Parallax

10 March, 1831

A king signs away his unwanted foreigners

The French Foreign Legion began as a way of getting unemployed foreign soldiers out of Paris and into Algeria. Nobody at its founding expected it to last, let alone to become a legend.

Paris, France

On 10 March 1831 King Louis-Philippe signed a short ordinance. It created ‘a legion composed of foreigners’, to be called the Foreign Legion, open to men between eighteen and forty. A law passed the day before had already settled the essential point: the new corps could be used only outside the mainland territory of the kingdom. The Minister of War, Marshal Soult, who had fought for Napoleon across Europe and knew what a use foreign troops could be, saw it through.

The king had been on the throne for seven months, put there by the Paris barricades of July 1830, and his capital was full of men who worried him. The revolution had disbanded the Swiss regiments of the old royal guard and the German Hohenlohe regiment, leaving their soldiers without employment. Failed risings in Poland, Italy, Belgium and the German states were sending more exiles into France every month, many of them trained soldiers with radical opinions. At the same time the previous regime had bequeathed an expedition to Algiers that was proving expensive and unpopular, and that French conscripts and their families disliked.

The Legion solved both problems at once. Recruits were grouped by language: Swiss and Germans in the first three battalions, then Spaniards, Italians, Belgians and Dutch, and Poles. Its first colonel was a Swiss veteran, Baron Christophe Stoffel. A recruit was supposed to produce a birth certificate and a testimonial of good conduct, but a general could waive both, and in practice a man was accepted under whatever name he chose to give. That convenience, intended to speed up recruitment, became the institution’s most famous feature.

The first battalions reached Algeria in 1831 and spent as much time draining marshes and building roads as fighting. Fever killed far more of them than the enemy did. Discipline was poor, the national battalions brawled with one another, and desertion was common. Then, in 1835, the government disposed of the entire corps in one stroke by ceding it to the Queen Regent of Spain for her war against the Carlists. Some 4,000 men went. They were left unpaid and unsupplied, and when the remnant was dissolved in 1838 only a few hundred were still in the ranks.

A second legion had by then been raised to replace the first, this time with the nationalities mixed. It was this corps that took part in the storming of Constantine in 1837 and settled at Sidi Bel Abbes in western Algeria, its home for more than a century. Its sacred day came later and far away. At Camaron in Mexico, on 30 April 1863, sixty-five legionnaires under Captain Jean Danjou held a farmyard for most of a day against roughly two thousand Mexican troops and refused to surrender until a handful were left standing. Danjou’s wooden hand, recovered afterwards, is still paraded every year.

How it came to this

France had employed foreign soldiers for centuries: Scots archers, Swiss guards, Irish and German regiments under the old monarchy, Poles and Italians under Napoleon. The revolution of 1830, made in the name of the nation, found mercenary royal guards intolerable and dissolved them. But the law also barred foreigners from the regular French army, so the men had nowhere to go. A separate corps, kept overseas, was the compromise.

The destination was Algeria. In June 1830, weeks before he fell, Charles X had sent an army to seize Algiers from its Ottoman governor, citing an old quarrel in which the Dey had struck the French consul with a fly whisk. Louis-Philippe inherited the occupation without a policy for it. Over the next decade it turned into a war of conquest against the forces of the Emir Abd el-Kader, fought with a ruthlessness that included burning crops and villages. The Legion grew up inside that war, and Algeria remained its base until Algerian independence in 1962.

How each side saw it

The Legion’s own tradition

The Legion tells its history as a story of strangers made into a family by shared hardship. Its motto is ‘The Legion is our fatherland’, and its code of honour, recited by recruits, binds them to their mission and to one another rather than to a flag they were born under. Camerone, as the French spell it, is read aloud every 30 April at every post. General Paul-Frederic Rollet, who shaped these rituals in the 1920s and 1930s, deliberately built a cult of tradition to hold together men with nothing else in common. A law of 1999 lets a legionnaire wounded in action become French ‘by spilled blood’.

Algerians

To the people of Algeria the Legion was an instrument of conquest and then of occupation for 130 years. Abd el-Kader’s letters and the Arabic chronicles of the resistance describe the French columns of the 1830s and 1840s as destroyers of harvests, flocks and villages; the Legion marched in those columns and garrisoned the land taken. Sidi Bel Abbes itself was built on confiscated tribal land. During the war of independence from 1954 to 1962 its parachute regiments were among the units used in the Battle of Algiers, where torture was systematic. Algerian historians such as Mostefa Lacheraf wrote this history from the side of the colonised.

The men in the ranks

Memoirs by legionnaires are far less romantic than the official story. Erwin Rosen, a German who served before the First World War and deserted, described in his book of 1910 a life of exhausting marches, tiny pay, brutal punishments and the black depression the men called le cafard. Before 1914 a campaign in Germany denounced the Legion as a trap for runaway boys. Douglas Porch’s history shows desertion as a constant, and shows too that many men joined out of hunger or statelessness, not adventure: Alsatians after 1871, Russians after 1917, Spanish Republicans in 1939, Germans in 1945.

Mexico

Mexicans know the battle as Camaron and remember it as an episode in the defence of the republic against a foreign invasion. The legionnaires were there as part of Napoleon III’s attempt to impose the Austrian archduke Maximilian as emperor, an enterprise that ended with Maximilian shot at Queretaro in 1867. The Mexican commander, Colonel Francisco de Paula Milan, led largely local militia who took heavy losses attacking the hacienda and who treated the wounded survivors decently. A Mexican monument stands near the French one at the site, and the two armies now hold a joint ceremony there.

