Parallax

23 June, 1314

Bannockburn: the first day

A king on a pony killed an English knight with one blow of an axe in front of both armies. By the next evening the largest force England had sent north in a generation was scattered and Edward II was running for a boat.

Near Stirling, Scotland

On the afternoon of Sunday 23 June 1314, the eve of the feast of St John, the leading division of an English army came up the old Roman road towards Stirling Castle. It had covered the twenty miles from Edinburgh to Falkirk the day before and had pushed on again in the heat. Ahead, where the road entered the woodland of the New Park beyond the stream called the Bannock Burn, Robert Bruce, King of Scots, had drawn up his men and dug the open ground on either side with small pits covered with brushwood to break up a charge.

Bruce was out in front of his line ordering his spearmen, mounted on a small riding horse and carrying only an axe, with a gold circlet on his helmet. An English knight, Sir Henry de Bohun, nephew of the Earl of Hereford, recognised him, lowered his lance and charged. Bruce turned his pony aside at the last moment, stood in his stirrups and brought the axe down through de Bohun’s helmet and skull. According to the poet John Barbour, when his captains rebuked him for the risk, he said only that he was sorry to have broken a good axe. The Scots then drove the English vanguard back across the burn.

Meanwhile about three hundred English cavalry under Robert Clifford and Henry Beaumont rode round by the low ground to the east to reach the castle. Thomas Randolph, Earl of Moray, brought a body of spearmen out of the wood to block them. The horsemen could not break the ring of spears and were beaten off with loss. Sir Thomas Gray was captured there; his son later wrote down what his father told him of it.

The English spent the short night in the wet flat land of the carse, between the Bannock Burn and the River Forth, watering their horses and expecting a night attack. Bruce considered withdrawing. A Scottish knight in English service, Sir Alexander Seton, crossed over in the dark and told him the enemy were discouraged and could be beaten.

At dawn on the 24th the Scots did what infantry were not supposed to do: they came down out of the wood and advanced on the cavalry. They knelt to pray, and Edward II is said to have thought they were begging mercy. The young Earl of Gloucester charged and was killed among the spears. The English, packed between stream and river, had no room to deploy their archers or their numbers. When the line broke, Edward was led from the field, was refused entry at Stirling, and rode sixty miles to Dunbar, where he found a ship.

How it came to this

The death of Alexander III in 1286, and then of his granddaughter and heir, left the Scottish throne disputed. Edward I of England was invited to judge between the claimants and used the role to assert lordship over the kingdom. He invaded in 1296, deposed the king he had chosen, John Balliol, and carried off the Stone of Scone. Risings under William Wallace and others followed. In February 1306 Robert Bruce, grandson of one of the original claimants, killed his rival John Comyn in a church at Dumfries and had himself crowned at Scone six weeks later.

He was defeated within months, three of his brothers were executed and his wife and daughter were imprisoned. Edward I died in 1307 on his way north. Against his less warlike son, Bruce avoided battle, destroyed his Scottish enemies the Comyns, and took the English-held castles one by one by surprise and scaling ladders. By spring 1314 Stirling was almost the last. Its commander agreed with Bruce’s brother Edward to surrender if no relieving army came within three miles by Midsummer Day. That bargain obliged Edward II to march and Bruce to face him.

How each side saw it

English chroniclers

The anonymous author of the Life of Edward II, writing soon after, blamed pride: the English lords quarrelled over who should lead the vanguard and despised an enemy on foot, and he compared the disaster to the defeat of French knighthood by Flemish townsmen at Courtrai in 1302. The Lanercost chronicle describes men and horses drowning in the burn. Thomas Gray’s Scalacronica preserves his father’s soldierly memory of the first day. A Carmelite friar, Robert Baston, brought north to celebrate the expected victory in Latin verse, was captured and made to write a poem on the English defeat as his ransom.

The Scottish national tradition

The fullest account is Barbour’s long poem The Bruce, written about 1375 for Bruce’s grandson Robert II. It supplies the speeches, the duel and the famous lines in praise of freedom, and it is sixty years later than the events and frankly heroic. The Declaration of Arbroath of 1320, a letter from Scottish barons to the pope, states the principle in whose name later generations read the battle: that they fought not for glory or riches but for freedom alone. Bannockburn became the central scene of Scottish patriotic memory, from Burns’s song Scots Wha Hae to the modern anthem Flower of Scotland.

Bruce’s Scottish enemies

Many Scots fought against Bruce or stood aside. To the Comyns, the MacDougalls of Argyll and adherents of the Balliol line he was a usurper who had committed murder on consecrated ground, for which the pope excommunicated him. Scottish knights rode in Edward II’s army. After the victory a parliament at Cambuskenneth in November 1314 declared forfeit the lands of all who had not come into his peace. The families so dispossessed, known as the Disinherited, returned with English backing in 1332 and reopened the war. Their side of the story survives mainly in English records.

