The jury at the federal courthouse in Foley Square had been out overnight. At eleven in the morning on 29 March 1951 its foreman announced that Julius Rosenberg, Ethel Rosenberg and their co-defendant Morton Sobell were guilty of conspiracy to commit espionage. The charge was not treason, which the Constitution reserves for aid to an enemy in wartime; the Soviet Union had been an ally when the acts took place. But the 1917 Espionage Act allowed death for the offence in time of war, and Judge Irving Kaufman thanked the jurors for a verdict he said was his own.
The trial had lasted three weeks. Julius was 32, an electrical engineer, the son of garment workers from the Lower East Side, dismissed from an army Signal Corps job in 1945 for concealing his Communist Party membership. Ethel, 35, had been a clerk and union organiser and now kept house for their two small sons. The prosecution, led by Irving Saypol with a 24-year-old assistant named Roy Cohn, said Julius ran a ring of informants and had drawn in Ethel’s younger brother, David Greenglass, an army machinist at the Los Alamos bomb laboratory.
Greenglass was the chief witness. He described handing over sketches of the lens moulds used to detonate the plutonium bomb. A courier, Harry Gold, who had also carried material from the physicist Klaus Fuchs, told of knocking at the Greenglasses’ door in Albuquerque with half a cut-up Jell-O box as his token. Then came the testimony that bound Ethel to the plot: David and his wife Ruth both swore that in September 1945 Ethel had sat at a portable typewriter in the Rosenbergs’ flat and typed up David’s handwritten notes on the bomb.
The Rosenbergs denied everything and refused, on Fifth Amendment grounds, to say whether they were Communists, which did them no good with the jury. Their lawyer, Emanuel Bloch, made the fateful request that Greenglass’s sketch be sealed from the public, so conceding that it was a real secret.
On 5 April Kaufman sentenced both to death. He told them their crime was worse than murder and held them responsible for the Korean War and its casualties. Sobell got thirty years; Greenglass, fifteen; Ruth was never charged. After two years of appeals and worldwide protest, with clemency refused by President Eisenhower, the couple were electrocuted at Sing Sing on the evening of 19 June 1953, minutes before the Jewish Sabbath began. Julius died at the first shock. Ethel was still alive after the standard three, and two more were applied.
How it came to this
The Soviet Union exploded its first atomic bomb in August 1949, years before American officials had expected. That same year China fell to the Communists; in February 1950 Fuchs confessed in London and Senator Joseph McCarthy made his first accusations; in June war began in Korea. Fuchs’s confession led the FBI to Gold, Gold to Greenglass, and Greenglass, arrested in June 1950, named his brother-in-law. Julius was arrested in July and Ethel in August.
Behind the arrests lay a source the government could not use in court. From 1946 army codebreakers in the project later called Venona had been reading fragments of wartime Soviet intelligence cables. They showed an agent, code-named Antenna and then Liberal, running a network of engineers in New York, and identified him as Julius Rosenberg. Ethel had no code name. The government’s internal papers show that her arrest was meant as a lever to make her husband talk. FBI director J. Edgar Hoover himself advised against executing the mother of two young children. Neither Rosenberg ever named anyone.