Benedict Arnold died early on Sunday 14 June 1801 at his house in Gloucester Place, Marylebone, after several days of delirium. He was sixty. Dropsy and gout had crippled him, and the leg twice shattered in American service had never healed properly. His wife Peggy wrote to their sons that he had suffered greatly. He was buried a week later across the river at St Mary’s, Battersea, with a respectable procession and no military honours. He left debts that Peggy spent her remaining three years paying off.
Twenty-one years earlier he had been a major general in the Continental Army and commander of West Point, the fortress that controlled the Hudson River. Since May 1779 he had been writing in cipher to Major John Andre, the adjutant of the British commander in New York, passing information and bargaining over terms. By the summer of 1780 the offer was specific: he would arrange for West Point and its garrison to fall, for 20,000 pounds.
On the night of 21 September Andre came ashore from the sloop Vulture to meet him in the woods below the fort. The ship was driven downstream by American guns before Andre could return, and he set off overland in civilian clothes with plans of the defences in his stocking. Three militiamen stopped him near Tarrytown on the 23rd, searched him and found the papers. A confused officer sent word of the capture to Arnold himself.
The message reached him at breakfast on 25 September, an hour before George Washington was due to arrive. Arnold went upstairs to tell his wife, rode to the river, and ordered his bargemen to row him to the Vulture. From the ship he wrote to Washington that love of his country had guided his conduct and asked protection for Peggy, who was innocent. Washington, finding the commander gone and then reading the captured documents, is reported to have asked: ‘Whom can we trust now?’
Andre was hanged as a spy at Tappan on 2 October. Arnold received a brigadier’s commission in the British army, 6,315 pounds and a pension. He led raids that burned Richmond in Virginia and New London in his native Connecticut, where the garrison of Fort Griswold was cut down after surrendering. He sailed for England at the end of 1781, tried trade in New Brunswick and privateering in the West Indies, and was never again given a command.
How it came to this
Arnold was a New Haven merchant and apothecary who marched his militia company to war within days of Lexington in 1775. He helped seize Fort Ticonderoga, led a column through the Maine wilderness to attack Quebec, where he was shot in the leg, and in 1776 built a scratch fleet on Lake Champlain whose defeat at Valcour Island nevertheless delayed a British invasion by a year. At Saratoga in 1777 he led the decisive assaults and was badly wounded again in the same leg. The victory brought France into the war. His superior, Horatio Gates, took the credit.
He had grievances. Congress had promoted five junior officers over his head, questioned his accounts and been slow to repay what he had spent. As military governor of Philadelphia from 1778 he lived far beyond his means, traded on his office, and married Peggy Shippen, the eighteen-year-old daughter of a family with loyalist connections who had known Andre during the British occupation. Pennsylvania’s radical government had him court-martialled, and in 1780 Washington issued a mild public reprimand. By then he had been in contact with the enemy for a year.