Parallax

7 June, 1494

Spain and Portugal divide the world at Tordesillas

In a small Castilian town, envoys of two Iberian crowns drew a line down an ocean nobody could yet measure and awarded each other everything on either side. No one who lived there was asked.

Tordesillas, Castile, Spain

The delegations met in the spring of 1494 at Tordesillas, a walled town on the Duero where the court of Ferdinand and Isabella was then staying. Portugal sent Rui de Sousa, an elderly and experienced diplomat, with his son Joao and the jurist Aires de Almada. For Castile and Aragon there were the royal steward Enrique Enriquez, the chief accountant Gutierre de Cardenas and Dr Rodrigo Maldonado. They brought pilots and cosmographers with them, among them the Portuguese navigator Duarte Pacheco Pereira, because the argument was about geography that existed mostly on paper.

The trouble had started fifteen months earlier. Christopher Columbus, returning from his first voyage, was driven by a storm into Lisbon and boasted of his discoveries to King John II of Portugal before he had reported to his own employers. John took the view that any islands in that quarter fell to him under an earlier treaty that reserved the seas south of the Canaries for Portugal, and let it be known that he was fitting out a fleet.

Ferdinand and Isabella turned to Rome. The pope, Alexander VI, was a Borgia from Valencia and their subject by birth. In a series of bulls in 1493 he granted Castile all lands found west of a line drawn from pole to pole a hundred leagues beyond the Azores and Cape Verde Islands, and then, in a further bull, appeared to open even the route to India to Spanish ships sailing west. That was more than Portugal could accept. Its captains had spent seventy years working down the African coast, and Bartolomeu Dias had rounded the Cape six years before.

John II ignored the pope and dealt directly with his neighbours, who had no wish for a war while their attention was on Italy. The bargain signed on 7 June moved the line to 370 leagues west of the Cape Verde Islands. Whatever lay to the west would be Castile’s, whatever lay to the east Portugal’s. Each side promised not to send ships exploring in the other’s half, and a joint expedition was to sail within ten months to fix the line and set up markers where it crossed land.

That expedition never sailed. No pilot alive could determine longitude at sea, the treaty did not say which of the Cape Verde Islands to measure from, and nobody agreed how long a league was. The line was a legal idea. Castile ratified it in July and Portugal in September, and in 1506 a later pope gave it his blessing.

How it came to this

The two crowns had divided the ocean once before. The Treaty of Alcacovas in 1479, which ended a war over the Castilian succession, left the Canary Islands to Castile and gave Portugal Madeira, the Azores, the Cape Verde Islands and everything discovered or to be discovered southward along the coast of Guinea. A papal bull confirmed it. This was the document John II had in mind when Columbus appeared in Lisbon.

Behind such arrangements lay a medieval doctrine that the pope, as vicar of Christ, could assign the lands of non-Christians to a Christian prince who undertook to convert them. Portuguese kings had obtained bulls of this kind since the 1450s, which also licensed them to conquer and enslave ‘Saracens and pagans’ in Africa. By 1494 Portugal had forts and a thriving trade in gold and enslaved people on the Guinea coast and was close to opening the sea road to India. Castile, having completed the conquest of Granada in 1492, had only Columbus’s islands, which he insisted were the edge of Asia.

How each side saw it

The Portuguese crown

For John II the essential thing was the South Atlantic. His ships sailing for the Cape had learned to swing far out to the west to pick up favourable winds, and a line only a hundred leagues from the islands cramped that manoeuvre. Pushing it to 370 leagues secured the route to India, which Vasco da Gama completed in 1498. It also, as it turned out, placed the eastern bulge of South America on Portugal’s side. Portuguese chroniclers such as Joao de Barros present the treaty as a triumph of the king’s diplomacy over a pope who had favoured his rivals.

Castile and Columbus

Ferdinand and Isabella believed they had given away open water and kept the Indies. Columbus, consulted by letter, assured them his islands lay far west of any such line. The monarchs’ instructions and the papal bulls on which they relied framed the grant as a duty to bring the inhabitants to the Christian faith. From 1513 Spanish expeditions carried a formal text, the Requerimiento, to be read aloud to the people they encountered, informing them in Spanish that the pope had donated their country to the crown of Castile and that resistance would justify war and enslavement.

The other European powers

France, England and later the Dutch never accepted that two kingdoms could close the oceans by private contract. Francis I of France is reported to have asked to see the clause in Adam’s will that divided the world between his brothers of Spain and Portugal; the remark is known only at second hand. Elizabeth I’s ministers told the Spanish ambassador that possession required occupation, not a papal grant. In 1609 the Dutch jurist Hugo Grotius, writing to justify a seizure of a Portuguese ship, argued in Mare Liberum that the sea could belong to no one.

The peoples on either side of the line

The Taino of the Caribbean, the Tupi of the Brazilian coast and every other nation whose land was allotted knew nothing of the treaty and left no response to it. Objection came first from within Spain: the Dominican theologian Francisco de Vitoria argued at Salamanca in 1539 that the pope had no temporal authority over peoples who were true owners of their lands, and Bartolome de las Casas pressed the same case at court. Indigenous organisations in the Americas campaigned for decades against the underlying ‘doctrine of discovery’, which the Vatican formally repudiated in 2023.

