Parallax

24 March, 1603

Elizabeth I dies without naming her heir aloud

For forty-four years she had refused to say who would follow her. At the end she could not speak at all, and the men around her bed reported that she had made a sign.

Richmond Palace, Surrey, England

In January 1603 Elizabeth moved her court up the Thames to Richmond, the warmest of her houses, in foul weather. She was 69, older than any English monarch before her. In February her cousin and companion of many years, the Countess of Nottingham, died, and the queen sank into a melancholy that nothing lifted. Her coronation ring, which she had worn since 1559 and called her wedding ring to the kingdom, had grown into the flesh and had to be filed off.

Her kinsman Robert Carey came to court in March and found her sitting low on cushions in a withdrawing room. She took his hand and wrung it hard. ‘No, Robin, I am not well,’ she said, and spoke of a heaviness about her heart, and in the course of their talk, he wrote, she fetched not so few as forty or fifty great sighs. He had never known her sigh before except when the Queen of Scots was beheaded.

She would not eat, would take no medicine and would not go to bed. For days she remained on the cushions, at times standing for hours, at times silent with a finger in her mouth. Her throat was swollen with ulcers. When the Lord Admiral, Nottingham’s widower, at last persuaded her to lie down, partly by entreaty and partly by force, she had already told him that if he were used to seeing in his bed what she saw in hers, he would not ask it. Robert Cecil, her Secretary of State, is reported to have told her that to content the people she must go to bed, and to have been answered that ‘must’ was not a word to be used to princes.

By Wednesday 23 March she had lost her speech. That afternoon the councillors came to ask about the succession. According to the account they put about, when the King of Scots was named she lifted her hand to her head, which they took for assent. In the evening she signed for John Whitgift, Archbishop of Canterbury. The old man knelt by the bed and prayed until his knees gave out; when he blessed her and made to rise she gestured for him to go on, and he did so for a long half hour more, twice.

She died between two and three on the morning of Thursday 24 March. The lawyer John Manningham, who had it that day from her chaplain, wrote in his diary that she departed mildly like a lamb, easily like a ripe apple from the tree. Carey, who had horses posted along the Great North Road, was let out of the palace gate and rode for Scotland. He reached Edinburgh late on the Saturday, bruised from a fall, and knelt to James VI as King of England. At ten that morning Cecil had already read the proclamation at Whitehall and in Cheapside. There was, Manningham noted, no great shouting.

How it came to this

Elizabeth came to the throne in November 1558 as the daughter of Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn, declared illegitimate after her mother’s execution and regarded as such by Catholic Europe. She re-established a Protestant national church, declined every proposal of marriage, and governed through a small council dominated first by William Cecil and then by his son Robert. The pope excommunicated her in 1570. She kept her Catholic cousin Mary, Queen of Scots, in custody for nineteen years and signed her death warrant in 1587. The next year the Spanish Armada failed, and war with Spain continued for the rest of the reign.

Her last decade was harsh. Harvests failed repeatedly in the 1590s, taxation and prices rose, and the rebellion of Hugh O’Neill, Earl of Tyrone, made Ireland the most costly war of the reign. Her last favourite, the Earl of Essex, attempted a coup and was beheaded in 1601. She forbade any discussion of the succession, having said early on that she knew how people turn towards the rising sun. Behind her back Robert Cecil had been corresponding in cipher with James VI of Scotland since 1601.

How each side saw it

English Catholics

For Catholics the reign had meant fines for refusing to attend the parish church, the outlawing of their priests, and the execution of close to two hundred priests and lay people as traitors, among them Edmund Campion and Margaret Clitherow. The government’s position, set out by William Cecil, was that they died for treason, since the pope had released her subjects from obedience. One of the queen’s maids of honour, Elizabeth Southwell, later a Catholic convert living abroad, wrote an account in 1607 in which the queen dies tormented by visions and names no heir, and her corpse bursts in its coffin. Its hostility is evident; some of its detail may still be accurate.

Gaelic Ireland

In Ulster the queen’s death came at the end of nine years of war. Her deputy, Lord Mountjoy, had broken O’Neill’s rebellion by burning crops and killing cattle, and his secretary Fynes Moryson described the famine that followed, including people found dead with mouths stained green from eating nettles and docks. O’Neill submitted at Mellifont on 30 March 1603, six days after Elizabeth died; Mountjoy knew and kept the news from him until it was done. The Annals of the Four Masters, compiled by Franciscan scholars in the 1630s, record the war as the overthrow of the native lords. Their lands in Ulster were planted with settlers within a few years.

Her own subjects in 1603

The cult of Gloriana came later. Contemporary letters suggest that many at court were tired of an ageing queen, of high taxes, of monopolies granted to favourites, and of uncertainty about what would follow. Bishop Godfrey Goodman, a schoolboy in London at the time, remembered that the people were very generally weary of an old woman’s government. He added that within a few years, after experience of James and his Scottish favourites, the queen seemed to revive and her memory was much magnified, with more bells and bonfires on the anniversary of her accession than on the coming in of the new king.

What is disputed

Whether she named James is the main doubt. The sign of the hand comes from councillors who had already arranged his accession; Southwell denies it, and Carey says only that she put her hand to her head. The exchange with Cecil about the word ‘must’ is reported at second hand. No post-mortem was permitted, so the cause of death is conjecture: infection of the throat and lungs, or blood poisoning, are the usual suggestions. The date is old style. England’s year then began on 25 March, so she died on the last day of 1602 by her subjects’ reckoning, and on 3 April 1603 by the Gregorian calendar.

