Parallax

16 June, 1487

A boy king loses his army at Stoke

A ten-year-old crowned in Dublin as Edward VI was carried into England behind German pikemen and Irish foot soldiers. The real last battle of the Wars of the Roses was fought over him, and the winner put him to work in the kitchens.

East Stoke, Nottinghamshire, England

On 24 May 1487, in Christ Church Cathedral in Dublin, a boy of about ten was crowned King Edward VI of England. There was no crown to hand, so a gold circlet was borrowed from a statue of the Virgin. Afterwards he was carried through the streets on the shoulders of a very tall Anglo-Irish gentleman, Darcy of Platten, so the crowd could see him. Almost the whole government of English Ireland, led by the Earl of Kildare, had accepted him as Edward, Earl of Warwick, nephew of Edward IV and Richard III and, by Yorkist reckoning, the rightful king.

Henry VII’s government said he was Lambert Simnel, the son of an Oxford tradesman, coached in princely manners by an ambitious priest. The real Warwick, it insisted, was a prisoner in the Tower, and in February it had walked him through London to St Paul’s to prove it.

The men behind the boy were serious. John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln, was Richard III’s nephew and had probably been his intended heir. Francis, Viscount Lovell, had been Richard’s closest friend. Margaret of York, dowager Duchess of Burgundy and sister of two Yorkist kings, paid for some 2,000 German and Swiss mercenaries under a noted captain, Martin Schwartz. With several thousand Irish soldiers under Kildare’s brother Thomas FitzGerald, they landed on the Furness coast of Lancashire on 4 June and marched fast across the Pennines.

Few Englishmen joined them. York shut its gates. Turning south, they forded the Trent and on the morning of 16 June drew up, about 8,000 strong, on a ridge above the village of East Stoke near Newark. Henry had perhaps 12,000 men, but only his vanguard, under the Earl of Oxford, was up in time to fight.

The rebels charged downhill and for a while Oxford’s line was in trouble. The Germans fought with professional skill. The Irish, brave but mostly without armour, were shot down by English archers in great numbers. After some three hours the rebel line broke and men were killed in a gully leading to the river still called the Red Gutter. Lincoln, Schwartz and FitzGerald died on the field. Lovell vanished and was never certainly seen again. The boy was taken alive. Henry, noting that he was a child and a tool of others, pardoned him and sent him to turn the spit in the royal kitchens. He later became a falconer, and was still living decades afterwards.

How it came to this

Henry Tudor had won the crown at Bosworth less than two years earlier with a thin claim through his mother and an army paid for by France. He strengthened it by marrying Elizabeth of York, eldest daughter of Edward IV, but he ruled a country where many held that better claimants existed. Edward IV’s two sons had disappeared in the Tower in 1483 and no bodies had been shown. Their cousin Warwick, son of the executed Duke of Clarence, was a boy of ten when Henry locked him up in 1485.

Ireland was Yorkist ground. Richard, Duke of York, had governed it in the 1450s, and the great Anglo-Irish families, the FitzGeralds above all, had prospered under his house and ran the lordship with little interference. A king who owed them his throne would leave them alone. Burgundy, where Margaret held court at Mechelen, gave any enemy of the Tudors money and ships. Early in 1487 the priest Richard Symonds brought his pupil to Dublin, and Lincoln, who had so far served Henry, slipped away to Flanders to join the enterprise.

How each side saw it

The Tudor court

The official story was set down in the act of attainder passed that November and by Henry’s court historians, Bernard Andre and the Italian Polydore Vergil. It names the boy as Lambert Simnel, son of an Oxford joiner or organ maker, and makes the priest the author of the scheme, with Lincoln and Margaret as cynical backers who knew the child was a fraud. In this version the king’s clemency to the boy displays both mercy and contempt. Vergil wrote decades later with access to people who had been there, but every surviving narrative was written for, or under, the winning side.

The Yorkist leaders

Lincoln and Lovell left no statement of their aims. Margaret of Burgundy’s hostility to Henry is plain from her spending and from her later support for Perkin Warbeck; Tudor writers called her a Juno pursuing the king with endless malice. Whether her nephew Lincoln believed in the boy, meant to rule through him, or planned to take the crown himself once Henry was dead is unknown. Vergil says Henry was angry that Lincoln had been killed against his orders, because he had wanted to question him and learn how far the conspiracy reached among the English nobility.

The Anglo-Irish lords

In Dublin the coronation was a lawful act. A parliament was summoned in the name of Edward VI, coins were struck, and the city of Waterford, which stayed loyal to Henry, was threatened for refusing to recognise him. Irish annals record the arrival of a young prince of the house of York and treat him as genuine. Kildare was too powerful to punish and kept his office. A story in the later Book of Howth has Henry entertain the Irish lords in 1489 with Simnel serving the wine, and remark that they would crown apes next. It is a good story of uncertain truth.

The boy

No word spoken by the child himself is recorded by anyone. A herald with Henry’s army wrote that the lad the rebels called king was taken and that his name was in fact John. The attainder calls him Lambert. He appears afterwards only in passing, as a kitchen servant, as a falconer, and perhaps as an attendant at a courtier’s funeral in 1525. The men who died at Stoke for him are also mostly silent; the Irish dead, the largest group, are not named in any English source, and the German companies are known chiefly through the reputation of their captain.

