Parallax

20 March, 1413

Henry IV dies in a room called Jerusalem

He took the English crown from his cousin in a few weeks and spent thirteen years paying for it, in rebellions, debt, and an illness his subjects read as the judgement of God.

Westminster, England

In the last winter of his life Henry IV could no longer walk without help. He was 45, and for eight years he had suffered from a disfiguring disease of the skin and from sudden collapses that left him, more than once, taken for dead. Parliament had been summoned for February 1413 but he was too ill to open it. Some time in March he went to pray at the shrine of Edward the Confessor in Westminster Abbey and there fell down in a seizure. The monks carried him to the abbot’s lodging and laid him on a pallet before the fire in a panelled room.

The story told by the London chroniclers a generation or two later is that when he came to himself he asked where he was, and on hearing that the chamber was called Jerusalem he gave thanks, because it had been foretold that he would die in Jerusalem. He had long spoken of leading a crusade to the Holy Land, which he had visited as a pilgrim twenty years before. He died in that room on 20 March.

A second story comes from the Burgundian chronicler Enguerrand de Monstrelet. The king lay so still that his attendants covered his face, and the Prince of Wales took away the crown that stood on a cushion beside the bed. Henry revived, missed it, and sent for his son, who said he had believed his father dead. The king, sighing, asked what right the prince could have to the crown when he himself, as his son well knew, had never had any. The prince answered that as his father had kept it by the sword, so would he.

A third concerns his conscience. One English chronicle says that his confessor, John Tille, urged him to repent of the death of Archbishop Scrope of York, whom he had had beheaded in 1405, and of the wrong he had done in taking the throne. Henry is said to have replied that for the first he had the pope’s absolution, and that for the second his sons would never allow him to make restitution.

His will, written in English four years earlier, begins with the words of a man who called himself a sinful wretch and asked his subjects’ pardon. He was not buried at Westminster among the kings but, at his own wish, in Canterbury Cathedral, close to the shrine of Thomas Becket. His body was taken down the Thames and by road through Kent, and his widow, Joan of Navarre, later lay beside him. The prince was crowned Henry V on 9 April, in a snowstorm.

How it came to this

Henry of Bolingbroke was born in Lincolnshire, probably in 1367, the eldest surviving son of John of Gaunt, Duke of Lancaster, and so a grandson of Edward III. His first cousin Richard II became king in 1377 at the age of ten. As a young man Henry was a celebrated jouster who fought alongside the Teutonic Knights in Lithuania. He was also one of the five lords who humbled Richard in 1387-88 and had the king’s friends executed, which Richard did not forget. In 1398, after Henry and Thomas Mowbray accused each other of treason, Richard stopped their trial by combat and banished both.

When Gaunt died in February 1399, Richard made the exile permanent and took the Lancastrian inheritance, the largest in England, into his own hands. Every landowner could see what that meant for his own heirs. While Richard was campaigning in Ireland, Henry landed in Yorkshire in July with a few dozen followers, saying he came only for his duchy. The north joined him, Richard was captured in Wales, and on 30 September Henry claimed the vacant throne before Parliament, speaking in English. Richard died in Pontefract Castle within five months.

How each side saw it

The Percy family

The Earl of Northumberland and his son Henry Hotspur did more than anyone to make Henry king, and in 1403 they tried to unmake him. Their manifesto, preserved in the chronicle of John Hardyng, who served in Hotspur’s household, charges that Henry swore on the sacrament at Doncaster to claim nothing but his inheritance, then seized the crown, had Richard starved to death, and kept the rightful heir, the young Earl of March, in custody. Hotspur was killed at Shrewsbury that July. Henry’s supporters denied that any such oath was broken, and historians note that Hardyng wrote decades later with debts to the Percys.

The Welsh under Owain Glyndwr

In September 1400 Owain Glyndwr was proclaimed Prince of Wales by his followers, beginning the longest revolt of the reign. Parliament answered in 1401-02 with statutes forbidding Welshmen to hold office, bear arms, own land in English towns or gather without licence. Glyndwr’s own surviving documents, including the letter sent from Pennal to the King of France in 1406, describe a nation oppressed by ‘the fury of the barbarous Saxons’ and set out plans for an independent Welsh church and two universities. Welsh poets praised him as the promised deliverer. English chroniclers such as Adam Usk, himself Welsh, record burned towns and a devastated country on both sides.

Richard’s partisans and the French court

Jean Creton, a French squire who travelled with Richard II in 1399, wrote a verse history of the deposition that presents Henry as a perjured traitor and Richard as a betrayed and Christ-like king. It circulated at the French court, where Richard’s child queen Isabella was the king’s daughter, and France refused for years to recognise Henry’s title. In England rumours that Richard was alive in Scotland persisted throughout the reign, and Franciscan friars were hanged for spreading them. Henry’s government maintained that Richard had resigned of his own free will, a version enrolled in the official record of Parliament.

