Parallax

6 June, 1861

Cavour dies eleven weeks after making Italy

The Piedmontese count who outmanoeuvred emperors, popes and Garibaldi to unite a peninsula he had barely visited fell ill with a fever, was bled by his doctors, and was dead in a week at 50.

Turin, Italy

Camillo Benso, Count of Cavour, came home from parliament on the evening of 29 May 1861 feeling unwell, and in the night was seized by vomiting and a violent fever. He was the first prime minister of a Kingdom of Italy that had been proclaimed only on 17 March. He held the foreign ministry as well, slept little, and for months had been working without rest on the absorption of the south.

He had been through a bruising spring. On 18 April Giuseppe Garibaldi, in red shirt and grey poncho, had risen in the chamber to accuse him of treating the volunteers who conquered the south with contempt and of having tried to provoke a fratricidal war. The sitting broke up in uproar. Cavour, white with anger, kept his answer civil. The king arranged a stiff reconciliation a few days later, but friends thought the scene had shaken him badly.

His physicians treated the fever as medicine then prescribed: they opened a vein. Over the next days they bled him again and again, five times or more, until, one account says, the blood would hardly flow. He rallied and received his ministers at his bedside, then relapsed into delirium. In it he talked of business: Naples, the railways, the loans. His niece, Giuseppina Alfieri, who nursed him, recorded that he kept returning to the southerners, saying that they must not be ruled by a state of siege, since anyone could govern that way.

On 5 June Victor Emmanuel came to the family palace and sat with him. Cavour had long before arranged with a Franciscan, Fra Giacomo da Poirino, the parish priest, that he would not be refused the sacraments as a friend of his had been. The friar came, heard him, and gave him absolution and the last rites, although the makers of the new kingdom lay under papal excommunication. To him Cavour is said to have repeated his political formula: a free Church in a free State.

He died at about seven on the morning of 6 June. The shops of Turin closed, and the funeral drew a crowd unlike any the city had seen. The king offered burial among the royal tombs at Superga; the family took him instead to the village church at Santena, where he lies in the family vault.

How it came to this

Cavour was born in Turin in 1810, a younger son of the Piedmontese nobility, in a city then annexed to Napoleon’s France. French was his first language and he spoke Italian carefully, as something learned. After a short army career he travelled in Britain and France, studied their parliaments, banks and railways, and made a fortune from scientific farming. He founded a newspaper called Il Risorgimento in 1847 and became prime minister of Piedmont-Sardinia in 1852.

His method was to make Italy a problem for the great powers. He sent Piedmontese troops to the Crimea to earn a seat at the peace table, and in 1858 met Napoleon III secretly at Plombieres to plan a war that would drive Austria from the north. The war of 1859 won Lombardy; central Italy voted to join; and Nice and Savoy went to France as the price. When Garibaldi unexpectedly conquered Sicily and Naples in 1860, Cavour sent the royal army south through the Papal States to meet him, taking control before the revolution could reach Rome. He never went further south than Tuscany.

How each side saw it

Garibaldi, Mazzini and the democrats

To the republicans Cavour was the man who captured a national revolution for a dynasty. Mazzini, under sentence of death in Piedmont throughout, held that he had made not Italy but a larger Piedmont. Garibaldi could not forgive the cession of Nice, his birthplace, bargained away to a French emperor, nor the disbanding of his southern army with few of its officers taken into the regular service. Both men held that Cavour had stopped the movement short of Rome and Venice out of fear of the people who had made it. Garibaldi’s memoirs remain the sharpest statement of that grievance.

The papacy

Pius IX saw in Cavour the author of laws that dissolved religious houses in Piedmont in 1855 and of the invasion that stripped the Church of most of its territory in 1860. The pope had excommunicated all who took part in that seizure. Cavour’s deathbed absolution, given without a formal retraction, was treated in Rome as a scandal: Fra Giacomo was summoned to explain himself and removed from his parish when he would not disclose what had passed. Catholic writers of the time read the minister’s sudden death, weeks after he had declared Rome the future capital, as a judgement.

The south

Southern critics, from Bourbon loyalists in 1861 to the meridionalisti who studied the region’s poverty later in the century, argue that unification under Cavour meant annexation: Piedmont’s laws, tariffs, taxes, conscription and officials were extended wholesale to a society he had never seen. Free trade exposed southern workshops to northern competition, and the Bourbon debt and gold reserve were merged into the national accounts. Defenders reply that he died before he could shape policy there and that his last recorded words on the subject urged restraint. The war against the so-called brigands was fought by his successors.

