On the morning of Wednesday 22 June 1633, Galileo Galilei was brought to the convent of Santa Maria sopra Minerva, where the cardinals of the Holy Office met. He was sixty-nine, the most famous natural philosopher in Europe and mathematician to the Grand Duke of Tuscany. He wore the white shirt of a penitent and knelt while the sentence was read to him.
It declared him ‘vehemently suspected of heresy’, the second most serious finding available to the tribunal, for having held that the sun is the centre of the world and does not move, that the earth moves and is not the centre, and that an opinion may be defended as probable after it has been declared contrary to Holy Scripture. His Dialogue on the Two Chief World Systems was banned. He was condemned to imprisonment at the pleasure of the Holy Office and to recite the seven penitential psalms once a week for three years. Seven of the ten cardinal inquisitors signed. Three, including the pope’s nephew Francesco Barberini, did not.
Then, still on his knees and with his hand on the Gospels, he read the formula of abjuration put before him. He swore that with a sincere heart he abjured, cursed and detested the errors named, and that he would denounce to the Holy Office anyone he found suspected of heresy.
It was the end of a process that had begun the previous autumn, when Pope Urban VIII ordered him to Rome despite doctors’ certificates that he was too ill to travel. He arrived in February and lodged with the Tuscan ambassador. Questioned in April, he claimed that his book had in fact shown the weakness of the Copernican case, a defence no reader of it could believe. The tribunal’s commissary, Vincenzo Maculano, then spoke to him privately and brought him to admit that he had, out of vanity, made the arguments for the earth’s motion too strong. On 21 June he was asked under formal threat of torture what he really held. He answered that since the Church’s ruling of 1616 he had not held the Copernican opinion, and that he was in their hands.
He was never put in a cell. The sentence was commuted next day to confinement at the Tuscan embassy, then at the palace of the Archbishop of Siena, a friend, and from December at his own small villa at Arcetri outside Florence. His daughter, the nun Suor Maria Celeste, took over the recitation of the psalms. She died four months after he came home.
How it came to this
In 1610 Galileo’s telescope had shown mountains on the moon, four moons circling Jupiter and the phases of Venus, the last of which was incompatible with the ancient system of Ptolemy. He came to argue openly that Copernicus was right and the earth goes round the sun. In 1616 the Church’s consultors declared that proposition formally heretical as contrary to Scripture, Copernicus’s book was suspended pending correction, and Cardinal Robert Bellarmine was sent to tell Galileo to abandon the opinion. Exactly what he was told became the centre of the trial.
In 1623 his admirer Maffeo Barberini became Pope Urban VIII and received him six times. Galileo understood that he might write about the two systems provided he treated the earth’s motion as a hypothesis. The Dialogue, published in Florence in February 1632 with a licence from the Church’s censors, was not that: it was a brilliant argument for Copernicus in Italian, and it placed the pope’s own favourite objection, that God could produce the appearances in ways beyond human understanding, in the mouth of a slow-witted character named Simplicio.