Parallax

18 March, 1584

Ivan the Terrible dies over a chessboard

The first tsar of Russia collapsed while setting out the pieces for a game. Whether anyone helped him on his way has been argued for more than four centuries.

The Kremlin, Moscow

The fullest account of the last day of Ivan IV comes from an Englishman. Jerome Horsey, an agent of the Muscovy Company who had the run of the court, wrote years afterwards that the tsar, swollen and foul-smelling with disease, had himself carried each day in a chair into his treasury. There, Horsey says, Ivan showed him and the assembled nobles his jewels, lecturing on the hidden properties of the lodestone, the turquoise and the diamond, and placed spiders inside a circle scratched around a piece of unicorn’s horn to see whether they would die.

According to the same account the tsar had sent north for some sixty soothsayers, who agreed that he would die on 18 March. When the day came and he felt well, he sent his favourite Bogdan Belsky to tell them they would be burned or buried alive for their lies. They answered that the day was not over until the sun had set.

About the third hour of the afternoon Ivan went to the bath, sang as he usually did, and came out, Horsey says, more cheerful. He sat on his bed in a loose gown and called for a chessboard. Belsky, Boris Godunov and others stood around him. As he was setting out the pieces he fainted and fell backwards. There was an outcry; one man ran for spirits, another for the apothecary, others for his confessor and the physicians. In the meantime, in Horsey’s ambiguous words, he was strangled and stark dead.

He was 53 and had ruled, in name at least, for fifty years. Following a custom of Muscovite princes he was tonsured as a monk, under the name Jonah, either as he lay dying or just after. The Kremlin gates were shut and the guards doubled while the boyars swore allegiance to his son Fyodor, a gentle and devout man of 26 who was widely thought incapable of governing. Ivan was buried in the Archangel Cathedral beside the elder son, also Ivan, whom he had struck in a rage in November 1581 and who had died days later.

The date was 18 March by the Julian calendar then used in Russia and England, 28 March by the new Gregorian reckoning that Catholic Europe had adopted less than two years before. In Moscow, Horsey wrote, there was fear of tumult. A riot against Belsky did break out within weeks, and he was sent away from the capital. Godunov, whose sister was married to the new tsar, stayed.

How it came to this

Ivan became Grand Prince of Moscow at the age of three in 1533 and grew up amid feuding boyar clans. In 1547 he was crowned tsar, a title derived from caesar that claimed the inheritance of Byzantium and parity with the khans. The first part of his reign brought a new law code, church and military reforms, and the conquest of the Tatar khanates of Kazan in 1552 and Astrakhan in 1556, which gave Muscovy the whole length of the Volga. In 1558 he went to war for Livonia and an outlet on the Baltic, a struggle against Poland-Lithuania and Sweden that lasted twenty-five years and ended in the loss of everything gained.

In 1565 he divided the realm in two, keeping one part, the oprichnina, as a personal domain policed by black-clad horsemen answerable only to him. Over seven years they killed nobles, churchmen, officials and their households, and in 1570 sacked Novgorod. The metropolitan Filipp, who rebuked the tsar, was deposed and strangled. Crimean Tatars burned Moscow in 1571. By the 1580s much of central Russia was depopulated by war, flight, taxation and terror.

How each side saw it

Prince Andrei Kurbsky, the defector

Kurbsky commanded Ivan’s armies, fled to Lithuania in 1564 and is credited with a History of the Grand Prince of Moscow and a famous exchange of letters with the tsar. In them he accuses Ivan of destroying the strong men God gave him and of turning from a pious ruler into a persecutor once he abandoned his good advisers. Ivan’s replies insist that a tsar answers to God alone and is free to reward and punish his slaves. In 1971 the American historian Edward Keenan argued that the whole correspondence is a seventeenth-century fabrication; most specialists reject that, but the manuscripts are all late copies.

The Tatars of Kazan

For the Volga Tatars the central event of the reign is the fall of Kazan in October 1552, when Ivan’s army mined the walls, stormed the city and killed much of its male population. Tatars were barred from living inside the rebuilt town, mosques were destroyed, and resistance in the countryside went on for years. The khanate’s own chronicles did not survive, so the siege is known mainly from Russian sources such as the Kazan History. In modern Tatarstan a day of remembrance for the defenders has been held each October since 1989, and proposals to honour Ivan elsewhere in Russia draw protests from Tatar organisations.

Foreign witnesses

Much of the darkest detail comes from outsiders with reasons of their own. Heinrich von Staden, a German adventurer who served in the oprichnina, wrote his account to sell a plan for invading Russia. The papal envoy Antonio Possevino, the main source for the killing of the tsarevich, had failed to convert Ivan to union with Rome. Horsey wrote decades later and liked a good story. Russian historians have long warned that these texts fed a European image of Muscovite barbarism during the Livonian War, when anti-Russian pamphlets circulated widely in Germany and Poland. The domestic records, however, confirm mass killing on a large scale.

Russian statist tradition

From the nineteenth century a school of Russian historians, beginning with Konstantin Kavelin and Sergei Solovyov, read the terror as the brutal but necessary breaking of an aristocracy that stood in the way of a unified state. Stalin took up the argument, commissioned Sergei Eisenstein’s film, and complained in 1947 that its second part showed Ivan as indecisive and the oprichniki as degenerates. The view survives: a statue of Ivan was unveiled in Oryol in 2016. A small Orthodox movement has sought his canonisation, which Patriarch Alexy II firmly refused, pointing to the murdered Metropolitan Filipp, whom the Church does venerate.

