Parallax

2 June, 1882

Garibaldi dies on his island, and is refused his pyre

The most famous revolutionary of the nineteenth century asked to be burned in the open air in his red shirt. The country he had helped to create buried him under a block of granite instead.

Caprera, Sardinia, Italy

By the spring of 1882 Giuseppe Garibaldi could no longer walk, hold a pen properly or turn himself in bed. Arthritis had been crippling him for years, and bronchitis had now settled on his chest. He was 74. He lay in a whitewashed farmhouse he had built himself on Caprera, a granite island off the north coast of Sardinia where he grew beans, kept goats and named his donkeys after his enemies, one of them Pius IX.

On the afternoon of 2 June he asked for his bed to be turned to the window so that he could see the sea. According to his family, two small birds settled on the sill, and he told those in the room not to drive them off, since they might be the souls of his two dead infant daughters come to fetch him. He died at about twenty past six in the evening with his third wife, Francesca Armosino, beside him. A clock in the house, stopped at that time, is still shown to visitors.

He had left precise instructions. Years before, in writing, he had told his doctor that he wished to be cremated, not in an oven but on an open pyre of the island’s own wood: acacia, myrtle, lentisk and other aromatic scrub. He was to lie on it in his red shirt with his face to the sun. A pinch of ash was to go into an urn beside the graves of his daughters. He warned that the mayor should be told only when it was done, because priests and politicians would interfere.

They interfered. The news reached Rome by telegraph, and ministers, deputies and old comrades sailed for the island. A man who was by now the kingdom’s founding legend could not, it was felt, be burned like a pagan on a hillside, and there was no legal provision for such a thing. Some urged embalming and a tomb in Rome. The family gave way to a compromise that was neither his wish nor the capital’s: burial on Caprera.

The funeral took place on 8 June in a violent storm that veterans read as the general’s opinion of the proceedings. The coffin was lowered into the ground near the house and closed with a rough block of granite.Towns across the peninsula soon began commissioning the statues and renaming the squares that still bear his name.

How it came to this

Garibaldi was born in 1807 in Nice, then under French rule, the son of a coastal skipper. A follower of Giuseppe Mazzini’s republican movement, he was condemned to death in 1834 for a failed mutiny in Genoa and fled to South America. There he spent twelve years fighting for the breakaway republic of Rio Grande do Sul against the Brazilian empire and then for Montevideo, where his Italian Legion first wore the red shirts. He came home in 1848 with a Brazilian wife, Anita, who died beside him in the retreat from the fallen Roman Republic a year later.

His fame rests on 1860. With about a thousand volunteers he landed at Marsala in Sicily, beat the Bourbon army at Calatafimi, took Palermo, crossed to the mainland and entered Naples by train. He then handed the entire south to Victor Emmanuel II of Piedmont-Sardinia and went home to Caprera, refusing titles and money. His later attempts to take Rome ended with a wound from Italian bullets at Aspromonte in 1862 and defeat by French rifles at Mentana in 1867.

How each side saw it

The Bourbon south

In the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies the Thousand were, legally, foreign filibusters invading a recognised state. Bourbon loyalist writers such as Giacinto de’ Sivo described a conquest eased by bribed generals and British warships standing off Marsala. Peasants who had expected land got little: at Bronte in August 1860 Garibaldi’s lieutenant Nino Bixio had five men shot after a rural rising. The decade of so-called brigandage that followed, put down by the new Italian army with summary executions, is treated by a present-day revisionist movement in the south as a colonial war. Most academic historians accept the violence but reject the picture of a prosperous kingdom destroyed.

The Catholic Church

To Pius IX and the Jesuit journal La Civilta Cattolica, Garibaldi was a Freemason and a declared enemy of the faith who had twice marched on the pope’s own city. He returned the feeling, calling the papacy the cancer of Italy and writing anticlerical novels. Devout Italians were instructed not to take part in the politics of a state built partly on seized papal territory. His wish for cremation, a practice the Church then forbade and freethinkers promoted for that reason, was understood on both sides as a last gesture against it.

Republicans, and Garibaldi himself

Mazzini’s followers held that Garibaldi had thrown away a people’s revolution by giving the south to a king. Garibaldi never forgave the monarchy’s minister Cavour for ceding Nice, his birthplace, to France in 1860, which he said had made him a foreigner in his own land. In old age he sat in parliament as a man of the far left, backed universal suffrage and the First International, and wrote that the Italy he saw, poor, heavily taxed and governed by cliques, was quite different from the one he had dreamed of.

What is disputed

The deathbed scene with the birds rests on family recollection, chiefly that of his daughter Clelia, and cannot be checked. Who decided against the pyre is argued over: the family blamed pressure from Rome, while some politicians claimed the widow consented freely. Descendants have at times asked for the tomb to be opened to establish the state of the remains. Historians also differ on 1860 itself. Denis Mack Smith stressed how much Garibaldi forced the hand of a reluctant Cavour; Rosario Romeo gave Cavour the larger share; Lucy Riall has shown how deliberately the hero’s image was manufactured in his own lifetime.

