Parallax

29 March, 1951

The Rosenbergs are found guilty

A New York jury convicted a married couple of conspiring to give atomic secrets to the Soviet Union. Decades later the files showed that he had been a spy and that the evidence which sent her to the electric chair was invented.

New York City, United States

The jury at the federal courthouse in Foley Square had been out overnight. At eleven in the morning on 29 March 1951 its foreman announced that Julius Rosenberg, Ethel Rosenberg and their co-defendant Morton Sobell were guilty of conspiracy to commit espionage. The charge was not treason, which the Constitution reserves for aid to an enemy in wartime; the Soviet Union had been an ally when the acts took place. But the 1917 Espionage Act allowed death for the offence in time of war, and Judge Irving Kaufman thanked the jurors for a verdict he said was his own.

The trial had lasted three weeks. Julius was 32, an electrical engineer, the son of garment workers from the Lower East Side, dismissed from an army Signal Corps job in 1945 for concealing his Communist Party membership. Ethel, 35, had been a clerk and union organiser and now kept house for their two small sons. The prosecution, led by Irving Saypol with a 24-year-old assistant named Roy Cohn, said Julius ran a ring of informants and had drawn in Ethel’s younger brother, David Greenglass, an army machinist at the Los Alamos bomb laboratory.

Greenglass was the chief witness. He described handing over sketches of the lens moulds used to detonate the plutonium bomb. A courier, Harry Gold, who had also carried material from the physicist Klaus Fuchs, told of knocking at the Greenglasses’ door in Albuquerque with half a cut-up Jell-O box as his token. Then came the testimony that bound Ethel to the plot: David and his wife Ruth both swore that in September 1945 Ethel had sat at a portable typewriter in the Rosenbergs’ flat and typed up David’s handwritten notes on the bomb.

The Rosenbergs denied everything and refused, on Fifth Amendment grounds, to say whether they were Communists, which did them no good with the jury. Their lawyer, Emanuel Bloch, made the fateful request that Greenglass’s sketch be sealed from the public, so conceding that it was a real secret.

On 5 April Kaufman sentenced both to death. He told them their crime was worse than murder and held them responsible for the Korean War and its casualties. Sobell got thirty years; Greenglass, fifteen; Ruth was never charged. After two years of appeals and worldwide protest, with clemency refused by President Eisenhower, the couple were electrocuted at Sing Sing on the evening of 19 June 1953, minutes before the Jewish Sabbath began. Julius died at the first shock. Ethel was still alive after the standard three, and two more were applied.

How it came to this

The Soviet Union exploded its first atomic bomb in August 1949, years before American officials had expected. That same year China fell to the Communists; in February 1950 Fuchs confessed in London and Senator Joseph McCarthy made his first accusations; in June war began in Korea. Fuchs’s confession led the FBI to Gold, Gold to Greenglass, and Greenglass, arrested in June 1950, named his brother-in-law. Julius was arrested in July and Ethel in August.

Behind the arrests lay a source the government could not use in court. From 1946 army codebreakers in the project later called Venona had been reading fragments of wartime Soviet intelligence cables. They showed an agent, code-named Antenna and then Liberal, running a network of engineers in New York, and identified him as Julius Rosenberg. Ethel had no code name. The government’s internal papers show that her arrest was meant as a lever to make her husband talk. FBI director J. Edgar Hoover himself advised against executing the mother of two young children. Neither Rosenberg ever named anyone.

How each side saw it

The prosecution and the court

The government’s position was that the Rosenbergs had handed Stalin the most dangerous weapon in history and shortened the American monopoly by years. Kaufman’s sentencing speech put it in those terms and blamed them for more than 50,000 American casualties in Korea. Officials also held that the couple had their lives in their own hands: a confession and names would have brought commutation, and a telephone line to Washington was kept open at Sing Sing on the last night. Later disclosures showed that Kaufman discussed the sentence privately with the prosecutors before imposing it, which the rules of his office forbade.

The Rosenbergs and their sons

In letters from the death house, published in 1953, Julius and Ethel insisted they were innocent victims of a political frame-up and compared their case to Dreyfus and to Sacco and Vanzetti. Their supporters stressed that the judge, the prosecutors and the defendants were all Jewish, and saw in the trial an effort to prove Jewish loyalty at their expense. Their sons, Michael and Robert, adopted by Abel and Anne Meeropol, campaigned for decades to reopen the case. Since 2008 they have accepted that their father spied for the Soviet Union, though not that he gave away the bomb, and they seek a formal exoneration of their mother.

The Greenglass family

David Greenglass served nine and a half years and lived afterwards under another name. In interviews with the journalist Sam Roberts, published in 2001, he said he had no memory of his sister typing anything and had told the story because the prosecutors wanted it and because Ruth had first suggested it. He thought Ruth had probably done the typing herself. He said he had chosen his wife and children over his sister and would do it again. Ruth’s grand jury testimony, unsealed in 2008, says she wrote the notes out by hand and makes no mention of Ethel typing. David’s, released in 2015, does not implicate Ethel either.

Soviet intelligence

Moscow said nothing for forty years. In 1997 Alexander Feklisov, the officer who had handled Julius in New York, said publicly that Rosenberg was a committed and productive agent who supplied electronics and aviation secrets, including a working proximity fuse carried out of the factory at Christmas 1944. On the bomb, Feklisov said, Julius gave nothing of value, and Ethel knew of her husband’s work but was never an agent. Notebooks copied from KGB archives by Alexander Vassiliev, published in 2009, broadly agree, while suggesting Ethel helped recruit her brother and sister-in-law.

