Parallax

27 June, 1472

The women of Beauvais hold the wall

A Burgundian army that had just butchered a surrendered town arrived before a city with almost no soldiers in it. The townspeople shut the gates, and a young woman tore an enemy standard from the rampart.

Beauvais, Picardy, France

The Burgundian vanguard came up to Beauvais on the morning of Saturday 27 June 1472, led by Philippe de Crevecoeur, lord of Esquerdes. The city had old walls, a bishop, a prosperous cloth trade and no royal garrison, only a handful of men-at-arms who happened to be there under a captain named Louis de Balagny. Everyone inside knew what had happened at Nesle two weeks before, where the duke’s men had killed the defenders who had taken refuge in the church. Beauvais refused the summons to open.

Crevecoeur attacked at once, at two gates. At the Porte de Bresles his guns blew a hole through the gate, and for a time the Burgundians and the townsmen fought hand to hand in the gap. The defenders then did something desperate: they set the ruined gate alight and kept feeding it with faggots, so that a wall of fire blocked the way. Women and girls carried the wood, and carried arrows, powder, stones and wine to the men on the wall. The reliquary of the town’s patron, Saint Angadreme, was borne along the ramparts.

The duke, Charles the Bold, arrived with the main army in the afternoon and did not press the assault before dark. That evening the first royal troops rode in from Noyon after a forced march and went straight to the walls. More followed over the next days, until the place held several thousand professional soldiers. Charles never closed the ring. Wagons of food and munitions kept coming in by the southern roads from Paris and Rouen.

On 9 July, after a heavy bombardment, the Burgundians tried a general assault with ladders. It lasted about three hours and failed with heavy loss. It is in these assaults, on the first day by the usual telling, that a young woman of the town, Jeanne Laisne, grappled with a Burgundian who had planted his standard on the wall, threw him back and carried the flag off. The standard was hung in the church of the Dominicans.

On 22 July Charles broke camp and marched off to burn his way through Normandy. He had lost some weeks, many men and a good deal of his reputation. Posterity named the girl Jeanne Hachette, after the small axe she is said to have used.

How it came to this

The quarrel between Louis XI of France and Charles, Duke of Burgundy, was the great feud of fifteenth-century western Europe. The dukes were princes of the French royal house who had assembled, by marriage and purchase, a state running from Holland to the Alps, richer than the kingdom and only partly within it. Charles wanted a crown of his own. Louis, patient, devious and short of battlefield nerve, meant to bring every great vassal to heel. In 1468 Charles had held the king a virtual prisoner at Peronne.

In May 1472 the king’s younger brother, the Duke of Guyenne, died. He had been the figurehead of the princes’ opposition, and Charles publicly accused Louis of having him poisoned. Breaking a truce, the duke crossed the Somme in June with a large army and a fine artillery train. Nesle was stormed and its garrison slaughtered; Roye surrendered without a fight. Beauvais lay next on the road towards Normandy, where Charles hoped to join hands with the Duke of Brittany.

How each side saw it

The Burgundian camp

The best witness is Philippe de Commynes, then still the duke’s chamberlain and present at the siege. In his Memoirs he says the town could have been taken on the first day had the attack been pushed, and that it was folly to sit before it without blocking the far side. He shows Charles furious, refusing advice and blaming his captains. For Commynes the siege was a lesson in how anger ruins princes. A few weeks later he slipped away by night and entered the service of Louis XI.

Louis XI and the crown

The king made the most of it. Letters patent of 1473 thanked Beauvais, freed it from certain taxes and ordered a yearly procession in honour of Saint Angadreme in which the women were to walk ahead of the men, and allowed them to dress as they pleased whatever their rank. A further royal letter names Jeanne Laisne, daughter of Mathieu Laisne, credits her with taking a Burgundian standard, and exempts her and her husband Colin Pilon from tax for life. To the crown, the story showed loyal townspeople standing with their king against an over-mighty prince.

Later France and its historians

The nickname Hachette is not in the royal letters and appears only later, and her surname is given in some accounts as Fourquet. That she was a butcher’s daughter is tradition. In the nineteenth century some scholars doubted she existed, until the letters patent were set against them; others noted that the collective courage of the women of Beauvais, which the king honoured first, had been narrowed into one heroine to stand beside Joan of Arc. A bronze statue was raised in the main square in 1851, and the city still holds its procession each June with the women in front.

What is disputed

Which day she seized the standard is uncertain: local tradition says the first assault on 27 June, some historians the general assault of 9 July. The hatchet itself rests on the later nickname, not on any contemporary description. Her father’s trade, her age and even her family name vary between sources. Numbers are loose throughout: Burgundian strength is given as anything up to 80,000 by old writers, which modern historians cut drastically, and estimates of the duke’s losses run from a few hundred to three thousand. The charge that Louis poisoned his brother, the pretext for the campaign, has never been supported by evidence.

