Parallax

21 March, 1556

Cranmer puts his right hand in the fire

The archbishop who wrote the English prayer book had signed away everything he believed. Given a pulpit to say so in public, he said the opposite, and ran to the stake.

Oxford, England

It rained in Oxford on the morning of Saturday 21 March 1556, so the sermon that should have been preached at the stake was moved indoors, to the University Church of St Mary. Thomas Cranmer, 66 years old, deprived Archbishop of Canterbury, was led in between two Spanish friars and placed on a low platform opposite the pulpit, in a torn gown and an old square cap. A Catholic eyewitness who signed himself J.A. wrote that it was a sorrowful sight even to those who condemned him.

Cranmer had spent two and a half years in prison. In the past two months he had signed six statements, each fuller than the last, accepting the pope, the mass and transubstantiation and calling himself a worse offender than the thief on the cross. By the ordinary practice of the Church a penitent heretic who had not relapsed was spared. The queen’s government had decided that he would burn regardless, and that his public recantation beforehand would be the regime’s greatest triumph. A text had been agreed and already sent to the printer.

The preacher, Henry Cole, explained to the congregation why this penitent must nevertheless die, and promised that masses would be said for his soul. Cranmer wept as he listened. Then he was invited to speak. He prayed, urged the people to obey the queen and to love one another, and recited the creed, all as expected. Then he came, he said, to the great thing that troubled his conscience more than anything he had ever done: the writings he had signed contrary to the truth he held in his heart, for fear of death. Since his hand had offended, it would be punished first. As for the pope, he refused him as Christ’s enemy and Antichrist.

There was uproar. Cole shouted to stop the heretic’s mouth, and Cranmer was pulled down from the platform. Witnesses agree that he then went so fast through the streets to the ditch outside the north gate, where Hugh Latimer and Nicholas Ridley had been burned five months earlier, that the friars could hardly keep up with him.

He was chained to the stake in a long shirt, bareheaded. When the wood was lit he stretched out his right hand and held it in the flame where everyone could see, withdrawing it only once to wipe his face. He was heard to say ‘this unworthy right hand’ repeatedly, and at the end the words of the first martyr, Stephen: ‘Lord Jesus, receive my spirit.’ J.A., who thought his cause wicked, wrote that his patience in the torment would have been admirable in a better one.

How it came to this

Cranmer was an obscure Cambridge theologian when, in 1529, he suggested a way round the pope in the matter of Henry VIII’s marriage to Catherine of Aragon. In 1533, as the new Archbishop of Canterbury, he pronounced that marriage void and so made Catherine’s daughter Mary a bastard in law. He served Henry for fourteen more years, keeping his own Protestant convictions, and a German wife, largely out of sight. Under the boy king Edward VI he was free to act: the Books of Common Prayer of 1549 and 1552, mostly his work, replaced the Latin mass with services in English.

When Edward died in 1553 Cranmer signed the document diverting the crown to Lady Jane Grey. Mary took the throne within days, restored the mass, and in 1554 reconciled England to Rome. Cranmer was convicted of treason but kept alive to be tried for heresy under papal authority, a process that took until February 1556, when he was ceremonially stripped of his orders. His whole career had rested on the doctrine that subjects must obey their prince in religion. His prince now commanded him to be a Catholic.

How each side saw it

Queen Mary’s Church

To Mary, Cardinal Pole and their bishops, Cranmer was the chief author of twenty years of schism, the man who had broken a lawful marriage, torn down the mass and led a nation’s souls into peril. A Catholic narrative of the time, Bishop Cranmer’s Recantacyons, probably by Nicholas Harpsfield, treats his last speech as the final proof of a lifelong dissembler who had changed his opinions to please each master. Pole wrote that his crimes were too great for the usual mercy. The government printed the six recantations anyway, without the ending, and was mocked for it in London.

John Foxe and the Protestant tradition

Foxe, an exile during Mary’s reign, gathered documents and eyewitness reports for his Acts and Monuments, first published in English in 1563 and soon placed in cathedrals and parish churches. For him Cranmer’s fall and recovery showed God’s strength made perfect in weakness, and the burning hand became one of the best-known images in English Protestantism. Foxe did not hide the recantations but blamed them on isolation, false promises of life and the persuasion of the friars. His book made the roughly 280 people burned under Mary into the founding martyrs of a national church, and fixed the queen’s reputation for centuries.

Those Cranmer himself helped to condemn

Cranmer was not an opponent of burning heretics. As archbishop he took part in the proceedings against John Frith in 1533 and John Lambert in 1538, both burned for denying the bodily presence of Christ in the sacrament, a doctrine he later abandoned himself. Under Edward he condemned the Anabaptist Joan Bocher, burned in 1550, and the Unitarian George van Parris. When the people of Devon and Cornwall rose against his new prayer book in 1549 he wrote a scornful reply to their demands; several thousand of them were killed. Their side survives chiefly in the list of articles that he answered.

