Parallax

8 June, 1795

The boy in the Temple dies

A ten-year-old prisoner, king of France to royalists and citizen Capet to his jailers, died of neglect and tuberculosis in a Paris tower. Whether it was really him took two centuries and a preserved heart to settle.

The Temple prison, Paris, France

In May 1795 the guardians of the Temple tower noted in their register that the child Capet was unwell. The prisoner was Louis-Charles, son of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette, ten years old. He had swellings at the knees, wrists and elbows, could hardly stand, and almost never spoke. The Convention’s committee sent one of the best surgeons in Paris, Pierre-Joseph Desault, who prescribed rubbing and fresh air and then died suddenly himself on 1 June. His place was taken by Philippe-Jean Pelletan.

Pelletan was shocked by what he found and had the boy carried to a lighter room overlooking the garden. It was too late for it to matter. On the afternoon of 8 June, with the keeper Lasne holding him, the child died at about three o’clock.

The committee kept the death secret for a day. On 9 June four doctors opened the body in the tower and found the organs riddled with tubercular tumours. Their report says that they were shown the body of a boy who appeared to be about ten and whom the commissioners told them was the son of the late Louis Capet. Two of the four had attended him in life, and then only for a few days. During the autopsy Pelletan cut out the heart, wrapped it in his handkerchief and slipped it into his pocket.

The body was put in a plain coffin and buried on the evening of 10 June in a common grave at the cemetery of Sainte-Marguerite, without a marker. His sister Marie-Therese, fifteen, held on the floor above, was not told. She learned weeks later that her mother, her aunt and her brother were all dead.

The worst had been done long before the doctors came. In July 1793 the boy had been taken from his mother and given to a cobbler, Antoine Simon, with orders to make a good republican of him; he was taught revolutionary songs and coarse language, and was induced to sign a statement accusing his mother of incest, which was read out at her trial. When Simon left in January 1794 the child was shut alone in a barred room for six months. Food was pushed through a grating. Nobody cleaned the room or him. Only after Robespierre fell in July did a deputy, Barras, visit, and order that he be washed and given a keeper who would speak to him.

How it came to this

Louis-Charles was born at Versailles in 1785 and became dauphin, heir to the throne, when his elder brother died in June 1789, weeks before the Bastille fell. He was brought to Paris with his parents that October, was in the carriage on the failed flight to Varennes in 1791, and went with them into the Temple, a medieval keep once owned by the Knights Templar, after the monarchy was overthrown on 10 August 1792.

His father was guillotined on 21 January 1793. From that day the royalists, the emigre princes and the foreign courts at war with France recognised the boy as Louis XVII, and his uncle the Count of Provence declared himself regent. That made a sickly child the most valuable hostage in Europe. The republic could neither release a living claimant nor easily put a child on trial, and royalist plots to free him, real and imagined, gave his jailers reason to isolate him. Spain was negotiating for his handover as a condition of peace in the very weeks in which he died.

How each side saw it

The revolutionary government

To the Convention there was no king in the Temple, only a child of the last tyrant whose name was a rallying cry for invasion and civil war. Placing him with Simon was presented as giving him a citizen’s upbringing. The solitary confinement that followed was ordered by no recorded decree; it arose when the Commune abolished the post of tutor and nobody took responsibility. After Thermidor the committees improved his conditions and sent doctors, but would not free him. The official record of his death and burial was properly drawn up, and republican historians long held that the documents left nothing to explain.

The royalist tradition

For royalists he was the martyr-child of the Revolution, deliberately degraded and left to rot. Their chief witness was his sister, later Duchess of Angouleme, whose prison memoir describes what she could hear of him from the floor above. Alcide de Beauchesne’s biography of 1852, drawn from interviews with the surviving keepers Gomin and Lasne, fixed the picture of the brutal cobbler and the saintly victim. Historians treat Beauchesne’s long deathbed dialogues as embroidery, and note that Simon and his wife seem to have been rough but not unkind. The months of solitary confinement are confirmed by the committees’ own records.

Believers in a substitution

Rumour said at once that the dauphin had been smuggled out and a dying child put in his place. More than a hundred men later claimed to be him. The most persistent, a clockmaker from Prussia called Karl Wilhelm Naundorff, convinced several former servants of the royal household and was buried at Delft in 1845 under the name Louis XVII; his descendants still use the name Bourbon. Believers pointed to the doctors’ cautious wording, to Desault’s sudden death, to a skeleton dug up at Sainte-Marguerite that belonged to a youth in his late teens, and to the Duchess of Angouleme’s refusal to meet any claimant.

What is disputed

In 2000 geneticists in Leuven and Munster, at the instigation of the historian Philippe Delorme, compared mitochondrial DNA from the heart with hair from Marie Antoinette and her sisters and samples from living maternal relatives. They matched. Most historians regard the question as closed. Sceptics object that the heart’s history is broken, since it was stolen once, lost in a riot in 1830 and passed through several hands, and that the test shows only maternal kinship to the Habsburgs, not which child. Tests on Naundorff’s remains in 1998 found no match, though a 2014 study of a descendant’s Y chromosome has been cited in his favour.

