Parallax

3 March, 1513

Ponce de Leon sails for Bimini, and not for a fountain

The voyage that gave Florida its name set out from Puerto Rico under a royal contract about land, gold and labour. The magic spring was attached to it by a hostile chronicler after its commander was dead.

San German, Puerto Rico

Three ships left the west coast of Puerto Rico in the first days of March 1513: the Santiago, the San Cristobal and the Santa Maria de la Consolacion. Their owner and commander, Juan Ponce de Leon, was a veteran of nearly twenty years in the Indies. He had helped put down the Taino of eastern Hispaniola, had led the conquest of Puerto Rico in 1508 and governed it, and had grown rich there from gold washed and fields worked by Taino labourers assigned to him. He had then lost the governorship, not through any failure but because the courts in Spain upheld the hereditary claim of Diego Columbus, the admiral’s son.

King Ferdinand, who disliked the Columbus claim, offered a consolation. A contract dated 23 February 1512 licensed Ponce to find and settle, at his own expense, an island called Bimini that was rumoured to lie to the north-west. The document is detailed about the division of gold, the title of adelantado and the allotment of the natives. It says nothing about any spring.

The pilot was Anton de Alaminos, the best in the Caribbean. The ships worked north-west through the Bahamas, whose Lucayan people had already been carried off almost to the last by slavers supplying Hispaniola. On 27 March, Easter Sunday, the lookouts saw land. In the first days of April Ponce went ashore somewhere on the Atlantic coast of the peninsula and took possession. He called it La Florida, because it was the season Spaniards call Pascua Florida, the Easter of flowers, and because the shore was green and level.

Turning south, the ships met a current so strong that with a fair wind they were driven backwards. Alaminos remembered it; six years later he used the Gulf Stream to carry Cortes’s first treasure to Spain, and it became the homeward road of every Spanish fleet. The ships rounded the Keys and went up the Gulf coast, where they met the Calusa. Trade turned to fighting within days, and one man among the Calusa addressed the Spaniards in their own language, a sign that slavers or castaways had been there first.

Ponce was back in Puerto Rico by October, sailed to Spain and was confirmed as adelantado of Florida and Bimini. He did not return until 1521, with two ships, some two hundred settlers, priests, horses and seed. The Calusa attacked the landing. An arrow struck him in the thigh, the colony was abandoned, and he died of the wound in Havana that July.

How it came to this

By 1513 the Spanish had been in the Caribbean for twenty years and had run through its people. The Taino of Hispaniola, perhaps several hundred thousand in 1492, though estimates vary enormously, had been reduced to a few tens of thousands by forced labour in the gold streams, hunger, flight and disease. Puerto Rico followed the same course; a Taino rising there in 1511, led by the cacique Agueybana, was put down by Ponce himself. Colonists short of workers sent ships to raid the Bahamas and the mainland coasts for captives. Exploration and slaving were hard to tell apart, and every new island was assessed for both gold and hands.

The crown did not pay for these ventures. It issued contracts, called capitulaciones, under which a private captain bore the cost and received titles and a share of whatever he found. The system rewarded men who moved fast and claimed much. It also meant that a captain out of favour, as Ponce was after the Columbus ruling, had strong reason to find somewhere new where the admiral’s heirs had no rights.

How each side saw it

The Calusa and their neighbours

The Calusa of south-west Florida left no writing. They were a fishing people without agriculture who nonetheless supported a king, a priesthood and large shell-built towns such as Mound Key, and they took tribute from much of the southern peninsula. What is known of them comes from archaeology and from Spaniards, above all Hernando de Escalante Fontaneda, who was shipwrecked as a boy around 1549 and lived among them for seventeen years. Their response in 1513 and 1521 was consistent: they would trade briefly and then fight. They kept the Spanish out of their country for nearly two centuries, until disease and slave raids from the English colonies destroyed them in the early 1700s.

The Taino of Puerto Rico

The wealth that paid for the three ships came from the encomienda, the grant of Taino villagers to work for a Spanish master. The Taino side reaches us only through Spanish writers, most forcefully Bartolome de las Casas, who knew many of the conquerors and described Ponce’s wars on Hispaniola and Puerto Rico as slaughter, including the use of a war dog, Becerrillo, against the Taino. Spanish chroniclers of the opposite temper praised the same campaigns as pacification. Puerto Rico today has both a city named for Ponce’s family and a movement of people who identify as Taino descendants and object to his statue in San Juan.

Oviedo and the Spanish chroniclers

The fountain appears in print in 1535, fourteen years after Ponce’s death, in the history of Gonzalo Fernandez de Oviedo, who says the captain went looking for a spring that made old men young and treats it as proof of his vanity and foolishness. Some historians suspect that Oviedo, who courted the Columbus family, had no wish to flatter their rival. Francisco Lopez de Gomara repeated the tale in 1551, Fontaneda added that he himself had bathed in many Florida rivers without effect, and in 1601 the royal historian Antonio de Herrera wove it into what became the standard account of the voyage.

Modern historians

Most scholars now hold that the fountain was not the purpose of the voyage and may not have been in Ponce’s mind at all. They point to the silence of the contract and of his own surviving letters, and to the lateness and hostility of Oviedo. Robert Fuson and Douglas Peck, among others, also stress that Ponce was probably not the first European to see Florida: the Cantino map of 1502 shows a peninsula in roughly the right place, and slaving voyages leave few records. The story survived because it was good, and because Washington Irving and Florida’s tourist trade retold it.

