It rained in Oxford on the morning of Saturday 21 March 1556, so the sermon that should have been preached at the stake was moved indoors, to the University Church of St Mary. Thomas Cranmer, 66 years old, deprived Archbishop of Canterbury, was led in between two Spanish friars and placed on a low platform opposite the pulpit, in a torn gown and an old square cap. A Catholic eyewitness who signed himself J.A. wrote that it was a sorrowful sight even to those who condemned him.
Cranmer had spent two and a half years in prison. In the past two months he had signed six statements, each fuller than the last, accepting the pope, the mass and transubstantiation and calling himself a worse offender than the thief on the cross. By the ordinary practice of the Church a penitent heretic who had not relapsed was spared. The queen’s government had decided that he would burn regardless, and that his public recantation beforehand would be the regime’s greatest triumph. A text had been agreed and already sent to the printer.
The preacher, Henry Cole, explained to the congregation why this penitent must nevertheless die, and promised that masses would be said for his soul. Cranmer wept as he listened. Then he was invited to speak. He prayed, urged the people to obey the queen and to love one another, and recited the creed, all as expected. Then he came, he said, to the great thing that troubled his conscience more than anything he had ever done: the writings he had signed contrary to the truth he held in his heart, for fear of death. Since his hand had offended, it would be punished first. As for the pope, he refused him as Christ’s enemy and Antichrist.
There was uproar. Cole shouted to stop the heretic’s mouth, and Cranmer was pulled down from the platform. Witnesses agree that he then went so fast through the streets to the ditch outside the north gate, where Hugh Latimer and Nicholas Ridley had been burned five months earlier, that the friars could hardly keep up with him.
He was chained to the stake in a long shirt, bareheaded. When the wood was lit he stretched out his right hand and held it in the flame where everyone could see, withdrawing it only once to wipe his face. He was heard to say ‘this unworthy right hand’ repeatedly, and at the end the words of the first martyr, Stephen: ‘Lord Jesus, receive my spirit.’ J.A., who thought his cause wicked, wrote that his patience in the torment would have been admirable in a better one.
How it came to this
Cranmer was an obscure Cambridge theologian when, in 1529, he suggested a way round the pope in the matter of Henry VIII’s marriage to Catherine of Aragon. In 1533, as the new Archbishop of Canterbury, he pronounced that marriage void and so made Catherine’s daughter Mary a bastard in law. He served Henry for fourteen more years, keeping his own Protestant convictions, and a German wife, largely out of sight. Under the boy king Edward VI he was free to act: the Books of Common Prayer of 1549 and 1552, mostly his work, replaced the Latin mass with services in English.
When Edward died in 1553 Cranmer signed the document diverting the crown to Lady Jane Grey. Mary took the throne within days, restored the mass, and in 1554 reconciled England to Rome. Cranmer was convicted of treason but kept alive to be tried for heresy under papal authority, a process that took until February 1556, when he was ceremonially stripped of his orders. His whole career had rested on the doctrine that subjects must obey their prince in religion. His prince now commanded him to be a Catholic.