What followed

The Count of Provence took the title Louis XVIII and eventually reigned after Napoleon’s fall; the numbering itself kept the lost boy in the line of kings. Marie-Therese was exchanged for French prisoners in December 1795 and lived until 1851. The pretenders supplied material for novelists, Mark Twain among them. The heart, after a century and a half in private hands and a Spanish Bourbon chapel, was placed in the royal crypt at Saint-Denis on 8 June 2004. The case is an early instance of a state’s treatment of a child prisoner becoming a lasting charge against a revolution.

Read further

  • Deborah Cadbury, The Lost King of France: Revolution, Revenge and the Search for Louis XVII (2002)
  • Philippe Delorme, Louis XVII: la verite (2000)
  • Alcide de Beauchesne, Louis XVII: sa vie, son agonie, sa mort (1852)
  • Antonia Fraser, Marie Antoinette: The Journey (2001)
  • G. Lenotre, Le roi Louis XVII et l’enigme du Temple (1920)

Same day, other years

AD 632

The death of the Prophet Muhammad

Medina, ArabiaMiddle East

According to Islamic tradition Muhammad fell ill with fever and headache some months after returning from his final pilgrimage to Mecca, and died in Medina in the room of his wife Aisha, his head in her lap, on a Monday in the month of Rabi al-Awwal in the eleventh year of the Hijra. The date is conventionally converted to 8 June 632. He was about 62 and was buried where he died. He had by then united most of Arabia under the new faith. His companion Abu Bakr steadied the stunned community with the words that those who worshipped Muhammad should know he was dead, and those who worshipped God that God lives.

Seen from elsewhere. Sunni tradition holds that he named no successor and that the companions rightly chose Abu Bakr. Shia tradition holds that he had designated his cousin Ali, who was preparing the body for burial while others settled the leadership, and it gives a different date. The day itself rests on later sources and is a conversion.

AD 793

Northmen raid Lindisfarne

Lindisfarne, Northumbria, EnglandEurope

The monastery on the tidal island of Lindisfarne held the shrine of St Cuthbert and was among the most revered places in Christian Britain. In 793 seaborne raiders from Scandinavia landed there, killed some of the monks, drowned others, carried off young men as slaves and took the church’s plate. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle places the event in January; the date of 8 June comes from the Annals of Lindisfarne and is preferred by historians, since no fleet would cross the North Sea in midwinter. The Northumbrian scholar Alcuin, writing from Charlemagne’s court, said that such a terror had never before been seen in Britain. The raid is the conventional start of the Viking Age.

Seen from elsewhere. The raiders left no account, and everything known comes from churchmen who read the attack as punishment for sin. The community survived and stayed on the island for decades. It was not the first raid on England, and some scholars see pagan retaliation for Charlemagne’s forced conversions, a view others reject.

1924

Mallory and Irvine vanish on Everest

Mount Everest, TibetAsia

George Mallory, a 37-year-old former schoolmaster on his third expedition to the mountain, left the highest camp on the morning of 8 June 1924 with Andrew Irvine, a 22-year-old Oxford engineering student, using oxygen sets that Irvine had rebuilt. At 12.50 the geologist Noel Odell, climbing in support below, saw two dots on the north-east ridge moving up a rock step through a break in the cloud. The cloud closed, and they were not seen again. Mallory’s body was found in 1999 at about 8,150 metres, with injuries from a fall and a rope mark at his waist. A boot and foot identified as Irvine’s emerged from a glacier in 2024.

Seen from elsewhere. Whether they reached the summit twenty-nine years before Tenzing Norgay and Edmund Hillary cannot be known; the camera has never been found. For Tibetans the mountain is Chomolungma, and the British expeditions depended on Sherpa and Tibetan porters, seven of whom had died in an avalanche under Mallory’s leadership in 1922.

1972

Napalm falls on Trang Bang

Trang Bang, South VietnamAsia

North Vietnamese troops had occupied the village of Trang Bang on the road from Saigon to Cambodia, and villagers and South Vietnamese soldiers were sheltering in a temple. On 8 June 1972 a South Vietnamese Skyraider, mistaking them for the enemy as they ran, dropped napalm. A nine-year-old girl, Phan Thi Kim Phuc, tore off her burning clothes and ran down the road screaming, with other children, towards a group of journalists. The photograph of that moment, credited to Nick Ut of the Associated Press, was on front pages around the world the next day and won a Pulitzer Prize. She was taken to hospital, survived after fourteen months of treatment, and later settled in Canada.

Seen from elsewhere. The aircraft was South Vietnamese, not American, a point often lost. President Nixon wondered on tape whether the picture was staged. In 2025 a documentary claimed that a local stringer, Nguyen Thanh Nghe, took it; the AP, after an inquiry, kept Ut’s credit, while World Press Photo suspended its attribution.

Also on 8 June