Parallax

22 June, 1633

Galileo kneels before the Inquisition

In a Dominican convent in Rome, an old man in a penitent’s shirt swore that he had never believed what he had spent twenty years demonstrating. The Church took 359 years to say that the judges had been wrong.

Rome

On the morning of Wednesday 22 June 1633, Galileo Galilei was brought to the convent of Santa Maria sopra Minerva, where the cardinals of the Holy Office met. He was sixty-nine, the most famous natural philosopher in Europe and mathematician to the Grand Duke of Tuscany. He wore the white shirt of a penitent and knelt while the sentence was read to him.

It declared him ‘vehemently suspected of heresy’, the second most serious finding available to the tribunal, for having held that the sun is the centre of the world and does not move, that the earth moves and is not the centre, and that an opinion may be defended as probable after it has been declared contrary to Holy Scripture. His Dialogue on the Two Chief World Systems was banned. He was condemned to imprisonment at the pleasure of the Holy Office and to recite the seven penitential psalms once a week for three years. Seven of the ten cardinal inquisitors signed. Three, including the pope’s nephew Francesco Barberini, did not.

Then, still on his knees and with his hand on the Gospels, he read the formula of abjuration put before him. He swore that with a sincere heart he abjured, cursed and detested the errors named, and that he would denounce to the Holy Office anyone he found suspected of heresy.

It was the end of a process that had begun the previous autumn, when Pope Urban VIII ordered him to Rome despite doctors’ certificates that he was too ill to travel. He arrived in February and lodged with the Tuscan ambassador. Questioned in April, he claimed that his book had in fact shown the weakness of the Copernican case, a defence no reader of it could believe. The tribunal’s commissary, Vincenzo Maculano, then spoke to him privately and brought him to admit that he had, out of vanity, made the arguments for the earth’s motion too strong. On 21 June he was asked under formal threat of torture what he really held. He answered that since the Church’s ruling of 1616 he had not held the Copernican opinion, and that he was in their hands.

He was never put in a cell. The sentence was commuted next day to confinement at the Tuscan embassy, then at the palace of the Archbishop of Siena, a friend, and from December at his own small villa at Arcetri outside Florence. His daughter, the nun Suor Maria Celeste, took over the recitation of the psalms. She died four months after he came home.

How it came to this

In 1610 Galileo’s telescope had shown mountains on the moon, four moons circling Jupiter and the phases of Venus, the last of which was incompatible with the ancient system of Ptolemy. He came to argue openly that Copernicus was right and the earth goes round the sun. In 1616 the Church’s consultors declared that proposition formally heretical as contrary to Scripture, Copernicus’s book was suspended pending correction, and Cardinal Robert Bellarmine was sent to tell Galileo to abandon the opinion. Exactly what he was told became the centre of the trial.

In 1623 his admirer Maffeo Barberini became Pope Urban VIII and received him six times. Galileo understood that he might write about the two systems provided he treated the earth’s motion as a hypothesis. The Dialogue, published in Florence in February 1632 with a licence from the Church’s censors, was not that: it was a brilliant argument for Copernicus in Italian, and it placed the pope’s own favourite objection, that God could produce the appearances in ways beyond human understanding, in the mouth of a slow-witted character named Simplicio.

How each side saw it

Urban VIII and the Holy Office

For the tribunal the issue was obedience. Its file held a minute of 1616 recording that Galileo had been ordered not to hold, teach or defend the Copernican opinion in any way whatever, and he had not mentioned this when seeking his licence. Urban felt deceived and mocked by a man he had protected, at a moment when Spanish cardinals were accusing him in open consistory of being soft on heresy during the Thirty Years War. The judges could also say, correctly, that no proof of the earth’s motion existed in 1633: stellar parallax was not observed until 1838, and Galileo’s argument from the tides was wrong.

Galileo and his friends

Galileo produced a certificate in Bellarmine’s own hand stating only that he had been told the opinion could not be held or defended, with no ban on discussing it, and maintained that he had kept to it and had the censors’ licence. His deeper position, set out in his Letter to the Grand Duchess Christina of 1615, was that Scripture and nature cannot conflict, and that the Bible, in a phrase he borrowed from Cardinal Baronio, teaches how to go to heaven, not how the heavens go. The dispatches of the Tuscan ambassador Francesco Niccolini record the pope’s anger and the old man’s collapse in spirits.

The Jesuit astronomers

The mathematicians of the Jesuits’ Roman College had confirmed Galileo’s telescopic discoveries in 1611 and feted him. By 1633 he had quarrelled bitterly with two of the order’s leading men, Christoph Scheiner over sunspots and Orazio Grassi over comets. Most Jesuit astronomers adopted the system of Tycho Brahe, in which the planets circle the sun and the sun circles a stationary earth; it fitted every observation then possible. Galileo believed the order had engineered his downfall. One of them, Christoph Grienberger, is reported to have said that had he kept the Jesuits’ affection he could have written what he liked.

The later Church

The general prohibition on books teaching the earth’s motion was dropped from the Index in 1758, and the Dialogue itself was removed in the edition of 1835. In 1979 Pope John Paul II asked for the case to be re-examined, and in 1992 he accepted a commission’s report, saying that Galileo’s judges had failed to distinguish faith from an age-old cosmology and that the theologians, not the scientist, had misread the relation of Scripture to science. He called the affair a tragic mutual incomprehension. Critics, among them the historian Annibale Fantoli, found the commission too ready to share the blame with Galileo.