What is disputed

Where the line ran was never agreed; modern reconstructions place it between about 42 and 50 degrees west. Some Portuguese historians, notably Jaime Cortesao, argued that John II fought for the extra leagues because his pilots already knew of Brazil and kept it secret. No document shows this, and most scholars, Samuel Eliot Morison among them, think the motive was sailing room in the Atlantic. It is also disputed whether the negotiators meant the line to continue round the far side of the globe, and whether Alexander’s bulls conferred sovereignty or only a missionary charge.

What followed

Pedro Alvares Cabral landed in Brazil in 1500, east of the line, which is why the largest country in South America speaks Portuguese. When Magellan’s expedition reached the Spice Islands from the west, the two crowns argued over where the line fell on the other side of the world, until Charles V sold his claim to Portugal in 1529. Portuguese settlers in Brazil pushed far beyond the line, and the Treaty of Madrid in 1750 replaced it with borders based on actual occupation. The original treaties survive in Seville and Lisbon.

Read further

  • Frances Gardiner Davenport (ed.), European Treaties Bearing on the History of the United States and Its Dependencies to 1648 (1917)
  • Stephen R. Bown, 1494: How a Family Feud in Medieval Spain Divided the World in Half (2011)
  • J. H. Parry, The Spanish Seaborne Empire (1966)
  • C. R. Boxer, The Portuguese Seaborne Empire, 1415-1825 (1969)
  • Felipe Fernandez-Armesto, Columbus (1991)

Same day, other years

1692

Port Royal slides into the sea

Port Royal, JamaicaThe Americas

Port Royal, built on a sandspit at the mouth of Kingston harbour, was the richest English town in the Americas, grown fat on privateering against Spain and on the trade in enslaved Africans. Shortly before noon on 7 June 1692 three shocks of an earthquake turned the waterlogged sand beneath it to liquid. Whole streets of brick houses sank upright into the harbour, and a wave swept over what was left. About two-thirds of the town disappeared and some 2,000 people died within minutes; perhaps as many again died of injuries and fever in the weeks after. A pocket watch recovered from the seabed in the twentieth century had stopped at about 11.43.

Seen from elsewhere. The rector, Emmanuel Heath, and preachers on both sides of the Atlantic described God’s judgement on the wickedest city on earth, a reputation later writers enlarged. A large part of the population was enslaved, and their deaths went almost uncounted in the surviving letters. The survivors founded Kingston across the harbour.

1893

Gandhi is put off the train at Pietermaritzburg

Pietermaritzburg, Natal (now South Africa)Africa

Mohandas Gandhi was a 23-year-old London-trained barrister who had arrived in Natal shortly before to assist in a commercial lawsuit. Travelling to Pretoria with a first-class ticket, he was told at Pietermaritzburg, after a white passenger complained, to move to the van. He refused and was pushed out onto the platform by a constable with his luggage. He spent the winter night in the unlit waiting room, too cold to sleep, deciding whether to go back to India. He stayed in South Africa for twenty-one years, and it was there that he worked out the method of mass non-violent resistance that he called satyagraha.

Seen from elsewhere. The story rests on Gandhi’s own later tellings, chiefly his autobiography of the 1920s, and the date is the one tradition has fixed. Ashwin Desai and Goolam Vahed, among others, point out that his early campaigns sought better treatment for Indians as distinct from Africans, about whom he then wrote in contemptuous terms. Admirers reply that his views changed.

1917

The mines of Messines

Messines Ridge, West Flanders, BelgiumEurope

For more than a year British, Canadian, Australian and New Zealand tunnellers had dug galleries through the blue clay beneath the German front line on the ridge south of Ypres, and packed chambers at their ends with about 450 tonnes of explosive. At 3.10 on the morning of 7 June 1917 nineteen of these mines were fired within seconds of each other. The blast was reportedly heard in London. Whole German positions vanished, and General Plumer’s infantry, following a creeping barrage, took the ridge by mid-morning. It was among the most completely successful set-piece attacks of the war. Several further mines were never fired; lightning set one off in 1955, and others remain in the ground.

Seen from elsewhere. The figure of 10,000 Germans killed by the explosions is a British estimate; German casualty returns suggest the mines themselves killed far fewer, with most losses coming in the fighting that followed. Bavarian and Prussian regimental histories record survivors too dazed to resist. The advantage was largely lost in the seven-week pause before the main offensive at Ypres.

1981

Israel bombs Iraq’s nuclear reactor

Tuwaitha, near Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Late in the afternoon of 7 June 1981 eight Israeli F-16s, escorted by F-15 fighters, flew some 1,100 kilometres at low level across Jordanian and Saudi airspace and dropped sixteen bombs on Osirak, a French-built research reactor at the Tuwaitha complex outside Baghdad. The reactor, not yet loaded with fuel, was destroyed in under two minutes. Ten Iraqi soldiers and a French technician were killed, and all the aircraft returned. Menachem Begin’s government said that Saddam Hussein intended to build a bomb for use against Israel and that it would never allow an enemy to acquire such weapons, a position since known as the Begin doctrine.

Seen from elsewhere. The UN Security Council, including the United States, unanimously condemned the raid as a violation of the Charter. Iraq had signed the Non-Proliferation Treaty and the reactor was under international inspection. Researchers such as Malfrid Braut-Hegghammer argue from Iraqi sources that the attack turned a hesitant programme into a determined, hidden one.

Also on 7 June