Parallax

11 March, 1942

MacArthur leaves Corregidor by torpedo boat

Ordered out by his president, the American commander in the Philippines slipped through the Japanese blockade at dusk and left some 80,000 starving men behind him. Whether it was a rescue or a desertion depended on where you stood.

Corregidor, Manila Bay, Philippines

At about a quarter to eight on the evening of 11 March 1942, General Douglas MacArthur walked down to the shattered North Dock of Corregidor, the fortress island at the mouth of Manila Bay. With him were his wife Jean, their four-year-old son Arthur, the boy’s Cantonese nurse Ah Cheu, and seventeen staff officers. Waiting for them was PT-41, a seventy-seven-foot plywood torpedo boat commanded by Lieutenant John Bulkeley, with three more boats standing off in the dark. MacArthur raised his cap to the gunners on the dock and told Bulkeley to cast off.

He had been ordered to go. On 22 February President Roosevelt, advised that the Philippines could not be relieved and unwilling to hand Japan the capture of America’s best-known soldier, had directed him to Australia. MacArthur talked of resigning his commission and crossing to Bataan to fight as a volunteer; his staff talked him out of it. He delayed for over two weeks, then chose the torpedo boats over a submarine. He handed command to General Jonathan Wainwright, gave him a box of cigars and two jars of shaving cream, and promised to come back.

The run south covered 560 miles of water the Japanese navy controlled. The boats’ engines were worn out and fouled with carbon, and they lost one another the first night. In heavy seas most of the passengers were violently sick; MacArthur compared it to riding in a concrete mixer. At one point the crew of one boat nearly fired on another, taking it for a Japanese destroyer. At dawn on 13 March they reached Cagayan de Oro on Mindanao, where the Americans still held the Del Monte pineapple plantation and its airstrip.

There they waited four days for aircraft. When the B-17s finally came, the party flew by night to Batchelor Field near Darwin, shortly after a Japanese raid, and went on by air to Alice Springs and then by train across the desert. At the small railway junction of Terowie in South Australia on 20 March, MacArthur gave reporters the sentence that defined the rest of his war: ‘I came through and I shall return.’ Officials in Washington suggested he change it to ‘We shall return’. He declined.

On Bataan, the men he had left were on less than half rations and riddled with malaria and dysentery. Major General Edward King surrendered them on 9 April, about 76,000 Filipino and American troops, the largest capitulation in American history. Thousands died on the march to the prison camps that followed. Corregidor held out under bombardment until 6 May, when Wainwright surrendered the rest.

How it came to this

The Philippines had been an American possession since 1898 and was due for independence in 1946. MacArthur, a former US Army chief of staff, had spent six years in Manila as military adviser to President Manuel Quezon, with the rank of field marshal in a Philippine army that existed largely on paper. Recalled to American service in July 1941, he persuaded Washington that he could hold the whole archipelago on the beaches and abandoned the old plan for a fighting withdrawal into the Bataan peninsula.

The Japanese attacked on 8 December 1941. Some nine hours after news of Pearl Harbor reached Manila, their bombers caught MacArthur’s aircraft lined up on the ground at Clark Field and destroyed about half his air force. When General Masaharu Homma’s army landed at Lingayen Gulf two weeks later, the beach defence collapsed and MacArthur reverted to the Bataan plan, too late to move the food stocks the plan depended on. The retreat itself was skilfully handled. But from January the defenders were hungry, and no relief convoy ever sailed.

How each side saw it

The garrison of Bataan

The soldiers called him ‘Dugout Doug’. He had visited the Bataan front once, on 10 January, and otherwise directed the battle from the Malinta tunnel on Corregidor, where, to be fair, he made a point of standing in the open during air raids. A verse by the correspondent Frank Hewlett that the troops adopted called them the battling bastards of Bataan, with ‘no mama, no papa, no Uncle Sam’. Many survivors of the prison camps never forgave the repeated messages promising that help was on the way. Others, including Wainwright in his memoir, accepted that he had gone under orders and judged him a great commander.

Filipinos

Roughly six of every seven soldiers on Bataan were Filipino, and Filipinos made up most of the dead on the march and in Camp O’Donnell. During the occupation, MacArthur’s promise was a source of real hope: it was printed on matchbooks and leaflets smuggled to the guerrillas. But Filipino historians, Teodoro Agoncillo and Renato Constantino among them, have also asked hard questions about a general who was on the Commonwealth’s payroll, whose return in 1945 involved the destruction of Manila and the deaths of some 100,000 of its civilians, and whose country then delayed or denied the benefits promised to Filipino veterans.

The Japanese command

Tokyo’s propaganda broadcasts told the men on Bataan that their general had run away and left them to die. Privately the Japanese army was embarrassed for a different reason: the campaign had been scheduled to take fifty days and took five months. General Homma was relieved of his command for it and spent the rest of the war in retirement. In 1946 a military commission convened under MacArthur’s authority tried him in Manila for the Death March and had him shot. Homma said he had not known of the atrocities; two US Supreme Court justices, dissenting from the refusal to intervene, called the proceedings vengeance in the form of law.

What is disputed

Responsibility for the disaster at Clark Field has never been settled: MacArthur, his air commander Lewis Brereton and his chief of staff Richard Sutherland left incompatible accounts of who refused whom permission to bomb Formosa that morning. In 1979 Carol Petillo published evidence that MacArthur accepted 500,000 dollars from President Quezon in February 1942, while both were on Corregidor; whether this was a legitimate reward under his old contract or an improper payment that influenced his judgement is argued. Historians such as Richard Connaughton hold that he should have been dismissed for the defeat. The famous sentence itself is variously quoted, and was spoken at Terowie, not Adelaide or Melbourne.

