Parallax

17 March, 1680

La Rochefoucauld meets the thing he said could not be looked at

A duke who had failed at conspiracy, war and court politics died in Paris having written a few hundred sentences about self-love that readers have been arguing with ever since.

Paris, France

In the night of 16 to 17 March 1680, Francois VI, duc de La Rochefoucauld, died in his house in Paris at the age of 66. Gout had tormented him for years and in the last days it rose, as his physicians put it, into the chest. Bossuet, the great preacher of the age, came to give him the last sacraments. Madame de Sevigne, who reported the illness to her daughter in Provence, wrote that a man who had spent his whole life reflecting had not done so in vain, and that he met his last moments as if they held nothing new or strange for him.

It was a quiet end for a man whose first forty years had been a sequence of plots that went wrong. As the young prince de Marcillac he attached himself to the queen, Anne of Austria, and to the duchesse de Chevreuse in their intrigues against Cardinal Richelieu, which earned him eight days in the Bastille in 1637 and two years of exile on his estates at Verteuil. When Richelieu died he expected his reward from the queen and did not get it. Resentment, and a love affair with the duchesse de Longueville, sister of the prince de Conde, carried him into the Fronde, the civil wars of 1648-53 against Cardinal Mazarin.

He fought bravely and to no purpose. On 2 July 1652, in the battle at the Faubourg Saint-Antoine under the walls of Paris, a musket ball struck him across the face and for a time he was thought to have lost his sight. He came out of the Fronde half blind, in debt and politically finished, at 39.

What followed was the life for which he is remembered. Allowed back to Paris, he became a fixture of the salon of Madame de Sable, near the convent of Port-Royal, where she, the moralist Jacques Esprit and the duke turned the composing of sentences into a shared game, passing drafts back and forth by letter and inviting criticism. A pirated edition appeared in Holland in 1664; the first authorised one followed in Paris within months, dated 1665. He revised it for the rest of his life. The fifth edition of 1678 contained 504 maxims.

Their subject is amour-propre, the self-love that he found at the root of nearly everything people admire in themselves. From the fourth edition the book carried an epigraph stating that our virtues are most often only vices in disguise. The maxim that neither the sun nor death can be looked at steadily is number 26.

His last years were darkened by more than gout. At the crossing of the Rhine in June 1672 one of his sons was killed, his heir was wounded, and so was the young duc de Longueville, widely taken to be his son by the duchess, who died there. Sevigne, who saw him receive the news, wrote of his tears. His daily companion by then was Madame de La Fayette, the novelist, in whose house he spent most afternoons. When he died Sevigne asked where her friend would ever find such another.

How it came to this

The French high nobility of La Rochefoucauld’s youth still thought of itself as a partner of the crown, with a right to governorships, armies and a voice in council. Richelieu under Louis XIII, and Mazarin during the minority of Louis XIV, worked to reduce that partnership to service. The Fronde was the last armed attempt by princes and judges to reverse the process, and it ended in a confusion of shifting alliances in which almost every participant changed sides at least once. Its failure opened the way to the personal rule of Louis XIV from 1661 and to a court in which great nobles competed for favour rather than power.

The salons gave that defeated class something else to do. Hostesses such as the marquise de Sable presided over a culture of conversation, portraits in prose and polished short forms. Sable’s circle was close to the Jansenists of Port-Royal, who taught, following Saint Augustine, that human nature after the Fall was ruled by self-love and that apparent virtue without grace was counterfeit. La Rochefoucauld’s Memoires, printed without his consent in 1662, had made him enemies. The Maximes, by contrast, named no one and implicated everyone.

How each side saw it

Cardinal de Retz, his enemy in the Fronde

Retz and La Rochefoucauld loathed each other; the duke is said to have tried to crush the future cardinal between the doors of the Parlement in 1651. In his own Memoires Retz left a portrait of his rival that has stuck. There was always, he wrote, a certain je ne sais quoi about Monsieur de La Rochefoucauld: he was never a warrior though very much a soldier, never a good courtier though he always meant to be, never a good party man though all his life engaged in parties. The fault Retz named was irresolution. La Rochefoucauld wrote a counter-portrait of Retz that was hardly kinder.

The women of the salons

The Maximes were tested on women before they were printed. Madame de Sable collected opinions from her friends, and several were hostile. Madame de La Fayette, who did not yet know the author well, wrote to Sable in 1663 that one must have great corruption of mind and heart to be capable of imagining all this. Others objected that he had described his own heart and attributed it to mankind. La Fayette later became his closest friend. The remark attributed to her, that he gave her wit but she reformed his heart, is known only from later report and may be a salon polish of something plainer.

Later readers, from Voltaire to Nietzsche

Voltaire, in his history of the age of Louis XIV, called the little book one of the works that did most to form the taste of the nation, while observing that it contained scarcely more than one truth, that self-love is the motive of everything. Rousseau thought it a sad book that slandered humanity. Nineteenth-century moralists often treated it as the bitterness of a disappointed plotter. Nietzsche, who admired the French moralists above almost all other writers, took La Rochefoucauld as a model for the psychological aphorisms of Human, All Too Human, and as a forerunner in unmasking the motives behind morality.

