Parallax

2 March, 1476

The richest prince in Europe runs from the Swiss at Grandson

Charles the Bold lost few men beside Lake Neuchatel but left behind his artillery, his chapel, his seal and his jewels. The victors spent years quarrelling over the loot.

Grandson, Vaud, Switzerland

In February 1476 Charles, Duke of Burgundy, crossed the Jura in the snow with an army of around 20,000 and the most modern artillery train in Europe. He had come to punish Bern and its allies, who had spent the previous year seizing the castles of Vaud. The first to resist him was Grandson, on the shore of Lake Neuchatel, held by a Bernese garrison. After a bombardment the garrison gave itself up on 28 February, apparently believing it had been promised its lives. Charles had all 412 men hanged from the trees around the castle or drowned in the lake. It took several hours.

The army of the Swiss Confederation, some 18,000 to 20,000 men from Bern, Zurich, Lucerne, Schwyz, Uri and their allies, was already marching up the lake to relieve the castle. On the morning of 2 March its vanguard came out of the wooded hills near the village of Concise and found the Burgundians advancing along the shore. The Swiss formed a square of pikes and halberds and knelt to pray. Some chroniclers say the Burgundians took this for surrender.

Charles sent his heavy cavalry at the square. It could not break in; Louis de Chalon, lord of Chateau-Guyon, got as far as a Swiss banner and was killed there. The duke then ordered part of his line to pull back, to draw the Swiss down into open ground where his guns and archers could work. At that moment the main body of the Confederates appeared on the heights to the left, announcing itself with the great war horns of Uri and Lucerne. The Burgundian troops in the rear saw their own front ranks retiring and a fresh enemy arriving, and concluded the day was lost. The army dissolved. Charles rode among the fugitives striking at them with his sword and was carried away with them.

The Swiss had almost no cavalry and could not pursue. The killing was slight by the standards of the age, a few hundred on each side. What the victors found was the garrison of Grandson still hanging in the trees, and then the Burgundian camp, abandoned intact. In it were more than four hundred guns, hundreds of banners, the duke’s tents and silver plate, embroidered hangings, his portable chapel with its reliquaries, his golden seal, and a casket of jewels that included the pendant called the Three Brothers.

Peasant soldiers cut cloth of gold into strips and sold silver dishes as pewter. The cantons tried to hold everything in common for an orderly division, and failed.

How it came to this

Charles had inherited in 1467 a collection of lands running from Holland and Flanders to the borders of Savoy, the wealthiest in northern Europe, held partly from the French king and partly from the emperor. He wanted to join the two halves and turn the whole into a kingdom. That meant acquiring Alsace and Lorraine, which lay in between. In 1469 the Habsburg duke Sigismund pawned his Alsatian lands to Charles, whose governor there, Peter von Hagenbach, made himself so hated that the Rhine towns rose, tried him and beheaded him in 1474.

The towns found allies in the Swiss, and above all in Bern, which had its own ambitions to the west. Louis XI of France, who feared Charles more than anyone, paid pensions to the cantons and encouraged the war while staying out of it. In 1474 the Swiss beat a Burgundian force at Hericourt; in 1475 Bern and Fribourg overran Vaud, which belonged to Savoy, Burgundy’s ally, and massacred the defenders of Estavayer. Charles, having just conquered Lorraine, turned south to settle the matter in person.

How each side saw it

The Swiss Confederates

The Bernese councillor Diebold Schilling, who wrote and illustrated the city’s official chronicle within a few years, presents Grandson as God’s judgement on a tyrant who had murdered men after they surrendered. The hanged garrison is at the centre of his account, and it explains the order given before the next battle, at Murten, to take no prisoners. Swiss tradition made the three battles against Charles the founding proof that free townsmen and mountain farmers on foot could beat princes on horseback. A rhyme still taught in Swiss schools says that he lost his goods at Grandson, his courage at Murten and his blood at Nancy.

The Burgundian court

Charles’s own circle treated the day as a humiliating accident rather than a defeat in the field. The Milanese ambassador Giovanni Pietro Panigarola, who was with the duke and wrote home within days, describes a panic that began among camp servants and Italian mercenaries while Charles tried to rally them. The court chronicler Jean Molinet blamed cowardice in the rear. Charles himself wrote that he had lost little and would soon return, and within three months he had rebuilt his army at Lausanne. The execution of the garrison was, by the laws of war as he understood them, the lawful penalty for holding an untenable place against a prince.

Philippe de Commynes and the French king

Commynes had deserted Charles for Louis XI four years earlier and wrote his memoirs with that choice to justify. He says the duke lost only seven men-at-arms at Grandson but forfeited his honour and his possessions, and he gives the credit to Louis, who destroyed his rival without drawing a sword by paying others to fight. He also reports that Charles fell into a depression afterwards, let his beard grow and drank heavily. Historians use Commynes constantly and trust him cautiously: he was not there, and he had every reason to show that leaving Charles had been wise.

The people of Vaud

The French-speaking country around the lake was Savoyard, and its nobles and towns had mostly sided with Burgundy. For them the war began not with Charles’s cruelty at Grandson but with the Bernese invasion of 1475, the sack of their towns and the killing at Estavayer, where the garrison and many townsmen were put to the sword. Few of their own accounts survive, and the story has mostly been told from Bernese sources. Bern took permanent control of Vaud in 1536 and governed it as subject territory until 1798, which is why Vaudois historians have tended to read 1476 as the start of a conquest.

