Parallax

17 June, 1775

The hill the British took and could not afford

A night’s digging by New England farmers on the wrong hill cost the British army more than a thousand men in an afternoon, and taught both sides what kind of war they were in.

Charlestown, Massachusetts

After dark on 16 June 1775, Colonel William Prescott led about a thousand Massachusetts and Connecticut men across the narrow neck of the Charlestown peninsula, opposite Boston. Their orders named Bunker Hill. After an argument among the officers that nobody recorded in full, they went past it to the lower rise known as Breed’s Hill, which lay closer to the town and to the guns of the Royal Navy. The engineer Richard Gridley marked out a square redoubt and the men dug until dawn.

At first light the sloop Lively saw fresh earth where there had been pasture and opened fire. In Boston, General Thomas Gage met his three newly arrived major-generals. Henry Clinton argued for landing behind the rebels at the neck and cutting them off. Gage and William Howe preferred a landing at the tip of the peninsula and a direct advance, which was quicker to arrange and, they assumed, sufficient against untrained men. It took until early afternoon to ferry some 2,200 soldiers across.

The delay let the defenders extend their line to the Mystic River with a rail fence stuffed with hay, held by Connecticut men under Thomas Knowlton and New Hampshire men under John Stark. Stark’s men also piled a rough stone wall across the beach. Howe sent his light infantry along that beach to turn the flank. They were shot down at close range in column and did not get through. Charlestown, set alight by heated shot to clear out snipers, burned on the British left while the people of Boston watched from roofs and steeples.

Two frontal assaults on the fence and the redoubt failed under fire held until the range was very short. Howe, who lost every member of his staff killed or wounded, called for reinforcements and tried a third time, with packs off and bayonets fixed. By then the men in the redoubt had almost no powder. The British came over the wall, and the fighting inside was done with musket butts and stones. Joseph Warren, the physician who headed the Massachusetts Provincial Congress and had chosen to serve as a volunteer in the ranks, was shot dead in the retreat. Marine Major John Pitcairn, who had commanded at Lexington, fell on the parapet.

The British held the ground. They had lost 1,054 men killed and wounded, nearly half of those engaged, including more than eighty officers. American losses were around 450. Clinton wrote that it was ‘a dear bought victory, another such would have ruined us’. On the other side Nathanael Greene wished the Americans could sell them another hill at the same price.

How it came to this

Fighting had begun on 19 April, when a British column sent to seize military stores at Concord exchanged fire with militia at Lexington and was harried all the way back to Boston. Within days some fifteen thousand New England militiamen had gathered around the town. They had little artillery, no common commander beyond the ageing Artemas Ward, and enlistments that ran out at the end of the year. Gage, with about 6,500 regulars, was shut into a town on a peninsula and supplied by sea.

Both sides knew that the heights at Charlestown and Dorchester overlooked the harbour. In mid June the Massachusetts Committee of Safety learned that Gage meant to occupy them and decided to move first. In Philadelphia, meanwhile, the Continental Congress had adopted the army around Boston and on 15 June chose George Washington of Virginia to command it. He was still on the road north when the battle was fought, and most delegates still described their aim as the restoration of their rights within the empire, not independence.

How each side saw it

The British command

Gage reported to London that the rebels were not the despicable rabble too many had supposed, and that they had shown a spirit and conduct against the king’s troops that they never showed against the French. John Burgoyne, who watched from Copp’s Hill, described the burning town and the advancing lines in a letter that was printed across Britain. Howe wrote of a moment he had never felt before. The lesson the generals drew was caution: several historians trace Howe’s later reluctance to attack entrenched Americans, at Brooklyn and elsewhere, to that afternoon.

Loyalists in Boston

Perhaps a fifth of white colonists remained loyal to the Crown, and Boston was full of those who had fled the countryside. Anne Hulton, sister of a customs commissioner, wrote home of a town turned into a hospital and of friends killed. Peter Oliver, the exiled chief justice, later described Warren as an ambitious man who had hoped to be a general and died a rebel. For them the battle was not the birth of a nation but the moment a quarrel among British subjects became a civil war in which they would lose homes and country.

Black and Native soldiers in the ranks

Muster rolls studied by later researchers show at least a hundred men of African or Native descent among the defenders, some free, some enslaved. In December 1775 fourteen officers petitioned the Massachusetts legislature to reward Salem Poor, a free Black man, as ‘a brave and gallant soldier’. Tradition credits Peter Salem with the shot that killed Pitcairn, though the evidence is late. Weeks after the battle Washington’s council barred new Black enlistments, a ban partly reversed when the British began offering freedom to the enslaved men of rebel masters.