What is disputed

What killed him is not known. Contemporaries called the skin disease leprosy and dated it from the day Scrope was executed; when the tomb was opened in 1832 the face was found intact and bearded, which argues against it. Modern suggestions, reviewed by Peter McNiven, include psoriasis, syphilis and circulatory disease with strokes. The Jerusalem prophecy, the crown story and the confessor’s story all come from writers who were not present, and all served someone’s purpose. His year of birth was long given as 1366; Ian Mortimer has argued for April 1367. How Richard II died, by starvation imposed or self-inflicted, remains uncertain.

What followed

Henry V turned his father’s uneasy inheritance outwards, invading France in 1415. But the question the usurpation had opened was never closed. In 1460 Richard, Duke of York, claimed the throne through the Mortimer line that had been passed over in 1399, and the Wars of the Roses were fought on that ground. Henry’s reign also left England its first statute for burning heretics, passed in 1401, and a Parliament that had learned to bargain hard over taxation with a king who needed money. Shakespeare’s two plays fixed the image of a guilt-ridden ruler.

Read further

  • Chris Given-Wilson, Henry IV (2016)
  • Ian Mortimer, The Fears of Henry IV: The Life of England’s Self-Made King (2007)
  • Chris Given-Wilson (ed.), The Chronicle of Adam Usk, 1377-1421 (1997)
  • R. R. Davies, The Revolt of Owain Glyn Dwr (1995)
  • K. B. McFarlane, Lancastrian Kings and Lollard Knights (1972)

Same day, other years

1602

The Dutch East India Company receives its charter

The Hague, Dutch RepublicWorldwide

On 20 March 1602 the States General of the Dutch Republic merged several rival trading ventures into a single United East India Company, the VOC, and gave it a 21-year monopoly on Dutch trade east of the Cape of Good Hope. The charter let it build forts, keep soldiers, make treaties and wage war in the republic’s name. Its capital of about 6.4 million guilders was raised from the public, and because investors could not withdraw their money they sold their shares to one another, creating in Amsterdam the first continuous market in a company’s stock. For most of two centuries it was the largest commercial enterprise in the world.

Seen from elsewhere. In Asia the company was an armed power. In 1621 its governor-general Jan Pieterszoon Coen seized the Banda Islands to secure the nutmeg monopoly; of perhaps 15,000 Bandanese, most were killed, starved, enslaved or driven out. The VOC also ran a large slave trade around the Indian Ocean. Coen’s statue in his home town of Hoorn remains a subject of dispute.

1956

Tunisia becomes independent

Paris and TunisAfrica

A protocol signed in Paris on 20 March 1956 by the Tunisian prime minister, Tahar Ben Ammar, and the French foreign minister, Christian Pineau, ended the protectorate France had imposed by the Treaty of Bardo in 1881. It came eighteen days after Morocco’s independence and while France was committing ever more troops to Algeria next door. Elections five days later were swept by the Neo-Destour party of Habib Bourguiba, who had spent years in French prisons. He became prime minister in April, abolished the monarchy of the beys in 1957, and ruled as president for thirty years, pushing through a code of personal status that banned polygamy.

Seen from elsewhere. Bourguiba’s rival Salah Ben Youssef had condemned the step-by-step deal with France as a betrayal of the Algerians and of Arab unity; his supporters were suppressed and he was murdered in Frankfurt in 1961. France kept its naval base at Bizerte until 1963, after fighting there in 1961 in which several hundred Tunisians were killed.

1995

Nerve gas on the Tokyo underground

Tokyo, JapanAsia

During the morning rush hour of 20 March 1995, five members of the religious movement Aum Shinrikyo boarded trains on three underground lines converging on Kasumigaseki, the government district. Each carried plastic bags of liquid sarin wrapped in newspaper, which they punctured with sharpened umbrella tips before getting off. Thirteen people died, among them station staff who cleared the bags away with their hands, and several thousand sought hospital treatment. Police raided the group’s compound near Mount Fuji two days later. Its leader, Shoko Asahara, was arrested in May, and he and twelve followers were hanged in July 2018.

Seen from elsewhere. The cult had killed with sarin in Matsumoto nine months earlier, when police wrongly pursued one of the victims, Yoshiyuki Kono, as the suspect. Haruki Murakami’s interviews with survivors and with ordinary Aum members, published as Underground, asked what in Japanese society the group answered to. Opponents of capital punishment questioned whether Asahara was mentally fit to be executed.

2003

The invasion of Iraq begins

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Shortly before dawn on 20 March 2003, Baghdad time, American aircraft and cruise missiles struck a compound in the south of the city where Saddam Hussein was wrongly thought to be sleeping. It was still the evening of 19 March in Washington. Within hours American and British ground forces, with Australian and Polish contingents, crossed from Kuwait. Baghdad fell on 9 April. The governments of George W. Bush and Tony Blair had gone to war without a second United Nations resolution, on the stated ground that Iraq held weapons of mass destruction. The Iraq Survey Group reported in 2004 that it had none.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Iraqi Kurds and Shia, who had suffered mass killing under Saddam, welcomed his fall; the occupation that followed brought insurgency and sectarian war. Kofi Annan called the invasion illegal, and Britain’s Chilcot inquiry found in 2016 that peaceful options had not been exhausted. Counts of Iraqi dead range from about 200,000 documented civilians to survey estimates several times higher.

Also on 20 March