Parallax

10 June, 1190

Barbarossa drowns on the road to Jerusalem

The most powerful ruler in Latin Christendom had marched an army two thousand miles and beaten the Turks in the field. Then he went into a river in southern Anatolia, and the largest force of the Third Crusade fell apart on the bank.

River Saleph (Goksu), near Silifke, Cilicia

Frederick I, Holy Roman Emperor, was about sixty-seven when he left Regensburg in May 1189 at the head of the best organised army yet sent on crusade. He had planned it for a year. Every man had to show he could pay his own way for two seasons; envoys had gone ahead to Hungary, Constantinople and even to the Seljuk sultan at Konya to arrange markets and passage. Modern estimates put the force at perhaps 12,000 to 15,000 men, of whom some 3,000 were knights. Medieval writers spoke of 100,000.

The diplomacy failed almost at once. The Byzantine emperor Isaac II Angelos, who had an understanding with Saladin, imprisoned Frederick’s ambassadors and let his troops harass the column. Frederick occupied Philippopolis, wintered at Adrianople and considered attacking Constantinople itself before Isaac gave way and ferried the Germans across the Dardanelles in March 1190. In Anatolia the sultan’s sons broke their father’s promises. The crusaders, starving and eating their horses, fought their way to Konya and on 18 May stormed the city while the old emperor led the fight outside the walls.

By early June they had crossed the Taurus into the Christian kingdom of Cilician Armenia. On 10 June the army was strung out along the gorge of the Saleph, approaching Seleucia in fierce heat. What happened next is told in several ways. In one version Frederick, impatient with the crush on the mountain track, tried to ford the river on horseback, his horse lost its footing, and he was thrown into the current in his armour. In another he had eaten a meal on the bank and went in to cool himself, and either drowned or was seized by the shock of the cold water. He was pulled out dead or dying.

The effect was immediate. A participant’s account speaks of men who gave up hope there and then; some sailed for home from the Cilician ports, a few are said to have renounced their faith. Frederick’s son, Duke Frederick of Swabia, led the remainder to Antioch, where an epidemic killed many more.

The body was treated by the method later called the German custom. The entrails were buried at Tarsus, and at Antioch the corpse was boiled so that the flesh could be interred in the cathedral of St Peter. The bones were carried on in a bag towards Jerusalem, which the crusade never reached. They were probably buried at Tyre. No one knows where they are now.

How it came to this

Frederick of Hohenstaufen was elected German king in 1152 and crowned emperor in Rome three years later. Italians called him Barbarossa for his red beard. Much of his reign went on trying to make imperial authority real in northern Italy, where rich self-governing cities had stopped paying what the emperors claimed. He razed Milan in 1162, backed a series of antipopes against Alexander III, lost an army to disease outside Rome in 1167, and was beaten by the infantry and cavalry of the Lombard League at Legnano in 1176. He then made peace with the pope at Venice and with the cities at Constance, keeping his title and conceding their autonomy.

In July 1187 Saladin destroyed the army of the kingdom of Jerusalem at Hattin and took the holy city in October. Pope Gregory VIII called a new crusade. Frederick, who had been on the disastrous Second Crusade as a young man forty years before, took the cross at Mainz in March 1188 at an assembly he called the Court of Christ. The kings of France and England would go by sea. He chose the old land road through the Balkans.

How each side saw it

Saladin’s court

Muslim writers record real fear as the Germans approached. Baha al-Din Ibn Shaddad, Saladin’s judge and biographer, copies a letter from the head of the Armenian church warning the sultan of the size and iron discipline of Frederick’s army, and says troops were pulled from the siege lines at Acre to guard the north. The historian Ibn al-Athir of Mosul treats the drowning as a mercy of God: had the German king not died when he did, he wrote, people would one day have said that Syria and Egypt once belonged to the Muslims. He adds, with some scorn, that the water was barely waist deep.

The Byzantines

To Constantinople the crusade was an armed foreign host crossing imperial territory under a ruler who used the title of Roman emperor, which the Byzantines held to be theirs alone. Isaac II had reason for suspicion, since the Normans had sacked Thessalonica only four years earlier. Yet the main Greek witness, Niketas Choniates, who was governor of Philippopolis when the Germans arrived, blames his own emperor for bad faith and foolish prophecies, and writes an admiring obituary of Frederick as a man who left his palace in old age to suffer for Christ. The mistrust of 1189-90 was remembered on both sides when crusaders took Constantinople in 1204.

The Italian cities

In Lombardy Barbarossa was remembered for the destruction of Milan, whose citizens were dispersed and whose walls were pulled down in 1162, and for the hostages said to have been tied to his siege engines at Crema. Communal chronicles celebrated Legnano, where the Milanese defended their carroccio, the ox-drawn war wagon carrying the city’s standard. In the nineteenth century the nationalists of the Risorgimento made the battle a symbol of Italians uniting against a German master. Verdi wrote an opera about it in 1849, and it is named in the Italian national anthem. The emperor of German legend is the foreign tyrant of Italian memory.

The German national tradition

A folk tale held that the emperor was not dead but asleep inside the Kyffhauser hill in Thuringia, his beard grown through a stone table, waiting until ravens ceased to circle the summit. The story was first told of his grandson Frederick II and was transferred to Barbarossa only around 1500. Friedrich Ruckert’s poem of 1817 made it famous, and after unification in 1871 the new empire presented William I as ‘Barbablanca’, the fulfilment of the prophecy, with a colossal monument on the hill. In 1941 Hitler gave the name Barbarossa to the invasion of the Soviet Union.

