Parallax

12 June, 1937

Stalin shoots his marshal

The Red Army’s most gifted commander was tried in a single day behind closed doors and shot within hours, along with seven other generals. Over the next two years the officer corps that would have to face Hitler was torn apart.

Moscow, Soviet Union

On 11 June 1937 eight senior officers of the Red Army were brought before a special bench of the Soviet Supreme Court in Moscow. The hearing was closed and there were no defence lawyers. The chief accused was Marshal Mikhail Tukhachevsky, aged forty-four, until a month earlier first deputy commissar for defence. With him were the army commanders Iona Yakir and Ieronim Uborevich, who led the two most important military districts on the western frontier, and the commanders Kork, Eideman, Feldman, Primakov and Putna. A ninth man, the army’s chief political officer Yan Gamarnik, had shot himself when the police came for him.

The charge was that they had formed a ‘Trotskyite anti-Soviet military organisation’, spied for Germany and planned to bring about the defeat of the Soviet Union in war. The only evidence was their own confessions. Tukhachevsky had been arrested on 22 May at Kuibyshev on the Volga, where he had just been sent in demotion, and had signed within days. When the file was examined in the Khrushchev years, pages of his statement were found to be spotted with blood.

The presiding judge was Vasily Ulrikh, who handled most of the great show trials. Beside him, on Stalin’s instruction, sat serving commanders, among them the marshals Budyonny and Blyukher, required to condemn their own colleagues. Most of the accused repeated what they had signed. The verdict was read shortly before midnight: death, without appeal.

They were shot in the early hours of 12 June in the cellars of the security police. Yakir had written to Stalin protesting his devotion; Stalin wrote across the letter that he was a scoundrel and a prostitute, and other Politburo members added their agreement. The morning papers announced the executions, and meetings in factories and barracks across the country passed resolutions approving them.

Then the arrests widened. Of the five marshals of the Soviet Union, three were dead by 1939, including Blyukher, who had sat in judgement and died under interrogation. Thirteen of fifteen army commanders, fifty of fifty-seven corps commanders and 154 of 186 divisional commanders were removed, most of them shot. Tukhachevsky’s wife Nina and both his brothers were executed, his mother died in exile, his sisters were sent to camps, and his daughter was placed in an orphanage under another name.

How it came to this

Tukhachevsky was a nobleman’s son from Smolensk province who had been a lieutenant in the Tsar’s guards, a prisoner of war in Germany and, from 1918, a Bolshevik. In the Civil War he rose to command whole fronts while still in his twenties. In 1920 his drive on Warsaw ended in rout, and he blamed the southern front, where Stalin was political commissar, for withholding the cavalry he needed. The quarrel was never forgotten. In the 1930s he was the driving force behind the mechanisation of the Red Army and the doctrine of ‘deep operations’, the use of massed tanks, aircraft and paratroops to break through and strike far to the rear.

By 1937 the Great Terror was under way. Two public trials of old Bolsheviks had produced confessions of fantastic conspiracies, and the security chief Nikolai Yezhov was looking for more. The army was the one institution with the physical means to remove the leadership, its senior men had been appointed under Trotsky, and several had served on exchange with the German army in the 1920s under a secret agreement. Each of those facts could be made into evidence.

How each side saw it

Stalin and his circle

Stalin told a meeting of the Military Council on 2 June 1937 that a military-political conspiracy financed by the German general staff had been uncovered, and named Tukhachevsky as a spy. Whether he believed it is a matter of argument, but his closest colleague never recanted. In conversations recorded by the writer Felix Chuev in the 1970s, Vyacheslav Molotov insisted that the generals were unreliable, that Tukhachevsky might have wavered when war came, and that destroying a potential ‘fifth column’ in advance was the reason the Soviet Union held together in 1941. On this reasoning, innocent victims were a price worth paying.

The families

The condemned left no testimony beyond confessions dictated by their interrogators. Their side comes from relatives who survived. Under a decree on ‘family members of traitors to the motherland’, wives were sent to a special camp in Kazakhstan and children to state orphanages. Yakir’s son Pyotr, arrested at fourteen, spent seventeen years in camps and wrote A Childhood in Prison, published abroad in 1972. Tukhachevsky’s daughter Svetlana was arrested in turn when she came of age. After 1956 these families pressed for rehabilitation, and their letters and memoirs are a principal source for what the investigation actually did to the men.

The peasants of Tambov and the sailors of Kronstadt

Not everyone remembers Tukhachevsky as a victim. In March 1921 he commanded the assault across the ice that crushed the Kronstadt sailors’ revolt, and that summer he directed the suppression of the great peasant rising in Tambov province. His orders there provided for hostage-taking, the shooting of the eldest man in families that hid rebels, concentration camps for relatives, and, in an order dated 12 June 1921, the use of poison gas against forests where insurgents sheltered. How much gas was actually fired is disputed. In post-Soviet Russia, especially in Tambov, he is often described as an executioner who met an executioner’s end.

German intelligence

Walter Schellenberg, a senior officer of the SS security service, claimed in his memoirs that Reinhard Heydrich had forged letters implicating Tukhachevsky in dealings with German generals and sold them to Moscow, by way of the Czechoslovak president Edvard Benes, in order to behead the Red Army. The story was widely repeated for decades. Soviet archives opened after 1991 show no such dossier being used in the investigation or the trial, and many historians now think the tale was exaggerated by its authors, or that any forgery merely told Stalin what his own police were already manufacturing.