What followed

James travelled south at leisure and was crowned in July. England and Scotland now shared a monarch though they remained separate kingdoms until 1707. He made peace with Spain in 1604. Elizabeth was buried in Westminster Abbey on 28 April with a painted effigy on the coffin so lifelike that the crowd groaned; James later placed her in the same vault as her half-sister Mary I, and built a grander tomb for his own mother nearby. Her accession day, 17 November, was kept as a Protestant festival through the seventeenth century, and her reign became the standard against which the Stuarts were found wanting.

Read further

  • John Guy, Elizabeth: The Forgotten Years (2016)
  • Catherine Loomis, The Death of Elizabeth I: Remembering and Reconstructing the Virgin Queen (2010)
  • F. H. Mares (ed.), The Memoirs of Robert Carey (1972)
  • Robert Parker Sorlien (ed.), The Diary of John Manningham of the Middle Temple, 1602-1603 (1976)
  • Christopher Haigh, Elizabeth I (1988)

Same day, other years

1603

Tokugawa Ieyasu becomes shogun

Fushimi Castle, Kyoto, JapanAsia

On the twelfth day of the second month of the eighth year of Keicho, which is 24 March 1603 by the Gregorian calendar, envoys of the emperor Go-Yozei brought to Fushimi Castle the decree appointing Tokugawa Ieyasu shogun. He was 60 and had been the strongest man in Japan since his victory at Sekigahara in 1600, which ended more than a century of civil war. He made his headquarters at Edo, a castle town in the east that became Tokyo. Two years later he passed the title to his son to make it hereditary, while keeping real control. His house ruled Japan until 1868.

Seen from elsewhere. Ieyasu had sworn to protect Hideyori, the young heir of his former lord Toyotomi Hideyoshi. In 1614-15 he besieged Osaka Castle and destroyed the Toyotomi family, which their adherents regarded as plain usurpation. The lords who had opposed him at Sekigahara were kept from office for 250 years, and Christianity was banned in 1614. This is a different day from Elizabeth’s death, which is dated by the Julian calendar.

1882

Koch shows the cause of tuberculosis

Berlin, GermanyEurope

On the evening of 24 March 1882 Robert Koch, a former country doctor working at the Imperial Health Office, read a paper to the Physiological Society of Berlin in a small reading room crowded with his microscope slides. He showed that a slender rod-shaped bacterium, which he had learned to stain and to grow in pure culture, was present in every case of tuberculosis he examined and produced the disease when injected into guinea pigs. Tuberculosis then caused something like one death in seven in Europe. The audience is said to have sat silent. Paul Ehrlich, who was there, called it the greatest scientific experience of his life. The date is now World Tuberculosis Day.

Seen from elsewhere. Rudolf Virchow, the leading German pathologist, doubted the claim and held that poverty and housing mattered more than any germ. Koch’s supposed cure, tuberculin, announced in 1890 and kept secret for profit, failed and harmed patients. In East Africa in 1906-07 he tested an arsenic compound against sleeping sickness on Africans held in isolation camps; some were blinded.

1976

The armed forces take power in Argentina

Buenos Aires, ArgentinaThe Americas

In the early hours of 24 March 1976 the helicopter carrying President Isabel Peron from the Casa Rosada was diverted and she was placed under arrest. A junta of the three service chiefs, led by General Jorge Videla, dissolved Congress, banned parties and unions, and announced a Process of National Reorganisation. The dictatorship lasted until 1983. Its security forces abducted people from homes, workplaces and streets, held them in some 340 secret centres such as the Navy Mechanics School, tortured them, and killed most; many were thrown drugged from aircraft into the sea. Babies born to prisoners were given to other families. The Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo began marching in April 1977.

Seen from elsewhere. The junta said it was fighting a war against armed subversion, and much of the press, business and middle class welcomed the coup after years of guerrilla attacks and inflation. A national commission documented 8,960 disappearances in 1984; human rights organisations say 30,000. That figure has become politically contested in Argentina, where 24 March is a day of remembrance.

1999

NATO begins bombing Yugoslavia

Serbia, Montenegro and KosovoEurope

On the evening of 24 March 1999 NATO aircraft and cruise missiles struck targets across the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia. The alliance acted after the failure of talks at Rambouillet and a year of fighting in Kosovo between Serbian forces and the Kosovo Liberation Army, in which villages were burned and civilians killed. It did not have the authority of the UN Security Council, where Russia and China would have vetoed. The campaign lasted 78 days. During it Serbian forces expelled or drove out some 850,000 Kosovo Albanians. In June President Slobodan Milosevic agreed to withdraw, and Kosovo was placed under UN administration with a NATO-led force.

Seen from elsewhere. Serbia and Russia call the bombing an illegal aggression; strikes hit a passenger train, refugee columns, the state television building and the Chinese embassy. Human Rights Watch counted about 500 civilian dead, Belgrade many more. NATO governments called it a humanitarian necessity. Critics note that the mass expulsions accelerated once bombing began. An independent commission judged the war illegal but legitimate.

Also on 24 March