Parallax

9 June, AD 68

Nero dies in a freedman’s back room

Declared a public enemy by the Senate and abandoned by his guard, the last emperor of Augustus’s line fled Rome in a borrowed cloak and needed his secretary’s help to cut his own throat. Whether he was the monster of the surviving histories is another matter.

A villa outside Rome, between the Via Salaria and the Via Nomentana

By the first week of June in the year 68 Nero had lost the empire without losing a battle. Gaius Julius Vindex, the governor of Gallia Lugdunensis, had risen against him in March and been crushed by the Rhine legions at Vesontio in May. But Servius Sulpicius Galba, the elderly governor of nearer Spain, had also declared against him, the Rhine army had tried to make its own general emperor, and in Rome the Praetorian prefect Nymphidius Sabinus was telling the Guard that Nero had already fled and that Galba would pay each man a fortune for his loyalty. The other prefect, Tigellinus, simply stayed out of sight.

Our fullest account is Suetonius, writing half a century later. He says that Nero thought of sailing to Egypt, of throwing himself on the mercy of Galba, of addressing the people in black from the Rostra. When he asked officers of the Guard to flee with him, one answered with a line of Virgil: ‘Is it so hard a thing to die?’ He woke around midnight to find the palace guard gone, his friends’ doors shut and even the box containing his poison stolen.

The freedman Phaon offered his suburban villa, about four miles from the city. Nero rode there barefoot, in an old cloak with a cloth held over his face, with four companions, among them his secretary Epaphroditus and the eunuch Sporus. They crawled into the house from the back through brambles so as not to be seen. There he ordered a grave dug and, Suetonius says, kept repeating in tears: ‘Qualis artifex pereo’, what an artist dies in me.

A runner brought a letter. The Senate had declared him a public enemy, to be punished ‘in the ancient manner’. He asked what that meant and was told: stripped, his neck held in a wooden fork, and beaten to death with rods. He picked up two daggers, tried their points and put them down. When horses were heard on the road he quoted Homer on the thunder of hooves and then, with Epaphroditus guiding his hand, drove a blade into his throat.

A centurion ran in and pressed a cloak to the wound as if he had come to help. ‘Too late,’ Nero is supposed to have said. ‘This is loyalty.’ He was thirty years old and had ruled for nearly fourteen. Galba’s agent allowed a proper funeral. His old nurses Egloge and Alexandria and his former mistress Acte, a freedwoman he had loved since his teens, carried the ashes to the family tomb of the Domitii on the Pincian hill.

How it came to this

Nero became emperor at sixteen in the year 54, pushed onto the throne by his mother Agrippina, who was widely believed to have poisoned her husband Claudius to clear the way. His first years, guided by the philosopher Seneca and the Guard prefect Burrus, were later remembered as a model of good government. Then the killings began: his stepbrother Britannicus, his mother in 59, his first wife Octavia in 62. Senators who were suspected of plotting were ordered to kill themselves, Seneca among them after the conspiracy of Piso in 65.

What offended the Roman upper class almost as much was that the emperor sang, acted and raced chariots in public, and in 66-67 toured Greece collecting prizes. The great fire of 64 destroyed much of Rome, and on the cleared ground he built the vast Golden House. To deflect blame, Tacitus says, he had the city’s Christians burned and thrown to dogs. Costs rose, the coinage was debased, and provincial governors were squeezed for money. By 68 Britain and Judaea had both seen major revolts, and the men who commanded armies had concluded that an emperor could be made somewhere other than Rome.

How each side saw it

The senatorial historians

Everything we are told about Nero’s last hours comes from Suetonius, Tacitus and Cassius Dio, none of whom was alive at the time, and all of whom wrote under later dynasties that gained from blackening the last of the Julio-Claudians. Tacitus’s own narrative breaks off in the year 66. These authors drew on lost writers of senatorial sympathy, men whose friends and relatives Nero had killed. Their Nero is a matricide, a coward and a bad actor. Even contemporaries were wary: the Jewish historian Josephus remarked that many had written about Nero, some lying from gratitude and others from hatred.

The Roman crowd and the Greek East

Suetonius admits, grudgingly, that for years people laid spring and summer flowers on Nero’s tomb and set up his statues in the Forum. The emperors Otho and Vitellius both honoured his memory to win popular support. In Greece he had announced the province’s freedom from taxation at the Isthmian Games of 67, and Greek writers such as Plutarch and Pausanias found something to say for him. At least three impostors claiming to be Nero appeared in the eastern provinces over the next twenty years and found followers; the Parthian king, with whom Nero had made a lasting peace over Armenia, was slow to hand one of them over.

Christians and Jews

For Christians Nero was the first persecutor. Tacitus describes the executions after the fire of 64, and church tradition, recorded by Tertullian, Lactantius and Eusebius, holds that Peter and Paul died in Rome under him. Many scholars read the number 666 in the Book of Revelation as a Hebrew cipher for ‘Nero Caesar’, and some early Christians expected him to return as the Antichrist. Jewish memory is more mixed. The great revolt of 66 began in his reign, yet a story in the Babylonian Talmud has Nero refuse to destroy Jerusalem, flee, convert to Judaism and become an ancestor of Rabbi Meir.

Modern revisionists

Since the 1980s historians have tried to separate the reign from the legend. Miriam Griffin saw a regime undone by the absence of any agreed rule of succession. Edward Champlin argued that Nero was a deliberate showman whose performances and even crimes were staged with mythological meaning for a public that enjoyed them. John Drinkwater goes further and presents him as a largely passive figure whose court governed competently until money ran out. None of them denies the murders of his mother and wife. What they question is the picture of a mad tyrant hated by everyone, which they regard as the victors’ version.

