Parallax

20 June, AD 451

Attila is turned back on the Catalaunian Plains

A Roman general and a Gothic king who had spent years fighting each other joined forces for one day against the Huns. The king died, Attila got away, and nobody is sure where or exactly when it happened.

Near Troyes or Chalons, Gaul

In the spring of 451 Attila crossed the Rhine with the largest army the western provinces of the Roman Empire had seen. The Huns themselves were its core, but most of the men were subjects and allies: Gepids under their king Ardaric, Ostrogoths under Valamir and his brothers, Rugians, Sciri, Thuringians and some of the Franks. Metz was sacked on 7 April. The army moved on across northern Gaul towards Orleans, held by a king of the Alans named Sangiban whose loyalty to Rome was doubted.

The commander of what remained of the western Roman army was Flavius Aetius, who had spent part of his youth as a hostage among the Huns and had used Hun mercenaries for twenty years to keep the peoples settled in Gaul in check. He now needed those peoples. The essential one was the Visigothic kingdom of Toulouse under Theodoric I, an old enemy. A senator, Avitus, was sent to persuade him. Theodoric marched north with his sons Thorismund and Theodoric, and with them came Burgundians, Franks, Saxons and Armoricans.

They reached Orleans in mid June, by tradition just as the Huns were breaking into the city. Attila pulled back eastward into the open country of Champagne, where his horsemen had room, and the allies followed. The night before the battle, the sixth-century writer Jordanes says, Franks on the Roman side and Gepids on the Hun side stumbled into each other and fought in the dark.

The battle itself began in the afternoon with a race for a ridge that commanded the field, which Thorismund and Aetius won. Attila took the centre with his Huns. Aetius placed the suspect Alans in the middle of his own line, with Romans on one wing and Visigoths on the other. Jordanes, almost the only narrative we have, calls the fighting fierce, confused and immense, and says a stream ran with blood. The old king Theodoric was thrown from his horse and trampled, or struck by the spear of an Ostrogoth; his men found the body next day under a heap of dead.

At nightfall Attila withdrew behind his wagons. Jordanes says he had a pyre built of saddles, ready to burn himself rather than be taken. The assault never came. Aetius advised Thorismund to go home and secure his father’s throne against his brothers, and the Goths left. Attila waited, saw the allied camp empty, and retreated across the Rhine with his army intact.

How it came to this

The Huns had appeared north of the Black Sea in the 370s and driven Gothic peoples across the Danube into the empire. By the 440s Attila, ruling at first with his brother Bleda and then alone, controlled a realm stretching from the Rhine to the Caspian, based on the Hungarian plain. It lived on tribute. The eastern court at Constantinople paid him 2,100 pounds of gold a year after 447. The historian Priscus, who dined at his court on an embassy in 449, describes a plainly dressed man eating from a wooden plate while his guests were served on silver.

In 450 a new eastern emperor, Marcian, stopped the payments, and Attila turned west. He had pretexts. Honoria, sister of the western emperor Valentinian III, facing a forced marriage, had sent him her ring and an appeal; he chose to treat it as a betrothal and demanded half the western empire as her dowry. There was also a disputed succession among the Franks, and, according to Jordanes, encouragement from the Vandal king Geiseric in Africa, who wanted the Visigoths destroyed.

How each side saw it

The Huns

No Hun account of anything survives; they left no writing. What we know comes from Romans and Goths, chiefly Priscus, who met Attila, and Jordanes, writing a century later in Constantinople. The image of the ‘scourge of God’ is later still, a product of medieval churchmen. A different memory persists elsewhere: Attila is a hero in Hungarian tradition, where his name remains a common one for boys, and he appears as the dignified king Etzel in the German Nibelungenlied and as Atli in Norse saga. The historian Hyun Jin Kim argues that the Hun state was more organised and durable than Roman sources admit.

The Goths, through Jordanes

Jordanes, himself of Gothic descent, was summarising a lost Gothic history by Cassiodorus written for the Ostrogothic kings of Italy. His battle is a Gothic epic: the Visigoths win it, their king dies gloriously, and his funeral is held on the field within sight of the enemy. He also has to manage an awkward fact, that the Ostrogoths, the ancestors of his patrons, fought for Attila against their kin. Modern scholars treat his speeches and casualty figures as literature but accept the outline, since shorter contemporary chronicles by Prosper and Hydatius confirm the battle and Theodoric’s death.

The churches of Gaul

In the towns Attila passed, the memory that lasted was of bishops and holy women. At Orleans, Bishop Anianus is said to have gone to fetch Aetius and to have watched from the walls for his coming. At Troyes, Bishop Lupus was credited with persuading Attila to spare the city. In Paris, a young woman named Genevieve told the citizens not to flee, and the Huns did not come. These saints’ lives were written decades or centuries later to honour local patrons, but they preserve something real: the imperial government was barely visible, and bishops were becoming the leaders of the cities.