What is disputed

Herrera, writing ninety years later from a log now lost, gives 3 March for the departure; some reconstructions prefer the 4th, treating the 3rd as the day of embarkation. The landing place is unknown: St Augustine claims it, but Peck’s reconstruction of the track puts it near Melbourne Beach, far to the south, and others favour Ponce de Leon Inlet. His birth year is given as 1460 or 1474, which matters to the legend, since the later date makes him under forty when he sailed. Whether he was on Columbus’s second voyage, as often stated, rests on a single chronicler. The free African conquistador Juan Garrido later testified that he took part in the Florida voyage.

What followed

Spain made no lasting settlement in Florida until 1565, when Pedro Menendez de Aviles founded St Augustine, in part to destroy a French Protestant colony nearby. The name La Florida was applied for a time to the whole south-east of North America. Slaving along its coasts began within a few years of 1513 and carried diseases ahead of any colony. The peninsula passed to Britain, back to Spain and in 1821 to the United States. The fountain became an emblem of the state, with a tourist park in St Augustine that has sold cups of well water since the early 1900s.

Read further

  • Robert H. Fuson, Juan Ponce de Leon and the Spanish Discovery of Puerto Rico and Florida (2000)
  • Antonio de Herrera y Tordesillas, Historia general de los hechos de los castellanos (1601)
  • Gonzalo Fernandez de Oviedo, Historia general y natural de las Indias (1535)
  • Jerald T. Milanich, Florida Indians and the Invasion from Europe (1995)
  • Samuel Eliot Morison, The European Discovery of America: The Southern Voyages (1974)

Same day, other years

1575

The Mughals break the Afghan sultanate of Bengal at Tukaroi

Tukaroi, Odisha, IndiaAsia

Bengal and Bihar were ruled by an Afghan dynasty, the Karranis, whose young sultan Daud Khan had stopped acknowledging the emperor Akbar and had coins struck in his own name. Akbar’s general Munim Khan, with the Hindu revenue minister Raja Todar Mal as his deputy, pursued Daud south into Orissa and met him near the village of Tukaroi. The Afghan vanguard under Gujar Khan, led by elephants, smashed the Mughal centre and wounded the elderly Munim Khan, who was carried from the field. Gujar Khan was then killed by an arrow, Todar Mal held the wing together, and the Afghan army broke. Daud made peace, keeping only Orissa.

Seen from elsewhere. The fullest account is Abul Fazl’s Akbarnama, the emperor’s official history, in which Daud is a rebel receiving correction. Afghan histories written later treat him as a legitimate king. The peace lasted months: Daud retook Bengal, and was captured and beheaded in 1576. Bengal’s local chiefs fought the Mughals for another generation.

1861

Alexander II frees Russia’s serfs

St Petersburg, RussiaEurope

On 19 February by the Russian calendar, 3 March in the West, the tsar signed a manifesto ending the legal bondage of some 23 million people owned by private landlords. They could now marry, trade, own property and go to court without a master’s leave. Defeat in the Crimean War had convinced Alexander that it was better, as he told the Moscow nobility, to abolish serfdom from above than wait for it to abolish itself from below. The announcement was held back for two weeks and troops were moved into the capitals before priests read it out in the churches. The land, however, was not given: peasants were to buy their allotments through payments spread over forty-nine years.

Seen from elsewhere. Many peasants were sure the real decree, granting land freely, was being hidden by the gentry. At Bezdna in April soldiers fired on a crowd that believed this, killing at least fifty by the official count. Landowners complained of ruin. Alexander Herzen, in exile, first hailed the tsar and then called the settlement a new serfdom.

1924

Turkey abolishes the caliphate

Ankara, TurkeyMiddle East

The Grand National Assembly voted to abolish an office that Ottoman sultans had claimed for four centuries and that many Sunni Muslims regarded as the succession to the Prophet’s leadership of the community. The sultanate had been ended in 1922; the last caliph, Abdulmejid II, a painter and musician with no political power, had held the religious title alone since then. That night police put him and his family in cars to a station outside Istanbul and onto a train for Switzerland. Every member of the Ottoman dynasty was expelled. The same day the assembly closed the ministry of religious law and placed all schools, including the madrasas, under the state.

Seen from elsewhere. Mustafa Kemal’s supporters argued that sovereignty belonged to the nation and that a caliph was a standing invitation to foreign meddling and domestic reaction. In India the Khilafat movement, which had campaigned for the caliph’s protection, collapsed. Sharif Hussein of Mecca claimed the title and found little support. Later Islamist movements have treated 3 March as the date of a wound.

1991

Los Angeles police are filmed beating Rodney King

Los Angeles, United StatesThe Americas

After a car chase that ended in the San Fernando Valley shortly after midnight, four Los Angeles police officers struck a Black motorist, Rodney King, more than fifty times with batons and kicked him as he lay on the ground, while other officers stood by. A plumber named George Holliday, woken by the noise, filmed it from his balcony with a new video camera and gave the tape to a local television station. King was left with facial fractures and a broken leg. The four officers were tried for assault in a mostly white suburb. Their acquittal on 29 April 1992 set off six days of rioting in which more than sixty people died.

Seen from elsewhere. The officers said King, who had been drinking and was on parole, kept trying to get up, and that they followed their training. An official commission found a pattern of excessive force and racist language in the department. Two officers were later convicted on federal charges. Korean-American shopkeepers, whose businesses bore much of the destruction, remember the riots as their own abandonment.

Also on 3 March