What is disputed

Whether the recantations were sincere is the central argument. Diarmaid MacCulloch reads them as the collapse of a man whose theory of royal authority had trapped him, followed by a genuine recovery once he knew he would die. Catholic historians have seen calculation at both stages, and Eamon Duffy stresses that the regime’s campaign of persuasion was more serious and more successful than Foxe allowed. The precise wording of the final speech differs between Foxe, the J.A. letter and the Catholic account. It is also debated whether Mary’s refusal of mercy was personal revenge for her mother or a judgement that his offence was unique.

What followed

Reginald Pole was consecrated Archbishop of Canterbury the day after the burning. He and Mary both died on 17 November 1558, and under Elizabeth I Cranmer’s second prayer book was restored with small changes. Its language, revised in 1662, shaped English worship and English prose for four hundred years and travelled wherever the Anglican Church went. The manner of his death undid much of what his recantations had given the Catholic cause. A Martyrs’ Memorial was put up in Oxford in 1841-43, partly as a Protestant rebuke to the Catholic-leaning Oxford Movement; a cross set in the roadway of Broad Street marks the site.

Read further

  • Diarmaid MacCulloch, Thomas Cranmer: A Life (1996)
  • Eamon Duffy, Fires of Faith: Catholic England under Mary Tudor (2009)
  • John Foxe, Acts and Monuments (1563)
  • Jasper Ridley, Thomas Cranmer (1962)
  • Ashley Null, Thomas Cranmer’s Doctrine of Repentance (2000)

Same day, other years

1617

Pocahontas is buried at Gravesend

Gravesend, EnglandEurope

The parish register of St George’s, Gravesend, records the burial on 21 March 1617 of ‘Rebecca Wrolfe, wife of Thomas Wrolfe gent., a Virginia lady born’. She was Matoaka, known as Pocahontas, a daughter of the paramount chief Powhatan, and about twenty-one. Captured by the English in 1613, she had been baptised and married to the tobacco planter John Rolfe, and in 1616 the Virginia Company brought her to London with her infant son to advertise the colony. She was received at court. She fell ill as the ship taking her home sailed down the Thames, and was carried ashore to die. The cause is unknown.

Seen from elsewhere. She left no words of her own. An oral history published in 2007 by members of the Mattaponi tribe holds that she was raped in captivity and may have been poisoned; academic historians treat it with caution but agree the English accounts are self-serving. John Smith’s tale of her saving his life first appeared in 1624, after she was dead.

1804

France receives the Code Napoleon

Paris, FranceEurope

On 21 March 1804 the thirty-six laws drafted over the previous four years were promulgated together as the Civil Code of the French. Four jurists led by Jean-Etienne-Marie Portalis had fused the customary law of northern France, the Roman law of the south and the legislation of the Revolution into 2,281 articles of plain prose. Bonaparte, then First Consul, presided over more than half the sessions of the Council of State that revised it. It confirmed equality of citizens before the law, the abolition of feudal dues, freedom of contract and secure private property. French armies carried it across Europe, and it later served as a model from Louisiana to Egypt and Japan.

Seen from elsewhere. The code gave husbands authority over wives, who owed obedience, could not contract or go to law without consent, and faced harsher rules on adultery. It forbade paternity suits and curtailed the divorce law of 1792. Nor did its equality reach the colonies, where Bonaparte had restored slavery in 1802.

1935

Persia asks the world to call it Iran

Tehran, IranMiddle East

From Nowruz, the Persian new year, on 21 March 1935, the government of Reza Shah required foreign legations to use the name Iran in all official dealings. The word was not new. It derives from the same root as ‘Aryan’ and had been the people’s own name for their country since at least Sasanian times, whereas ‘Persia’ came from the Greeks, who named the whole after the south-western province of Fars. The shah, a soldier who had taken the throne in 1925, was building a centralised state with a national army, railways, a university and a dress code, and the change was meant to mark a break with the Qajar past.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Iranian scholars regretted it, arguing that ‘Persia’ carried the associations of an ancient culture while ‘Iran’ meant little abroad; the historian Ehsan Yarshater later campaigned to revive the older name. The suggestion is often said to have come from Iran’s legation in Berlin, and the appeal of the Aryan idea at that date has been debated. In 1959 both names were declared acceptable.

1960

Police open fire at Sharpeville

Sharpeville, Transvaal, South AfricaAfrica

The Pan Africanist Congress, led by Robert Sobukwe, called on Black South Africans to leave at home the passbooks they were required to carry and present themselves for arrest on 21 March 1960. At Sharpeville, a township near Vereeniging, several thousand people gathered outside the police station. Early in the afternoon, without an order to disperse being heard, police fired more than a thousand rounds into the crowd. The official count was 69 dead, including women and children, and about 180 wounded; most had been shot from behind. The government declared a state of emergency, detained thousands and banned both the PAC and the African National Congress.

Seen from elsewhere. Police told the inquiry that a hostile crowd of 20,000 had stoned them, and recalled nine policemen killed at Cato Manor weeks before. Witnesses described a smaller, largely peaceable gathering. The Truth and Reconciliation Commission found in 1998 that the shooting was a gross violation of human rights. Research by Nancy Clark and William Worger puts the dead at 91 or more.

Also on 21 March