What is disputed

Whether Ivan was murdered is unresolved. Horsey’s ‘strangled’ may mean choked by a seizure, and later Russian tales blaming Belsky and Godunov were written when Godunov’s enemies ruled. When Soviet scientists opened the tomb in 1963 they found high levels of mercury, which some take as proof of poison and others explain by the mercury ointments used as medicine; the bones also showed painful spinal growths. The number of his victims is contested too: Ruslan Skrynnikov reconstructed about 3,300 names from the memorial lists Ivan sent to monasteries, with two to three thousand dead at Novgorod, against chronicle figures in the tens of thousands. His epithet, grozny, means awe-inspiring rather than terrible.

What followed

Fyodor reigned under Godunov’s management until 1598 and died childless. Ivan’s youngest son, Dmitry, had died at Uglich in 1591 with his throat cut, by accident or on orders. The dynasty that had ruled since the ninth century was extinct, and Russia fell into the famine, pretenders, civil war and foreign occupation known as the Time of Troubles, which ended with the election of the first Romanov in 1613. Ivan’s legacy has been fought over ever since: the conquest of the Volga and the first steps into Siberia on one side, and on the other a model of power without limits.

Read further

  • Isabel de Madariaga, Ivan the Terrible: First Tsar of Russia (2005)
  • Andrei Pavlov and Maureen Perrie, Ivan the Terrible (2003)
  • Lloyd E. Berry and Robert O. Crummey (eds), Rude and Barbarous Kingdom: Russia in the Accounts of Sixteenth-Century English Voyagers (1968)
  • Ruslan G. Skrynnikov, Ivan the Terrible, translated by Hugh F. Graham (1981)
  • Edward L. Keenan, The Kurbskii-Groznyi Apocrypha (1971)

Same day, other years

1314

The last Grand Master of the Templars is burned

Paris, FranceEurope

Jacques de Molay had led the Knights Templar since about 1292 and had been a prisoner since the mass arrests ordered by Philip IV of France in October 1307. Under torture or the threat of it he had confessed to denying Christ at his reception into the order. In March 1314 three cardinals sentenced him and three other dignitaries to perpetual imprisonment in front of Notre-Dame. Molay and Geoffroi de Charney, preceptor of Normandy, then declared that the order was innocent and their confessions false. The king, without waiting for the Church, had them burned that evening on a small island in the Seine.

Seen from elsewhere. The summons calling king and pope before God’s tribunal within the year is a later legend; the contemporary verse chronicle of Geoffroi de Paris has Molay say only that God would avenge them. The traditional date is 18 March, though the historian Alain Demurger argues for 11 March. A document found in the Vatican archives shows Clement V had absolved the leaders in 1308.

1922

Gandhi asks his judge for the heaviest sentence

Ahmedabad, IndiaAsia

On 18 March 1922 Mohandas Gandhi was tried for sedition over three articles in his weekly Young India. He pleaded guilty. In a written statement he described how a loyal subject who had recruited for the empire had become, as he put it, an uncompromising disaffectionist, and told the judge either to resign or to impose the severest penalty the law allowed. Robert Broomfield, the English judge, said Gandhi was unlike any person he had tried or was likely to try, sentenced him to six years, and added that no one would be better pleased if the government later reduced the term. Gandhi was released after two years, following surgery for appendicitis.

Seen from elsewhere. The Government of India held that his campaign had already cost lives: six weeks earlier a crowd at Chauri Chaura had burned 22 policemen in their station. Gandhi had called off non-cooperation in response, a decision that dismayed Jawaharlal Nehru, Subhas Chandra Bose and many others in the nationalist movement, who thought a winning struggle had been abandoned.

1938

Mexico takes the oil

Mexico City, MexicoThe Americas

At ten o’clock on the night of 18 March 1938 President Lazaro Cardenas announced on the radio that Mexico was expropriating the property of seventeen foreign oil companies, chief among them subsidiaries of Royal Dutch Shell and Standard Oil of New Jersey. The companies had refused to comply with a Supreme Court ruling in favour of their workers in a wage dispute. Crowds filled the capital in support, and in the following weeks people queued at the Palace of Fine Arts to donate towards the compensation: wedding rings, savings, chickens. A state company, Petroleos Mexicanos, was created in June. Britain broke off diplomatic relations.

Seen from elsewhere. The companies called it confiscation, demanded payment for the oil still underground as well as their plant, and organised a boycott of Mexican crude. Mexico replied that the constitution of 1917 had vested the subsoil in the nation. Washington, wanting an ally as war approached, pressed for a negotiated settlement, reached with the American firms in 1942 and the British in 1947.

1962

France and the Algerian nationalists sign at Evian

Evian-les-Bains, FranceAfrica

After more than seven years of war, delegations of the French government and the provisional government of the Algerian Republic signed accords at Evian on 18 March 1962. Krim Belkacem signed for the National Liberation Front, Louis Joxe for France. A ceasefire took effect at noon the next day. The agreements provided for a referendum on independence, guarantees for European settlers, and continued French use of the naval base at Mers el-Kebir and the Saharan test sites. French voters approved them in April by more than 90 per cent, and Algeria became independent in July after 132 years of French rule.

Seen from elsewhere. The settler-backed Secret Army Organisation answered with bombings and shootings, and some 800,000 Europeans left within months. Algerian auxiliaries of the French army, the harkis, were largely left behind; estimates of those killed in reprisals range from about 10,000 to 150,000. Algeria counts 1.5 million war dead, most French historians 300,000 to 400,000.

Also on 18 March