Parallax

31 March, 1854

Perry’s treaty at Kanagawa

An American squadron, a model railway and a Confucian scholar who refused to be hurried: the agreement signed on a beach near Yokohama gave the United States much less than it had asked for, and set off the fall of the shoguns anyway.

Yokohama, Kanagawa, Japan

Commodore Matthew Perry had first appeared off Uraga, at the mouth of Edo Bay, on 8 July 1853 with two steam frigates and two sailing sloops. He refused to go to Nagasaki, where foreigners were supposed to be dealt with. He refused to see junior officials, and after six days was allowed to hand over a letter from President Millard Fillmore at Kurihama, in front of several thousand armed retainers. He said he would come back for the answer in the spring with more ships.

He came back early, in February 1854, eventually with nine vessels, about a quarter of the United States Navy. After weeks of haggling over where to meet, talks opened on 8 March in a timber hall built for the purpose at the fishing village of Yokohama. Perry landed with five hundred sailors and marines and three bands. The shogunate’s chief negotiator was Hayashi Akira, head of the Confucian academy in Edo. Neither side could speak the other’s language, so everything passed through Dutch and written Chinese.

Perry asked for kind treatment of shipwrecked sailors, ports where American ships could buy coal and provisions, and trade. Hayashi granted the first two with little argument. On trade he would not move. Japan, he said, had all it needed, and commerce was about profit; it had nothing to do with the saving of lives, which the commodore had declared to be his purpose. Perry, according to the Japanese record, thought for a while and dropped the demand.

Between sessions the two sides entertained each other. The Americans laid a circle of track and ran a quarter-size steam locomotive, on whose carriage roof samurai officials rode in their robes, and strung a mile of telegraph wire. The Japanese sent sacks of rice carried by sumo wrestlers. There was a banquet aboard the flagship Powhatan, at which one guest embraced Perry and crushed his epaulettes, and a blackface minstrel show put on by the crew.

The treaty was signed on 31 March 1854. Its twelve articles opened Shimoda at once and Hakodate a year later as ports of call for supplies, promised help to castaways, gave the United States any privilege later granted to another power, and allowed for an American consul at Shimoda. The English and Japanese texts did not agree on whether that consul needed the consent of both governments or only of one.

How it came to this

In the 1630s the Tokugawa shoguns expelled the Portuguese, suppressed Christianity and forbade Japanese to travel abroad on pain of death. But the country was never sealed. Dutch merchants traded from the artificial island of Dejima at Nagasaki, Chinese ships came to the same port, and Japan dealt with Korea through Tsushima, with the Ryukyu kingdom through Satsuma and with the Ainu through Matsumae. The word sakoku, ‘closed country’, was coined only in 1801, by a Nagasaki scholar translating a European book. Through the Dutch, officials in Edo knew about the Opium War and knew a year ahead that Perry was coming.

The Americans had their own reasons. Hundreds of whaling ships worked the seas off Japan, and crews wrecked there had been confined, sometimes harshly, before being handed to the Dutch. With California acquired in 1848, a steamship route to Shanghai needed coaling stations. Earlier approaches had failed: the merchant ship Morrison was fired on in 1837, and Commodore Biddle was turned away in 1846. Perry, a veteran of the Mexican War and a promoter of steam, resolved to succeed by ceremony and the open display of force.

How each side saw it

The shogunate’s officials

The Japanese negotiating record shows men who knew they could not fight and meant to give away as little as possible. Abe Masahiro, the senior councillor, had taken the unprecedented step of circulating Fillmore’s letter to all the feudal lords and asking their views; most wanted the Americans refused but could not say how. Abe’s answer was to concede ports of refuge, avoid war, and buy time to build coastal forts and a navy. By that measure Hayashi did well: no trade, no residence in Edo, two remote harbours. The cost was to the government’s authority, which had rested on the claim that it alone decided such things.

Perry and the United States

The official Narrative of the expedition, compiled by Francis Hawks under Perry’s eye, presents a firm but peaceful mission that brought a secluded people into the community of nations without firing a shot. Perry believed dignity and stubbornness were the keys: he stayed out of sight in his cabin and let it be known that he would go to Edo itself if refused. He regarded the Japanese as clever and curious and expected them to rival the West in manufactures. He also seized the opportunity to press a separate compact on the Ryukyu kingdom and to stake a claim in the Bonin Islands. He came home to public honours.

The ‘expel the barbarians’ party

Tokugawa Nariaki, lord of Mito and the shogun’s kinsman, wrote in his memorial of 1853 that to yield under threat would destroy the nation’s spirit and invite endless further demands, and that war, even a losing one, was better. Younger samurai drew a sharper conclusion: a government that could not keep foreigners out had forfeited its right to rule. Yoshida Shoin tried to stow away on Perry’s ship at Shimoda to study the enemy, was jailed, and went on to teach several of the men who overthrew the shogunate. A popular comic verse punned that four cups of strong tea, or four steamships, were enough to end a peaceful sleep.

Historians of the ‘opening’

The older American story had Perry unlocking a hermit kingdom. Ronald Toby and others have shown that Tokugawa foreign relations were managed and selective, not closed. Japanese scholars such as Mitani Hiroshi stress the shogunate’s own debates and its good intelligence. William McOmie and others point out that Russia’s Admiral Putiatin was negotiating at Nagasaki in the same months, and that Britain, Russia and the Netherlands had their own agreements by 1856. On this reading Perry hastened a change already close, and the true rupture was the commercial treaty of 1858.

