Parallax

11 June, 1292

Roger Bacon is buried at Oxford

A quarrelsome Franciscan who told a pope that Christendom was neglecting mathematics, languages and experiment went to his grave almost unnoticed. Later ages turned him first into a wizard and then into a martyr of science, and he was probably neither.

Greyfriars, Oxford, England

The only record of Roger Bacon’s end is a note by the fifteenth-century antiquary John Rous, who says he was buried among the Franciscans at Oxford on the feast of St Barnabas, 11 June, in 1292. He would then have been in his seventies. The friary has gone, the grave is lost, and no contemporary thought the event worth a line.

The life behind it turned on one letter. In June 1266 Pope Clement IV wrote to Bacon, whom he had heard of years earlier as Cardinal Guy de Foulques, ordering him to send, secretly and without regard to any rule of his order, the writings on the reform of learning that he understood Bacon to have completed. There were no such writings. Bacon, a Paris master of arts who had joined the Franciscans about a decade earlier, had ideas, grievances and no finished book. His order had forbidden friars since 1260 to publish anything without their superiors’ approval.

He set to work in a hurry. He complained afterwards that he had no money for parchment or copyists, that his superiors kept him at other duties, and that he had to beg from friends. In roughly eighteen months he nevertheless produced three long treatises, the Opus Majus, the Opus Minus and the Opus Tertium, and sent the first to Italy with a favourite pupil named John, together with a lens.

The Opus Majus is a plea for funds and a programme. It opens with the causes of human error: trust in unworthy authority, custom, popular opinion, and the hiding of ignorance behind a show of wisdom. It then argues that theologians cannot read Scripture properly without Greek and Hebrew, that mathematics is the gateway to every science, that the Julian calendar had drifted and should be corrected, and that claims about nature must be tested by what he called experimental science. The long section on optics draws heavily on the Iraqi scholar Ibn al-Haytham.

Clement died in November 1268. There is no sign that he read any of it. Bacon went on writing, with rising bitterness about the Paris theologians. A Franciscan chronicle compiled a century later says that around 1278 the head of the order condemned his teaching for ‘certain suspected novelties’ and had him confined. For how long is unknown. He was free and at Oxford by 1292, when he began one last unfinished compendium of theology, still attacking the errors of his age.

How it came to this

In the first half of the thirteenth century the Latin West was absorbing a flood of new texts: Aristotle’s works on nature, with the commentaries of Ibn Rushd and Ibn Sina, and Arabic treatises on mathematics, medicine, astronomy and optics, translated in Spain and Sicily. The new universities at Paris and Oxford had to decide what a Christian scholar should do with pagan and Muslim learning. Paris banned lectures on Aristotle’s natural philosophy for a time; by the 1240s Bacon was one of the first to teach it there.

At Oxford he came under the influence of Robert Grosseteste, bishop of Lincoln, who had written on light and insisted on the value of mathematics and Greek. Bacon was born into a family of some means, traditionally at Ilchester in Somerset, some time between about 1214 and 1220, and says he spent a great deal of his own money on books, instruments and tables. The Franciscan order he joined was itself divided over poverty and prophecy, and its minister general, Bonaventure, distrusted astrology and alchemy, both of which Bacon defended as useful.

How each side saw it

The Franciscan order

The friars’ own record is a single sentence in the Chronicle of the Twenty-Four Generals, written about 1370. It says that the minister general Jerome of Ascoli, later Pope Nicholas IV, on the advice of many brothers, condemned the teaching of Brother Roger Bacon, master of sacred theology, as containing suspected novelties, and ordered his imprisonment. It names no doctrine. From the order’s side the difficulty may have been discipline as much as ideas: Bacon had abused eminent friars by name in his writings, championed astrology at a moment when Paris was condemning it in 1277, and perhaps sympathised with the radical wing that preached strict poverty.

The Enlightenment and Victorian tradition

From the sixteenth century English popular culture knew ‘Friar Bacon’ as a magician who built a talking head of brass, the subject of a play by Robert Greene. Later writers reversed the image. To eighteenth and nineteenth-century admirers he was a modern mind born too early: inventor of gunpowder, spectacles and the telescope, prophet of flying machines and powered ships, founder of the experimental method, and victim of a Church afraid of knowledge. This is the Bacon of school histories and of the book tradition that gives him a decade or more in a dark cell. It rests on very little that he or his contemporaries actually wrote.

Historians of Arabic science

Scholars who work on the Islamic world point out how much of Bacon’s reputation for originality belongs to others. His optics is an exposition of Ibn al-Haytham’s Book of Optics, composed in Cairo two and a half centuries earlier, together with al-Kindi and Ptolemy. His account of an explosive powder describes a toy already known in China and reached him through sources he does not name. His case for studying Arabic was partly practical: the texts were better. Bacon himself was open about this debt and said plainly that the Latins had nothing of value in philosophy that did not come from other tongues.

Modern medievalists

Recent scholars such as David Lindberg, Jeremiah Hackett and Amanda Power read Bacon as a man of his century. His ‘experimental science’ included personal experience, craft knowledge and even divine illumination, and it was meant to confirm conclusions rather than to test hypotheses in the modern way. He believed in the influence of the stars and in alchemical prolongation of life. Above all, his purpose was religious: learning was to be reformed so that Christendom could convert unbelievers and withstand the Antichrist, whose arrival he thought close. On this view he was an unusually energetic critic within medieval scholarship and not a scientist stranded in the wrong age.

