In May 1795 the guardians of the Temple tower noted in their register that the child Capet was unwell. The prisoner was Louis-Charles, son of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette, ten years old. He had swellings at the knees, wrists and elbows, could hardly stand, and almost never spoke. The Convention’s committee sent one of the best surgeons in Paris, Pierre-Joseph Desault, who prescribed rubbing and fresh air and then died suddenly himself on 1 June. His place was taken by Philippe-Jean Pelletan.
Pelletan was shocked by what he found and had the boy carried to a lighter room overlooking the garden. It was too late for it to matter. On the afternoon of 8 June, with the keeper Lasne holding him, the child died at about three o’clock.
The committee kept the death secret for a day. On 9 June four doctors opened the body in the tower and found the organs riddled with tubercular tumours. Their report says that they were shown the body of a boy who appeared to be about ten and whom the commissioners told them was the son of the late Louis Capet. Two of the four had attended him in life, and then only for a few days. During the autopsy Pelletan cut out the heart, wrapped it in his handkerchief and slipped it into his pocket.
The body was put in a plain coffin and buried on the evening of 10 June in a common grave at the cemetery of Sainte-Marguerite, without a marker. His sister Marie-Therese, fifteen, held on the floor above, was not told. She learned weeks later that her mother, her aunt and her brother were all dead.
The worst had been done long before the doctors came. In July 1793 the boy had been taken from his mother and given to a cobbler, Antoine Simon, with orders to make a good republican of him; he was taught revolutionary songs and coarse language, and was induced to sign a statement accusing his mother of incest, which was read out at her trial. When Simon left in January 1794 the child was shut alone in a barred room for six months. Food was pushed through a grating. Nobody cleaned the room or him. Only after Robespierre fell in July did a deputy, Barras, visit, and order that he be washed and given a keeper who would speak to him.
How it came to this
Louis-Charles was born at Versailles in 1785 and became dauphin, heir to the throne, when his elder brother died in June 1789, weeks before the Bastille fell. He was brought to Paris with his parents that October, was in the carriage on the failed flight to Varennes in 1791, and went with them into the Temple, a medieval keep once owned by the Knights Templar, after the monarchy was overthrown on 10 August 1792.
His father was guillotined on 21 January 1793. From that day the royalists, the emigre princes and the foreign courts at war with France recognised the boy as Louis XVII, and his uncle the Count of Provence declared himself regent. That made a sickly child the most valuable hostage in Europe. The republic could neither release a living claimant nor easily put a child on trial, and royalist plots to free him, real and imagined, gave his jailers reason to isolate him. Spain was negotiating for his handover as a condition of peace in the very weeks in which he died.