What followed

Roosevelt awarded MacArthur the Medal of Honor, partly to counter enemy propaganda about his departure. As commander in the South-West Pacific he fought his way back through New Guinea and waded ashore at Leyte on 20 October 1944, announcing ‘I have returned.’ He went on to take the Japanese surrender, govern occupied Japan and command in Korea until President Truman sacked him in 1951. The Philippines became independent on 4 July 1946. Bataan Day, 9 April, is a national holiday there, now called the Day of Valour, and it commemorates the men who stayed.

Read further

  • D. Clayton James, The Years of MacArthur, Volume 2: 1941-1945 (1975)
  • Louis Morton, The Fall of the Philippines (1953)
  • Carol Morris Petillo, Douglas MacArthur: The Philippine Years (1981)
  • Teodoro A. Agoncillo, The Fateful Years: Japan’s Adventure in the Philippines, 1941-45 (1965)
  • William Manchester, American Caesar: Douglas MacArthur, 1880-1964 (1978)

Same day, other years

1845

Hone Heke fells the flagstaff and Kororareka burns

Kororareka (Russell), Bay of Islands, New ZealandOceania

Hone Heke, a Ngapuhi chief, had been the first to sign the Treaty of Waitangi in 1840. Within four years he had concluded that it had cost his people their authority and their trade, as the capital and its customs revenue moved south to Auckland. Three times his men cut down the British flagstaff on the hill above Kororareka. On 11 March 1845, while his ally Te Ruki Kawiti attacked the town as a diversion, Heke took the blockhouse and felled the pole a fourth time. The settlers were evacuated by ship, the powder magazine blew up, and most of the town was burned. The Northern War lasted ten more months.

Seen from elsewhere. Other Ngapuhi chiefs, led by Tamati Waka Nene, fought against Heke and beside the British. The governor declared victory in 1846, but James Belich has argued that the British won no decisive battle and that Heke and Kawiti kept their land and standing. The government did not dare re-erect the flagstaff; Kawiti’s son raised a new one himself in 1858.

1917

British and Indian troops take Baghdad

Baghdad, Ottoman IraqMiddle East

After the humiliation of Kut, where 13,000 British and Indian soldiers had surrendered to the Ottomans in April 1916, a rebuilt army under Lieutenant-General Stanley Maude advanced up the Tigris with river gunboats and overwhelming numbers. The Ottoman commander Khalil Pasha abandoned Baghdad, and Maude’s troops, most of them Indian, entered the city on 11 March 1917. A week later a proclamation in Maude’s name, drafted in London by Mark Sykes, told the inhabitants that ‘our armies do not come into your cities and lands as conquerors or enemies, but as liberators’. Maude died of cholera in the city that November.

Seen from elsewhere. Iraqis soon measured the proclamation against events. Britain kept the country under military rule and then a League of Nations mandate, and in 1920 a revolt across the Euphrates valley was put down with troops and aircraft at a cost of several thousand Iraqi lives. Sykes had already agreed with France, in secret, how the Ottoman Arab lands would be divided.

2004

Bombs on the Madrid commuter trains

Madrid, SpainEurope

Between 7.37 and 7.40 on a Thursday morning, ten bombs hidden in rucksacks exploded on four packed suburban trains running into Atocha station. They killed 191 people from seventeen countries and injured about 1,800, the worst attack in Spain’s modern history. A general election was three days away. The conservative government of Jose Maria Aznar, which had sent troops to Iraq against the wishes of most Spaniards, insisted that the Basque group ETA was responsible, even as the police evidence pointed to a jihadist cell. Voters turned the government out on 14 March. Seven suspects blew themselves up in a flat in Leganes three weeks later, and twenty-one people were convicted in 2007.

Seen from elsewhere. Parts of the Spanish right and press maintained for years that ETA, or elements of the security services, had a hidden hand; the courts found no evidence of it. A separate argument concerns the plot’s origin: the court described a local cell inspired by al-Qaeda, while the researcher Fernando Reinares argues it was approved by al-Qaeda’s leadership before the election date was even known.

2011

The Tohoku earthquake, the tsunami and Fukushima

North-eastern JapanAsia

At 2.46 in the afternoon a magnitude 9 earthquake, the strongest recorded in Japan, ruptured the sea floor off the Tohoku coast. The shaking lasted about six minutes. Within the hour a tsunami overtopped sea walls along hundreds of kilometres of coast, in places running up slopes to a height of nearly forty metres, and swept away whole towns. About 18,500 people were killed or never found, most of them drowned. At the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear plant the wave knocked out the backup generators; three reactor cores melted, hydrogen explosions wrecked the buildings, and more than 150,000 people were evacuated from the surrounding districts.

Seen from elsewhere. The plant’s operator, TEPCO, called the wave beyond all expectation. An independent commission of the Japanese parliament concluded in 2012 that the accident was ‘profoundly man-made’, the result of collusion between regulator and industry and of ignored warnings about earlier great tsunamis. Japan’s Supreme Court ruled in 2022 that the state was not liable. Fishing communities and neighbouring countries opposed the release of treated water from 2023.

Also on 11 March