Parallax

19 June, 1867

An emperor is shot on the Hill of the Bells

A Habsburg archduke who had come to Mexico to rule as a liberal monarch died in front of a republican firing squad, between two Mexican generals who had stayed with him to the end.

Queretaro, Mexico

Early on 19 June 1867 three carriages left the Capuchin convent in Queretaro, where the prisoners had been held, and drove through lines of republican infantry to the Cerro de las Campanas, a stony rise on the edge of town. In them were Ferdinand Maximilian of Habsburg, thirty-four years old, brother of the Emperor of Austria and for three years Emperor of Mexico, and his generals Miguel Miramon and Tomas Mejia. Miramon had been a conservative president of Mexico at twenty-seven. Mejia was an Otomi from the Sierra Gorda whose mountain villages had followed him through twenty years of civil war.

Maximilian had been captured on 15 May after a siege of seventy-one days, when a colonel of his own guard, Miguel Lopez, let republican troops into the convent of La Cruz at night. He was tried by a court martial of young officers sitting on the stage of the town’s theatre, under a law of 1862 that prescribed death for anyone aiding foreign intervention. He declined to attend. His lawyers argued that a military court was not competent to try him and that a sovereign who had been recognised by most of Europe could not be a common usurper. The sentence was death for all three.

Appeals reached President Benito Juarez at San Luis Potosi from the governments of Europe, from the United States, from Victor Hugo and from Garibaldi. Princess Agnes Salm-Salm, the American wife of one of Maximilian’s officers, went down on her knees to him. Miramon’s wife came with her children. Juarez granted a delay of three days and nothing more.

On the hill, according to the accounts of those present, Maximilian embraced his companions and gave Miramon the place of honour in the centre. He handed each man in the firing party a gold coin and asked them to aim at his chest. He said, in Spanish, that he forgave everyone and asked everyone’s forgiveness, hoped his blood would be the last shed for the good of the country, and ended with a cheer for Mexico. Mejia, ill and holding a crucifix, said little. The volley was fired shortly after seven.

The body was embalmed, poorly, and kept for months while the two governments argued about its return. An Austrian admiral finally took it home on the Novara, the same frigate that had carried Maximilian to Veracruz in 1864, and he was buried in the Habsburg vault in Vienna in January 1868. In Paris Edouard Manet painted the scene several times. The censors would not let the pictures be shown.

How it came to this

Mexico had fought a three-year civil war, ending in 1861, between liberals who wanted to break the economic power of the Church and the army and conservatives who defended both. The victorious government of Juarez, bankrupt, suspended payments on its foreign debt. France, Britain and Spain sent ships to Veracruz to collect. The British and Spanish soon left. Napoleon III stayed, intending to plant a friendly Catholic monarchy on the American mainland while the United States was occupied with its own civil war. His army was beaten at Puebla on 5 May 1862 but took Mexico City the next year.

Mexican conservative exiles then offered a crown to Maximilian, who accepted in April 1864 after being shown a plebiscite in his favour collected under French bayonets. He and his wife Charlotte of Belgium, known in Mexico as Carlota, turned out to be liberals: he confirmed the sale of Church lands and freedom of worship, which lost him the clergy without winning over the republicans. When the American Civil War ended, Washington pressed France to leave. The last French troops sailed in March 1867.

How each side saw it

Juarez and the republicans

For Juarez, a Zapotec lawyer from Oaxaca who had carried the constitutional government around northern Mexico in a black carriage for four years, Maximilian was the instrument of a foreign invasion that had cost tens of thousands of Mexican lives. Republicans pointed above all to the decree Maximilian signed on 3 October 1865, ordering that members of armed bands be shot within twenty-four hours of capture, under which the republican generals Arteaga and Salazar were executed. Pardon, they argued, would invite the next European adventurer. Entering the capital in July, Juarez declared that between individuals as between nations, respect for the rights of others is peace.

Mexican conservatives and the Church

The men who had gone to Miramar to offer the crown, among them Jose Maria Gutierrez de Estrada, believed that only a Catholic prince could end half a century of coups and protect Mexico from absorption by the United States, which had taken half its territory in 1848. Many were dismayed when their emperor kept the liberal Reform laws, and the papal nuncio left in anger. The historian Erika Pani has argued that the empire should be seen as a Mexican political project with deep local roots and thousands of Mexican officials, not simply as a French imposition.

Indigenous communities

Support for the empire among Indigenous villages was wider than later national history allowed. Liberal law had ordered the break-up of communal lands, and some communities saw a distant monarch as a better guarantor of them, in the manner of the Spanish Crown. Maximilian issued decrees in Nahuatl as well as Spanish, set up a board to hear the complaints of the poor, and in 1865 limited working hours and debt servitude on estates. Mejia’s following in the Sierra Gorda was of this kind. These communities left petitions in the archives but few narratives of their own.

