Parallax

27 March, 1814

Horseshoe Bend

In a loop of an Alabama river, Andrew Jackson’s army and its Cherokee and Creek allies destroyed the Red Stick Creeks in an afternoon. The allies who helped him win lost their land along with the defeated.

Tallapoosa River, Mississippi Territory (now Alabama)

The Tallapoosa River bends back on itself in eastern Alabama to enclose about a hundred acres of ground. The Muscogee, whom Americans called Creeks, knew the place as Tohopeka. In the winter of 1813-14 about a thousand warriors of the Red Stick faction gathered there with several hundred women and children, and closed the neck of the loop with a zigzag wall of pine logs, five to eight feet high and pierced with loopholes. Canoes were drawn up at the river bank behind them in case they had to leave.

On the morning of 27 March 1814 Major General Andrew Jackson of the Tennessee militia arrived in front of the wall with about 2,600 Tennessee volunteers and regulars of the 39th Infantry. With him were some 500 Cherokee and 100 Lower Creek warriors under the Creek leader William McIntosh. He sent General John Coffee with the mounted men and the Native allies round to the far bank to seal the bend. At half past ten his two small cannon opened fire. For two hours the balls sank into the soft pine without doing damage.

What decided the battle happened at the back. Cherokee warriors swam the river, took the Red Sticks’ canoes and used them to ferry men across. They set fire to the village and attacked the defenders from behind. Jackson heard the firing, saw the smoke and ordered the drums to beat the charge. Major Lemuel Montgomery was shot dead on top of the barricade; a young ensign named Sam Houston went over it with an arrow in his thigh.

Once the wall was passed the fight turned into a slaughter that went on until dark. The Red Sticks, by most accounts, neither asked for quarter nor were offered much. Men who took to the river were shot in the water by Coffee’s troops on the far bank. The next day Jackson’s soldiers counted 557 bodies on the ground, cutting the tip off each nose to keep the tally straight, and Coffee estimated that 250 to 300 more had died in the river. Some soldiers cut strips of skin from the dead to make bridle reins. About 350 women and children were taken prisoner and given to the allied warriors. Jackson lost 49 killed and about 150 wounded, his allies 23 killed.

The Red Stick war leader Menawa, hit seven times, lay among the dead until night, then crawled to the river and escaped in a canoe. He lived to be removed to the west more than twenty years later.

How it came to this

The Muscogee confederacy held most of what is now Alabama and Georgia. By 1813 it was split. Leaders of the Lower Towns, encouraged by the United States agent Benjamin Hawkins, had taken up ploughs, cattle, cotton and, in some cases, enslaved African labourers. Many in the Upper Towns saw this as the road to losing everything. They were stirred by the visit of the Shawnee leader Tecumseh in 1811 and by their own prophets, who preached a return to older ways and painted their war clubs red.

The quarrel began as a civil war among the Creeks. It drew in the United States after American militia ambushed a Red Stick supply party at Burnt Corn Creek in July 1813, and after the Red Sticks stormed Fort Mims, north of Mobile, on 30 August, killing about 250 or more settlers, mixed-ancestry Creeks and militia. With Britain already at war with the United States, Tennessee, Georgia and the Mississippi Territory all sent armies into Creek country. Jackson’s was the one that reached the Tallapoosa.

How each side saw it

The Red Sticks

The Red Sticks left no written account of their own. What is known of their reasoning comes through Hawkins’s letters, the testimony of captives, and Muscogee oral tradition recorded later. In that tradition they were defending a way of life and a homeland against chiefs who had sold out and settlers who never stopped coming. Their prophets had promised that the barricade at Tohopeka could not be taken. The leader William Weatherford, who was not at the battle, walked into Jackson’s camp afterwards and, in the version reported by American witnesses, said he had done the white people all the harm he could and asked only for food for the women and children.

Andrew Jackson and the settlers

To Jackson and the Tennesseans the campaign was the answer to Fort Mims and to a frontier they believed the British and Spanish were arming against them. His report to Governor Blount speaks of a determination to exterminate the hostile party and regrets that some women and children were killed by accident. He had executed a young militiaman, John Woods, for insubordination two weeks before to hold his army together. The victory made him a national figure and a major general in the regular army. In the settlers’ view it opened rich land to farming and made the Gulf coast safe.

The Cherokee and Creek allies

Cherokee tradition holds that their warriors won the battle by crossing the river, and that Junaluska saved Jackson’s life there. Whatever the truth of that story, the allies’ reward was small. At the treaty that followed, the Creek leaders who had fought beside Jackson were made to sign away their own towns’ land along with the Red Sticks’. The Cherokee came home to find Tennessee troops had looted their farms. Junaluska is reported to have said in old age that had he known Jackson would drive his people from their homes he would have killed him at the Horseshoe. Among the Cherokee present was the future principal chief John Ross.

What is disputed

Numbers on the Red Stick side are American counts and estimates; the total of 800 to 900 dead is probably about right but cannot be checked. Whether the killing after the wall fell was a battle against men who refused to surrender, as Jackson reported, or a massacre is argued by historians; the mutilation of bodies is confirmed by soldiers’ own letters. Junaluska’s rescue of Jackson and his later remark rest on Cherokee tradition written down long afterwards. Historians also differ on whether to call the conflict part of the War of 1812, as American textbooks did, or a Muscogee civil war that the United States turned to its own use.

