Parallax

21 June, 1527

Machiavelli dies, passed over by the republic he had served

The author of The Prince spent fourteen years trying to get back into government. When Florence finally threw out the Medici and restored the republic he loved, it gave his old job to someone else, and he was dead within a fortnight.

Florence, Italy

In May 1527 Niccolo Machiavelli was fifty-eight and on the road, working for the papal army as an assistant to his friend Francesco Guicciardini. On the sixth of that month the unpaid troops of the emperor Charles V broke into Rome and sacked it, and the Medici pope Clement VII was shut up in Castel Sant’Angelo. Ten days later Florence, ruled by the Medici since 1512, expelled the family’s young representatives without bloodshed and proclaimed the republic again.

Machiavelli had been waiting half his adult life for that news. From 1498 to 1512 he had been second chancellor of the Florentine republic and secretary to its committee for war, riding on missions to the king of France, the emperor, the pope and Cesare Borgia, and raising a citizen militia to replace hired soldiers. He hurried home expecting, or at least hoping, to be recalled.

He was not. The men now in charge were followers of the dead friar Savonarola and old republicans who remembered that Machiavelli had spent the past decade courting the Medici, had dedicated a book on princely rule to one of them and had taken a Medici cardinal’s money to write the history of the city. On 10 June the Great Council elected a different man to the secretaryship. A younger contemporary, Giovan Battista Busini, later wrote that the disappointment made him ill.

He had long suffered from stomach trouble and treated it with pills of his own recipe, largely aloes. Around 20 June he took a dose and was seized by violent pains. Friends are said to have gathered at the house across the river from the city centre. A letter in the name of his son Piero says that he allowed a friar, Fra Matteo, to hear his confession and stay with him to the end, and that he left the family in the greatest poverty. He was buried in the church of Santa Croce on 22 June.

None of the works for which he is known had been printed. The Prince, written in 1513, circulated in manuscript copies; so did the Discourses on Livy. Florence knew him chiefly as the author of a bawdy and very successful comedy, Mandragola. Five years after his death a Roman printer issued The Prince with a papal privilege, and his reputation began.

How it came to this

Machiavelli’s republic fell in the late summer of 1512, when a Spanish army sacked the neighbouring town of Prato, the militia he had trained ran, and the Medici returned behind foreign pikes. He was dismissed in November. In February 1513 his name was found on a list drawn up by two young conspirators against the new regime. He was arrested and given six drops of the strappado, hoisted by his wrists tied behind his back, and admitted nothing. A general amnesty on the election of Giovanni de’ Medici as Pope Leo X released him.

He withdrew to a small farm at Sant’Andrea in Percussina, seven miles south of the city. A letter of 10 December 1513 to his friend Francesco Vettori describes his days: snaring thrushes, quarrelling over cards at the inn, and in the evening putting on the robes he had worn at court to enter his study and question the ancient writers. He had, he added, written a short work on principalities. He hoped it would show the Medici that fifteen years spent studying statecraft had not been wasted, and get him employment, even if they began by having him roll a stone.

How each side saw it

The Florentine republicans of 1527

Busini, a republican exile writing to the historian Benedetto Varchi in 1549, explained why the restored republic would not have him. Everyone hated him because of The Prince, he wrote: the rich thought it a manual to teach the duke how to take their property, the poor how to take their liberty; the followers of Savonarola thought him a heretic, the good thought him dishonest and the wicked thought him more wicked or more able than themselves. To the men who had kept faith through fifteen years of Medici rule he was simply a former servant of the republic who had spent that time seeking the tyrants’ favour.

The Church

The first printed editions carried papal permission, but opinion turned within a generation. The English cardinal Reginald Pole, who read The Prince in the 1530s, wrote that it had been composed by the finger of Satan and blamed it for the policies of Henry VIII’s minister Thomas Cromwell. In 1559 all Machiavelli’s works were placed on the first Roman Index of Prohibited Books, where they stayed for centuries. Jesuit writers such as Pedro de Ribadeneyra answered him with treatises on the Christian prince, objecting above all to his view that religion should be judged by its usefulness to the state.

The republican tradition

Another line of readers always held that the real Machiavelli is in the Discourses, with their praise of the Roman republic, free citizens in arms and the good sense of the people. Spinoza thought The Prince a warning in disguise. Rousseau called it the book of republicans, exposing what kings do while pretending to advise them. English commonwealthmen such as James Harrington drew on him, and through them he reached the American founders. Modern scholars including Quentin Skinner and Maurizio Viroli have restored this reading, placing him among civic humanists whose first loyalty was to a self-governing city.

Marietta Corsini and the household

Machiavelli married Marietta Corsini in 1501 and they had at least six children. Almost nothing of her survives except one affectionate letter of 1503, written while he was away in Rome, telling him the new baby looks like him and asking him to write more often. She managed the farm through the years of disgrace and his long absences, and his letters and plays make no secret of his affairs with other women. His will of 1522 provided for her and the children. She outlived him by about a quarter of a century on very little money.

