Parallax

26 June, 1284

The children of Hamelin vanish

A German town recorded that 130 of its young people were led away on a single summer day and never came back. The rats came later; the loss seems to have been real.

Hamelin, Lower Saxony, Germany

The oldest written account is short. A Latin note copied into a manuscript at Luneburg around the middle of the fifteenth century says that in the year 1284, on the day of Saints John and Paul, the twenty-sixth of June, a handsome young man of about thirty, finely dressed, came into Hamelin over the Weser bridge. He carried a silver pipe of strange design and began to play it through the town. The children who heard him, 130 in number, followed him out through the east gate towards the place of execution called Calvary, and there they disappeared. The mothers ran from town to town and found nothing.

The note says it is taken from an old book, and adds that the mother of a certain dean, Johann von Lude, saw the children leave. That is as close to a witness as the story gets. There is no mention of rats, of a broken bargain or of a town council that refused to pay.

Hamelin itself remembered. A stained-glass window in the Market Church, made around 1300 and destroyed in 1660, showed a figure in many colours with a crowd of children in white; later writers described it and one copied its inscription. The lane by which the children were said to have left is still called the Bungelosenstrasse, the street without drums, and by old custom no music is played in it, even for a wedding procession. An inscription of 1602 on a house at its corner repeats the date and the number.

The rats arrive in the sixteenth century. A chronicle written for the counts of Zimmern in Swabia in the 1560s is the first to say that the stranger had rid the town of a plague of rats, was cheated of his fee and took the children in revenge. That version, with its plain moral, is the one that travelled. The brothers Grimm printed it in 1816 from a dozen older sources, adding the children who lagged behind and were left to tell the tale, and the claim that the children came out again in Transylvania.

Robert Browning turned it into English verse in 1842 for a friend’s sick child, and gave the world its picture of the piper. He also gave a different date, 22 July 1376, which he took from a seventeenth-century English book. Hamelin holds to 1284.

How it came to this

Hamelin in the 1280s was a small walled market town on the Weser, grown up around an abbey and a river crossing with its mills. It had lately passed from the lordship of the abbey of Fulda to the dukes of Brunswick, after a quarrel in which the townsmen marched out against the bishop of Minden in 1260 and were badly beaten at Sedemunde. Many of its young men were killed or captured that day, and some older scholars thought that defeat was the true seed of the legend.

The wider setting was the great eastward migration of German speakers. Throughout the thirteenth century princes, bishops and monastic orders in Brandenburg, Pomerania, Prussia, Bohemia and Moravia were founding villages and towns on thinly settled land, and they needed people. Recruiting agents, called locators, toured the crowded west offering land and freedom from dues, and are said to have dressed brightly and used a drum or pipe to gather a crowd. Lower Saxony and Westphalia supplied many of the settlers.

How each side saw it

Hamelin’s own tradition

The town’s memory is of a bereavement, not a fable. The church window, the street name and the house inscription all record a loss and a date, and none of the early evidence blames the citizens for it. A much-quoted line said to come from the town’s records, dated 1384, reads ‘It is a hundred years since our children left’, though the document itself cannot now be produced. Local tradition also held that the town once reckoned its years from the event. Today Hamelin performs the story in the open air every summer Sunday, and the rats do most of the work for the tourist trade.

The emigration school

Since the 1940s the leading explanation has been that the ‘children’ were the town’s young people, recruited to settle land in the east. Wolfgang Wann argued for Moravia, where Bishop Bruno of Olomouc, a Schaumburg from the Weser region, had been planting German colonists. Hans Dobbertin preferred Pomerania and a party lost at sea. The linguist Jurgen Udolph traced Hamelin-area surnames and place names to the Uckermark and Prignitz north of Berlin. On this reading the piper is a locator, and ‘lost’ means lost to their families, as emigrants to America were lost to Irish villages.

Folklorists and sceptics

Other scholars doubt that any single event can be recovered. Some read the piper as Death, leading a dance of the dead after an epidemic or a landslip. Some link the story to the dancing manias recorded along the Rhine, or to a late echo of the Children’s Crusade of 1212. Gernot Husam has proposed a midsummer gathering near Coppenbrugge that ended in violence. Folklorists such as Wolfgang Mieder treat the tale chiefly as a story that each age has reused, from Reformation sermons on the Devil to cartoons of political demagogues, and warn that the emigration theory rests on inference rather than documents.

What is disputed

Nearly everything beyond the date and the number. No document from 1284 survives; the earliest witnesses are a lost window of about 1300 and a manuscript of about 1440, and Browning’s date of 1376 comes from Richard Verstegan in 1605. The popular plague explanation is weak, since the Black Death reached Germany only in 1349 and the oldest versions contain no rats. The Moravian theory is one of several emigration theories, and none is proven. Whether the missing were small children or young adults turns on a Latin and Low German word that could mean either ‘children’ or simply ‘natives of the town’.