What is disputed

Scholars disagree about what kind of book the Maximes is. An older reading saw worldly, even Epicurean, cynicism. Jean Lafond and others have argued since the 1970s that it is an Augustinian work, close to Port-Royal, which strips away false virtue to leave room for grace; against that, the author removed most references to God after the first edition. How much Madame de Sable and Jacques Esprit contributed to individual maxims cannot be settled, since the sentences were worked over collectively. His death is given as 17 March because it came in the small hours; some older reference books print 16 March.

What followed

The Maximes has never been out of print. It fixed the detached aphorism as a French literary form, taken up by La Bruyere, Vauvenargues and Chamfort, and its suspicion of stated motives runs through later thought, from the Jansenist-tinged novels of Madame de La Fayette to Nietzsche and to psychoanalysis. La Fayette published La Princesse de Cleves in 1678, and contemporaries assumed the duke had a hand in it; she outlived him by thirteen years. The political world he had fought for, in which a duke might bargain with his king as an equal, did not return.

Read further

  • La Rochefoucauld, Collected Maxims and Other Reflections, translated by E. H. Blackmore, A. M. Blackmore and Francine Giguere (2007)
  • Madame de Sevigne, Selected Letters, translated by Leonard Tancock (1982)
  • Jean Lafond, La Rochefoucauld: Augustinisme et litterature (1977)
  • W. G. Moore, La Rochefoucauld: His Mind and Art (1969)
  • Cardinal de Retz, Memoires

Same day, other years

AD 180

Marcus Aurelius dies on the Danube frontier

Vindobona or Sirmium, Roman PannoniaEurope

The emperor Marcus Aurelius died on campaign on 17 March 180, aged 58, after nearly two decades in which Rome had fought Parthia in the east and the Marcomanni, Quadi and Sarmatians along the Danube, while an epidemic brought back by the eastern army killed soldiers and civilians across the empire. The private notebook he kept in Greek, known as the Meditations, was partly written in camp. He left the empire to his eighteen-year-old son Commodus, the first son born to a reigning emperor to succeed in more than a century, who made peace on the frontier within months and went home to Rome.

Seen from elsewhere. The peoples he fought left no written account; the reliefs on his column in Rome show their villages burned and their captives beheaded. Christians remembered his reign for the killings at Lyon in 177. Ancient writers disagree on where he died, and Cassius Dio alleges that his doctors hastened the end to please Commodus.

1861

A Kingdom of Italy is proclaimed, without Rome or Venice

Turin, PiedmontEurope

On 17 March 1861 a parliament sitting in Turin passed a law of a single article by which Victor Emmanuel II of Sardinia took for himself and his successors the title King of Italy. In less than two years the wars of 1859 and Garibaldi’s expedition of the Thousand had joined Lombardy, the central duchies, most of the Papal States and the Bourbon kingdom of the Two Sicilies to Piedmont. The king kept his old numeral, the Piedmontese constitution was extended to the whole country, and Cavour, the architect of the settlement, died less than three months later. Venetia remained Austrian until 1866 and Rome papal until 1870.

Seen from elsewhere. In the south the new state was met by a guerrilla war that Turin called brigandage and put down with tens of thousands of troops and summary executions; a strand of southern opinion still calls unification a conquest. Pope Pius IX refused to recognise the kingdom and forbade Catholics to take part in its politics.

1959

The Dalai Lama slips out of Lhasa

Lhasa, TibetAsia

On the night of 17 March 1959 the fourteenth Dalai Lama, Tenzin Gyatso, then 23, left the Norbulingka summer palace disguised as a soldier with a rifle over his shoulder. For a week crowds of Tibetans had surrounded the palace, fearing that an invitation to a theatrical performance at the Chinese army headquarters was a plan to abduct him. That afternoon two shells had landed in the grounds. He crossed the Kyichu river with his family and ministers and rode south over the Himalaya, reaching India on 31 March. The People’s Liberation Army shelled the Norbulingka on 20 March and crushed the rising in Lhasa within days.

Seen from elsewhere. Beijing’s account is that a reactionary clique of serf-owning nobles and monks rebelled to preserve feudal rule, and it marks 28 March as Serfs’ Emancipation Day. The Tibetan government in exile speaks of the destruction of a nation. Death tolls for the rising are disputed, and a widely quoted figure of 87,000 rests on a contested reading of a Chinese military document.

1992

White South Africans vote to negotiate apartheid away

South AfricaAfrica

After losing a run of by-elections to the right-wing Conservative Party, President F. W. de Klerk called a referendum of the white electorate for 17 March 1992, asking whether it supported continuing the reform process he had begun in 1990, aimed at a new constitution through negotiation. He promised to resign if he lost. Turnout was about 85 per cent, and 68.7 per cent voted yes, with a majority in every region but one, the northern Transvaal around Pietersburg. It was the last time South Africans voted in a racially restricted poll. Talks resumed, broke down in June after the Boipatong massacre, and led to the all-race election of April 1994.

Seen from elsewhere. The black majority, whose future was the subject, had no vote. The African National Congress objected to a racial referendum in principle yet urged whites to vote yes. The Conservative Party under Andries Treurnicht argued that whites were being asked to sign away self-determination, and said the campaign had been swamped by business money and media pressure.

Also on 17 March