What followed

Charles the Bold never again came so close to breaking Louis XI. He turned east, towards Lorraine, the Rhine and the Swiss, and was killed outside Nancy in January 1477. Louis seized the duchy of Burgundy and Picardy, while the Low Countries passed by marriage to the Habsburgs, a division that set France and the house of Austria against each other for two and a half centuries. Beauvais kept its privileges and its festival. The Fetes Jeanne Hachette are still held on the last weekend of June, one of the oldest civic commemorations in France.

Read further

  • Philippe de Commynes, Memoirs: The Reign of Louis XI, translated by Michael Jones (1972)
  • Jean de Roye, Journal, known as the Chronique scandaleuse
  • Paul Murray Kendall, Louis XI: The Universal Spider (1971)
  • Richard Vaughan, Charles the Bold: The Last Valois Duke of Burgundy (1973)

Same day, other years

1844

Joseph Smith is killed by a mob

Carthage, Illinois, United StatesThe Americas

The founder of the Latter Day Saint movement was in jail awaiting trial, with his brother Hyrum and two companions, when a crowd of armed men with blackened faces rushed the building late in the afternoon. Hyrum was shot through the door and died at once. Joseph Smith emptied a small pistol that had been smuggled in to him, ran to the window and was hit several times as he fell from it. He was thirty-eight. He had been arrested after ordering, as mayor of Nauvoo, the destruction of a newspaper press that had attacked him over plural marriage.

Seen from elsewhere. To his followers it was the martyrdom of a prophet, abandoned by a governor who had promised protection. His neighbours in Hancock County feared a church that voted as a bloc, ran its own courts and commanded a private militia. Five men were tried for the killings and acquitted. Most Saints left for Utah in 1846.

1905

Mutiny on the battleship Potemkin

Black Sea, off Odessa, Russian EmpireEurope

On 14 June by the Russian calendar, 27 June in the west, the crew of the newest battleship in the Black Sea Fleet refused to eat borscht made with maggoty meat. The second-in-command threatened to shoot the ringleaders and killed a sailor named Grigory Vakulenchuk. The crew rose, killed seven officers including the captain, and ran up the red flag under a committee led by Afanasy Matyushenko. They steamed to Odessa, where a general strike was under way, and then wandered the Black Sea for eleven days before surrendering the ship to Romania.

Seen from elsewhere. The navy saw a breakdown of discipline exploited by revolutionaries. Soviet tradition made it a rehearsal for 1917, above all through Sergei Eisenstein’s 1925 film. The massacre on the Odessa steps as he staged it is invention, though troops did kill many people in the port that week, and so is the scene of sailors about to be shot under a tarpaulin.

1954

Guatemala’s elected president is forced out

Guatemala City, GuatemalaThe Americas

Jacobo Arbenz, a reforming army officer elected in 1950, resigned in a radio address on the evening of 27 June and took refuge in the Mexican embassy. Nine days earlier a few hundred exiles under Colonel Carlos Castillo Armas had crossed from Honduras, armed, trained and paid by the CIA in an operation codenamed PBSuccess. They fought little. The work was done by a fake rebel radio station, a few aircraft bombing the capital and the belief among Guatemala’s officers that the United States would invade if they resisted. Arbenz’s land reform, which had expropriated idle estates of the United Fruit Company, was reversed.

Seen from elsewhere. Washington held that Arbenz, who relied on communist advisers and had bought Czech arms, was opening a Soviet foothold. Historians differ on how much United Fruit’s lobbying counted against Cold War fear; Piero Gleijeses stresses the latter. Guatemala then endured four decades of military rule and civil war. President Clinton expressed regret in 1999.

1977

Djibouti, France’s last African mainland colony, becomes independent

DjiboutiAfrica

France had held the hot, dry coast at the mouth of the Red Sea since the 1880s, chiefly for its harbour and its railway to Addis Ababa. Long after the rest of French Africa was independent it remained the French Territory of the Afars and the Issas. In a referendum in May 1977 more than 98 per cent of those voting chose independence, and on 27 June the flag was raised over the new republic with Hassan Gouled Aptidon as president. France kept a large garrison there by agreement, and other powers have since leased bases along the same shore.

Seen from elsewhere. Earlier votes in 1958 and 1967 had favoured staying French, amid expulsions of Somalis and accusations of rigging. Many Afars feared domination by the Issa Somali majority and by neighbouring Somalia. Their grievances led to an armed rebellion between 1991 and 1994.

Also on 27 June