What followed

Garibaldi became the one figure of unification that monarchists, republicans, socialists and later both Fascists and anti-Fascist partisans all claimed. Communist brigades in the resistance of 1943-45 took his name, and so did Italian volunteers in Spain. In Brazil and Uruguay he is remembered as a hero of their own wars. Caprera is now a national museum, the house kept as it was on the day he died. The argument about what unification did to the south, which began in his lifetime, remains a live subject in Italian politics.

Read further

  • Lucy Riall, Garibaldi: Invention of a Hero (2007)
  • Denis Mack Smith, Garibaldi: A Great Life in Brief (1956)
  • G. M. Trevelyan, Garibaldi and the Thousand (1909)
  • Christopher Hibbert, Garibaldi and His Enemies (1965)
  • Giuseppe Garibaldi, Autobiography, translated by A. Werner (1889)

Same day, other years

AD 455

The Vandals enter Rome

Rome, ItalyEurope

Gaiseric, king of the Vandals, ruled the richest provinces of Roman Africa from Carthage and commanded the strongest fleet in the Mediterranean. In 455 the emperor Valentinian III, with whom he had a treaty and a marriage alliance, was murdered. Gaiseric sailed for Italy. The usurper Petronius Maximus was killed by a Roman crowd as he tried to flee, and on 2 June the Vandals entered the undefended city. Pope Leo I met the king and obtained a promise that there would be no burning or slaughter. For fourteen days the Vandals stripped Rome methodically, taking palace treasures, statues, the empress Eudoxia and her daughters, and thousands of captives back to Africa.

Seen from elsewhere. Every surviving account comes from Roman and Catholic writers hostile to the Vandals, who were Arian Christians. Even they describe an orderly plunder, not a destruction, and the word ‘vandalism’ dates only from 1794. Procopius’s claim that the spoils included the treasures of the Jerusalem Temple was written a century later.

1763

A ball game takes Fort Michilimackinac

Straits of Mackinac, Great LakesThe Americas

After France lost Canada, British garrisons moved into the forts of the Great Lakes without treaties and cut off the gifts on which diplomacy with the Native nations depended. In 1763 a broad rising, named by the British after the Odawa leader Pontiac, took most of those posts within weeks. At Michilimackinac on 2 June, Ojibwe men led by Minweweh, joined by visiting Sauk, played a game of baggatiway, a form of lacrosse, outside the open gate while the garrison watched. The ball was lobbed over the stockade, the players ran in after it, and women handed them weapons hidden under blankets. Most of the thirty-five soldiers were killed or captured; the French residents were left alone.

Seen from elsewhere. The British called it treachery. The trader Alexander Henry, who survived, recorded Minweweh telling him earlier that the English had conquered the French but not the Ojibwe, whose lakes and woods were their own inheritance. Neighbouring Odawa, angry at not being consulted, took the prisoners and ransomed them at Montreal.

1962

Soviet troops fire on strikers at Novocherkassk

Novocherkassk, Russia, Soviet UnionEurope

On 1 June 1962 the Soviet government raised meat and butter prices by up to a third. At the Novocherkassk Electric Locomotive Works the announcement followed a cut in piece rates, and when workers complained, the director is said to have told them to eat liver pies instead. The plant struck and blocked the railway. On 2 June several thousand people marched into the city behind red flags and portraits of Lenin. In the square outside the party headquarters, soldiers opened fire. Twenty-six people are known to have been killed and about ninety wounded. The bodies were buried secretly in scattered graves, seven alleged ringleaders were later shot and over a hundred people were imprisoned.

Seen from elsewhere. The state treated the marchers as hooligans and criminals and kept the event out of print until the late 1980s. General Matvei Shaposhnikov, who refused to send tanks against the column, was later forced out of the army and the party. Who gave the order to fire has never been firmly established.

2012

Mubarak is sentenced to life

Cairo, EgyptAfrica

Hosni Mubarak ruled Egypt for almost thirty years until eighteen days of protest forced him out in February 2011. Around 850 people were killed in that uprising. On 2 June 2012 a Cairo court found the former president, wheeled into the dock on a hospital bed, guilty of failing to stop the killing of demonstrators, and sentenced him and his interior minister, Habib al-Adly, to life imprisonment. He was the first Arab ruler to be tried in an ordinary court by his own people after a popular revolt. The same judgment acquitted six senior police commanders and cleared Mubarak’s sons of corruption on a time limit.

Seen from elsewhere. Protesters filled Tahrir Square that night, believing the acquittals and the weak evidence, which the judge blamed on uncooperative security agencies, invited an appeal. Supporters saw a war veteran humiliated. The verdict was overturned in 2013; Mubarak was finally acquitted of the killings in 2017 and died a free man in 2020.

Also on 2 June