What is disputed

No evidence of a real plot has been found, and Soviet commissions in 1957 and the early 1960s declared the case fabricated. Why Stalin acted remains contested. Robert Conquest saw a calculated removal of any possible rival centre of power. Peter Whitewood argues that Stalin and Yezhov had come to believe genuinely, on bad intelligence, that the army was riddled with foreign agents. The damage is also debated: about 34,000 officers were dismissed in 1937-38 and roughly 11,000 later reinstated, and Roger Reese contends that the army’s rapid expansion harmed its competence at least as much as the purge. The executions took place around midnight, so both 11 and 12 June are given.

What followed

The Red Army’s poor showing against Finland in 1939-40 persuaded German planners that it was leaderless, a judgement that fed directly into the decision to invade in 1941. Several of the officers who then saved the Soviet Union, among them Rokossovsky, had been released from prison only shortly before. The methods of deep operations that Tukhachevsky had championed, dropped after his death, were revived for the offensives of 1943-45. He and his co-defendants were legally cleared in January 1957. The file remains one of the clearest cases of how the Terror worked: accusation, torture, confession, and a trial whose sentence was decided in advance.

Read further

  • Robert Conquest, The Great Terror: A Reassessment (1990)
  • Peter Whitewood, The Red Army and the Great Terror: Stalin’s Purge of the Soviet Military (2015)
  • Roger R. Reese, Stalin’s Reluctant Soldiers: A Social History of the Red Army, 1925-1941 (1996)
  • Oleg V. Khlevniuk, Stalin: New Biography of a Dictator (2015)
  • Felix Chuev, Molotov Remembers: Inside Kremlin Politics (1993)

Same day, other years

1898

Aguinaldo declares Philippine independence

Kawit, Cavite, PhilippinesAsia

From the window of his family house in Kawit, south of Manila, the revolutionary general Emilio Aguinaldo had the independence of the Philippines proclaimed on the afternoon of 12 June 1898. A new flag was unfurled and a march that became the national anthem was played by a town band. The declaration, read by the lawyer Ambrosio Rianzares Bautista, ended more than three centuries of Spanish rule on paper. Aguinaldo had returned from exile a month earlier aboard an American ship, after Commodore Dewey destroyed the Spanish squadron in Manila Bay, and his forces had since taken most of Luzon outside the capital.

Seen from elsewhere. Neither Spain nor the United States recognised it. Washington bought the islands from Spain for 20 million dollars that December and fought a war against Aguinaldo’s republic in which several hundred thousand Filipinos died, mostly civilians. Aguinaldo’s own adviser Apolinario Mabini thought the declaration premature and objected that it placed the country under American protection.

1963

Medgar Evers is shot in his driveway

Jackson, Mississippi, United StatesThe Americas

Medgar Evers, a thirty-seven-year-old army veteran, was the Mississippi field secretary of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People. He had investigated lynchings, organised boycotts of white-owned shops in Jackson and helped James Meredith enter the state university. Just after midnight on 12 June 1963, hours after President Kennedy’s televised address calling civil rights a moral issue, he got out of his car at home carrying a bundle of T-shirts and was hit in the back by a rifle bullet fired from a thicket across the road. He died within the hour. His wife Myrlie and their three children were in the house. He was buried at Arlington National Cemetery.

Seen from elsewhere. The rifle belonged to Byron De La Beckwith, a fertiliser salesman and member of the segregationist Citizens’ Council. Two all-white juries failed to agree in 1964; a former governor shook his hand in the courtroom, and a state agency quietly helped the defence vet jurors. He was convicted of the murder in 1994.

1964

Mandela is sentenced to life imprisonment

Pretoria, South AfricaAfrica

In the Palace of Justice in Pretoria, Judge Quartus de Wet sentenced Nelson Mandela and seven others to life imprisonment for sabotage. Most had been arrested the previous July at Liliesleaf farm in Rivonia, the hidden headquarters of Umkhonto we Sizwe, the armed wing of the African National Congress. The accused had expected to hang. In April Mandela had told the court, in a four-hour statement from the dock, that a democratic and free society was an ideal for which he was prepared to die. The seven Black and Indian prisoners, among them Walter Sisulu, Govan Mbeki and Ahmed Kathrada, were flown to Robben Island that night. Denis Goldberg, who was white, was held in Pretoria.

Seen from elsewhere. The prosecutor, Percy Yutar, presented the case as a Communist-directed plan for guerrilla war and foreign invasion, and the United States and Britain long treated the ANC as a terrorist organisation. Mandela admitted sabotage and argued that fifty years of peaceful protest had met only bans and bullets. He was released in February 1990.

1993

Nigeria votes, and the generals cancel the result

NigeriaAfrica

After ten years of military rule, Nigerians went to the polls on 12 June 1993 to choose a civilian president from the two parties the regime had permitted. Observers judged the vote the freest and calmest in the country’s history. Unofficial tallies showed a clear win for Moshood Abiola, a Yoruba Muslim businessman from the south-west, who drew support across the usual regional and religious lines. On 23 June the head of state, General Ibrahim Babangida, annulled the election before the final figures were announced. Strikes and riots followed. Babangida stepped aside in August, and in November General Sani Abacha took power. Abiola was arrested in 1994 and died in detention in July 1998.

Seen from elsewhere. Babangida spoke at the time of court challenges, vote-buying and threats to national security, and many believed northern officers would not accept a southern president. In a memoir published in 2025 he acknowledged that Abiola had won. Since 2018 Nigeria has kept 12 June as Democracy Day.

Also on 12 June