Parallax

4 June, 1940

The last ship leaves Dunkirk

The Admiralty hoped to lift 45,000 men in two days. Nine days later 338,000 were across the Channel, and tens of thousands of the French soldiers who had held the line for them were marching into captivity.

Dunkirk, France

At 3.40 on the morning of 4 June 1940 the old destroyer HMS Shikari cast off from the east mole at Dunkirk with about 380 French soldiers on board. She was the last ship out. Behind her, on the mole and in the streets behind the harbour, stood a crowd of men who had come down from the perimeter in the night and found no more vessels to take them. A few hours later General Beaufrere surrendered the town. Between 35,000 and 40,000 French troops, most of the rear guard that had made the final nights possible, became prisoners.

Operation Dynamo had begun on the evening of 26 May under Vice-Admiral Bertram Ramsay, working from tunnels in the cliffs beneath Dover Castle. The British Expeditionary Force, the French First Army and the Belgians had been cut off from the rest of France when German armour reached the Channel coast. Ramsay’s staff expected the port to fall within forty-eight hours.

The docks were wrecked by bombing on the first day. The naval officer sent to run the beaches, Captain William Tennant, tried an experiment: he brought a ship alongside the east mole, a narrow breakwater of timber and concrete nearly a mile long that had never been meant for berthing. It held. About two-thirds of all the men rescued walked out along that walkway, under air attack, onto destroyers, cross-Channel ferries and minesweepers. The rest waded out from ten miles of open beach, where queues stood for hours up to their shoulders in water and small craft ferried them to ships waiting offshore.

Those small craft are what Britain remembers. Several hundred private boats, Thames pleasure steamers, lifeboats, cockle boats and Dutch coasters were gathered, most of them crewed by naval ratings and some by their owners. They mattered chiefly as ferries in the shallows. Six British and three French destroyers were sunk, and more than two hundred vessels in all. On 29 May alone the navy lost so many destroyers that the Admiralty briefly withdrew its modern ones.

In all 338,226 men were landed in England, roughly 198,000 British and 140,000 French and Belgian. They left behind almost every gun, tank and lorry the army possessed. That afternoon Churchill told the House of Commons that wars are not won by evacuations, and went on to say that Britain would fight on the beaches and never surrender.

How it came to this

On 10 May 1940 Germany attacked the Netherlands, Belgium and France. The best Allied armies, including the British force of about 400,000 under Lord Gort, advanced into Belgium to meet what they took to be the main blow. It was a feint. Seven panzer divisions came through the Ardennes forest, crossed the Meuse at Sedan on 13 May and drove west behind them, reaching the sea near Abbeville a week later. The northern armies were now in a pocket with their backs to the coast.

A planned counter-attack to break out southward came to little. On 25 May Gort decided on his own authority to abandon it and fall back on Dunkirk, the one port still open. The day before, the German armour had been halted on the canal line a few miles from the town on an order confirmed by Hitler, and it stayed halted for nearly three days. On 28 May the Belgian army, which held the eastern side of the pocket, laid down its arms after eighteen days of fighting.

How each side saw it

The French

French commanders learned late that the British were leaving, and for the first days British ships took almost only British troops. General Weygand and Admiral Abrial, who commanded at Dunkirk, protested bitterly. Churchill promised in Paris on 31 May that the two armies would leave arm in arm, and from then French numbers rose sharply. But the last line was French, and so were the men left on the mole. Vichy propaganda later made much of the claim that England fights to the last Frenchman. French historians also stress the six days that the encircled First Army held seven German divisions at Lille.

The German command

General Halder’s diary records the army staff’s fury at the halt order of 24 May, which he blamed on Hitler’s nerves. Rundstedt, who first proposed the pause, wanted to rest worn tanks for the coming battle in the south and thought the marshy ground unsuitable; Goering had promised that the Luftwaffe would finish the pocket alone. After the war some generals said Hitler had let the British go to ease a peace. Most historians, following Karl-Heinz Frieser, see a military misjudgement and a wish to assert authority over his generals, not a gift.

The Belgians

King Leopold III’s capitulation was denounced at once by the French prime minister Paul Reynaud as a betrayal without warning, and Churchill echoed him in milder terms. The Belgian case, set out by the king’s defenders and accepted by many later historians, is that London had been told the army was at the end of its strength, that the British were already withdrawing to the coast without informing the Belgians, and that eighteen days of resistance had shielded the very flank through which the evacuation ran. The dispute fed the crisis that cost Leopold his throne in 1951.

What is disputed

The motive for the halt order remains the main argument. The weight given to the little ships is another: they carried only a small fraction of the men directly, and the image of a civilian armada owes much to J. B. Priestley’s broadcast of 5 June. Aircraft losses are contested, with the RAF’s contemporary claims far above the roughly 130 to 160 German aircraft now accepted, against its own loss of about 145 to 177. Soldiers on the beaches believed the RAF had stayed away; much of the air fighting took place inland and out of sight.