What is disputed

Almost every date in Bacon’s life is conjecture. His birth is put anywhere from 1214 to 1220, and his death in 1292 or 1294; the day, 11 June, depends on John Rous, writing two centuries later. The imprisonment is attested by one late source, and some historians doubt it happened at all or think it amounted to house arrest. The supposed gunpowder formula hidden in an anagram was ‘found’ in 1904 in a letter whose relevant chapters may not be his. He described magnifying lenses but did not make a telescope. The title Doctor Mirabilis was given after his death.

What followed

Bacon’s works circulated in manuscript and his optics was read in universities for three centuries, alongside those of John Pecham and Witelo. The calendar reform he urged was carried out by Pope Gregory XIII in 1582, with no acknowledgement. The Opus Majus was first printed in 1733. Since then each age has made its own Bacon: the sorcerer, the Protestant hero persecuted by Rome, the forerunner of his namesake Francis Bacon, and for a time the supposed author of the undeciphered Voynich manuscript, which radiocarbon dating has since placed in the fifteenth century. The argument about how far medieval learning prepared the way for modern science still often begins with him.

Read further

  • Roger Bacon, The Opus Majus of Roger Bacon, translated by Robert Belle Burke (1928)
  • Jeremiah Hackett (ed.), Roger Bacon and the Sciences: Commemorative Essays (1997)
  • Amanda Power, Roger Bacon and the Defence of Christendom (2013)
  • David C. Lindberg, Roger Bacon’s Philosophy of Nature (1983)
  • Brian Clegg, The First Scientist: A Life of Roger Bacon (2003)

Same day, other years

1770

The Endeavour strikes the Great Barrier Reef

Endeavour Reef, off north-east AustraliaOceania

Shortly before eleven at night, by the ship’s reckoning of 11 June, HMS Endeavour ran onto coral while James Cook was feeling his way north inside a reef he did not know was there. The crew threw overboard some forty to fifty tons of guns, ballast and stores, and floated her off on the next night’s tide with the pumps barely keeping pace. A midshipman, Jonathan Monkhouse, directed the hauling of a sail packed with wool and oakum under the hull to plug the hole. Cook beached the ship at a river mouth, the site of modern Cooktown, and spent seven weeks on repairs. It was the longest stay of the voyage on Australian soil.

Seen from elsewhere. The river was Waalumbaal Birri, country of the Guugu Yimithirr, whose word ‘gangurru’ the visitors wrote down as kangaroo. Their oral history, like Cook’s journal, records a quarrel when the crew refused to share turtles they had taken, and an elder who came forward to make peace. Weeks later Cook claimed the whole coast for George III.

1898

The Guangxu Emperor begins a hundred days of reform

Beijing, ChinaAsia

Three years after Japan’s victory had exposed the weakness of the Qing state, the twenty-six-year-old Guangxu Emperor issued an edict on 11 June 1898 declaring reform to be national policy. Over the following weeks, advised by the scholar Kang Youwei and his pupil Liang Qichao, he sent out dozens of decrees: an imperial university in the capital, modern schools, an end to the formal ‘eight-legged’ examination essay, a reorganised army, railways, and the abolition of idle offices. On 21 September his aunt, the Empress Dowager Cixi, resumed power. The emperor was confined to an island in the palace lakes, and six reformers, including Tan Sitong, were beheaded. Kang and Liang escaped abroad.

Seen from elsewhere. The familiar story, written by Kang and Liang in exile, casts Cixi as the enemy of all change. Later historians, among them Luke Kwong, argue that Kang inflated his own role, that Cixi did not at first oppose the programme, and that she struck after hearing of a plan to seize her. She adopted many of the same reforms after 1901.

1903

Serbian officers murder their king and queen

Belgrade, SerbiaEurope

In the night of 10-11 June 1903 (28-29 May by the calendar then used in Serbia) a group of army officers broke into the royal palace in Belgrade, blowing in a door with dynamite. After a two-hour search they found King Alexander Obrenovic and Queen Draga hiding in a small room behind their bedchamber, shot them many times, mutilated the bodies with sabres and threw them from a window into the garden. The prime minister, the war minister and the queen’s two brothers were also killed. Among the organisers was a young captain, Dragutin Dimitrijevic, known as Apis. Parliament offered the throne to Peter Karadjordjevic, head of the rival dynasty.

Seen from elsewhere. The plotters, and much of Serbian opinion, held that they had rid the country of a king who had twice overturned the constitution, leaned on Austria and married a widely disliked commoner. Abroad the butchery caused revulsion; Britain withdrew its minister for three years. Apis went on to lead the Black Hand, which armed the Sarajevo assassins of 1914.

1963

A monk burns himself to death in Saigon

Saigon, South VietnamAsia

On the morning of 11 June a procession of some 350 Buddhist monks and nuns stopped at a busy junction near the Cambodian legation. Thich Quang Duc, a monk in his sixties, got out of a car, sat down in the lotus position on a cushion, and was doused with petrol by a younger monk. He struck a match himself and burned without moving or crying out. The protest was aimed at the government of President Ngo Dinh Diem, a Catholic, whose forces had shot dead nine people in Hue a month earlier during a demonstration against a ban on flying the Buddhist flag. Malcolm Browne’s photographs were on front pages around the world next day.

Seen from elsewhere. The Diem government said the monk had been drugged and used by Communists; the president’s sister-in-law, Madame Nhu, spoke of a ‘barbecue’. Buddhists rejected the word suicide. Thich Nhat Hanh wrote to Martin Luther King that it was an act of the highest courage meant to move hearts. Diem was overthrown and killed in November.

Also on 11 June