What is disputed

The Legion counts its birthday from the law of 9 March, though the ordinance creating it is dated 10 March, and both dates appear in reputable books. More seriously contested is its image. The belief that it was a haven for criminals is exaggerated: recruits have long been screened. The claim that it was filled with former SS men in Indochina after 1945 was examined by Eckard Michels, who found Germans were indeed the largest group but SS veterans a small minority. The numbers at Camaron vary between accounts, and the French and Mexican versions differ on how many legionnaires remained when the fighting stopped.

What followed

The Legion fought in the Crimea, Italy, Mexico, Indochina, Dahomey, Madagascar and Morocco, and in both world wars. It lost heavily at Dien Bien Phu in 1954. In April 1961 its First Foreign Parachute Regiment led the generals’ putsch in Algiers against de Gaulle’s decision to leave Algeria, and was disbanded. The following year the Legion left Sidi Bel Abbes for Aubagne, near Marseille, taking its dead commanders’ remains and Danjou’s hand with it. It survives as a force of about 9,000 men from well over a hundred countries, and as the model for every later proposal to let foreigners earn citizenship by military service.

Read further

  • Douglas Porch, The French Foreign Legion: A Complete History of the Legendary Fighting Force (1991)
  • Eckard Michels, Deutsche in der Fremdenlegion 1870-1965 (1999)
  • Erwin Rosen, In the Foreign Legion (1910)
  • Jennifer Sessions, By Sword and Plow: France and the Conquest of Algeria (2011)
  • Tony Geraghty, March or Die: France and the Foreign Legion (1986)

Same day, other years

1762

Jean Calas is broken on the wheel

Toulouse, FranceEurope

Jean Calas was a Protestant cloth merchant of sixty-three in a Catholic city. In October 1761 his eldest son Marc-Antoine was found dead in the family shop. A rumour spread that the young man had meant to convert to Catholicism and that his family had strangled him to prevent it. The judges of the Parlement of Toulouse convicted the father, and on 10 March 1762 he was tortured, broken on the wheel, strangled and burned, insisting to the end that he was innocent. Voltaire took up the case, wrote his Treatise on Tolerance around it, and in 1765 a royal court in Paris cleared Calas’s name.

Seen from elsewhere. The family first said they had found the body on the floor, then that he had hanged himself; they had lied to spare a suicide’s corpse from public disgrace, and the change of story convicted them. The historian David Bien argued that the judges followed the rules of evidence of their day and were not simply bigots. What actually happened to Marc-Antoine is still unknown.

1922

Gandhi is arrested for sedition

Ahmedabad, IndiaAsia

Police came to the Sabarmati ashram on the evening of 10 March and arrested Mohandas Gandhi for three articles in his weekly Young India. A month earlier he had called off the nationwide non-cooperation campaign after a crowd at Chauri Chaura burned a police station and killed twenty-two policemen. At his trial on 18 March he pleaded guilty, said that preaching disaffection towards the existing system of government had become a passion with him, and asked for the heaviest penalty. The judge, Robert Broomfield, sentenced him to six years and said he would be glad if the government later reduced it. Gandhi was released in 1924 after an operation for appendicitis.

Seen from elsewhere. The Government of India had hesitated for months, fearing an explosion, and moved only once Gandhi had suspended his own movement. Many of his colleagues were furious at that suspension: Jawaharlal Nehru, Subhas Chandra Bose and Lala Lajpat Rai all thought he had thrown away a winning position because of one village. Gandhi answered that a movement that could not stay non-violent was not ready.

1952

Batista seizes power in Cuba

Havana, CubaThe Americas

Before dawn Fulgencio Batista, a former president and army strongman, drove into Camp Columbia, the main barracks in Havana, and took over the armed forces without a fight. President Carlos Prio Socarras took refuge in the Mexican embassy. Elections had been due on 1 June, and Batista was running third. He cancelled them, suspended the constitution of 1940 and dissolved Congress; the United States recognised his government within three weeks. Among the candidates who lost their chance of a seat was a young lawyer, Fidel Castro, who filed a court petition against the coup and, when it was ignored, organised the attack on the Moncada barracks the following year.

Seen from elsewhere. Batista said he had acted to forestall a coup by Prio and to end the corruption and political gangsterism of the elected governments, which were real enough that much of the public shrugged at first. Cuban exiles and the revolutionary government have argued ever since over whether the island’s later course was a consequence of the coup or of the revolution.

1959

Lhasa rises around the Dalai Lama’s palace

Lhasa, TibetAsia

Word spread through Lhasa that the Chinese military command had invited the twenty-three-year-old Dalai Lama to a theatrical performance and asked him to come without his usual armed escort. Fearing he would be abducted, a crowd of many thousands surrounded the Norbulingka, his summer palace, on 10 March to stop him going. The protest turned into a rejection of Chinese rule and of the agreement of 1951. On the night of 17 March the Dalai Lama slipped out disguised as a soldier and reached India two weeks later. On 20 March the People’s Liberation Army shelled the Norbulingka and put down the rising within days.

Seen from elsewhere. Beijing describes a rebellion by serf-owning aristocrats and monasteries, backed by the CIA, which had in fact trained Tibetan guerrillas; it marks 28 March as Serfs’ Emancipation Day. Tibetan exiles keep 10 March as National Uprising Day. Their figure of 87,000 Tibetans killed comes from a captured Chinese document whose wording, scholars such as Warren Smith note, covers captures and surrenders as well as deaths.

Also on 10 March