Parallax

5 June, 1916

Kitchener drowns off Orkney

Britain’s war minister, the face on the recruiting poster, sailed for Russia in a gale and was dead within three hours. His colleagues mourned in public and, some of them, felt relief in private.

Off Marwick Head, Orkney, Scotland

Field Marshal Lord Kitchener arrived at Scapa Flow, the Grand Fleet’s anchorage in Orkney, on the morning of 5 June 1916. He lunched with Admiral Jellicoe aboard the flagship and listened to an account of the battle fought off Jutland five days earlier. He seemed, Jellicoe remembered, glad to be getting away from London for three weeks. He was bound for Arkhangelsk and then Petrograd, to discuss munitions and money with the Tsar’s government and to judge for himself how long Russia could go on fighting.

The ship assigned to him was HMS Hampshire, an armoured cruiser that had come through Jutland untouched. A north-easterly gale was blowing. Jellicoe’s staff therefore changed her course to pass up the west side of Orkney, where the islands should have given shelter and where, it was thought, the sea was too rough for a submarine to have laid mines. Hampshire sailed at a quarter to five with two destroyers as escort.

Within an hour the wind had swung round to the north-west and she was steaming straight into it. The destroyers could not keep up in the head sea, and Captain Savill signalled them to turn back. At about twenty to eight, a mile and a half off the cliffs of Marwick Head, an explosion tore open the hull below the bridge. She had struck one of a line of mines laid a week before by the German submarine U-75. The power failed, the boats could not be lowered, and Hampshire went down by the bow in about fifteen minutes.

A survivor heard an officer shout to make way for Lord Kitchener, and saw him come up to the quarterdeck, talking calmly with two of his staff. Nobody saw him afterwards. His entire staff was lost with him, among them his military secretary and closest companion, Colonel Oswald FitzGerald, whose body was later washed ashore. A few dozen men got away on three open rafts into seas breaking against a rock coast, and most of them died of cold before they reached it. Twelve came ashore alive. The number lost, long given as about 650, was put at 737 after a recount for the centenary.

The news was published in London the following afternoon. Blinds were drawn, shops closed, and crowds stood silently outside the War Office. Kitchener was 65. His body was never recovered.

How it came to this

Herbert Kitchener had been the empire’s most celebrated soldier for nearly twenty years. He made his name in 1898 by destroying the Mahdist army at Omdurman and retaking the Sudan, commanded in South Africa in the later, guerrilla phase of the Boer War, reorganised the army in India and governed Egypt. When war came in August 1914 the Liberal government made him Secretary of State for War by public demand. Almost alone in the cabinet he said the conflict would last at least three years and would be decided by armies of millions, and he set about raising them from volunteers. Some two and a half million men enlisted before conscription began.

By 1916 his standing with his colleagues had collapsed. He was secretive, would not delegate and disliked explaining himself to politicians. After the shell shortage of 1915 the supply of munitions was taken from him and given to Lloyd George, and at the end of that year control of strategy passed to the Chief of the Imperial General Staff, Sir William Robertson. He kept his office because the public would not have understood his removal. The Russian mission suited everyone.

How each side saw it

The Sudanese

At Omdurman, known in Sudan as Karari, Kitchener’s machine-guns and artillery killed some 10,000 or more of the Khalifa’s soldiers in a morning for the loss of 48 of his own, and many wounded were left or finished off on the field, as the young Winston Churchill reported with disgust in The River War. Kitchener then had the Mahdi’s tomb blown up and the bones thrown into the Nile. The memoirs of Babikr Bedri, who fought there, describe the battle from the Sudanese ranks. In Sudanese national memory Karari is a day of sacrifice against a foreign conquest.

Afrikaners and Black South Africans

To break the Boer commandos, Kitchener’s columns burned some 30,000 farms and moved the families into guarded camps. About 28,000 Boer civilians, most of them children, died there of measles, typhoid and hunger, as Emily Hobhouse’s reports made known in Britain. At least 20,000 Black Africans, held in separate camps and long left out of the record, died as well. Kitchener regarded the camps as a military necessity and the deaths as a failure of administration. For Afrikaners they became the founding grievance of twentieth-century nationalism, commemorated at the Women’s Memorial in Bloemfontein.

His cabinet colleagues

Lloyd George, who was to have gone to Russia with him and stayed behind to deal with Ireland, wrote in his War Memoirs that Kitchener’s mind was like a lighthouse, throwing out a brilliant beam and then leaving everything in darkness. Asquith’s wife Margot is credited with the remark that if he was not a great man he was at least a great poster. Ministers had found him impossible to work with, yet most conceded afterwards that his early insistence on a long war and a mass army had been right when their own forecasts were wrong.

Orcadians

People on the west coast of Orkney saw the cruiser in trouble and later said that they were ordered away from the cliffs by soldiers, and that the Stromness lifeboat was forbidden to launch. The naval base was slow to send ships, having first been told a vessel was merely in difficulty. The Admiralty denied that anything more could have been done in such seas. Islanders’ accounts, collected over decades, kept alive the belief that men who reached the rocks alive died for want of help. Orkney raised its own stone tower to Kitchener on Marwick Head in 1926.