What is disputed

The sources do not agree on how he died. The crusade history attributed to Ansbert has him trying to swim the river against advice; other Latin accounts have his horse fall; Arabic writers say he went in to bathe. Whether he drowned or suffered heart failure in cold water cannot now be decided. The size of the army is uncertain, and so is the larger question of what it might have done. Many historians think a German force arriving intact at Acre would have changed the Third Crusade; John Freed and others caution that it was already badly worn down. The claim that Legnano was the first victory of infantry over knights is an old exaggeration.

What followed

Only a remnant of the German army reached the siege of Acre, where Frederick of Swabia died in January 1191. Before he died he supported a field hospital founded by merchants from Bremen and Lubeck, which grew into the Teutonic Order. Richard I of England and Philip II of France took Acre, but Jerusalem stayed in Saladin’s hands under the truce of 1192. In Germany Barbarossa’s son Henry VI inherited an empire that added Sicily and then collapsed into civil war on his early death in 1197. The sleeping emperor outlasted them all as a political symbol, used by liberals, monarchists and National Socialists in turn.

Read further

  • G. A. Loud (trans.), The Crusade of Frederick Barbarossa: The History of the Expedition of the Emperor Frederick and Related Texts (2010)
  • John B. Freed, Frederick Barbarossa: The Prince and the Myth (2016)
  • Ibn al-Athir, The Chronicle of Ibn al-Athir for the Crusading Period, translated by D. S. Richards
  • Niketas Choniates, O City of Byzantium: Annals of Niketas Choniates, translated by Harry J. Magoulias (1984)
  • Knut Gorich, Friedrich Barbarossa: Eine Biographie (2011)

Same day, other years

1692

Bridget Bishop is hanged at Salem

Salem, Massachusetts BayThe Americas

Bridget Bishop, a widow three times married and aged about sixty, was the first person tried by the special court set up to deal with the accusations of witchcraft that had spread from Salem Village that spring. She had been charged with witchcraft once before, in 1680. Neighbours now testified that her spectre had tormented them at night, and the afflicted girls fell into fits when she looked at them. At her first examination she said: ‘I am innocent to a witch. I know not what a witch is.’ She was convicted on 2 June and hanged eight days later. Eighteen more people were hanged by September, and one man was pressed to death.

Seen from elsewhere. The judges held that the devil could not take the shape of an innocent person, so visions counted as proof. One judge, Nathaniel Saltonstall, resigned after her execution, and leading ministers urged caution. The court was dissolved in October. A day of public repentance followed in 1697, but Bishop’s own conviction was formally cleared only in 2001.

1838

The Myall Creek massacre

Myall Creek station, New South Wales, AustraliaOceania

On a Sunday afternoon a party of twelve armed stockmen, eleven of them convicts or former convicts led by a free settler’s son, John Fleming, rode into Henry Dangar’s cattle station on the Gwydir frontier. About thirty Wirrayaraay people, mostly women, children and old men, were camped beside the huts under the protection of the station hands. The riders roped them together, led them over a ridge and killed at least twenty-eight with swords and pistols, then burned the bodies. A hut keeper, George Anderson, refused to take part and gave evidence. After one acquittal, seven of the men were retried, convicted and hanged in Sydney that December.

Seen from elsewhere. Much of colonial opinion sided with the killers. Landholders paid for their defence, and the Sydney Herald protested at hanging white men for the deaths of Aboriginal people, who could not themselves testify in court. Fleming was never caught. Historians note that frontier killings continued afterwards but were more carefully hidden. Descendants of victims and perpetrators dedicated a joint memorial in 2000.

1871

American marines storm the forts of Ganghwa

Ganghwa Island, KoreaAsia

Five United States warships under Rear Admiral John Rodgers had anchored off Korea’s west coast in May, carrying the minister to China, Frederick Low, who wanted a treaty and an explanation for the destruction of the American merchant ship General Sherman five years earlier. Korea admitted no Western trade. When shore batteries fired on survey boats in the channel leading to Seoul, Rodgers demanded an apology and, getting none, landed about 650 sailors and marines on 10 June. Over two days they took the island’s forts one by one. Some 240 Korean defenders died at the last citadel, most fighting to the end, for three American dead. The fleet left in July without a treaty.

Seen from elsewhere. Koreans call it Sinmiyangyo, the Western disturbance of 1871, and at the time counted it a success: the foreigners went away. The regent, the Daewongun, set up stone tablets declaring that not to fight invaders was to sell the country. The captured flag of General Eo Jae-yeon stayed at the US Naval Academy until it was lent back in 2007.

1942

Lidice is destroyed

Lidice, BohemiaEurope

Reinhard Heydrich, the SS general governing occupied Bohemia and Moravia, died on 4 June 1942 of wounds from an attack by two parachutists sent from Britain by the Czechoslovak government in exile. Hitler ordered reprisals. On a thin and mistaken lead the Gestapo fixed on the mining village of Lidice, north-west of Prague. On 10 June police shot 173 men and boys over fifteen in batches against a barn wall padded with mattresses. The women were sent to Ravensbruck. Of the village’s children, 82 were gassed at Chelmno and a handful were given to German families. The buildings were burned, dynamited and levelled, and the name was removed from maps.

Seen from elsewhere. Unlike most such crimes, this one was announced by German radio as a warning. It had the opposite effect: towns from Mexico to Illinois took the name Lidice, and Britain repudiated the Munich agreement that August. Czechs have argued ever since over whether the assassination, which the home resistance had begged London to call off, was worth about 5,000 lives taken in reprisal.

Also on 10 June