenant William Calley, was convicted.

Seen from elsewhere. The army’s inquiry counted 347 dead; the Vietnamese memorial at Son My lists 504. Calley said he had followed his captain’s orders, and much of the American public saw him as a scapegoat; he served some three years, mostly under house arrest. Historians still dispute whether My Lai was an aberration or, as Nick Turse argues, an extreme case of a wider pattern.

1988

Poison gas falls on Halabja

Halabja, Iraqi KurdistanMiddle East

In the last months of the Iran-Iraq war, Kurdish fighters and Iranian troops took the town of Halabja, a few miles inside Iraq. On 16 March Iraqi aircraft bombed it for hours with conventional explosives and then with chemical weapons, mustard gas and nerve agents. Families died in cellars where they had sheltered from the bombs, and in the streets as they tried to flee. Between 3,200 and 5,000 people were killed and thousands more injured, nearly all civilians, in the largest chemical attack on a civilian population on record. It formed part of the Anfal campaign against Iraq’s Kurds directed by Saddam Hussein’s cousin Ali Hassan al-Majid, who was hanged for it in 2010.

Seen from elsewhere. Baghdad at first blamed Iran, and some American officials, whose government was then supporting Iraq, repeated the suggestion; later investigation, set out by Joost Hiltermann, found no basis for it. Western firms had supplied the chemical precursors, and a Dutch trader was convicted for it in 2005. Survivors complain that Saddam Hussein was executed for other crimes before he could be tried for Halabja.

Also on 16 March