What is disputed

The date itself is uncertain. Suetonius says Nero died on the anniversary of Octavia’s murder, which is usually taken as 9 June, but the reign lengths given by Cassius Dio and others point to 11 June, and some scholars prefer that. The famous ‘what an artist’ line rests on Suetonius alone, and ‘artifex’ may mean craftsman or performer rather than artist in the modern sense. Tacitus himself doubted that Nero started the fire of 64, and the story that he ‘fiddled’ while Rome burned is impossible as told: he was at Antium when it broke out, and the instrument did not exist. The scale of the persecution of Christians is also debated.

What followed

Galba reached Rome in the autumn and was murdered in the Forum the following January. Otho, Vitellius and Vespasian followed in what became known as the Year of the Four Emperors. Tacitus drew the lesson that ‘the secret of empire’ was out: an emperor could be made by the armies. Vespasian’s new Flavian dynasty filled in the lake of the Golden House and built the Colosseum on the site as a gift to the people. Epaphroditus was later executed by Domitian for having helped an emperor to die. Nero’s name became a byword for tyranny, a reputation that scholars are still arguing about.

Read further

  • Suetonius, The Twelve Caesars: Nero
  • Tacitus, Annals, books 13-16
  • Miriam T. Griffin, Nero: The End of a Dynasty (1984)
  • Edward Champlin, Nero (2003)
  • John F. Drinkwater, Nero: Emperor and Court (2019)

Same day, other years

1898

Britain leases the New Territories for 99 years

Beijing, ChinaAsia

In the scramble for concessions that followed China’s defeat by Japan, Britain pressed the Qing court for more land around Hong Kong, arguing that the colony could not be defended against modern artillery. The convention signed in Beijing on 9 June 1898 by the British minister Sir Claude MacDonald and the veteran statesman Li Hongzhang leased the area north of Kowloon and more than two hundred islands, rent-free, for 99 years from 1 July. It increased the colony’s area roughly tenfold. When British officials arrived to raise the flag in April 1899, village militias fought them for six days; several hundred villagers are thought to have died.

Seen from elsewhere. Chinese governments, Nationalist and Communist alike, classed the convention as an unequal treaty signed under duress and never accepted its validity. MacDonald is said to have thought 99 years ‘as good as forever’. It was not: the lease’s expiry in 1997 made the rest of Hong Kong unworkable alone and forced the return of the whole colony.

1923

A coup overthrows Bulgaria’s peasant government

Sofia, BulgariaEurope

In the early hours of 9 June 1923 army units directed by the Military League seized Sofia and arrested the ministers of Aleksandar Stamboliyski, leader of the Agrarian Union, who had governed Bulgaria since its defeat in the First World War. Stamboliyski had taxed the towns to favour the villages, replaced conscription with compulsory labour service, and sought peace with Yugoslavia, which enraged the Macedonian revolutionary organisation IMRO. He was caught near his home village of Slavovitsa a few days later. His captors tortured him, cut off the hand that had signed the treaty with Belgrade, and killed him on 14 June. Professor Aleksandar Tsankov formed the new government.

Seen from elsewhere. The plotters and the urban parties said they had removed a dictator who ruled through his paramilitary Orange Guard and had rigged the April elections. Agrarians remember a murdered democrat. How much Tsar Boris III knew beforehand is still disputed. The Communists stood aside in June, rose in September on Moscow’s instruction, and were crushed.

1954

‘Have you no sense of decency, sir?’

Washington DC, United StatesThe Americas

For four years Senator Joseph McCarthy of Wisconsin had accused government departments of harbouring Communists. In 1954 he turned on the United States Army, and the resulting Senate hearings were broadcast live on television to millions. On 9 June McCarthy interrupted the Army’s counsel, the Boston lawyer Joseph Welch, to announce that a young man in Welch’s firm, Fred Fisher, had once belonged to the National Lawyers Guild, which he called a Communist front. Welch replied that he had not until then gauged the senator’s cruelty, and asked: ‘Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last?’ The gallery applauded. In December the Senate voted 67 to 22 to condemn McCarthy.

Seen from elsewhere. McCarthy’s defenders note that Welch had himself disclosed Fisher’s past to the press weeks before, so the outrage was partly theatre. Decrypted Soviet cables released in 1995 confirmed that Soviet agents had worked in Washington, though historians such as John Earl Haynes and Harvey Klehr find that McCarthy’s own accusations seldom matched the real cases.

1967

Israel attacks the Golan Heights

Golan Heights, SyriaMiddle East

On the fifth day of the Six-Day War, with Egypt and Jordan already beaten and Syria having accepted a United Nations ceasefire hours earlier, the Israeli defence minister Moshe Dayan reversed his own earlier opposition and ordered an assault on the Syrian plateau overlooking Galilee. He gave the order directly to the northern command early on 9 June, before the prime minister, Levi Eshkol, had been told. Israeli infantry and armour climbed the escarpment under fire, and by the evening of 10 June they held Quneitra and the whole heights. Most of the Syrian population, on various estimates between 80,000 and 130,000 people, fled or were driven out and were not allowed back.

Seen from elsewhere. Israelis pointed to years of Syrian shelling of the farming settlements below. In a 1976 interview published after his death, Dayan said most of those clashes had been provoked by Israel and that the attack was a mistake driven by the kibbutzim’s wish for land. Syria and the UN regard the Golan as occupied territory; Israel applied its law there in 1981.

Also on 9 June