What is disputed

Who he was remains open. The sources disagree about his name, his father’s trade and his age, and Vergil says he was first coached to play Richard, Duke of York, one of the princes in the Tower. ‘Lambert Simnel’ is so odd a name that some think it invented. Michael Bennett accepts the official outline with reservations. John Ashdown-Hill argued that the Dublin king may have been the real Warwick and Henry’s prisoner the substitute, a minority view. Numbers at the battle are estimates, and royal losses, passed over by Tudor writers, may have been heavy. Lovell’s supposed skeleton, said to have been found walled up at Minster Lovell in 1708, is unverified.

What followed

Stoke, not Bosworth, was the last pitched battle between Lancaster and York, and Henry never led an army in the field again. He had his queen crowned that November and tightened the laws against private armies. A second pretender, Perkin Warbeck, troubled him through the 1490s with the same foreign backers. In 1499 both Warbeck and the real Earl of Warwick, who had spent most of his life in the Tower, were executed. For Ireland the result was Poynings’ Law of 1494, which made its parliament subordinate to the English council and stayed in force, in one form or another, for nearly three hundred years.

Read further

  • Michael Bennett, Lambert Simnel and the Battle of Stoke (1987)
  • Polydore Vergil, Anglica Historia, edited and translated by Denys Hay (1950)
  • S. B. Chrimes, Henry VII (1972)
  • John Ashdown-Hill, The Dublin King: The True Story of Edward, Earl of Warwick, Lambert Simnel and the ‘Princes in the Tower’ (2015)
  • Nathen Amin, Henry VII and the Tudor Pretenders: Simnel, Warbeck and Warwick (2020)

Same day, other years

1948

Three planters are shot and the Malayan Emergency begins

Sungai Siput, Perak, MalayaAsia

On the morning of 16 June 1948 three young Chinese men cycled up to the office of the Elphil rubber estate in Perak and shot dead its British manager, Arthur Walker. Half an hour later, at a neighbouring estate, another group tied John Allison and his assistant Ian Christian to chairs and killed them. The colonial government declared a state of emergency in Perak that day and across Malaya within two days, banning the Malayan Communist Party, whose guerrillas had fought the Japanese with British arms a few years before. The war in the jungle lasted twelve years. Some half a million rural people, most of them Chinese, were moved into guarded ‘new villages’.

Seen from elsewhere. The party’s leader, Chin Peng, wrote in his memoirs that the killings were carried out by local militants without orders and that the crackdown caught the party unprepared. Communists called the conflict the Anti-British National Liberation War. British troops killed twenty-four unarmed villagers at Batang Kali that December, an incident never officially investigated to the satisfaction of the families.

1955

Navy aircraft bomb the Plaza de Mayo

Buenos Aires, ArgentinaThe Americas

Shortly after midday on 16 June 1955, some thirty aircraft of the Argentine navy and air force bombed and strafed the Casa Rosada and the square in front of it in an attempt to kill President Juan Peron and start a coup. Peron had been warned and was in the army ministry nearby. The bombs fell on a weekday crowd; one struck a trolleybus full of passengers. More than 300 people died and several hundred were wounded, nearly all civilians. Loyal troops retook the navy ministry by evening and the pilots flew to Uruguay. That night Peronist crowds burned a dozen churches in the city centre. Peron was overthrown three months later.

Seen from elsewhere. The rebels, some of whose planes bore the slogan ‘Christ conquers’, said they were striking at a dictator who jailed opponents, muzzled the press and was at war with the Church. For decades the raid was passed over as a failed rising. No one was convicted. In 2009 the Argentine state recognised the victims as casualties of state terrorism.

1963

Valentina Tereshkova becomes the first woman in space

Baikonur Cosmodrome, Kazakh SSRAsia

Valentina Tereshkova was twenty-six, a former textile mill worker from Yaroslavl whose father had been killed in the Winter War, and an amateur parachutist. That last skill mattered, because Vostok cosmonauts ejected and landed separately from their capsules. She was launched in Vostok 6 on 16 June 1963, using the call sign Chaika, seagull, while Valery Bykovsky was already in orbit in Vostok 5. She circled the Earth forty-eight times in just under three days, longer than all the American astronauts to that date put together, and came down by parachute in the Altai region on 19 June. No other woman flew in space for nineteen years.

Seen from elsewhere. Soviet leaders presented the flight as proof of socialist equality. Internally the chief designer, Sergei Korolev, was displeased with her performance, citing sickness and fatigue, and the women’s cosmonaut group was disbanded in 1969. Tereshkova said decades later that she had found an error in the capsule’s descent programme which would have sent it into a higher orbit, and had been told to keep quiet.

1976

Police open fire on the schoolchildren of Soweto

Soweto, Johannesburg, South AfricaAfrica

The apartheid government had ordered that half the subjects in Black secondary schools be taught in Afrikaans, a language many pupils and teachers barely knew and associated with their rulers. On the morning of 16 June 1976 between ten and twenty thousand pupils in uniform marched through Soweto towards a rally at Orlando stadium, singing and carrying placards. Police blocked the route in Orlando West, used tear gas and then live rounds. Among the first to die were Hastings Ndlovu, fifteen, and Hector Pieterson, twelve, who was photographed by Sam Nzima being carried by another boy with his sister running alongside. Rioting and shooting spread across the country for months.

Seen from elsewhere. The government blamed agitators and said the police had fired in self-defence when stoned; its commission of inquiry put the dead at 575 by early 1977, and other estimates are higher. Two white officials were also killed by the crowd, one of them a welfare worker known for his sympathy. Thousands of young people left to join the exiled liberation movements. The date is now Youth Day.

Also on 16 June