Parallax

23 March, 1801

Tsar Paul is strangled in his new castle

He had built a moated fortress in St Petersburg to keep assassins out. He had lived in it for forty days when his own officers walked into his bedroom.

St Michael’s Castle, St Petersburg

On the evening of 11 March 1801 by the Russian calendar, 23 March in the west, the Emperor Paul dined with nineteen people in his new residence, St Michael’s Castle, whose walls were still so damp that fog hung in the rooms. His eldest son Alexander was at the table. Paul was in good humour and admired a new porcelain service painted with views of the castle. Earlier that day he had dismissed the Horse Guards picket at his door, whose colonel he distrusted, leaving two valets in the antechamber. Afterwards he went to his bedroom, where the door leading to his wife’s apartments had been locked and bolted on his own orders.

Across the city, at the quarters of General Talyzin, some fifty or sixty officers were drinking champagne. Their host was Count Peter von der Pahlen, military governor of the capital and the man the emperor trusted with his safety. With him were Platon Zubov, last favourite of Catherine the Great, his brothers, and Leonty Bennigsen, a tall Hanoverian general. Pahlen told them that the emperor must be made to abdicate. Asked what would happen if he resisted, he is said to have answered that one cannot make an omelette without breaking eggs.

Towards midnight they set out in two columns. Pahlen’s took the long way round and arrived when it was over. The other, led by Bennigsen and the Zubovs, was let in over the drawbridge by an adjutant, and shed men at every turn of the stairs. About a dozen reached the antechamber. One valet was cut down and the other ran. The bed was empty but warm. Bennigsen found the emperor in his nightshirt behind a fire screen.

Accounts of the next minutes differ, since everyone present had reason to lie. Paul was told he was under arrest and must sign an act of abdication. He argued, raised his voice, perhaps pushed someone. Nikolai Zubov, a huge man and drunk, struck him on the left temple with a gold snuffbox. He fell, the lamp went out, and in the dark a group of officers finished it with a sash. Bennigsen always maintained that he had stepped out of the room to fetch a light.

Alexander, aged 23, was waiting in his rooms on the floor below. He had been told that his father would be deposed and confined, not killed, and had chosen to believe it. When Pahlen brought the news he broke down. Memoirs have Pahlen telling him to stop being a child and go and reign. He showed himself to the guards and said that his father had died of an apoplectic stroke and that everything would be as it had been under his grandmother. St Petersburg lit its windows that night as if for a festival.

How it came to this

Paul was born in 1754 to the future Catherine II and her husband Peter, though court gossip named another father. When he was seven his mother took the throne in a coup and his father was killed by her supporters within days. She kept Paul from power for thirty-four years and was thought to intend that the crown should pass over him to her grandson Alexander. He waited at Gatchina, drilling a private army in Prussian uniforms. On her death in 1796 he had his father’s remains exhumed, crowned and buried beside her.

As emperor he fixed the succession by law in the male line, limited the labour peasants owed their lords to three days a week, and set about disciplining the nobility and the Guards: officers were exiled or flogged for faults on parade, and nobles lost exemptions granted by Catherine’s charter. He banned round hats, waistcoats and foreign books. In foreign policy he joined the coalition against France, then quarrelled with Britain over Malta, embargoed British trade, and in January 1801 ordered the Don Cossacks to march on India.

How each side saw it

The conspirators

Bennigsen left a written account and Pahlen talked years later to the emigre general Langeron, who took notes. Both present the plot as a patriotic necessity: the emperor was deranged, no one’s rank, liberty or back was safe, the break with England was ruining the landowners who exported grain and timber, and the heir had consented. Both shift the killing itself onto drunken subordinates and insist that only abdication was intended. Pahlen admitted, however, that he had frightened Paul with tales of a conspiracy involving the empress and her sons in order to obtain arrest warrants that he then showed to Alexander.

A loyal officer, Nikolai Sablukov

Sablukov, the Horse Guards colonel whose picket was sent away that evening, wrote reminiscences later published in English. He describes a ruler who was irritable and suspicious but also chivalrous, just to subordinates who stood up to him, and hated chiefly by a pampered aristocracy for making it serve. The rank and file, he says, were not sorry for the officers and received the news in sullen silence; his own troopers at first refused the oath to Alexander until they had been shown the body. Paul’s widow, Maria Feodorovna, never forgave the conspirators and saw to it that Pahlen was banished to his estates.

Paris and London

Napoleon, who had been negotiating an alliance with Paul, blamed Britain at once. He is reported to have said that the English had missed him in Paris, referring to the bomb plot of December 1800, but had not missed him in St Petersburg. The link usually cited is Olga Zherebtsova, sister of the Zubovs and mistress of Lord Whitworth, the British ambassador expelled in 1800. No document showing British payment has been found. The death certainly served London: news of it reached the Baltic just after Nelson’s attack on Copenhagen, and the league of northern powers against Britain collapsed.

What is disputed

Whether Paul was mad is the oldest question. Nineteenth-century memoirs, written by the class he had offended, say so; Roderick McGrew and the contributors to Hugh Ragsdale’s reassessment see an obsessive but coherent ruler with a programme, and the Russian historian Natan Eidelman called the reign an attempt at unenlightened absolutism. How much Alexander knew is the second question: he knew of the plot, and whether he believed the promise to spare his father cannot be shown. The details in the bedroom, including who struck first and whose sash was used, vary from memoir to memoir. The murder took place around or just after midnight, so some date it to 24 March.