What followed

In August 1814 Jackson dictated the Treaty of Fort Jackson, taking some 23 million acres, about half of Alabama and part of Georgia, mostly from the Creeks who had been his allies. Many surviving Red Sticks went south to join the Seminoles in Florida and fought on. Jackson went on to New Orleans and the presidency, where in 1830 he signed the Indian Removal Act. In 1836-37 the remaining Muscogee were marched west to what is now Oklahoma, and the Cherokee followed in 1838. Cotton planters and the people they enslaved filled the land between.

Read further

  • Gregory A. Waselkov, A Conquering Spirit: Fort Mims and the Redstick War of 1813-1814 (2006)
  • Joel W. Martin, Sacred Revolt: The Muskogees’ Struggle for a New World (1991)
  • Robert V. Remini, Andrew Jackson and the Course of American Empire, 1767-1821 (1977)
  • Claudio Saunt, A New Order of Things: Property, Power, and the Transformation of the Creek Indians, 1733-1816 (1999)
  • Frank L. Owsley Jr., Struggle for the Gulf Borderlands: The Creek War and the Battle of New Orleans, 1812-1815 (1981)

Same day, other years

1836

The Goliad executions

Goliad, Texas (then Mexico)The Americas

A week earlier Colonel James Fannin and several hundred men fighting for Texan independence had surrendered on the open prairie to the Mexican general Jose de Urrea. Most were recent volunteers from the United States. On Palm Sunday, 27 March 1836, the prisoners held in the old mission fort at Goliad were told they were going to gather wood or be shipped home. They were marched out in three columns along different roads, halted, and shot at close range. The wounded, Fannin among them, were killed inside the fort. About 340 to 400 died; some thirty escaped into the river bottoms, and a few doctors and craftsmen were spared.

Seen from elsewhere. Mexico’s congress had decreed in December 1835 that armed foreigners taken on its soil would be treated as pirates. Urrea wrote asking clemency; Santa Anna ordered the law carried out, and the local commander, Jose Nicolas de la Portilla, recorded his anguish in his diary. A Mexican woman, Francita Alavez, hid several prisoners and is remembered in Texas as the Angel of Goliad.

1933

Japan walks out of the League of Nations

Tokyo, Japan, and Geneva, SwitzerlandAsia

Japan gave formal notice on 27 March 1933 that it was leaving the League of Nations, of whose council it had been a permanent member since 1920. The cause was Manchuria. Japanese troops had seized the region from China after staging an explosion on the railway near Mukden in September 1931, and had set up the state of Manchukuo under the last Qing emperor, Puyi. A League commission under Lord Lytton found that the new state was not a genuine independence movement. When the Assembly adopted the report in February by 42 votes to one, the Japanese delegate Matsuoka Yosuke led his delegation out of the hall.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan argued that it had treaty rights and large investments in Manchuria, that China was not an organised state able to protect them, and that Western empires were condemning what they had done themselves. For China, which had trusted the League instead of fighting, the outcome showed that collective security offered words and no help.

1941

Belgrade overthrows its own signature

Belgrade, YugoslaviaEurope

On 25 March 1941 the government of Yugoslavia, surrounded by Axis states, signed the Tripartite Pact in Vienna. Two days later, before dawn, air force officers led by General Dusan Simovic and Brigadier Borivoje Mirkovic occupied Belgrade’s ministries without bloodshed. They deposed the regent, Prince Paul, and declared the seventeen-year-old King Peter II of age. Crowds filled the streets of Belgrade and other Serbian towns chanting ‘better war than the pact, better the grave than a slave’. Hitler, furious, ordered Yugoslavia destroyed as a state that same day. German bombers struck Belgrade on 6 April, and the country was overrun in eleven days.

Seen from elsewhere. British agents had encouraged the plotters and Churchill said Yugoslavia had found its soul. Prince Paul’s defenders argue that he had secured terms sparing the country from occupation and that the coup invited catastrophe. The demonstrations were largely Serbian; many Croats were indifferent or hostile, and the new government itself quietly told Berlin it would honour the pact.

2002

The Passover bombing at the Park Hotel

Netanya, IsraelMiddle East

About 250 guests, many of them elderly and some survivors of the Holocaust, had sat down to the Passover seder in the dining room of the Park Hotel in the coastal town of Netanya. A man disguised as a woman walked past the guard and detonated a suitcase of explosives. Thirty people were killed and about 140 injured. Hamas claimed the attack, the deadliest single bombing of the second Palestinian uprising, which came in a month when more than a hundred Israelis died in such attacks. Two days later Israel called up reservists and launched Operation Defensive Shield, reoccupying the main towns of the West Bank.

Seen from elsewhere. The bombing came as Arab leaders met in Beirut to endorse a Saudi peace plan, and the Palestinian Authority condemned it. Hamas presented it as an answer to occupation and to Israeli killings of Palestinians. Palestinians remember the weeks that followed for the siege of Arafat’s compound and the destruction in the Jenin refugee camp, where at least 52 Palestinians and 23 Israeli soldiers died.

Also on 27 March