Parallax

6 March, 1204

Chateau Gaillard falls, and Normandy with it

Richard the Lionheart built the most advanced castle in Europe to bar the road to Rouen. Five years after his death, a winter siege that left hundreds of townspeople to starve between the lines delivered it to the King of France.

Les Andelys, Normandy, France

The castle stands on a chalk spur three hundred feet above a loop of the Seine, a day’s ride upstream from Rouen. Richard I had it built in barely two years, between 1196 and 1198, at a cost of some twelve thousand pounds, more than he spent on every castle in England put together during his whole reign. It had three wards in line along the ridge, each to be taken before the next could be reached, and an inner wall built in a row of curved bastions so that no stretch of it was sheltered from the defenders’ fire. Richard is said to have called it his fair daughter. He died of a crossbow wound in April 1199, and his brother John inherited it.

In August 1203 Philip II of France arrived below the rock with an army. He took the fort on the river island and the new town of Petit Andely on the bank. John attempted one relief, a night attack by land and river that failed when the boats, rowing against the current, arrived hours after the troops they were meant to support. Philip then ringed the castle with a double ditch and a line of timber towers and waited. In December John sailed for England and did not come back.

The castellan, Roger de Lacy, constable of Chester, had a strong garrison and a serious problem: well over a thousand townspeople had fled up the hill into his outer defences and were eating his stores. He sent them out in batches. The French let the first two groups through. Then Philip, who was absent, sent orders that no more were to pass, since every mouth inside shortened the siege. The last group, at least four hundred men, women and children, found the gates shut behind them and the French shooting at them in front. They spent the winter in the rocks and ditches between the two armies.

The assault came in late February. Miners working under hide-covered shelters brought down part of a tower in the outer ward. The middle ward fell by stealth: a soldier named Peter, nicknamed Bogis for his snub nose, found a way with a few companions up to an unguarded window of a chapel John had added against the wall, got inside, and made enough noise that the defenders thought a large force was in and fell back.

Only the inner ward remained. The French mined it from the natural rock bridge that crossed its ditch and battered it with a great stone-thrower they called Cabulus. On 6 March 1204 a section of wall gave way. The garrison, about a hundred and fifty men still on their feet, was overrun before it could reach the keep. De Lacy had never offered to surrender.

How it came to this

The kings of England were also dukes of Normandy, and through the marriage of Henry II to Eleanor of Aquitaine they held Anjou, Poitou and Gascony as well: more of France than the French king ruled directly. For all of it they owed him homage. The Capetian kings in Paris had spent half a century trying to turn that formal lordship into real power, and Philip II, who came to the throne in 1180, pursued the aim with patience and good accounts. Richard, a far better soldier, had held him off, and Chateau Gaillard was built to close the Seine valley, the direct route from Paris to Rouen.

John gave Philip his opening. In 1200 he married Isabella of Angouleme, who was betrothed to one of his own Poitevin vassals; the injured family appealed to Philip as overlord, John refused to appear, and in 1202 Philip’s court declared his French lands forfeit. John then captured his nephew and rival Arthur of Brittany, who was never seen after April 1203. The belief that John had killed him cost the king most of the support he still had among Norman and Breton lords.

How each side saw it

The French royal account

Almost everything known about the siege comes from William the Breton, Philip’s chaplain, who was present and described it twice, in a prose chronicle and in a Latin epic, the Philippide. For him it is the story of a patient and lawful king recovering what a faithless vassal had forfeited. He gives the names of ordinary soldiers, admires de Lacy’s defence and does not hide the fate of the townspeople, though he arranges it to display Philip’s mercy in finally feeding them. He is an eyewitness and also a court poet, and no account from inside the walls exists to check him against.

English chroniclers and barons

The English monastic writers blamed John. Roger of Wendover, writing a generation later at St Albans, says that as messengers reported each loss the king stayed in bed with his young wife and remarked that he would win it all back in a day; the scene is probably invented, but it shows what was believed. The verse biography of William Marshal, who led the failed relief, shows John suspicious of everyone and leaving Normandy almost by stealth. The barons drew a practical conclusion: many held lands on both sides of the Channel and now had to choose a lord. The nickname Softsword stuck.

The Normans

Normandy did not fight to the last for its duke. Town after town opened its gates, and Rouen negotiated a thirty-day truce and surrendered when no help came. Historians since F. M. Powicke have explained this less as love of France than as exhaustion: the duchy had been taxed without pause to pay for Richard’s wars and ransom and for John’s mercenaries, who were hated for their plundering. Philip confirmed the customs of the towns and the rights of the Norman church. Lords who stayed loyal to John lost their Norman estates, and those who submitted to Philip lost their English ones.

The people of Petit Andely

The civilians left between the lines have no voice of their own in the record. William the Breton says they ate the dogs the garrison drove out, then grass, and that a newborn child was eaten; that when Philip returned and saw them he ordered food given and let them go, and that many died from eating after so long without. Medieval siege custom gave both commanders a defensible case, de Lacy to save his stores and Philip to exhaust them. The expulsion of ‘useless mouths’ was repeated at Calais in 1346 and Rouen in 1418, with the same result.