What is disputed

The date of 20 June was worked out by the historian J. B. Bury from the tradition that Orleans was relieved on 14 June; others have argued for late September, and no ancient source gives the day. The site is unknown: Jordanes names both the Catalaunian plains near Chalons and a place called Maurica, which many scholars put nearer Troyes. His figure of 165,000 dead is impossible. Whether Aetius deliberately let Attila escape to keep the Goths in fear is an ancient suspicion. And where Gibbon and Edward Creasy saw a battle that saved Europe, Bury and later historians call it a check to an army already retreating; Kim reads it as no defeat at all.

What followed

Attila invaded Italy the next year and destroyed Aquileia before turning back after a meeting with an embassy led by Pope Leo I, in an army weakened by famine and disease. He died in 453, on the night of a new marriage, and his subject peoples broke his sons’ power at the river Nedao soon after. Aetius was killed in 454 by Valentinian III with his own hand; Valentinian was murdered by Aetius’s old soldiers the following spring. The western empire had twenty-one years left.

Read further

  • Jordanes, The Gothic History, translated by Charles C. Mierow (1915)
  • Otto Maenchen-Helfen, The World of the Huns (1973)
  • E. A. Thompson, A History of Attila and the Huns (1948)
  • Peter Heather, The Fall of the Roman Empire: A New History (2005)
  • Hyun Jin Kim, The Huns, Rome and the Birth of Europe (2013)

Same day, other years

1756

The Black Hole of Calcutta

Calcutta, BengalAsia

The young Nawab of Bengal, Siraj ud-Daulah, marched on the East India Company’s settlement at Calcutta after it strengthened its fort without his leave, sheltered a fugitive from his court and abused its trading privileges. The governor and many others escaped downriver by ship. When Fort William fell on 20 June, the Europeans left behind were shut overnight in the garrison’s own lock-up, a room about eighteen feet by fourteen with two small barred windows, in the hottest week of the year. John Zephaniah Holwell, the senior survivor, wrote that 146 went in and 23 came out alive.

Seen from elsewhere. Holwell’s is the only detailed account, and Indian historians have long doubted its numbers. Brijen Gupta’s study of the records concluded that about 64 were confined and 21 survived. Nothing shows the Nawab ordered it. The British raised a monument to the dead; it was moved from the city centre in 1940 after a nationalist campaign led by Subhas Chandra Bose.

1789

The Tennis Court Oath

Versailles, FranceEurope

Three days after the deputies of the Third Estate had declared themselves the National Assembly of France, they arrived at their meeting hall at Versailles to find the doors locked and guarded. The official reason was that carpenters were preparing it for a royal session. Suspecting a move to dissolve them, they walked through the rain to a nearby indoor tennis court. There, with the astronomer Jean-Sylvain Bailly presiding from a table, they swore on a motion of Jean-Joseph Mounier not to separate until the kingdom had a constitution. All but one of the 577 present took the oath.

Seen from elsewhere. The one, Joseph Martin-Dauch of Castelnaudary, signed with the word ‘opposant’, saying he could not swear to carry out decisions the king had not sanctioned; Bailly had him let out by a side door for his safety. Louis XVI declared the Assembly’s acts void on 23 June and gave way four days later. Bailly was guillotined in 1793.

1900

The siege of the Peking legations begins

Beijing, ChinaAsia

On the morning of 20 June the German minister, Clemens von Ketteler, set out in a sedan chair for the Qing foreign office and was shot dead in the street by a Manchu soldier. That afternoon Chinese troops and Boxer fighters opened fire on the diplomatic quarter, where some nine hundred foreigners and about three thousand Chinese Christians had barricaded themselves. The court declared war on the foreign powers the next day. The siege lasted fifty-five days, until an eight-nation relief force broke into the city on 14 August. Tens of thousands of Chinese Christians had been killed across north China.

Seen from elsewhere. The Boxers arose in Shandong amid drought, flood and anger at missionaries’ legal privileges and Germany’s seizure of territory. The court acted after foreign warships stormed the Taku forts. The relief force looted Beijing and killed large numbers of civilians in punitive raids; the German emperor had told his troops to make themselves remembered like Attila’s Huns. China today honours the Boxers as patriots.

1973

Gunfire greets Peron’s return at Ezeiza

Buenos Aires, ArgentinaThe Americas

Juan Peron was flying home after almost eighteen years of exile, and a crowd often put at two million or more gathered near Ezeiza airport to welcome him. His movement by then held both a revolutionary left, including the Montonero guerrillas and the Peronist Youth, and a trade-union and nationalist right. As the left’s columns approached the platform where he was to speak, armed men of the right posted on and around it opened fire. Shooting went on for hours. Peron’s aircraft was diverted to a military base. The official count was thirteen dead and several hundred wounded.

Seen from elsewhere. The organisers on the platform said the left had come to seize the stage or kill Peron; the journalist Horacio Verbitsky’s investigation concluded that it was a planned ambush. No court ever established the facts or the true toll. Peron sided with the right, and the death squads and dictatorship of the following years grew from the same division.

Also on 20 June