What followed

The men brought home were the trained core around which Britain rebuilt its army, and their return made it politically possible for Churchill’s cabinet to refuse negotiation. Most of the French soldiers were shipped back to France within a week and were captured when the country fell on 22 June. Another 190,000 Allied troops were taken off from western ports later in the month. During the retreat SS units murdered about 180 British prisoners at Le Paradis and Wormhoudt. In Britain ‘Dunkirk spirit’ became a lasting phrase for cheerfulness in defeat; in France the word still carries a note of abandonment.

Read further

  • Hugh Sebag-Montefiore, Dunkirk: Fight to the Last Man (2006)
  • Walter Lord, The Miracle of Dunkirk (1982)
  • Karl-Heinz Frieser, The Blitzkrieg Legend: The 1940 Campaign in the West (2005)
  • Marc Bloch, Strange Defeat (1946)
  • Julian Thompson, Dunkirk: Retreat to Victory (2008)

Same day, other years

1913

Emily Davison steps in front of the King’s horse

Epsom, EnglandEurope

Emily Wilding Davison was a 40-year-old graduate and a militant of the Women’s Social and Political Union who had been imprisoned nine times and force-fed dozens of times. On Derby Day, 4 June 1913, she ducked under the rail at Tattenham Corner as the field came round and stood in the path of Anmer, the horse owned by George V. Horse, jockey and woman went down, and a newsreel camera recorded it. The jockey, Herbert Jones, recovered. Davison died of a fractured skull four days later without regaining consciousness. Thousands of suffragettes in white escorted her coffin through London.

Seen from elsewhere. Whether she meant to die is unresolved. She carried a return rail ticket and two suffragette flags, and analysis of the film suggests she reached for the bridle, perhaps to attach one. At the time much of the press, and the royal household, treated her as a dangerous fanatic and reserved its sympathy for the jockey and horse.

1920

Hungary signs the Treaty of Trianon

Versailles, FranceEurope

In the Grand Trianon palace on 4 June 1920, two Hungarian delegates of no great rank signed the peace that the victors of the First World War had drawn up for their country. The old Kingdom of Hungary lost about two-thirds of its territory and more than half its population to Romania, Czechoslovakia, the new Yugoslav kingdom and Austria. Most of those transferred were Romanians, Slovaks, Serbs, Croats and others who had been minorities under Hungarian rule, but more than three million ethnic Hungarians also found themselves in foreign states, many living just beyond the new borders. Church bells tolled in Budapest and shops closed.

Seen from elsewhere. For Hungarians it is the central national injury, marked since 2010 as a Day of National Cohesion. For Romanians, Slovaks and South Slavs the treaty recognised self-determination after decades of enforced Magyarisation, and Romania made 4 June a commemorative day in 2020. The peacemakers refused plebiscites almost everywhere.

1979

Jerry Rawlings takes power in Ghana

Accra, GhanaAfrica

Flight Lieutenant Jerry John Rawlings, 31, was on trial for his life after a failed mutiny in May 1979, and had used the dock to denounce the corruption of Ghana’s military rulers. Before dawn on 4 June junior officers and soldiers freed him from his cell and seized the broadcasting station. The Armed Forces Revolutionary Council that he led promised a ‘house-cleaning’. Within weeks eight senior officers, among them three former heads of state, had been shot by firing squad on a beach range after secret trials. The council handed over to an elected civilian president in September. Rawlings overthrew him too in 1981 and governed, latterly as an elected president, until 2001.

Seen from elsewhere. Admirers saw a necessary purge of men who had ruined a rich country. Ghana’s National Reconciliation Commission, sitting in 2002-04, heard from families of the executed and from traders who had been flogged or had goods and markets destroyed. Rawlings conceded that there had been excesses and continued to defend the uprising.

1989

The army clears Tiananmen Square

Beijing, ChinaAsia

For seven weeks students, joined by workers and Beijing residents, had occupied the square at the centre of the capital, calling for a free press, dialogue with the leadership and an end to official corruption. Martial law was declared on 20 May, but crowds blocked the first troops. On the night of 3 June armoured columns forced their way in from the western suburbs, firing on people in the avenues, above all at Muxidi. By dawn on 4 June the remaining students had negotiated their way out of the square. Most of the dead were ordinary citizens killed on the approach roads. Arrests, executions of workers and a purge of the party followed.

Seen from elsewhere. The government called the events a counter-revolutionary riot and gave a toll of 200 to 300, soldiers included; diplomatic and Red Cross estimates ran from several hundred to several thousand, and a group of bereaved parents, the Tiananmen Mothers, has documented over 200 named victims. Officials argue that the decision secured the stability behind China’s later growth. Public mention is censored.

Also on 4 June