What is disputed

The best-known detail, that Bogis got in by crawling up a latrine shaft, is how the episode is usually told; William the Breton speaks of an unguarded chapel window, and historians differ over how the men reached it. The numbers of the expelled, from about 1,400 to over 2,000, are his estimates. Richard’s sayings about the castle come from writers such as Gerald of Wales and may be embroidery. On the larger question, John Gillingham holds that Normandy was lost through John’s failures of leadership, while J. C. Holt and others argued that Philip’s revenues had by then overtaken the Angevins’, making the outcome likely whoever ruled.

What followed

Rouen surrendered on 24 June 1204, and of the duchy only the Channel Islands stayed with the English crown, as they still do. John spent ten years and vast sums trying to recover it; the defeat of his allies at Bouvines in 1214 ended the attempt and led directly to the baronial revolt and Magna Carta. A nobility that had been Anglo-Norman became English. Chateau Gaillard changed hands several times in the Hundred Years War and was partly demolished on the orders of Henry IV of France around 1600. Its ruins still overlook the river.

Read further

  • F. M. Powicke, The Loss of Normandy, 1189-1204 (1913)
  • W. L. Warren, King John (1961)
  • John Gillingham, Richard I (1999)
  • Jim Bradbury, Philip Augustus: King of France, 1180-1223 (1998)
  • Daniel Power, The Norman Frontier in the Twelfth and Early Thirteenth Centuries (2004)

Same day, other years

1521

Magellan’s starving fleet reaches Guam

Guam, Mariana IslandsOceania

After more than three months crossing an ocean far wider than anyone in Europe had supposed, the three surviving ships of Ferdinand Magellan’s expedition sighted high green islands. The crews had been eating sawdust, rats and the leather wrappings of the yards, and men were dying of scurvy. Chamorro islanders came out in fast outrigger canoes, swarmed aboard and carried off whatever was loose, including the flagship’s skiff. Magellan landed next day with forty armed men, burned forty or fifty houses and several canoes, killed seven islanders, recovered the boat and took on food and water. He sailed on after three days, naming the group the Islands of Thieves. Seven weeks later he was killed in the Philippines.

Seen from elsewhere. The only accounts are European, chiefly the journal of Antonio Pigafetta. Chamorro scholars point out that the islanders had brought food and probably understood the exchange as reciprocal taking between hosts and guests. The insulting name lasted until 1668, when Spanish missionaries arrived; the wars and epidemics that followed reduced the Chamorro population by perhaps nine tenths.

1836

The Alamo falls to Santa Anna

San Antonio de Bexar, TexasThe Americas

After thirteen days of siege, General Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna sent about 1,800 Mexican soldiers against the walls of a former Franciscan mission before dawn. The defenders, somewhere between 180 and 250 men under William Travis and James Bowie, beat back two rushes; the third came over the north wall, and the fighting ended room by room inside the barracks and the church. Every man who had borne arms was killed, among them the former Tennessee congressman David Crockett, and the bodies were burned. Santa Anna spared the women and children and Travis’s enslaved servant Joe, and sent them out to spread the news. Mexican losses are disputed, from Santa Anna’s own figure of 70 dead to estimates of 600 killed and wounded.

Seen from elsewhere. Mexico had declared that armed foreigners taken on its soil would be treated as pirates. The diary of the Mexican officer Jose Enrique de la Pena says Crockett and a few others were captured and executed on Santa Anna’s order; its authenticity has been fought over. Tejanos died defending the mission too, and slavery was among the causes they defended.

1857

The Dred Scott ruling denies citizenship to Black Americans

Washington, United StatesThe Americas

Dred Scott, enslaved in Missouri, had sued for his freedom and that of his wife Harriet and their daughters on the ground that an army surgeon who owned him had kept him for years in Illinois and in federal territory where slavery was prohibited. After eleven years in the courts the Supreme Court ruled against him by seven to two. Chief Justice Roger Taney wrote that people of African descent, free or enslaved, were not and could never be citizens of the United States and so could not sue in its courts, and that Congress had no power to ban slavery from the territories. The Missouri Compromise of 1820 was therefore void.

Seen from elsewhere. Taney believed he was settling the slavery question for good. Justice Benjamin Curtis, dissenting, showed that free Black men had voted in five states when the Constitution was adopted. Frederick Douglass predicted the ruling would hasten slavery’s end by its very extremity. The Scotts were freed by a new owner that May; Dred Scott died the next year.

1957

The Gold Coast becomes independent Ghana

Accra, GhanaAfrica

At midnight the Union flag came down over the parliament building in Accra and the red, gold and green flag with a black star went up. Kwame Nkrumah, who six years earlier had been released from a colonial prison to lead the government, told a huge crowd on the old polo ground that Ghana was free for ever, and that its independence was meaningless unless linked to the total liberation of Africa. The country took its name from a medieval empire far to the north-west. It is generally counted as the first colony in sub-Saharan Africa to win its independence, Sudan to the north having preceded it by a year, and delegates from across the continent, with Martin Luther King among the foreign guests, watched it happen.

Seen from elsewhere. Not all Ghanaians celebrated. The Asante-based National Liberation Movement had demanded a federal constitution and feared rule by Nkrumah’s party, and many Ewe in British Togoland opposed being absorbed. Within eighteen months a Preventive Detention Act allowed imprisonment without trial. The army overthrew Nkrumah in 1966 while he was abroad.

Also on 6 March