Parallax

19 March, 1687

La Salle is shot by his own men in Texas

He had claimed the whole Mississippi valley for Louis XIV. Five years later he was lost four hundred miles from the river, and a quarrel over buffalo meat finished him.

East Texas, exact site uncertain

By the middle of March 1687 Rene-Robert Cavelier, sieur de La Salle, had been walking north-east across Texas for two months with sixteen companions. They were trying to reach the French posts on the Illinois river, well over a thousand miles away, and from there Canada and France, to bring help for the handful of colonists left behind in a rotting stockade near the Gulf coast. The party wore clothes cut from the sails of a wrecked ship and crossed swollen rivers in a boat of buffalo hide.

On 15 March La Salle sent several men to recover a cache of maize and beans hidden on an earlier journey. The food had spoiled, but on the way back his Shawnee hunter, Nika, killed two buffalo, and the men camped to smoke the meat. La Salle sent his nephew, Crevel de Moranget, with horses to fetch it. Moranget, hot-tempered and disliked, flew at the men for setting aside the marrow bones and choice cuts for themselves, and took the lot.

For Pierre Duhaut, a merchant who had sunk money in the venture and blamed La Salle for his brother’s death in the wilderness, it was enough. That night he and four others agreed to act: the surgeon Liotot, a former buccaneer known as Hiems, a man named Tessier and the young Jean L’Archeveque. Liotot took an axe and killed Moranget, Nika and La Salle’s servant Saget as they slept.

When his nephew failed to return, La Salle set out on the morning of 19 March with a Recollect friar, Anastase Douay, and an Indian guide. Douay recalled that he talked on the way of grace and of his debts to God, and seemed weighed down by a sadness he could not explain. Seeing eagles circling, he fired his gun to draw attention. L’Archeveque showed himself across a river and answered La Salle’s questions insolently. As La Salle stepped forward to rebuke him, Duhaut, hidden in the long grass, shot him through the head. He died without speaking, about 43 years old.

The killers stripped the body and dragged it into the bushes. Liotot is reported to have mocked it with the words ‘There you lie, great Pasha.’ It was left unburied. The news reached the main camp through L’Archeveque, who warned Henri Joutel, La Salle’s loyal lieutenant, that he was marked too. Joutel lived, because the murderers needed the others and soon turned on each other: within weeks Hiems and a French deserter living among the Hasinai shot Duhaut and Liotot dead in a dispute over the stolen goods.

Joutel, Douay, La Salle’s brother the Abbe Jean Cavelier and four more went on. They reached a French outpost on the Arkansas in July, and Canada the following year. At the fort on the Illinois they told Henri de Tonti, La Salle’s oldest associate, that his chief was alive and well, and borrowed furs against his credit.

How it came to this

La Salle, born at Rouen in 1643 and briefly a Jesuit novice, came to Canada in 1667 and made himself the leading fur-trade explorer of the Great Lakes with the backing of the governor, Frontenac. In 1682 he took canoes down the Mississippi to the Gulf of Mexico and on 9 April, before a cross and a column bearing the royal arms, claimed the entire basin for France and named it Louisiana. The peoples who lived there were not consulted. He then persuaded Louis XIV, who was at war with Spain, to fund a colony at the river’s mouth that could threaten the silver mines of northern Mexico.

Four ships left La Rochelle in July 1684 with about 300 soldiers, artisans, women and children. Spanish privateers took one; La Salle quarrelled constantly with the naval commander, Beaujeu. In early 1685 the fleet missed the Mississippi and landed at Matagorda Bay. The storeship Aimable ran aground, Beaujeu sailed home, and the last vessel, La Belle, was wrecked in 1686. Disease, snakebite, desertion and fighting with the Karankawa reduced the colony to a few dozen.

How each side saw it

Henri Joutel, the loyal lieutenant

Joutel, a former soldier from Rouen, kept the journal on which almost every later account depends. He was not present at the murder and heard of it within hours. He admired La Salle’s courage, endurance and knowledge of the country, yet he states plainly that his commander’s haughtiness and harshness towards those under him drew on him an implacable hatred and were the cause of his death. Joutel also records his own fear, and his decision not to avenge La Salle but to keep quiet, stay close to the abbe and survive. His narrative was printed in abridged form in Paris in 1713.

The men who killed him

The conspirators left no statement of their own. Duhaut and Liotot were dead within weeks, and what is known of their grievances comes through Joutel: lost investments, a brother abandoned on the march, men flogged and driven. Jean L’Archeveque, the decoy, was found living among the Hasinai by a Spanish expedition in 1689, questioned in Mexico City, and later became a trader and soldier in Spanish New Mexico. The young brothers Pierre and Jean-Baptiste Talon, who had been with the expedition as boys, gave an account to French officials in 1698 that confirms the outline and the bitterness in the camp.

The Karankawa and the Hasinai

Neither people left a written record, and they appear only in French and Spanish reports. The Karankawa of the coast approached the newcomers peaceably in 1685; relations broke down after the French seized canoes and blankets in reprisal for goods taken from the wreck of the Aimable, and killing on both sides followed. Around the turn of 1688-89 they overran the settlement, killed the remaining adults and adopted several children. The Hasinai, the Caddo confederacy farther inland, treated La Salle’s parties as trading guests, sheltered French deserters, and were drawn within three years into a Spanish mission system they had not asked for.

The Spanish authorities

To Madrid and Mexico City the colony was an armed intrusion into the Gulf, which Spain regarded as its own sea. Once captured sailors revealed the plan, the viceroy sent out five expeditions by sea and six by land to find and destroy it. Alonso de Leon reached the ruins in April 1689 and described broken chests, torn books and three bodies, one a woman’s, which his chaplain buried. His report is the main source for the colony’s end. Spain answered by founding missions among the Hasinai in 1690, the beginning of Spanish Texas.

