Parallax

5 March, 1776

Boston wakes to rebel guns on Dorchester Heights

In one moonlit night Washington’s army built two forts on frozen ground overlooking the British fleet. A storm stopped the battle both generals expected, and twelve days later the garrison sailed away.

Boston, Massachusetts

The hills of the Dorchester peninsula look down on Boston from the south-east and on the anchorage beyond it. Neither army had occupied them in ten months of siege: the British lacked the men, the Americans the cannon. That changed in late January 1776, when the Boston bookseller Henry Knox, now a colonel of artillery, arrived at Cambridge with nearly sixty guns and mortars dragged three hundred miles on ox-sledges from Fort Ticonderoga. George Washington wanted to use them to cover an assault across the harbour ice. His generals talked him out of it and proposed the heights instead.

The difficulty was that the ground was frozen too hard to dig. Lieutenant Colonel Rufus Putnam, a millwright with no formal training in engineering, found the answer in a borrowed British textbook: timber frames called chandeliers, which could be made in advance, carried up and packed with bundles of brushwood and baskets of earth. Carpenters built them through February. Barrels filled with stones were prepared to roll down on an attacking column.

On the nights of 2 and 3 March American batteries north and west of the town opened fire to draw attention. On Monday 4 March they fired again, the British answered, and under the noise General John Thomas led about two thousand men and some three hundred ox-carts across the low neck to Dorchester. Bales of hay screened the causeway. The moon was full, with a haze lying on the low ground. The carts made several journeys. A fresh shift of three thousand men took over before dawn, and by first light there were two forts on the hilltops with guns in them.

General William Howe is reported to have said that the rebels had done more in a night than his whole army could have done in months; his engineers guessed that at least twelve thousand men had been at work. Admiral Shuldham told him the fleet could not stay under those guns. It was 5 March, the anniversary of the Boston Massacre, and Washington reminded his men of it. Howe ordered 2,400 troops into boats to storm the hill that night. Washington, hoping for exactly that, had four thousand men waiting to cross the Charles and attack the town from the other side.

In the evening the wind rose to a gale with snow and sleet. Transports were driven ashore, and by morning the assault was impossible. Howe cancelled it and resolved to leave. On 17 March some nine thousand soldiers and more than eleven hundred loyalist civilians sailed out of the harbour in about 120 ships.

How it came to this

Fighting had begun on 19 April 1775, when British regulars sent from Boston to seize militia stores at Concord were shot at all the way back. Within days some fifteen thousand New England militiamen ringed the town, which then stood almost on an island. In June the British took the hills at Charlestown in the battle known as Bunker Hill, at a cost of over a thousand casualties, nearly half the force engaged. After that neither side moved. Washington arrived in July to command an army short of powder, tents and discipline, much of which went home when its enlistments expired at the new year.

Inside Boston, about 6,500 civilians remained from a population of 16,000, with a garrison larger than that. Food came by sea from Britain and Nova Scotia and often did not come. Soldiers pulled down houses, wharves and the Liberty Tree for firewood, and cavalry exercised their horses in the Old South Meeting House. Smallpox was in the town. London had told Howe months earlier to abandon Boston for New York; he had been waiting for ships.

How each side saw it

The British command

Howe’s dispatches to the colonial secretary, Lord Dartmouth, present the evacuation as the execution of a decision already taken. Boston was a poor base, commanded by hills and leading nowhere, and the government had authorised him to quit it the previous autumn. In this account the works on Dorchester settled the timing and nothing more. Junior officers were less composed. Several recorded their relief that the storm had prevented an uphill attack on entrenchments, with Bunker Hill fresh in mind, and the engineer Archibald Robertson judged in his diary that the planned attack staked the whole army on a reckless throw.

The loyalists

More than a thousand civilians left with the fleet: crown officials, merchants, clergy, and country people who had fled into Boston for protection. Peter Oliver, the last royal chief justice of Massachusetts, later wrote a bitter history of what he called the American rebellion, describing neighbours terrorised by mobs and a prosperous province ruined by lawyers and smugglers. They had a few days to choose what to carry and were packed into transports for Halifax, where there was little shelter. Massachusetts banished several hundred of them by name in 1778 and confiscated their property. Most never came back.

The besieging army and patriot Boston

For the Americans it was the first clear success of the war, won almost without loss. Washington’s letters show pride in the night’s work and frank disappointment that the storm denied him a battle he thought he would win. Abigail Adams, listening from Braintree, wrote to her husband of windows rattling through the cannonade and of her astonishment when the fleet went. Those who entered the town found houses stripped and shops looted. Washington sent in first only men who had already had smallpox. Congress voted him a gold medal, the first it ever awarded.

Black New Englanders

Free and enslaved Black men had fought at Lexington and Bunker Hill. Washington, a Virginian slaveholder, at first barred them from enlisting, then reversed himself at the end of 1775 for free Black veterans, after Virginia’s royal governor, Lord Dunmore, offered freedom to enslaved men who joined the king. So Black soldiers were in the lines around Boston in March 1776. A week before Dorchester, Washington wrote to thank the enslaved Boston poet Phillis Wheatley for verses in his honour. Few of these men left accounts of their own; they are known from muster rolls, pension claims and petitions for freedom submitted to the Massachusetts legislature.