What is disputed

Julius’s espionage is now accepted by almost all historians; Sobell admitted his own in 2008. What remains argued is Ethel’s part. Ronald Radosh, Harvey Klehr and John Earl Haynes hold that she was a knowing accomplice who helped bring in the Greenglasses, though the sentence was indefensible. The Meeropols, Walter Schneir and others answer that awareness is not conspiracy and that she was convicted on perjured testimony. The worth of Greenglass’s sketches is also contested: physicists who examined them called them crude, and Fuchs and Theodore Hall gave Moscow far more.

What followed

The Rosenbergs remain the only American civilians put to death for espionage during the Cold War. Abroad, the executions damaged the standing of the United States among people who had no sympathy for Stalin; Jean-Paul Sartre called them a legal lynching, and the Pope had asked for mercy. At home the case became a test of political identity for half a century, with belief in the couple’s innocence or guilt tracking left and right. The release of the Venona cables in 1995 ended much of that, and moved the argument to the conduct of the trial and to a sister sent to her death on her brother’s word.

Read further

  • Ronald Radosh and Joyce Milton, The Rosenberg File: A Search for the Truth (1983)
  • Sam Roberts, The Brother: The Untold Story of Atomic Spy David Greenglass and How He Sent His Sister, Ethel Rosenberg, to the Electric Chair (2001)
  • Walter Schneir and Miriam Schneir, Invitation to an Inquest (1965)
  • John Earl Haynes and Harvey Klehr, Venona: Decoding Soviet Espionage in America (1999)
  • Robert Meeropol, An Execution in the Family: One Son’s Journey (2003)

Same day, other years

1461

Towton, fought in a snowstorm

Towton, Yorkshire, EnglandEurope

The largest battle of the Wars of the Roses was fought on Palm Sunday on a plateau south of Tadcaster. Edward of York, eighteen years old and proclaimed king in London three weeks before, faced the army of the Lancastrian Henry VI. Snow blew into the Lancastrians’ faces. The Yorkist archers, with the wind behind them, outranged the enemy and goaded them into attacking. The hand-to-hand fighting lasted for hours until fresh troops under the Duke of Norfolk came up on the Yorkist right. The Lancastrian line broke and the fugitives were cut down or drowned crossing the Cock Beck. Edward was crowned in June.

Seen from elsewhere. For Lancastrians Henry was the anointed king and Edward a usurper; Henry and Queen Margaret fled to Scotland and fought on for years. The contemporary figure of 28,000 dead, from letters sent after the battle, is doubted by most historians. A grave found at Towton Hall in 1996 held dozens of men with repeated blows to the head, some apparently killed after capture.

1857

Mangal Pandey fires on his officers

Barrackpore, Bengal, IndiaAsia

On a Sunday afternoon at the Barrackpore cantonment near Calcutta, a sepoy of the 34th Bengal Native Infantry named Mangal Pandey walked onto the parade ground with a loaded musket and called on his comrades to join him. He shot at the adjutant, Lieutenant Baugh, bringing down his horse, and wounded him and the sergeant-major with a sword. The guard, ordered to seize him, did not move; only one soldier, Shaikh Paltu, held him back. When the general rode up, Pandey turned the musket on himself and survived. He was hanged on 8 April. The army was then seething over a new rifle cartridge rumoured to be greased with cow and pig fat. In May the regiments at Meerut mutinied and marched on Delhi.

Seen from elsewhere. The court martial recorded that Pandey said he had taken bhang and opium and acted alone. British soldiers afterwards called all mutineers ‘Pandies’. Indian nationalists from V. D. Savarkar onward made him the first martyr of a war of independence. The historian Rudrangshu Mukherjee has argued that he was an isolated figure turned into a hero after the event.

1947

Madagascar rises against France

Moramanga and Manakara, MadagascarAfrica

On the night of 29 March 1947 several hundred men armed mostly with spears and cutting tools attacked the French army camp at Moramanga, on the railway east of the capital, while others struck at Manakara and plantations along the coast. The rising spread through the eastern forests and at its height held perhaps a third of the island. France sent reinforcements, including Senegalese and North African troops, and took until late 1948 to put it down. Villages were burned, suspects were tortured, and in May 1947 more than a hundred prisoners locked in railway wagons at Moramanga were machine-gunned. Tens of thousands of villagers who fled into the forest died there of hunger and disease.

Seen from elsewhere. France blamed the nationalist party, the MDRM, and tried its three deputies, who denied ordering violence. A French military estimate of 89,000 dead was later cut by officials to 11,000; the historian Jean Fremigacci argues for 30,000 to 40,000, mostly from starvation, while Malagasy memory holds to 100,000. The insurgents killed several hundred Europeans and many Malagasy they considered collaborators.

1974

Farmers digging a well strike a clay head

Lintong, Shaanxi, ChinaAsia

During a drought in the spring of 1974, men from the village of Xiyang, east of Xi’an, were sinking a well about a mile from the burial mound of the First Emperor of Qin. A few metres down they hit hard red earth, then fragments of a life-sized pottery figure, bronze arrowheads and bricks. A local museum official, Zhao Kangmin, collected the pieces and reassembled two warriors. State archaeologists followed and uncovered the first of the pits: ranks of infantry, archers, chariots and horses, each face individually finished, made to guard an emperor who died in 210 BC. Around 8,000 figures are thought to lie in the three main pits. The emperor’s own tomb has not been opened.

Seen from elsewhere. The date usually given, 29 March, is not firmly documented. Credit is contested: the farmers, led by Yang Zhifa, were paid a trifle and lost their fields to the museum, while Zhao held that recognising the find was the real discovery. The ancient historian Sima Qian, who described the tomb in detail, never mentions the army.

Also on 29 March