What is disputed

Why La Salle landed in Texas is still argued. One view, set out by Peter Wood, is honest error: he could not fix longitude and believed the Mississippi entered the western Gulf. Another is that he aimed deliberately at a point near New Spain, having misrepresented the geography to win royal backing. Joutel’s journal gives 19 March for the murder; a few accounts say 20 March. The site is unknown: Navasota has a statue, but other historians place it on the Trinity or farther east. Francis Parkman’s heroic portrait has given way to assessments, such as Robert Weddle’s, that stress his secrecy and poor judgement.

What followed

Louis XIV sent no relief. France returned to the Gulf only in 1699, when Iberville found the Mississippi from the sea, and La Salle’s claim became the legal root of French Louisiana, sold to the United States in 1803. American negotiators later cited his Texas landing in arguing that the purchase reached the Rio Grande. In 1995 Texas state archaeologists found the wreck of La Belle in Matagorda Bay and excavated it inside a cofferdam, recovering the hull, bronze cannon, trade goods and the skeleton of a crewman. The site of the settlement on Garcitas Creek was confirmed in 1996.

Read further

  • William C. Foster (ed.), The La Salle Expedition to Texas: The Journal of Henri Joutel, 1684-1687 (1998)
  • Robert S. Weddle, The Wreck of the Belle, the Ruin of La Salle (2001)
  • Francis Parkman, La Salle and the Discovery of the Great West (1879)
  • James E. Bruseth and Toni S. Turner, From a Watery Grave: The Discovery and Excavation of La Salle’s Shipwreck, La Belle (2005)
  • Peter H. Wood, ‘La Salle: Discovery of a Lost Explorer’, American Historical Review (1984)

Same day, other years

1279

The Song dynasty ends in the sea at Yamen

Yamen, Guangdong, ChinaAsia

The last court of the Southern Song, driven down the coast by the armies of Kublai Khan, had taken refuge on a fleet anchored in the estuary at Yamen, with a boy emperor of about seven, Zhao Bing. Its commander, Zhang Shijie, chained his ships together into a floating fortress. On 19 March 1279 the Yuan admiral Zhang Hongfan, himself a northern Chinese in Mongol service, attacked from two sides after cutting the defenders off from fresh water. When the line broke, the chief minister Lu Xiufu took the child on his back and jumped into the sea. Chinese histories say that tens of thousands followed or drowned.

Seen from elsewhere. For the Yuan it was the reunification of China after three centuries of division, and Kublai ruled as a Chinese emperor. The Song loyalist Wen Tianxiang, held prisoner on a Yuan ship during the battle, refused to urge surrender and was executed in 1283; later ages made him a model of fidelity. The figure of 100,000 dead is traditional and cannot be checked.

1932

A horseman with a sword opens Sydney Harbour Bridge

Sydney, AustraliaOceania

The steel arch across Sydney Harbour took eight years to build and cost sixteen workers their lives. At its opening on 19 March 1932, in the depth of the Depression, the Labor premier of New South Wales, Jack Lang, was about to cut the ribbon when Francis de Groot, an Irish-born antique dealer in borrowed cavalry uniform, rode forward and slashed it with his sword, declaring the bridge open in the name of the decent citizens of the state. He belonged to the New Guard, a paramilitary movement that regarded Lang as a dangerous socialist. De Groot was fined five pounds; the ribbon was retied and cut again.

Seen from elsewhere. The bridge stands on the country of the Gadigal and Cammeraygal peoples, who had no say in it. Around 800 houses in The Rocks and North Sydney were demolished for the approaches, and tenants received no compensation. Two months after the opening the state governor dismissed Lang for defying federal law over debt payments.

1944

Germany occupies its ally Hungary

Budapest, HungaryEurope

Learning that Hungary was sounding out the Allies about a separate peace, Hitler summoned the regent, Admiral Miklos Horthy, to Klessheim castle near Salzburg and kept him there while German divisions crossed the frontier on 19 March 1944. There was almost no resistance. Horthy stayed in office and appointed a pro-German government under Dome Sztojay. Adolf Eichmann arrived in Budapest with a small staff the same day. Between 15 May and 9 July, about 437,000 Jews from the Hungarian provinces were deported, nearly all to Auschwitz-Birkenau, where most were murdered on arrival. It was the fastest deportation of the Holocaust.

Seen from elsewhere. A memorial erected in Budapest in 2014 shows Hungary as an innocent angel seized by a German eagle. Historians, following Randolph Braham, point out that the round-ups were carried out by Hungarian gendarmes and officials under Hungarian laws. Horthy’s defenders note that he halted the transports in July, which spared most of Budapest’s Jews for a time.

1982

An Argentine flag goes up on South Georgia

Leith Harbour, South GeorgiaThe Americas

On 19 March 1982 a party of scrap-metal workers employed by an Argentine businessman, Constantino Davidoff, landed from the naval transport Bahia Buen Suceso at the derelict whaling station of Leith on the British island of South Georgia. They had a contract to dismantle it. They had not sought clearance at the British base at Grytviken, and scientists of the British Antarctic Survey found the Argentine flag flying and shots being fired at reindeer. London protested and sent the ice patrol ship Endurance with marines. Buenos Aires sent a warship to protect the men. Two weeks later Argentine forces invaded the Falkland Islands.

Seen from elsewhere. Argentina regards South Georgia and the Falklands, which it calls the Malvinas, as its territory, and held that Davidoff had notified the British embassy and needed no further leave. Whether the landing was a commercial venture exploited by the junta or a naval operation from the start is still debated. The war that followed killed 649 Argentines and 255 British.

Also on 19 March