The delegations met in the spring of 1494 at Tordesillas, a walled town on the Duero where the court of Ferdinand and Isabella was then staying. Portugal sent Rui de Sousa, an elderly and experienced diplomat, with his son Joao and the jurist Aires de Almada. For Castile and Aragon there were the royal steward Enrique Enriquez, the chief accountant Gutierre de Cardenas and Dr Rodrigo Maldonado. They brought pilots and cosmographers with them, among them the Portuguese navigator Duarte Pacheco Pereira, because the argument was about geography that existed mostly on paper.
The trouble had started fifteen months earlier. Christopher Columbus, returning from his first voyage, was driven by a storm into Lisbon and boasted of his discoveries to King John II of Portugal before he had reported to his own employers. John took the view that any islands in that quarter fell to him under an earlier treaty that reserved the seas south of the Canaries for Portugal, and let it be known that he was fitting out a fleet.
Ferdinand and Isabella turned to Rome. The pope, Alexander VI, was a Borgia from Valencia and their subject by birth. In a series of bulls in 1493 he granted Castile all lands found west of a line drawn from pole to pole a hundred leagues beyond the Azores and Cape Verde Islands, and then, in a further bull, appeared to open even the route to India to Spanish ships sailing west. That was more than Portugal could accept. Its captains had spent seventy years working down the African coast, and Bartolomeu Dias had rounded the Cape six years before.
John II ignored the pope and dealt directly with his neighbours, who had no wish for a war while their attention was on Italy. The bargain signed on 7 June moved the line to 370 leagues west of the Cape Verde Islands. Whatever lay to the west would be Castile’s, whatever lay to the east Portugal’s. Each side promised not to send ships exploring in the other’s half, and a joint expedition was to sail within ten months to fix the line and set up markers where it crossed land.
That expedition never sailed. No pilot alive could determine longitude at sea, the treaty did not say which of the Cape Verde Islands to measure from, and nobody agreed how long a league was. The line was a legal idea. Castile ratified it in July and Portugal in September, and in 1506 a later pope gave it his blessing.
How it came to this
The two crowns had divided the ocean once before. The Treaty of Alcacovas in 1479, which ended a war over the Castilian succession, left the Canary Islands to Castile and gave Portugal Madeira, the Azores, the Cape Verde Islands and everything discovered or to be discovered southward along the coast of Guinea. A papal bull confirmed it. This was the document John II had in mind when Columbus appeared in Lisbon.
Behind such arrangements lay a medieval doctrine that the pope, as vicar of Christ, could assign the lands of non-Christians to a Christian prince who undertook to convert them. Portuguese kings had obtained bulls of this kind since the 1450s, which also licensed them to conquer and enslave ‘Saracens and pagans’ in Africa. By 1494 Portugal had forts and a thriving trade in gold and enslaved people on the Guinea coast and was close to opening the sea road to India. Castile, having completed the conquest of Granada in 1492, had only Columbus’s islands, which he insisted were the edge of Asia.