Parallax

14 June, 1801

Benedict Arnold dies in London

He had been the best battlefield general the American rebels possessed, twice wounded in their cause. He died in debt in a rented London house, distrusted by the country he had joined and a synonym for treason in the one he had left.

Gloucester Place, London, England

Benedict Arnold died early on Sunday 14 June 1801 at his house in Gloucester Place, Marylebone, after several days of delirium. He was sixty. Dropsy and gout had crippled him, and the leg twice shattered in American service had never healed properly. His wife Peggy wrote to their sons that he had suffered greatly. He was buried a week later across the river at St Mary’s, Battersea, with a respectable procession and no military honours. He left debts that Peggy spent her remaining three years paying off.

Twenty-one years earlier he had been a major general in the Continental Army and commander of West Point, the fortress that controlled the Hudson River. Since May 1779 he had been writing in cipher to Major John Andre, the adjutant of the British commander in New York, passing information and bargaining over terms. By the summer of 1780 the offer was specific: he would arrange for West Point and its garrison to fall, for 20,000 pounds.

On the night of 21 September Andre came ashore from the sloop Vulture to meet him in the woods below the fort. The ship was driven downstream by American guns before Andre could return, and he set off overland in civilian clothes with plans of the defences in his stocking. Three militiamen stopped him near Tarrytown on the 23rd, searched him and found the papers. A confused officer sent word of the capture to Arnold himself.

The message reached him at breakfast on 25 September, an hour before George Washington was due to arrive. Arnold went upstairs to tell his wife, rode to the river, and ordered his bargemen to row him to the Vulture. From the ship he wrote to Washington that love of his country had guided his conduct and asked protection for Peggy, who was innocent. Washington, finding the commander gone and then reading the captured documents, is reported to have asked: ‘Whom can we trust now?’

Andre was hanged as a spy at Tappan on 2 October. Arnold received a brigadier’s commission in the British army, 6,315 pounds and a pension. He led raids that burned Richmond in Virginia and New London in his native Connecticut, where the garrison of Fort Griswold was cut down after surrendering. He sailed for England at the end of 1781, tried trade in New Brunswick and privateering in the West Indies, and was never again given a command.

How it came to this

Arnold was a New Haven merchant and apothecary who marched his militia company to war within days of Lexington in 1775. He helped seize Fort Ticonderoga, led a column through the Maine wilderness to attack Quebec, where he was shot in the leg, and in 1776 built a scratch fleet on Lake Champlain whose defeat at Valcour Island nevertheless delayed a British invasion by a year. At Saratoga in 1777 he led the decisive assaults and was badly wounded again in the same leg. The victory brought France into the war. His superior, Horatio Gates, took the credit.

He had grievances. Congress had promoted five junior officers over his head, questioned his accounts and been slow to repay what he had spent. As military governor of Philadelphia from 1778 he lived far beyond his means, traded on his office, and married Peggy Shippen, the eighteen-year-old daughter of a family with loyalist connections who had known Andre during the British occupation. Pennsylvania’s radical government had him court-martialled, and in 1780 Washington issued a mild public reprimand. By then he had been in contact with the enemy for a year.

How each side saw it

Arnold himself

Arnold published his defence in October 1780 in an address ‘To the Inhabitants of America’. He said he had taken up arms to redress grievances, not to break the empire; that Britain’s peace offers of 1778 had granted everything Americans first asked; and that Congress had since betrayed the cause by allying with Catholic, absolutist France, ‘the enemy of the Protestant faith’. He presented himself as acting to end a ruinous war. He never withdrew this account. The story that on his deathbed he asked for his old Continental uniform and begged God’s forgiveness for wearing any other has no contemporary source and is generally regarded as a later American invention.

The American Patriots

To his former comrades the offence was beyond explanation. He had sold a fortress and its 3,000 men for money, and had tried to hand over Washington with it. Towns burned him in effigy; Philadelphia paraded a two-faced figure with the devil at its shoulder. Congress ordered his name struck from the army’s rolls. Benjamin Franklin observed that Judas sold one man and Arnold three million. The monument on the Saratoga battlefield to the ‘most brilliant soldier of the Continental Army’ shows only a boot and does not name him. In American English his name remains the ordinary word for a traitor.

The British

Sir Henry Clinton paid what was promised and used Arnold in the field, and George III received him civilly. But many officers would not serve under him, and the army held him responsible for the death of the popular Andre, for whom Clinton had refused to exchange him. The Whig opposition treated him as a mercenary: when the Earl of Lauderdale insulted him in the House of Lords in 1792, they fought a duel. His repeated applications for military employment in the wars against France were declined. Among the American Loyalists who settled in New Brunswick he was disliked as a hard creditor.

Peggy Shippen Arnold

When Washington arrived on the day of the flight, Peggy was found in her room in apparent hysterics, crying that hot irons were on her head and that the general had come to kill her child. Washington and his aide Alexander Hamilton were convinced she knew nothing, and she was given safe passage. For a century and a half historians agreed. Then the papers of British headquarters, published by Carl Van Doren in 1941, showed that she had handled letters in the correspondence from its beginning and was paid by the Crown for her services. She left no account of her own motives.

What is disputed

Motive is the central argument. Older accounts stress debt, vanity and resentment. James Kirby Martin emphasises the real injustices done to him by Congress, and Stephen Brumwell argues that his stated conviction, that the French alliance had corrupted the rebellion, should be taken seriously alongside the money. How far Peggy prompted the approach to Andre, her old acquaintance, is unknown. Washington’s ‘Whom can we trust now?’ comes from later recollection, not a document. Historians also differ over how much of the credit for Saratoga belongs to Arnold, since Gates’s partisans denied he had any authority to be on the field.