What is disputed

The site of the main battle is not agreed: older accounts put it on the higher dry ground, most recent ones on the carse, and archaeology before the 2014 anniversary found very little. Medieval figures of 100,000 English are fantasy; modern estimates are perhaps 15,000 to 20,000 against 6,000 or so Scots, with wide margins. Barbour’s tale that camp followers, the ‘small folk’, decided the day by appearing on a hill is doubted, as is his dating of the Stirling agreement to a full year earlier. The story that Knights Templar fought for Bruce has no medieval source at all.

What followed

Captured English lords were exchanged for Bruce’s wife, daughter and sister, held since 1306. The battle did not end the war: Edward II refused to recognise Bruce, and Scottish armies raided the north of England and invaded Ireland for years. Only after Edward’s deposition did an English government concede Scottish independence, in the Treaty of Edinburgh-Northampton of 1328. Bruce died the next year. The battle’s seventh centenary in 2014 fell three months before a referendum in which Scots voted to remain in the United Kingdom.

Read further

  • G. W. S. Barrow, Robert Bruce and the Community of the Realm of Scotland (1965)
  • Michael Brown, Bannockburn: The Scottish War and the British Isles, 1307-1323 (2008)
  • John Barbour, The Bruce, edited by A. A. M. Duncan (1997)
  • Michael Penman, Robert the Bruce: King of the Scots (2014)
  • Vita Edwardi Secundi, edited by Wendy R. Childs (2005)

Same day, other years

1757

Plassey

Palashi, BengalAsia

Robert Clive, with about three thousand men of the East India Company, two-thirds of them Indian sepoys, faced the army of Siraj ud-Daulah, Nawab of Bengal, perhaps fifty thousand strong, beside a mango grove on the Bhagirathi river. The outcome had been arranged beforehand. Clive held a secret agreement with the Nawab’s commander, Mir Jafar, and with the great banking house of the Jagat Seths. A rainstorm soaked the Nawab’s powder, his best general was killed, and the larger part of his army stood idle. The Company lost about twenty dead. Siraj fled and was murdered; Mir Jafar was made Nawab and paid enormous sums to the Company and to Clive.

Seen from elsewhere. In Bengal the day is remembered as a betrayal, not a battle, and Mir Jafar’s name is a byword for traitor. Historians differ on whether the plot grew from a crisis within the Nawab’s court or was driven by the Company, as Sushil Chaudhury argues. Company rule followed, and a famine in 1770 killed perhaps a third of Bengal’s people.

1894

A congress in Paris votes to revive the Olympic Games

Paris, FranceEurope

Pierre de Coubertin, a French baron convinced that sport on the English public-school model would strengthen his country’s youth, called a congress at the Sorbonne, nominally to discuss amateurism. On its final day, 23 June, the delegates voted unanimously to hold international games every four years in the manner of ancient Olympia and set up a committee to organise them. The Greek writer Demetrios Vikelas became its first president. The first Games were held in Athens in April 1896 with some 240 competitors, all of them men, from about fourteen countries.

Seen from elsewhere. Coubertin opposed women competing and said so for the rest of his life. The amateur rule he championed kept out those who could not afford to train unpaid. Greeks point to the Olympic revivals funded by Evangelis Zappas in Athens from 1859, and the English to William Penny Brookes’s games at Much Wenlock, both of which Coubertin knew.

1908

The Shah’s Cossacks shell Iran’s parliament

Tehran, IranMiddle East

Iran’s constitutional revolution had forced the creation of a parliament, the Majles, in 1906. Mohammad Ali Shah, who came to the throne months later, resented it from the start. On 23 June 1908 the Persian Cossack Brigade, an Iranian force under Russian officers led by Colonel Vladimir Liakhov, surrounded the parliament building in Tehran and bombarded it with artillery. Defenders and bystanders were killed, the assembly was dissolved, and leading constitutionalists, among them the preacher Malek al-Motakallemin and the editor Mirza Jahangir Khan, were strangled in the royal garden. Tabriz held out, and constitutionalist forces retook Tehran and deposed the Shah a year later.

Seen from elsewhere. The Shah’s party included the senior cleric Sheikh Fazlollah Nuri, who held that a constitution copied from Europe put man-made law above the sharia. He was hanged by the victors in 1909 and is honoured in the Islamic Republic today. Russia and Britain had agreed in 1907 to divide Iran into spheres of influence.

1985

Air India Flight 182 is bombed over the Atlantic

Off the coast of IrelandWorldwide

A Boeing 747 flying from Montreal to London on its way to Delhi broke up at 31,000 feet off south-west Ireland when a bomb exploded in the forward hold. All 329 people aboard were killed, among them more than eighty children; most were Canadians of Indian origin. The device had been checked in at Vancouver in a suitcase without a passenger. Less than an hour earlier a second suitcase from Vancouver had exploded at Tokyo’s Narita airport, killing two baggage handlers. Investigators traced both to Sikh militants in British Columbia seeking revenge for the Indian army’s assault on the Golden Temple in 1984.

Seen from elsewhere. Only one man, the bomb-maker Inderjit Singh Reyat, was ever convicted; two others were acquitted in 2005. A Canadian inquiry in 2010 found a cascading series of errors by police and intelligence, including erased wiretaps. Families said Canada had treated the attack as a foreign tragedy; the prime minister apologised that year.

Also on 23 June