Parallax

26 March, 1827

Beethoven dies in a thunderstorm

He had been dying for four months in a rented flat in Vienna. Almost everything said about his last hours comes from two men, one of whom was later caught forging evidence.

Vienna, Austria

Ludwig van Beethoven came back to Vienna on a December day in 1826 in an open cart, feverish, after a quarrel at his brother’s country house. He was 56 and had been deaf for years; visitors wrote their side of a conversation in notebooks and he answered aloud. Within days he had pneumonia, then jaundice, then a belly so swollen with fluid that his doctor, Andreas Wawruch, had him tapped four times. At the first tapping, seeing the water run, he is reported to have said that it was better from his belly than from his pen.

He lay in his second-floor rooms in the Schwarzspanierhaus through the winter, reading Walter Scott and a newly arrived edition of Handel. The Philharmonic Society of London sent a hundred pounds. Friends came: the young composer Ferdinand Hiller with his teacher Hummel, and possibly Franz Schubert. On 23 March he signed a one-sentence will leaving everything to his nephew Karl. On the 24th he received the last rites, and that day a case of Rhine wine he had asked for arrived from his publisher in Mainz. According to Anton Schindler, his unpaid secretary, he looked at the bottles and said: ‘Pity, pity, too late.’ He was unconscious by evening.

He lasted two more days. On the afternoon of 26 March the only people in the room were the composer Anselm Huttenbrenner and one woman. Huttenbrenner wrote, more than thirty years later, that at about a quarter to six, with snow on the ground, there was a flash of lightning and a great clap of thunder; the dying man opened his eyes, raised his right fist and let it fall. Huttenbrenner closed the eyes.

The next day the pathologist Johann Wagner opened the body. He found a shrunken, nodular liver and sawed out the bones around the ears in search of the cause of the deafness. Visitors cut locks from the head until, by one account, little hair was left. In a hidden drawer, friends found bank shares, the despairing letter to his brothers written at Heiligenstadt in 1802, and a love letter in pencil to an unnamed woman he called his Immortal Beloved.

The funeral on 29 March closed Vienna’s schools. Schubert was among the torchbearers. At the gates of the Wahring cemetery the actor Heinrich Anschutz spoke an oration written by the playwright Franz Grillparzer, because the rules did not allow speeches over the grave itself.

How it came to this

Beethoven was born in Bonn in December 1770, the son of a court singer who drank, and moved to Vienna at 21 to study with Haydn. He made his name as a pianist and improviser in aristocratic houses. Unlike most musicians of his day he never held a court post in Vienna: from 1809 three noblemen paid him an annuity simply to stay in the city, and he sold his works to publishers, sometimes the same work to more than one.

His hearing began to fail before he was thirty. The Heiligenstadt letter of 1802 speaks of thoughts of suicide and of being held back only by his art. By about 1818 he could not follow speech. In those years he also fought a long, bitter lawsuit against his sister-in-law Johanna for custody of her son Karl, whom he tried to raise as his own. In the summer of 1826 Karl, then nineteen, shot himself in the head and survived. Beethoven aged visibly afterwards. The last string quartets were finished in that same year.

How each side saw it

Anton Schindler and the Romantic legend

Schindler published the first major biography in 1840 and gave the nineteenth century the Beethoven it wanted: a titan defying fate, dying with a fist raised to the storm. He is the source for the wine remark and for the Latin tag ‘Plaudite, amici, comoedia finita est’, which he says was spoken after the priest left. He also claimed far longer intimacy with the composer than he had. In the 1970s researchers in Berlin showed that Schindler had written many entries into the conversation books after Beethoven’s death to support his own stories. Nothing that rests on his word alone is now taken on trust.

Johanna and Karl van Beethoven

The family’s side survives mainly in court papers and in Karl’s entries in the conversation books. Johanna, whom Beethoven called the Queen of the Night and accused of immorality before the courts, lost her only child to him for years. Karl’s remarks show a young man watched, lectured and forbidden to see his mother; he told the police after his suicide attempt that his uncle had tormented him too much. Karl was with his regiment in Moravia when Beethoven died. Huttenbrenner said only that the woman in the death room was Frau van Beethoven, which could mean Johanna or the other sister-in-law, Therese; the housekeeper Sali is another candidate.

The doctors, then and now

Wawruch’s own report blamed a chill and, by implication, drink. Wagner’s autopsy describes what modern physicians read as cirrhosis. A lock of hair sold in 1994 showed very high lead, and lead poisoning from adulterated wine or medicines became a popular explanation. In 2023 a team led by Tristan Begg sequenced DNA from several locks: five matched one another, and they showed inherited risk of liver disease and a hepatitis B infection. The famous lead-bearing lock turned out to come from a woman. Other authenticated locks have since been reported to contain high lead as well, so that question is not closed.

What is disputed

The last words are uncertain. The wine remark is the best supported, though it depends on Schindler; ‘I shall hear in heaven’ has no early source and is generally treated as invention. The thunderstorm rests on Huttenbrenner’s late memory, with some support from Vienna weather records. Mozart’s supposed prediction that the young Beethoven would make a noise in the world comes from a biography written decades later, and it is not certain the two ever met. The Immortal Beloved letter is a single letter of July 1812; Maynard Solomon argued for Antonie Brentano, while Marie-Elisabeth Tellenbach and others favour Josephine Brunsvik. Estimates of the funeral crowd run from 10,000 to 30,000.