What followed

The tale became one of the best known in the world, and ‘pied piper’ entered English as a term for anyone who leads the trusting to ruin. In German the Rattenfanger has served as an image of the Devil, of recruiting sergeants and, after 1945, of Hitler. Hamelin has made the story its livelihood. The underlying history matters too: the eastward settlement that may lie behind it reshaped central Europe, and its reversal in the expulsions of 1945 is one reason German scholars returned to the legend with such interest after the war.

Read further

  • Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, Deutsche Sagen (1816)
  • Robert Browning, The Pied Piper of Hamelin (1842)
  • Heinrich Spanuth, Der Rattenfanger von Hameln (1951)
  • Hans Dobbertin, Quellensammlung zur Hamelner Rattenfangersage (1970)
  • Wolfgang Mieder, The Pied Piper: A Handbook (2007)

Same day, other years

AD 363

The Emperor Julian dies on campaign in Persia

Near Samarra, Mesopotamia (now Iraq)Middle East

Julian, the last Roman emperor to worship the old gods, had invaded the Sasanian empire with one of the largest armies Rome ever sent east. He reached the walls of the capital, Ctesiphon, could not take it, burned his river fleet and turned north through scorched country. When Persian cavalry struck the column he rode into the fight without his breastplate, and a spear pierced his side. He died in his tent that night, in his early thirties, after a reign of twenty months. His successor Jovian bought the army’s escape by surrendering Nisibis and five provinces.

Seen from elsewhere. The officer Ammianus Marcellinus, who was there, does not say who threw the spear. The pagan orator Libanius hinted at a Christian in Roman ranks; Christians later credited a saint. The line ‘Thou hast conquered, Galilean’ first appears in Theodoret, eighty years on. A Persian rock relief at Taq-e Bostan shows a fallen Roman usually taken to be Julian.

1541

Francisco Pizarro is killed in Lima

Lima, PeruThe Americas

Nine years after he seized the Inca ruler Atahualpa at Cajamarca, the conqueror of Peru was cut down in his own palace. About twenty armed men crossed the main square at midday on a Sunday, shouting for the death of the tyrant, and burst in on Pizarro at table. Most of his guests fled. He was in his sixties and fought with a sword until he was stabbed in the throat. The attackers were followers of his former partner Diego de Almagro, whom Pizarro’s brother had executed in 1538, and they proclaimed Almagro’s young son governor.

Seen from elsewhere. The ‘men of Chile’ saw themselves as cheated partners left destitute by the Pizarros. For Andeans it was a quarrel among invaders: Manco Inca, holding out at Vilcabamba, sheltered some of the killers, who later murdered him. A body long displayed in Lima cathedral as Pizarro’s proved to be someone else when his real remains were identified in 1984.

1945

Fifty nations sign the United Nations Charter

San Francisco, United StatesWorldwide

After nine weeks of negotiation, delegates filed onto the stage of the Veterans War Memorial building to sign a treaty creating a new world organisation. China, as the first victim of Axis aggression, signed first. The war in Europe had ended seven weeks earlier; the war with Japan had seven weeks to run. The Charter set up a General Assembly of all members and a Security Council in which five powers, the United States, the Soviet Union, Britain, France and China, held permanent seats and a veto. It came into force on 24 October.

Seen from elsewhere. Smaller states, led by Australia’s Herbert Evatt, fought the veto and lost. Most of Africa and much of Asia were colonies and had no seat; W. E. B. Du Bois, present as an observer, protested that hundreds of millions of colonial subjects were left without rights. The historian Mark Mazower notes that the preamble was drafted by Jan Smuts of South Africa.

1955

The Freedom Charter is adopted at Kliptown

Kliptown, near Johannesburg, South AfricaAfrica

Some three thousand delegates met on a dusty football field for a Congress of the People, called by the African National Congress and its Indian, Coloured and white allies. Volunteers had spent months collecting demands from townships and farms. The resulting charter, read out clause by clause and approved by a show of hands, began with the words that South Africa belongs to all who live in it, black and white, and called for votes for all, equal rights and a share in the country’s wealth. On the second afternoon armed police surrounded the meeting, took every name and seized the documents.

Seen from elsewhere. The government treated the charter as a communist blueprint and tried 156 of its backers for treason; all were acquitted by 1961. Within the ANC, Africanists led by Robert Sobukwe rejected the opening line as giving away the land, and broke off in 1959 to form the Pan Africanist Congress.

Also on 26 June