What is disputed

Whether the treaty ‘opened’ Japan is the main dispute: it permitted no trade and no foreign residents beyond a consul. Accounts differ on how many ships Perry had in 1854, since vessels came and went; seven arrived in February and nine or ten were present by the signing. The claim that castaways were routinely executed is not supported by the record; they were held and repatriated through Nagasaki, though some died in confinement. How far Perry would really have used force is unknown. His orders from Washington allowed it only in self-defence, a limit he did not advertise.

What followed

The consul, Townsend Harris, arrived in 1856 and two years later obtained a full commercial treaty with fixed low tariffs and immunity from Japanese courts for Americans. Similar treaties with European powers followed. The minister who signed them without the emperor’s consent, Ii Naosuke, was cut down outside Edo castle in 1860. Rising prices, assassinations and civil war ended the shogunate in 1868. The new Meiji government made the revision of the unequal treaties its first aim, and built the army, navy and industry to achieve it. In 1945 the flag Perry had flown in Edo Bay was displayed on the battleship Missouri at Japan’s surrender.

Read further

  • Francis L. Hawks, Narrative of the Expedition of an American Squadron to the China Seas and Japan (1856)
  • Peter Booth Wiley, Yankees in the Land of the Gods: Commodore Perry and the Opening of Japan (1990)
  • Ronald P. Toby, State and Diplomacy in Early Modern Japan (1984)
  • Mitani Hiroshi, Escape from Impasse: The Decision to Open Japan (2006)
  • Marius B. Jansen, The Making of Modern Japan (2000)

Same day, other years

1492

Spain orders its Jews to leave

Granada, SpainEurope

Three months after taking Granada, the last Muslim kingdom in Iberia, Ferdinand of Aragon and Isabella of Castile signed an edict in the Alhambra giving every Jew in their realms until the end of July to accept baptism or go. Those who left could take no gold, silver or coin. The stated reason was that Jews were drawing converted Christians back to their old faith, which the Inquisition had been pursuing since 1480. Communities that had lived in Spain for more than a thousand years sold houses and vineyards for almost nothing. Many crossed into Portugal, where they were forcibly baptised five years later; others reached North Africa, Italy and the Ottoman empire.

Seen from elsewhere. The courtier Isaac Abravanel, who pleaded with the monarchs and offered money, recorded the expulsion as a catastrophe comparable to the fall of Jerusalem. Numbers are disputed: older estimates of 150,000 or more exiles have been cut by Henry Kamen and others to perhaps 40,000 to 50,000, with a larger number converting. Spain revoked the edict in 1968.

1889

Eiffel climbs his tower

Paris, FranceEurope

On 31 March 1889 Gustave Eiffel led a party of officials and journalists up the 1,710 steps of the iron tower his firm had built on the Champ de Mars, and unfurled a large tricolour at the top. The lifts were not yet working. The tower was the gateway to the world’s fair marking the centenary of the French Revolution. At 300 metres it was almost twice the height of any earlier structure, assembled in a little over two years from some 18,000 prefabricated parts and two and a half million rivets. Nearly two million people went up it during the exhibition. It was meant to stand for twenty years and was saved by its usefulness as a radio mast.

Seen from elsewhere. In 1887 a group of artists and writers including Maupassant, Gounod and the architect Charles Garnier published a protest against a ‘useless and monstrous’ factory chimney disfiguring Paris. The design itself was first sketched by two of Eiffel’s engineers, Maurice Koechlin and Emile Nouguier, with the architect Stephen Sauvestre; Eiffel bought their rights and gave it his name.

1917

Denmark hands over its Caribbean islands

Charlotte Amalie, St ThomasThe Americas

At four in the afternoon the Danish flag was lowered over the fort at Charlotte Amalie and the Stars and Stripes raised. For 25 million dollars in gold the United States had bought St Thomas, St John and St Croix, sugar colonies Denmark had held since the seventeenth century and no longer found profitable. Washington, about to enter the First World War, wanted the harbour kept out of German hands. Danish voters had approved the sale in a referendum. The islands’ 26,000 people, most of them descendants of enslaved Africans, had no binding vote, though an unofficial poll on St Croix organised by the labour leader David Hamilton Jackson backed the transfer overwhelmingly.

Seen from elsewhere. Many islanders hoped American rule would bring better wages and rights than Danish planters had allowed. Instead the territory was run by naval officers until 1931, citizenship came only in 1927, and residents still cannot vote for president. At the centenary in 2017 Denmark’s prime minister called the slave past unforgivable; he made no formal apology.

1964

The army moves against Goulart

Juiz de Fora and Rio de Janeiro, BrazilThe Americas

Before dawn on 31 March 1964 General Olimpio Mourao Filho set his troops marching from Juiz de Fora towards Rio de Janeiro. President Joao Goulart had spent the month announcing land reform and the nationalisation of oil refineries at mass rallies and siding with mutinous sailors against their officers. Units sent to stop the rebels joined them. Goulart flew from Rio to Brasilia and then to the south, decided against a civil war, and crossed into Uruguay. Congress declared his office vacant while he was still in the country. Marshal Castelo Branco became president. The generals stayed in power for twenty-one years, during which a national truth commission later counted 434 people killed or disappeared.

Seen from elsewhere. The officers and their many civilian supporters, including much of the press and the Church hierarchy, called it a revolution that saved Brazil from communism. Opponents say the takeover was completed on 1 April and backdated to avoid April Fools’ Day. American records show that Washington had a naval force on its way to help the plotters, which proved unnecessary.

Also on 31 March