What is disputed

The secrecy and the failures of rescue produced conspiracy theories almost at once: that German spies, Irish republicans or Bolsheviks had planted a bomb, that the government wanted him dead, or that he had survived. A Boer adventurer, Fritz Duquesne, claimed to have signalled the submarine from on board. An Admiralty report in 1926 and later surveys of the wreck support a mine and nothing else. The death toll was revised from about 650 to 737 in 2016. The famous pointing-finger poster, drawn by Alfred Leete for a magazine cover, may have been far less widely displayed during the war than later memory assumes, as James Taylor has argued.

What followed

Lloyd George succeeded Kitchener at the War Office and six months later replaced Asquith as prime minister. The volunteer divisions Kitchener had raised went into action on the Somme on 1 July, less than four weeks after his death, and suffered some 57,000 casualties on the first day. Russia’s war effort collapsed in revolution the following year. His reputation has swung between the imperial hero of 1916 and the architect of the camps; the wreck of Hampshire, lying upside down in about 60 metres of water, is a protected war grave.

Read further

  • Philip Magnus, Kitchener: Portrait of an Imperialist (1958)
  • George H. Cassar, Kitchener: Architect of Victory (1977)
  • Trevor Royle, The Kitchener Enigma (1985)
  • Thomas Pakenham, The Boer War (1979)
  • Winston S. Churchill, The River War (1899)

Same day, other years

1862

Vietnam cedes Saigon to France

Saigon, VietnamAsia

A French and Spanish expedition had attacked Vietnam in 1858, citing the execution of Catholic missionaries, and had taken Saigon the following year. On 5 June 1862 the envoys of the Emperor Tu Duc, led by the elderly mandarin Phan Thanh Gian, signed a treaty at Saigon. It gave France the three eastern provinces of the Mekong delta and the island of Poulo Condore, opened three ports to trade, guaranteed freedom for Christian worship and promised a large indemnity in silver. It was the first cession of Vietnamese territory to a European power, and the base from which France took the rest of the south in 1867 and the whole country by 1885.

Seen from elsewhere. The court at Hue signed because a rebellion in the north threatened the dynasty more directly. The resistance leader Truong Dinh refused the order to disband and fought on in the emperor’s name against the emperor’s treaty. Phan Thanh Gian poisoned himself in 1867; Vietnamese opinion still divides over whether he was a defeatist or a tragic patriot.

1873

Zanzibar’s slave market is closed

ZanzibarAfrica

Zanzibar was the great entrepot of the East African slave trade. Caravans brought captives from as far as the Congo basin to the coast, and thousands a year were sold in the open market in Zanzibar town for the island’s clove plantations or for shipment to Arabia and the Gulf. On 5 June 1873 Sultan Barghash bin Said signed a treaty with Britain forbidding all carriage of slaves by sea and closing the public markets in his dominions. He signed after the British consul, John Kirk, told him that the Royal Navy would otherwise blockade the island. An Anglican cathedral was built on the site of the market, its altar said to stand where the whipping post had been.

Seen from elsewhere. Barghash and the Omani planter class saw a ruinous demand imposed at gunpoint on a sovereign state; Britain made the island a protectorate in 1890. The trade moved to overland routes, and slavery itself stayed legal in Zanzibar until 1897. The enslaved left almost no testimony except what missionaries wrote down.

1967

The Six-Day War begins

Egypt, Israel and neighbouring statesMiddle East

In May 1967 President Nasser of Egypt moved troops into Sinai, ordered out the United Nations force that had separated the two armies since 1956 and closed the Straits of Tiran to Israeli shipping. Jordan and Syria joined a military pact with Cairo. At 7.45 on the morning of 5 June the Israeli air force attacked Egyptian airfields while the pilots were at breakfast, destroying about 300 aircraft, most of them on the ground, within hours. With the skies cleared, Israeli armour took Sinai and Gaza, then the West Bank and East Jerusalem from Jordan, and the Golan Heights from Syria. A ceasefire took hold on 10 June.

Seen from elsewhere. Israel presented the strike as pre-emption of an imminent attack on its existence. Arab governments called it aggression, and Arabs know the outcome as the Naksa, the setback; some 250,000 or more Palestinians were displaced. Historians remain divided on whether Nasser intended war or was bluffing. The occupation that began that week has not ended.

1981

The first report of what became AIDS

Atlanta and Los Angeles, United StatesWorldwide

On 5 June 1981 the weekly bulletin of the United States Centers for Disease Control carried a two-page note from Dr Michael Gottlieb and colleagues in Los Angeles. Five previously healthy young men, all homosexual, had been treated for a rare pneumonia normally seen only in people whose immune systems had been destroyed. Two were already dead. Within weeks doctors in New York and San Francisco were reporting similar cases along with an unusual skin cancer. The virus responsible, HIV, was identified in 1983-84. It has since killed more than forty million people, the majority of them in sub-Saharan Africa, and effective treatment did not arrive until 1996.

Seen from elsewhere. The report marks recognition, not a beginning: genetic studies place the virus’s spread in humans in central Africa in the early twentieth century. Activists charged that labelling it a disease of gay men delayed funding and action under the Reagan administration. In Africa, where transmission was mainly heterosexual, the drugs that transformed survival in rich countries remained unaffordable for years.

Also on 5 June