The courts of Europe

Franz Joseph had obliged his brother to renounce his rights to the Austrian succession before leaving, and restored them only when it was too late to matter. European monarchs saw a crowned head shot by a republic and were horrified; liberals such as Hugo asked for mercy on the ground that a republic should show itself better than kings. Blame fell chiefly on Napoleon III, who had made the throne and then withdrawn the army that held it up. Carlota, who had gone to Europe to plead with him and with the Pope, suffered a mental collapse and lived secluded until 1927.

What is disputed

Lopez insisted to the end of his life that he had opened the convent on Maximilian’s instructions to negotiate, not as a traitor; most historians doubt it but the question is open. How far Maximilian was the author of the October decree, which the French marshal Bazaine pressed on him after a false report that Juarez had left Mexican soil, is argued, as is the number shot under it. His last words survive in several versions written down afterwards. Whether Juarez could have pardoned him without losing his own generals, who wanted the execution, remains a matter of judgement.

What followed

The victory is known in Mexico as the Restored Republic, and it ended for good the idea of a Mexican monarchy and the conservative party that had sponsored it. Juarez governed until his death in 1872; one of his generals, Porfirio Diaz, then ruled for three decades. The battle of Puebla is still celebrated on 5 May. For Napoleon III the Mexican failure was a blow to prestige from which his regime did not recover before it fell in 1870. A chapel paid for by Austria stands on the hill.

Read further

  • Edward Shawcross, The Last Emperor of Mexico (2021)
  • M. M. McAllen, Maximilian and Carlota: Europe’s Last Empire in Mexico (2014)
  • Erika Pani, Para mexicanizar el Segundo Imperio (2001)
  • Brian Hamnett, Juarez (1994)
  • Samuel Basch, Erinnerungen aus Mexico (1868)

Same day, other years

1816

Metis and Hudson’s Bay men clash at Seven Oaks

Red River, present-day Winnipeg, CanadaThe Americas

The Red River Colony had been planted by Lord Selkirk and the Hudson’s Bay Company across the supply routes of the rival North West Company and of the Metis buffalo hunters, people of mixed Indigenous and European descent who provisioned it. In 1814 the colony’s governor banned the export of pemmican. On 19 June 1816 a mounted party of about sixty Metis led by Cuthbert Grant, carrying pemmican past the settlement, was confronted on foot by Governor Robert Semple and some two dozen men. In a few minutes of firing Semple and twenty of his party were killed. One Metis died.

Seen from elsewhere. The company and the settlers called it a massacre. A royal commissioner, William Coltman, concluded that Semple’s side had almost certainly fired first. The Metis remember the day as the victory of la Grenouillere, celebrated in a song by Pierre Falcon, and as the moment they first acted as a nation under their own flag.

1865

Freedom is announced in Texas

Galveston, TexasThe Americas

Two and a half years after Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation, and two months after Lee’s surrender, Union general Gordon Granger landed at Galveston and issued General Order No. 3, informing the people of Texas that all slaves were free. About a quarter of a million people were held in bondage in the state, many of them brought there during the war by owners fleeing Union armies. The order spoke of an absolute equality of personal rights between former masters and slaves. It also advised the freed to stay where they were and work for wages. The anniversary, Juneteenth, became a federal holiday in 2021.

Seen from elsewhere. Many planters kept the news back until the harvest was in, and freedpeople who left were in some places whipped or killed. Slavery remained legal in Delaware and Kentucky until the Thirteenth Amendment was ratified in December 1865. The tale of a messenger murdered on the road to Texas is folklore.

1913

The Natives Land Act comes into force

South AfricaAfrica

Three years after the Union of South Africa was formed, its all-white parliament passed a law forbidding Africans, more than two-thirds of the population, to buy or rent land outside scheduled reserves that made up about seven per cent of the country. It also outlawed sharecropping on white-owned farms, which in the Orange Free State put thousands of families and their cattle on the roads in midwinter. Sol Plaatje, secretary of the newly founded South African Native National Congress, rode out to record what he saw. The African, he wrote, awoke to find himself ‘not actually a slave, but a pariah in the land of his birth’.

Seen from elsewhere. Ministers presented the act as a temporary, even-handed separation that also barred whites from the reserves. White farmers wanted labourers, not tenants or competitors. Historians such as Harvey Feinberg note that conquest had taken most of the land already and that enforcement was patchy, but 1913 remains the legal starting date for South African land restitution claims.

1961

Kuwait becomes independent

KuwaitMiddle East

By an exchange of letters between the ruler, Sheikh Abdullah al-Salim al-Sabah, and the British political resident in the Gulf, the agreement of 1899 that had placed Kuwait’s foreign relations in British hands was ended. The small trading and pearling port had become, since oil exports began in 1946, one of the richest places on earth. Six days later the Iraqi leader Abd al-Karim Qasim announced that Kuwait was an integral part of Iraq. British troops were landed at the ruler’s request and later replaced by an Arab League force. Iraq recognised Kuwait in 1963.

Seen from elsewhere. Baghdad’s case was that Kuwait had been a district of the Ottoman province of Basra and that Britain had detached it by a secret and unlawful treaty. Kuwaitis answer that the Sabah family had governed autonomously since the eighteenth century. Saddam Hussein revived the Iraqi claim when he invaded in 1990.

Also on 19 June