What is disputed

The name is the first problem: almost all the fighting was on Breed’s Hill, and why Prescott’s party fortified it instead of Bunker Hill is not known. Who was in overall command, Prescott or Israel Putnam, became a bitter public quarrel after Henry Dearborn attacked Putnam’s conduct in print in 1818. The order not to fire ‘until you see the whites of their eyes’ appears in no account written at the time, is credited variously to Putnam, Prescott and Stark, and had been attributed to Prussian officers decades earlier. American casualty figures vary between about 400 and 450 depending on the return used.

What followed

Washington took command at Cambridge on 2 July. Gage was recalled and replaced by Howe in October. The siege ended only when cannon dragged from Fort Ticonderoga were placed on Dorchester Heights, and the British sailed away on 17 March 1776. In London the casualty list hardened opinion: the king proclaimed the colonies in open rebellion in August. The granite obelisk on Breed’s Hill, begun in 1825 with Lafayette laying the cornerstone, still carries the other hill’s name.

Read further

  • Nathaniel Philbrick, Bunker Hill: A City, a Siege, a Revolution (2013)
  • Richard M. Ketchum, Decisive Day: The Battle for Bunker Hill (1974)
  • Paul Lockhart, The Whites of Their Eyes: Bunker Hill, the First American Army, and the Emergence of George Washington (2011)
  • Richard Frothingham, History of the Siege of Boston (1849)
  • Peter Oliver, Origin and Progress of the American Rebellion, edited by Douglass Adair and John A. Schutz (1961)

Same day, other years

1579

Drake claims California for Elizabeth I

Point Reyes coast, CaliforniaThe Americas

Francis Drake brought the Golden Hind, heavy with silver taken from Spanish ships off Peru, into a bay on the coast north of present-day San Francisco to repair her before crossing the Pacific. He stayed about five weeks among the Coast Miwok. According to the account compiled from the notes of his chaplain, Francis Fletcher, the people wept, made long speeches and set a feathered headdress on Drake’s head, which the English took as a surrender of the country. Drake named it Nova Albion and nailed up a brass plate with a sixpence set in it.

Seen from elsewhere. The Miwok left no written account. Anthropologists, notably Robert Heizer, read the wailing and self-laceration the English described as mourning rites, suggesting the visitors were taken for returning dead rather than kings. The landing site is still argued over, and a ‘plate of brass’ found in 1936 was shown in 1977 to be a modern fake.

1631

Mumtaz Mahal dies in childbirth

Burhanpur, IndiaAsia

Arjumand Banu Begum, known by her title Mumtaz Mahal, had travelled with her husband, the Mughal emperor Shah Jahan, on his campaign in the Deccan. At Burhanpur she died after a long labour giving birth to her fourteenth child, a daughter. She was about thirty-eight. Court chroniclers record that the emperor withdrew from public business for a week and that his beard turned white. Her body was buried temporarily in a garden by the Tapti river and carried to Agra six months later, where work began on the tomb that became the Taj Mahal.

Seen from elsewhere. The building absorbed the labour of perhaps twenty thousand workers and vast revenue for some two decades. The stories that the craftsmen’s hands were cut off, and that a black twin was planned across the river, have no support in Mughal records. Claims that the tomb was a converted Hindu temple have been rejected by Indian courts and archaeologists.

1953

Soviet tanks put down a workers’ rising in East Germany

East Berlin and the German Democratic RepublicEurope

Building workers on East Berlin’s showpiece Stalinallee had walked off the job the day before in protest at an order to produce ten per cent more for the same pay. On 17 June strikes and marches spread to several hundred towns and involved around a million people. Demands moved quickly from work norms to free elections and the resignation of the government. Crowds stormed party offices and prisons. By midday the Soviet commandant had declared martial law and sent tanks into the streets. Researchers have confirmed at least fifty-five deaths, and thousands were arrested.

Seen from elsewhere. The ruling party called the day a fascist putsch organised from the West, pointing to broadcasts by the American radio station in West Berlin. West Germany made 17 June a national holiday. Bertolt Brecht, who had publicly backed the party, privately wrote a poem asking whether it would not be simpler for the government to dissolve the people and elect another.

1991

South Africa scraps its race register

Cape Town, South AfricaAfrica

The Population Registration Act of 1950 had required every South African to be classified from birth as white, coloured, Asian or African, and it was the record on which every other apartheid law depended: where a person could live, study, work and whom they could marry. Officials settled doubtful cases by examining hair, skin and speech, and reclassification split families. On 17 June 1991 the white-dominated parliament voted to repeal it, days after ending the Group Areas and Land Acts. President F. W. de Klerk said apartheid now belonged to history.

Seen from elsewhere. The African National Congress replied that the black majority still had no vote, and the existing register stayed in use until a new constitution was agreed. The white Conservative Party voted against, calling repeal a surrender. Nelson Mandela asked foreign governments to keep sanctions in place; democratic elections came three years later.

Also on 17 June