On 11 June 1937 eight senior officers of the Red Army were brought before a special bench of the Soviet Supreme Court in Moscow. The hearing was closed and there were no defence lawyers. The chief accused was Marshal Mikhail Tukhachevsky, aged forty-four, until a month earlier first deputy commissar for defence. With him were the army commanders Iona Yakir and Ieronim Uborevich, who led the two most important military districts on the western frontier, and the commanders Kork, Eideman, Feldman, Primakov and Putna. A ninth man, the army’s chief political officer Yan Gamarnik, had shot himself when the police came for him.
The charge was that they had formed a ‘Trotskyite anti-Soviet military organisation’, spied for Germany and planned to bring about the defeat of the Soviet Union in war. The only evidence was their own confessions. Tukhachevsky had been arrested on 22 May at Kuibyshev on the Volga, where he had just been sent in demotion, and had signed within days. When the file was examined in the Khrushchev years, pages of his statement were found to be spotted with blood.
The presiding judge was Vasily Ulrikh, who handled most of the great show trials. Beside him, on Stalin’s instruction, sat serving commanders, among them the marshals Budyonny and Blyukher, required to condemn their own colleagues. Most of the accused repeated what they had signed. The verdict was read shortly before midnight: death, without appeal.
They were shot in the early hours of 12 June in the cellars of the security police. Yakir had written to Stalin protesting his devotion; Stalin wrote across the letter that he was a scoundrel and a prostitute, and other Politburo members added their agreement. The morning papers announced the executions, and meetings in factories and barracks across the country passed resolutions approving them.
Then the arrests widened. Of the five marshals of the Soviet Union, three were dead by 1939, including Blyukher, who had sat in judgement and died under interrogation. Thirteen of fifteen army commanders, fifty of fifty-seven corps commanders and 154 of 186 divisional commanders were removed, most of them shot. Tukhachevsky’s wife Nina and both his brothers were executed, his mother died in exile, his sisters were sent to camps, and his daughter was placed in an orphanage under another name.
How it came to this
Tukhachevsky was a nobleman’s son from Smolensk province who had been a lieutenant in the Tsar’s guards, a prisoner of war in Germany and, from 1918, a Bolshevik. In the Civil War he rose to command whole fronts while still in his twenties. In 1920 his drive on Warsaw ended in rout, and he blamed the southern front, where Stalin was political commissar, for withholding the cavalry he needed. The quarrel was never forgotten. In the 1930s he was the driving force behind the mechanisation of the Red Army and the doctrine of ‘deep operations’, the use of massed tanks, aircraft and paratroops to break through and strike far to the rear.
By 1937 the Great Terror was under way. Two public trials of old Bolsheviks had produced confessions of fantastic conspiracies, and the security chief Nikolai Yezhov was looking for more. The army was the one institution with the physical means to remove the leadership, its senior men had been appointed under Trotsky, and several had served on exchange with the German army in the 1920s under a secret agreement. Each of those facts could be made into evidence.