What is disputed

The 1616 minute is unsigned and irregular in form; nineteenth-century scholars led by Emil Wohlwill thought it forged, while most now accept it as a genuine but questionable record. Whether the threat of torture was real or a legal formality is debated; at his age the rules made actual torture unlikely. Pietro Redondi argued in 1983 that the hidden charge was atomism and its threat to the doctrine of the Eucharist, a thesis few accept. The muttered ‘Eppur si muove’, ‘and yet it moves’, is first recorded in 1757 and is almost certainly legend. The book that suggested this day’s story placed the sentence on 21 June; the documents date it to the 22nd.

What followed

At Arcetri, forbidden to publish, Galileo finished his greatest work, the Two New Sciences on motion and the strength of materials, which was smuggled out and printed at Leiden in 1638. By then he was blind. He died on 8 January 1642; the pope forbade a public monument. Descartes, hearing of the sentence, suppressed his own treatise on the world. The trial became the standard exhibit in the argument that religion and science are at war, a reading most historians now consider too simple and the case itself too particular to bear.

Read further

  • Maurice A. Finocchiaro, The Galileo Affair: A Documentary History (1989)
  • J. L. Heilbron, Galileo (2010)
  • Annibale Fantoli, Galileo: For Copernicanism and for the Church (1994)
  • Dava Sobel, Galileo’s Daughter (1999)
  • Mario Biagioli, Galileo, Courtier: The Practice of Science in the Culture of Absolutism (1993)

Same day, other years

217 BC

Elephants meet at Raphia

Rafah, near GazaMiddle East

Two successor kingdoms of Alexander’s empire fought for the coast between Egypt and Syria. Ptolemy IV of Egypt brought, by the count of the historian Polybius, 70,000 infantry and 73 African elephants; Antiochus III, the Seleucid king, 62,000 infantry and 102 larger elephants from India. The African animals would not face the Indian ones and Ptolemy’s left wing collapsed. Antiochus rode off in pursuit and returned to find his centre beaten by the Ptolemaic phalanx. That phalanx included, for the first time, 20,000 native Egyptians trained and armed in the Macedonian manner.

Seen from elsewhere. Polybius thought arming the Egyptians a fatal success: confident of their strength, they soon rebelled, and Upper Egypt broke away under native pharaohs for twenty years. The Egyptian priests’ decree celebrating the victory, carved in three scripts, presents Ptolemy as a traditional pharaoh smiting his foes. The date of 22 June is calculated from that decree.

1772

Lord Mansfield frees James Somerset

London, EnglandEurope

James Somerset, an African enslaved in Virginia, had been brought to England by his owner, a customs official named Charles Stewart. In 1771 he escaped, was recaptured and was chained aboard a ship in the Thames bound for Jamaica, where he was to be sold. His godparents obtained a writ of habeas corpus, and the campaigner Granville Sharp found him lawyers. After months of argument the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Mansfield, ruled that slavery was so odious that nothing could support it but positive law, that English law gave a master no power to seize a man and ship him abroad, and that Somerset must be discharged.

Seen from elsewhere. Mansfield insisted afterwards that he had decided only that narrow point, and people continued to be bought and sold in Britain for years. The ruling did not touch the colonies or the slave trade. Black Londoners who had filled the gallery celebrated it as freedom. Some historians argue that it alarmed American slaveholders and nudged them towards independence; others find little evidence.

1897

The plague commissioner of Poona is shot

Pune, IndiaAsia

Bubonic plague reached Pune late in 1896. The government of Bombay gave a special committee under an Indian Civil Service officer, Walter Charles Rand, sweeping powers, and he used British soldiers to search houses, remove the sick to segregation camps, strip and examine residents and burn belongings. On the night of 22 June 1897, as carriages left a Government House reception for Queen Victoria’s Diamond Jubilee, Damodar Chapekar and his brother Balkrishna shot Rand and, by mistake, his escort Lieutenant Charles Ayerst. Ayerst died at once and Rand eleven days later. Three Chapekar brothers and an associate were hanged.

Seen from elsewhere. Officials held that the searches were a medical necessity and that reports of soldiers insulting women and entering shrines were exaggerated. The moderate leader Gokhale repeated such charges in England and then withdrew them for want of proof. The nationalist editor Tilak, whose newspapers had attacked Rand, was jailed for sedition. India remembers the Chapekars as early revolutionary martyrs.

1941

Germany invades the Soviet Union

The Soviet western frontierEurope

Before dawn more than three million German soldiers, with Romanian, Finnish and other allied forces, attacked along a front running from the Baltic to the Black Sea. It was the largest invasion in history. Stalin had dismissed repeated warnings, from his own agents and from Churchill, as provocation, and frontier units had orders not to respond. Well over a thousand Soviet aircraft were destroyed on the first day, most on the ground. Behind the armies came killing squads with orders to shoot Jews and Communist officials. The war that began that morning cost the Soviet Union about twenty-seven million lives.

Seen from elsewhere. Berlin announced a preventive strike against a Soviet attack in preparation. The claim was revived in the 1980s by the writer Viktor Suvorov and is rejected by most specialists. In the Baltic states and western Ukraine, annexed by Stalin and hit by mass deportations only days before, some people at first welcomed the Germans. Russia marks 22 June as the Day of Remembrance and Sorrow.

Also on 22 June