What followed

Alexander made peace with Britain, recalled the Cossacks and restored the nobility’s privileges. None of the conspirators was tried; Pahlen and Platon Zubov were quietly removed from court. The guilt is often said to have marked the new emperor’s whole reign and his later turn to mysticism. In Russia the official cause of death remained apoplexy, and the facts could not be printed until 1905. Paul’s succession law governed the dynasty to its end in 1917. It was the last of the eighteenth-century palace coups; when Guards officers next rose, in December 1825, they wanted a constitution.

Read further

  • Roderick E. McGrew, Paul I of Russia, 1754-1801 (1992)
  • Hugh Ragsdale (ed.), Paul I: A Reassessment of His Life and Reign (1979)
  • Marie-Pierre Rey, Alexander I: The Tsar Who Defeated Napoleon (2012)
  • N. A. Sablukov, ‘Reminiscences of the Court and Times of the Emperor Paul I of Russia’, Fraser’s Magazine (1865)

Same day, other years

1919

Mussolini founds the Fasci di Combattimento

Milan, ItalyEurope

On 23 March 1919 Benito Mussolini, a former socialist editor expelled from his party for supporting Italy’s entry into the war, gathered a meeting in a hall on the Piazza San Sepolcro in Milan lent by a businessmen’s association. Perhaps a hundred or two hundred people came: ex-servicemen from the assault troops, Futurist artists, nationalists and dissident syndicalists. They founded the Fasci Italiani di Combattimento. The programme published that June was radical: votes for women, an eight-hour day, a heavy tax on capital, seizure of war profits and abolition of the Senate. In the elections of November 1919 the movement did not win a single seat.

Seen from elsewhere. Italian socialists met the movement first as violence: three weeks after the meeting its supporters burned the Milan offices of the party newspaper Avanti! Once in power, the regime turned the founding into legend, and thousands claimed the title of sansepolcrista. The early left-wing programme was dropped as landowners and industrialists began funding the squads in 1920-21.

1931

Bhagat Singh is hanged in Lahore

Lahore, British IndiaAsia

Bhagat Singh, Shivaram Rajguru and Sukhdev Thapar, members of the Hindustan Socialist Republican Association, were hanged in Lahore Central Jail on the evening of 23 March 1931, hours ahead of the scheduled time. Singh was 23. They had been convicted of shooting dead a young police officer, John Saunders, in 1928, in mistaken revenge for the death of the nationalist leader Lala Lajpat Rai after a police baton charge. Singh had since made himself famous by throwing harmless bombs in the Central Assembly and by a long hunger strike for the rights of political prisoners. The bodies were removed secretly and cremated by the Sutlej at night.

Seen from elsewhere. The British authorities treated the case as the murder of two policemen, and tried it before a special tribunal created by ordinance, without the accused present. Gandhi, who had just concluded a pact with the viceroy, Lord Irwin, pleaded for commutation but did not make it a condition, and was met with black flags at the Karachi Congress. Both India and Pakistan now claim Singh.

1933

The Reichstag hands Hitler the power to legislate

Berlin, GermanyEurope

The German parliament met on 23 March 1933 in the Kroll Opera House, its own building having burned a month before. Stormtroopers lined the aisles and chanted outside. The bill before it allowed the government to enact laws, including laws that departed from the constitution, without parliament. The 81 Communist deputies had been arrested or driven into hiding, as had a number of Social Democrats. The Catholic Centre Party, after promises from Hitler that were never put in writing, voted in favour. The count was 444 to 94. Only the Social Democrats voted against, and their leader Otto Wels told the chamber that freedom and life could be taken from them, but not honour.

Seen from elsewhere. Centre Party members later said they had acted under threat and hoped to keep some hold on events. Historians dispute whether the party chairman, the priest Ludwig Kaas, traded its votes for the prospect of a concordat with the Vatican, signed that July: Klaus Scholder argued for a connection, Konrad Repgen against. The National Socialists presented the vote as a legal revolution.

1982

A coup brings Rios Montt to power in Guatemala

Guatemala City, GuatemalaThe Americas

On 23 March 1982 junior army officers surrounded the national palace and removed General Romeo Lucas Garcia, two weeks after an election widely seen as rigged. They installed a junta headed by the retired general Efrain Rios Montt, a convert to an evangelical church who preached to the nation on television each Sunday. He soon ruled alone. Over the next seventeen months the army carried the war against left-wing guerrillas into the Maya highlands, destroying hundreds of villages, killing their inhabitants and resettling survivors under military control. A truth commission sponsored by the United Nations concluded in 1999 that agents of the state had committed acts of genocide in those years.

Seen from elsewhere. Supporters credit him with curbing death squads in the capital and defeating an insurgency; President Reagan said in December 1982 that he was getting a bum rap. Maya survivors testified at his trial in 2013, when a Guatemalan court convicted him of genocide. The constitutional court annulled the verdict within days, and he died in 2018 during a retrial.

Also on 23 March