What followed

Had the plan worked, the British would have cut New England from the other states. Its failure instead gave the Patriots a villain at a low point of the war, and a year later the fighting effectively ended at Yorktown. Four of Arnold’s sons became British officers; one rose to lieutenant general. The United States wrote a narrow definition of treason into its Constitution in 1787, requiring two witnesses to an overt act, partly from experience of how freely the charge had been thrown about. Arnold’s career is still used to ask an awkward question: what the American rebels themselves were, in law, before they won.

Read further

  • Carl Van Doren, Secret History of the American Revolution (1941)
  • James Kirby Martin, Benedict Arnold, Revolutionary Hero: An American Warrior Reconsidered (1997)
  • Willard Sterne Randall, Benedict Arnold: Patriot and Traitor (1990)
  • Nathaniel Philbrick, Valiant Ambition: George Washington, Benedict Arnold, and the Fate of the American Revolution (2016)
  • Stephen Brumwell, Turncoat: Benedict Arnold and the Crisis of American Liberty (2018)

Same day, other years

1789

Bligh brings the Bounty’s launch to Timor

Kupang, TimorAsia

Forty-seven days after mutineers put him over the side of HMS Bounty near Tonga, Lieutenant William Bligh steered an open boat seven metres long into the Dutch harbour of Kupang on 14 June 1789. He had eighteen men with him and almost no freeboard. One had been killed by islanders on Tofua at the outset; after that Bligh avoided land, navigated with a sextant and a pocket watch across some 3,600 nautical miles, and kept everyone alive on a daily ration of an ounce of bread and a quarter of a pint of water, weighed out in a scale made of coconut shells. Several died of fever in the Dutch East Indies soon afterwards.

Seen from elsewhere. The family of the mutineers’ leader, Fletcher Christian, published accounts depicting Bligh as a foul-mouthed bully who drove his officers to despair. The historian Greg Dening found that he flogged less than most captains but humiliated men with words. The voyage’s purpose was to carry breadfruit to feed enslaved people in the West Indies. The mutineers later abducted Tahitian women and men to Pitcairn.

1830

A French army lands in Algeria

Sidi Ferruch (Sidi Fredj), near AlgiersAfrica

At dawn on 14 June 1830 the first of some 37,000 French soldiers waded ashore on a sandy peninsula west of Algiers from a fleet of several hundred ships. The stated cause was an insult three years old: the ruler of the Ottoman regency of Algiers, Hussein Dey, had struck the French consul with a fly-whisk during a quarrel over debts France owed for grain bought in the 1790s. The real hope of Charles X’s unpopular government was a quick victory before elections. Algiers surrendered on 5 July and the Dey’s treasury was shipped to France. The king was overthrown three weeks later anyway. France stayed for 132 years.

Seen from elsewhere. The surrender terms promised to respect the inhabitants’ religion, property and trade. Within months mosques were being turned into churches and barracks and land was confiscated, as the Algiers notable Hamdan Khodja protested in a book published in Paris in 1833. Resistance under the emir Abd al-Qadir lasted until 1847. Demographers estimate that the conquest and the famines that followed cost hundreds of thousands of Algerian lives.

1941

Soviet police deport tens of thousands from the Baltic states

Estonia, Latvia and LithuaniaEurope

In the night of 13-14 June 1941, a year after the Soviet Union annexed the three Baltic republics, security police teams went to listed addresses and gave families an hour or less to pack. Roughly 10,000 people were taken from Estonia, 15,000 from Latvia and 17,000 from Lithuania; similar operations struck Moldavia and the western borderlands of Ukraine and Belarus. They were former officials, officers, policemen, landowners, businessmen, clergy and their relatives. At the railway stations men were separated and sent to labour camps in the northern Urals, where most died within two years. Women, children and the old went in goods wagons to settlements in Siberia and Kazakhstan.

Seen from elsewhere. Soviet documents described a clearing of ‘anti-Soviet elements’ from a border zone on the eve of war; Germany invaded eight days later. The Baltic states mark 14 June as a day of mourning and regard the deportations as a crime against humanity or genocide, a term Russia rejects. Jews were among the deported in more than their share of the population, which complicates later claims about who collaborated with whom.

1982

The Argentine garrison surrenders at Stanley

Stanley, Falkland IslandsThe Americas

After night battles for the hills west of the islands’ capital, Argentine conscripts began streaming back into Stanley on the morning of 14 June 1982. That evening Brigadier General Mario Menendez signed a surrender to the British land commander, Major General Jeremy Moore, crossing out the word ‘unconditional’. About 11,000 men laid down their arms. The war had lasted 74 days from the Argentine landing on 2 April and killed 649 Argentines, 255 British servicemen and three islanders. In Buenos Aires crowds who had cheered the invasion turned on the military government. General Galtieri resigned within days, and elections in 1983 ended seven years of dictatorship.

Seen from elsewhere. Argentina has never given up its claim to the islands it calls the Malvinas, which it says it inherited from Spain and lost to a British seizure in 1833; the claim is written into its constitution. The islanders voted almost unanimously in 2013 to stay British. Argentine veterans have brought cases alleging that conscripts were starved and tortured by their own officers.

Also on 14 June