What is disputed

Numbers first. Older accounts, following Swiss chroniclers, gave Charles two or three times the Confederates’ strength; modern estimates, including Richard Vaughan’s, put the two armies at roughly equal size, around 20,000 each. Whether the garrison was promised its life is asserted by Swiss sources and denied by Burgundian ones. The jewels have attracted legend: the Sancy and the Florentine diamonds are both claimed to have been picked up at Grandson or after Charles’s death at Nancy, and neither provenance can be documented. The Three Brothers is real and traceable: it passed to the Fuggers and then to the English crown before vanishing in the seventeenth century.

What followed

Charles came back in June and was beaten far more bloodily at Murten. In January 1477 he was killed outside Nancy, and his body was found days later in a frozen pond. His daughter Mary married Maximilian of Habsburg, and the struggle between France and the Habsburgs over the Burgundian inheritance shaped European politics for two centuries. Swiss infantry became the most sought-after mercenaries on the continent. Disputes over sharing the booty strained the Confederation almost to breaking until the agreement of Stans in 1481. What survives of the loot is in the Bern Historical Museum.

Read further

  • Richard Vaughan, Charles the Bold: The Last Valois Duke of Burgundy (1973)
  • Philippe de Commynes, Memoirs: The Reign of Louis XI, translated by Michael Jones (1972)
  • Diebold Schilling, Amtliche Berner Chronik (1483)
  • Florens Deuchler, Die Burgunderbeute (1963)

Same day, other years

1657

The Meireki fire destroys most of Edo

Edo (Tokyo), JapanAsia

After eighty days without rain, a fire broke out in the Hongo district of the shogun’s capital on the eighteenth day of the first month of the year Meireki 3. A north-westerly gale drove it through a city built of wood and paper, and new outbreaks followed on the next two days. Crowds were trapped against the moats and at bridges; at one gate, shut by guards who feared escaping prisoners, thousands were crushed or burned. When it ended, perhaps two thirds of Edo was ash, including the great keep of the castle, which was never rebuilt. The government buried the unclaimed dead in a mass grave and founded the temple of Eko-in over it.

Seen from elsewhere. The traditional toll of over 100,000 comes from a popular account published four years later; some historians think 30,000 to 50,000 more likely. The tale that a priest burning a cursed kimono started it is a later legend. Another theory holds that the fire began in a senior councillor’s mansion and a temple was allowed to take the blame.

1836

Texas declares independence from Mexico

Washington-on-the-Brazos, TexasThe Americas

Fifty-nine delegates meeting in an unfinished frame building, with cloth stretched over the window openings against a freezing wind, adopted a declaration of independence while a Mexican army was besieging the Alamo 150 miles away. The text, modelled on the American one of 1776, accused General Santa Anna of overthrowing the federal constitution of 1824 under which the settlers had come. Most signers had been born in the United States; three, including Jose Antonio Navarro and Jose Francisco Ruiz, were Tejanos or Mexican-born. A constitution followed two weeks later. Santa Anna was defeated and captured at San Jacinto in April, and Texas remained a separate republic until the United States annexed it in 1845.

Seen from elsewhere. Mexico saw a revolt by immigrants who had sworn allegiance, backed from across the border, and never recognised it. Slavery was central: Mexico had decreed abolition in 1829, while the new constitution protected slaveholding and barred free Black people from living in Texas without the legislature’s permission. Many Tejanos who fought for the republic were later driven off their land.

1956

France ends its protectorate over Morocco

Paris and RabatAfrica

A joint declaration signed in Paris cancelled the Treaty of Fez of 1912 and recognised Morocco’s independence after forty-four years of French rule. It came with remarkable speed. In 1953 France had deposed Sultan Mohammed ben Youssef for his sympathy with the nationalists and flown him into exile in Madagascar. The result was a boycott, urban bombings and a rural Liberation Army, at a moment when France was already fighting in Algeria. In November 1955 Paris brought the sultan back to cheering crowds; four months later the protectorate was gone. Spain gave up its northern zone in April, and the sultan took the title King Mohammed V the following year.

Seen from elsewhere. Some 400,000 European settlers had been promised permanence and most left within a few years. Nationalists of the Istiqlal party expected a constitutional monarchy and found the palace keeping power. Moroccans celebrate independence on 18 November, the day of the king’s return, not 2 March. Spain kept Ceuta, Melilla, Ifni and the Sahara, disputes that continue.

1962

Ne Win’s army takes power in Burma

Rangoon, BurmaAsia

Before dawn, troops loyal to General Ne Win arrested Prime Minister U Nu, his cabinet and the leaders of the Shan and Karenni states, who were in Rangoon for a conference on turning the Union into a looser federation. The coup was almost bloodless. The exception was at the house of Sao Shwe Thaik, a Shan prince who had been Burma’s first president: soldiers shot dead his teenage son, and he himself died in custody that year. A Revolutionary Council of officers suspended the constitution, dissolved parliament and announced a ‘Burmese Way to Socialism’. In July the army fired on protesting students and dynamited the student union building at Rangoon University.

Seen from elsewhere. The generals said they had saved the Union from breaking up. Shan, Kachin, Karen and other minority leaders say the coup tore up the federal promise made at Panglong in 1947 and turned grievances into decades of insurgency. Nationalised and closed to the world, one of Asia’s richer countries became one of its poorest. The army has held or shared power almost continuously since.

Also on 2 March