What followed

His effects were auctioned within months; the manuscripts fetched little. Schubert died the next year and was buried, at his own wish, three graves away. Both bodies were exhumed in 1863 for study and moved in 1888 to the Central Cemetery. The image of the suffering genius who writes for posterity, fixed by the deathbed stories, shaped how composers from Wagner to Mahler saw themselves and how audiences learned to listen in silence. The Ninth Symphony’s choral theme is now the anthem of the European Union.

Read further

  • Alexander Wheelock Thayer, Thayer’s Life of Beethoven, revised and edited by Elliot Forbes (1964)
  • Maynard Solomon, Beethoven (1977)
  • Lewis Lockwood, Beethoven: The Music and the Life (2003)
  • Jan Swafford, Beethoven: Anguish and Triumph (2014)
  • Anton Schindler, Beethoven as I Knew Him, edited by Donald W. MacArdle (1966)

Same day, other years

1812

An earthquake shakes a young republic

Caracas, VenezuelaThe Americas

Venezuela had declared independence from Spain nine months earlier. On the hot afternoon of Maundy Thursday, 26 March 1812, with the churches full, an earthquake destroyed much of Caracas, La Guaira, Barquisimeto and Merida. Churches and barracks collapsed on the people inside them. Estimates of the dead range from about 10,000 to more than 20,000. The towns hit hardest were held by the patriots, while royalist Coro and Maracaibo were barely touched. Within four months the First Republic had collapsed, its commander Francisco de Miranda was a prisoner, and the young Simon Bolivar had fled to Curacao.

Seen from elsewhere. Royalist clergy, led by Archbishop Coll y Prat, preached that God had punished rebellion against the king, noting that the revolution had also begun on a Maundy Thursday. A royalist witness, Jose Domingo Diaz, reported Bolivar shouting in the ruins that if nature opposed them they would fight her too. Diaz was an enemy, and historians doubt his wording.

1885

First shots of the North-West Resistance

Duck Lake, Saskatchewan, CanadaThe Americas

The Metis of the South Saskatchewan valley, descendants of fur traders and First Nations women, had petitioned Ottawa for years for title to their river-lot farms. In March 1885 they formed a provisional government under Louis Riel, with the buffalo hunter Gabriel Dumont as military leader. On 26 March a column of North-West Mounted Police and volunteers from Fort Carlton met Dumont’s men on a snowy trail near Duck Lake. A parley turned into a scuffle and then a firefight lasting about half an hour. Twelve of the government party and five or six Metis and Cree were killed. Riel, carrying a crucifix, stopped the pursuit.

Seen from elsewhere. The Canadian government called it rebellion and sent some 5,000 troops by the new railway; Riel was hanged for treason in November. Metis tradition calls it a resistance in defence of land already theirs. Cree leaders such as Poundmaker and Big Bear, imprisoned afterwards, said they had not joined a rising; Canada exonerated Poundmaker in 2019.

1902

Cecil Rhodes dies at the Cape

Muizenberg, Cape Colony (now South Africa)Africa

Cecil Rhodes died of heart failure in a small seaside cottage at Muizenberg, aged 48, while the South African War he had helped to bring about was still being fought. The son of an English vicar, he had made a fortune consolidating the Kimberley diamond mines into De Beers, become prime minister of the Cape, and used a chartered company with its own police to seize the lands north of the Limpopo that were named Rhodesia after him. His body was carried by train to the Matobo hills and buried in the granite. His will founded the scholarships at Oxford that still bear his name.

Seen from elsewhere. For the Ndebele and Shona his company meant a fraudulent concession from King Lobengula in 1888, conquest in 1893 and the crushing of their risings in 1896-97. As Cape premier he sponsored the Glen Grey Act, which restricted African landholding and voting. Since the Rhodes Must Fall protests of 2015 his statues and his grave have been openly contested.

1979

Egypt and Israel sign a peace treaty

Washington, DC, United StatesMiddle East

On the north lawn of the White House, Anwar Sadat of Egypt and Menachem Begin of Israel signed the first peace treaty between Israel and an Arab state, with President Jimmy Carter as witness. It followed Sadat’s journey to Jerusalem in 1977 and thirteen days of negotiation at Camp David in 1978. The two countries had fought four wars in thirty years. Israel agreed to withdraw from the whole Sinai peninsula, including its settlements and airfields, which it completed in 1982; Egypt recognised Israel and opened the Suez Canal to its ships. The treaty has held ever since.

Seen from elsewhere. Most Arab governments and the Palestine Liberation Organisation called it a separate peace that abandoned the Palestinians, whose promised autonomy never materialised. Egypt was suspended from the Arab League, which moved its headquarters to Tunis. Israeli settlers evicted from Sinai felt betrayed by Begin. Sadat was shot dead by Egyptian Islamist soldiers at a parade in October 1981.

Also on 26 March