What is disputed

Even the day is uncertain. The standard date, followed here, is 21 June, with burial on the 22nd; the letter attributed to his son Piero says he died on the 22nd, and that letter’s authenticity, including its report of a deathbed confession, has been questioned. The story that he told his friends of a dream in which he chose hell with the ancient philosophers over heaven with the poor in spirit is recorded only much later. The larger dispute is over The Prince itself: sincere advice, a job application, a satire, or a trap. Leo Strauss called him a teacher of evil; Isaiah Berlin thought he had shown, to lasting discomfort, that Christian and political virtue cannot be reconciled.

What followed

The republic that rejected him fell after a ten-month siege in 1530, and the Medici returned as hereditary dukes. The Prince was printed in 1532 and translated across Europe; within fifty years ‘Machiavel’ was a stage villain in London and his name an adjective in several languages. He has since been claimed by absolutists, revolutionaries, nationalists of the Italian Risorgimento and theorists of international relations. A monument put up in Santa Croce in 1787 carries the inscription that no praise is equal to so great a name.

Read further

  • Roberto Ridolfi, The Life of Niccolo Machiavelli, translated by Cecil Grayson (1963)
  • Maurizio Viroli, Niccolo’s Smile: A Biography of Machiavelli (2000)
  • Quentin Skinner, Machiavelli (1981)
  • James B. Atkinson and David Sices (eds), Machiavelli and His Friends: Their Personal Correspondence (1996)
  • Isaiah Berlin, ‘The Originality of Machiavelli’, in Against the Current (1979)

Same day, other years

1582

Oda Nobunaga dies in the burning Honno-ji

Kyoto, JapanAsia

After two decades of war Oda Nobunaga had brought central Japan under his control and was close to mastering the rest. He was lodging at the Honno-ji temple in Kyoto with a small escort when one of his senior generals, Akechi Mitsuhide, who had been ordered west with some thirteen thousand men, marched them instead on the capital and surrounded the temple at dawn. Nobunaga fought, was wounded, and withdrew into the burning buildings to kill himself. His body was never found. His heir died the same morning. Eleven days later another general, Toyotomi Hideyoshi, destroyed Mitsuhide at Yamazaki and took up the work of unification.

Seen from elsewhere. Mitsuhide left no explanation, and theories range from personal humiliation and ambition to plots involving the court, the deposed shogun or rival generals. The Jesuit Luis Frois, in Japan at the time, portrayed Nobunaga as a man who wished to be worshipped. The Buddhist institutions he had burned, such as Mount Hiei in 1571, did not mourn him.

1734

Marie-Joseph Angelique is hanged in Montreal

Montreal, New FranceThe Americas

On 10 April 1734 a fire destroyed forty-six buildings in Montreal, including the hospital. Suspicion fell at once on Marie-Joseph Angelique, a Portuguese-born Black woman enslaved in the household of the widow Therese de Couagne, who had recently tried to run away with a white servant and had been told she was to be sold. No one had seen her set a fire. She was convicted after a six-week trial, largely on hearsay and the evidence of a five-year-old girl. On 21 June she was tortured, confessed while refusing to name any accomplice, was hanged in front of the ruins, and her body was burned.

Seen from elsewhere. She had denied the charge throughout until the torture. Historians read the surviving trial record in opposite ways: Afua Cooper sees an act of resistance by a woman who meant to escape, Denyse Beaugrand-Champagne an innocent scapegoat for an accidental fire. Both note what the case shows plainly, that slavery was an ordinary part of life in French Canada.

1948

The Manchester ‘Baby’ runs the first stored program

Manchester, EnglandEurope

In a laboratory at the University of Manchester, Freddie Williams, Tom Kilburn and Geoff Tootill had built a small experimental machine to test a new kind of memory that stored binary digits as spots of charge on a cathode-ray tube. On 21 June 1948 it ran a program of seventeen instructions, written by Kilburn, to find the highest factor of a number. The answer appeared after fifty-two minutes. The machine could hold only thirty-two words, but both the program and its data sat in the same electronic memory and could be changed without rewiring, which is the principle on which computers have worked since.

Seen from elsewhere. Which machine counts as the first computer depends on the definition. Konrad Zuse’s Z3 in Berlin, the secret Colossus at Bletchley Park and the American ENIAC all ran earlier but were programmed by tape, plugs or switches. The stored-program idea was set out in a 1945 report under John von Neumann’s name, and his colleagues long disputed his sole credit.

1964

Three civil rights workers disappear in Mississippi

Neshoba County, MississippiThe Americas

James Chaney, a Black Mississippian aged twenty-one, and Michael Schwerner and Andrew Goodman, white New Yorkers of twenty-four and twenty, were working on a summer campaign to register Black voters. On 21 June they drove to look at the ruins of a church burned by the Ku Klux Klan. A deputy sheriff arrested them, held them until after dark, released them and then stopped their car again on a country road and handed them to waiting Klansmen. They were shot and buried in an earth dam. Federal agents found the bodies forty-four days later. Seven men were convicted of civil rights offences in 1967; none served more than six years.

Seen from elsewhere. State officials at first called the disappearance a publicity hoax. Schwerner’s wife Rita said the country was searching only because two of the missing were white, and the search itself turned up the bodies of several murdered Black men nobody had looked for. Mississippi tried no one for the killings until 2005, when Edgar Ray Killen was convicted of manslaughter.

Also on 21 June