What is disputed

Howe’s remark survives in several versions, none in his own hand, giving a month or three months for the comparison. More substantial is the question of what the heights achieved. American tradition says they drove the British out; since Howe already had orders to go, many historians say they forced only the date and the haste. The supposed agreement to spare the town was never signed: Boston’s selectmen carried out an unaddressed paper stating Howe’s intention not to burn it if unmolested, and Washington, without replying, held his fire. Whether Howe welcomed the storm as an excuse is a matter of inference.

What followed

Howe regrouped at Halifax and that summer landed on Staten Island with the largest expeditionary force Britain had ever sent overseas. Washington, who had marched to meet him, was beaten on Long Island in August and lost New York. No British army returned to Boston. The loyalist exodus that began there eventually carried some sixty thousand people out of the thirteen colonies, many to Canada. Suffolk County, Massachusetts, has kept 17 March as Evacuation Day since 1901, a holiday that coincides with St Patrick’s Day.

Read further

  • David McCullough, 1776 (2005)
  • Richard Frothingham, History of the Siege of Boston (1849)
  • Allen French, The First Year of the American Revolution (1934)
  • Nathaniel Philbrick, Bunker Hill: A City, a Siege, a Revolution (2013)
  • Peter Oliver, Origin and Progress of the American Rebellion, edited by Douglass Adair and John A. Schutz (1961)

Same day, other years

1616

Rome suspends Copernicus’s book

Rome, Papal StatesEurope

Seventy-three years after Nicolaus Copernicus published On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres, the Congregation of the Index issued a decree suspending it ‘until corrected’ and banning outright a recent work by the Carmelite friar Paolo Foscarini, which had argued that a moving Earth could be reconciled with scripture. Days earlier a panel of theologians had advised the Holy Office that to say the Sun stands still at the centre of the world was foolish in philosophy and formally heretical, and Cardinal Bellarmine had told Galileo privately that he must not hold or defend the idea. Galileo was not named in the decree. The corrections, issued in 1620, altered about ten passages.

Seen from elsewhere. The Church’s defenders note that no proof of the Earth’s motion existed in 1616, that leading astronomers preferred Tycho Brahe’s compromise system, and that Bellarmine had written that scripture would need reinterpreting if a true demonstration were found. Critics answer that the decree settled a question of nature by authority. The book left the Index in the nineteenth century.

1906

American troops kill hundreds of Moros in the crater of Bud Dajo

Jolo, Sulu, PhilippinesAsia

Several hundred Tausug Muslims, by some counts close to a thousand, had moved with their families into the crater of an extinct volcano on Jolo island. They were refusing the head tax, disarmament and other measures of the American administration that had replaced Spain. On 5 March about 750 soldiers and constabulary sent by the provincial governor, General Leonard Wood, began climbing the slopes. Over three days they hauled up mountain guns and a machine gun and fired into the crater. When it ended at least 600 Moros were dead, women and children among them, and only a handful survived. The attackers lost between 15 and 21 men.

Seen from elsewhere. President Roosevelt cabled congratulations on a ‘brilliant feat of arms’. Wood said the women had fought alongside the men and children had been used as shields. Mark Twain wrote, in a piece he left unpublished, that it was a slaughter and no battle. In Sulu the dead are remembered as martyrs, and Filipino leaders have invoked the photographs since.

1931

Gandhi and the Viceroy sign a truce

New Delhi, IndiaAsia

A year after he walked to the sea at Dandi to make salt in defiance of the law, and after tens of thousands of Indians had gone to prison for following him, Mohandas Gandhi concluded an agreement with the Viceroy, Lord Irwin, reached in eight meetings at the new Viceroy’s House. Congress would suspend civil disobedience and attend the Round Table Conference in London. The government would release prisoners not convicted of violence, return confiscated property not yet sold, and allow people living near the coast to make salt for themselves. It was the first time the British had negotiated with the leader of the nationalist movement as an equal party.

Seen from elsewhere. Winston Churchill said it was nauseating to see a ‘half-naked’ lawyer-turned-fakir parleying with the King-Emperor’s representative. Jawaharlal Nehru and Subhas Bose thought Gandhi had given up the campaign for nothing on independence itself. The pact did not save Bhagat Singh, who was hanged on 23 March; young protesters met Gandhi with black flags days later.

1940

The Soviet Politburo orders the Katyn killings

Moscow, Soviet UnionEurope

A four-page memorandum from the head of the secret police, Lavrenty Beria, proposed that 25,700 Polish prisoners held since the Soviet invasion of eastern Poland be shot without trial as incorrigible enemies of Soviet power. They were army officers, many of them reservists who in civilian life were doctors, teachers, lawyers and engineers, together with police, landowners and officials. Stalin signed across the first page, followed by Voroshilov, Molotov and Mikoyan. In April and May about 22,000 were killed, each with a pistol shot to the back of the head, at Katyn forest near Smolensk and in prisons at Kalinin and Kharkiv. German troops found the Katyn graves in 1943.

Seen from elsewhere. Moscow blamed the Germans for fifty years and had the lie entered at Nuremberg, where the judges ignored it. Gorbachev admitted Soviet responsibility in 1990 and Yeltsin released the signed order in 1992. Russian prosecutors closed their inquiry in 2004 and have declined to call the killings genocide, as Poland asks. Some Russian nationalists and communists still deny the documents.

Also on 5 March