What is disputed

The illness is usually identified as malaria, picked up on the family’s rice lands, made fatal by repeated bleeding; rumours of poison circulated at once and have never been supported. His last words are variously reported, and the fullest version, including the phrases about Italy being made and a free Church in a free State, comes from his niece’s later account. Historians dispute how far he planned unification at all. Denis Mack Smith portrayed an improviser who had earlier dismissed Italian unity as nonsense and who tried to obstruct Garibaldi’s expedition; Rosario Romeo’s multi-volume biography presents a consistent liberal statesman.

What followed

No successor matched him. The governments that followed ruled the south through generals during a five-year rural war that killed thousands, added Venetia in 1866 through Prussia’s victory and took Rome in 1870 when the French garrison left. The pope declared himself a prisoner in the Vatican, and the quarrel between Church and state that Cavour had hoped to settle by negotiation lasted until 1929. The gap between north and south, which widened after unification, has remained the central question of Italian public life.

Read further

  • Denis Mack Smith, Cavour (1985)
  • Denis Mack Smith, Cavour and Garibaldi 1860: A Study in Political Conflict (1954)
  • Rosario Romeo, Cavour e il suo tempo (1969-84)
  • Harry Hearder, Cavour (1994)
  • Derek Beales and Eugenio F. Biagini, The Risorgimento and the Unification of Italy (2002)

Same day, other years

1674

Shivaji is crowned at Raigad

Raigad, Maharashtra, IndiaAsia

Shivaji Bhonsle had spent thirty years carving a Maratha state out of the hill forts of western India, at the expense of the sultanate of Bijapur and the Mughal empire of Aurangzeb. On 6 June 1674, by the calendar the English then used, he had himself consecrated as Chhatrapati, sovereign king, in his mountain capital of Raigad. The rites were conducted by Gaga Bhatt, a renowned pandit brought from Varanasi, and included a weighing of the king against gold and the pouring of water from sacred rivers. An English envoy from Bombay, Henry Oxinden, attended and left a description. The ceremony announced an independent Hindu kingship where none had been proclaimed for generations.

Seen from elsewhere. Local Brahmins had objected that Shivaji’s family were not of the warrior caste, and a Rajput genealogy was supplied before the rite. Mughal chroniclers such as Khafi Khan treated him as a rebel. He is now claimed at once by Hindu nationalists, by Maharashtrian regional pride and by anti-caste writers who stress his peasant following.

1944

The Allies land in Normandy

Normandy, FranceEurope

Shortly after midnight on 6 June 1944 British and American airborne troops dropped at either end of a fifty-mile stretch of the Normandy coast. From half past six, after a naval bombardment, infantry came ashore on five beaches from nearly 7,000 vessels: Americans at Utah and Omaha, British at Gold and Sword, Canadians at Juno. About 156,000 men landed that day. At Omaha, where the preliminary bombing had missed and the defenders held the bluffs, the first waves were cut down at the waterline. By nightfall the Allies held a shallow foothold at a cost of roughly 10,000 casualties, some 4,400 of them dead. German losses are estimated at 4,000 to 9,000.

Seen from elsewhere. About 3,000 French civilians died on the day itself and some 20,000 in the Normandy campaign, most under Allied bombs; Caen and Saint-Lo were levelled. In Soviet and Russian accounts the landing was a long-delayed second front, opened when the Red Army had already broken the bulk of German strength in the east.

1982

Israel invades Lebanon

Southern LebanonMiddle East

On 3 June 1982 gunmen of the Abu Nidal faction, a sworn enemy of Yasser Arafat, shot and gravely wounded Israel’s ambassador in London. Israel bombed Palestinian targets in Lebanon, the Palestine Liberation Organisation shelled northern Israel, and on 6 June Israeli forces crossed the border in an operation named Peace for Galilee. The cabinet had been told the aim was a zone about 40 kilometres deep. The defence minister, Ariel Sharon, pressed on to Beirut and besieged its western half for two months, until the PLO’s fighters left by sea. In September Lebanese Christian militiamen, admitted by the Israeli army, massacred Palestinians and others in the Sabra and Shatila camps.

Seen from elsewhere. Israel’s government said it was ending attacks on its northern towns; Menachem Begin himself later called it a war of choice, and an Israeli inquiry found Sharon indirectly responsible for the massacre. Lebanese sources count more than 17,000 dead in 1982. The occupation of the south, which lasted until 2000, gave rise to Hezbollah.

1984

The Indian Army storms the Golden Temple

Amritsar, Punjab, IndiaAsia

Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale, a Sikh preacher whose armed followers were blamed for a wave of killings in Punjab, had fortified the Golden Temple complex, the holiest site of Sikhism, with the help of a former general. Indira Gandhi’s government sent in the army. Operation Blue Star began with a siege in the first days of June, at a time when the shrine was full of pilgrims for a martyrdom anniversary. On the night of 5 June infantry attacked and were shot down in the marble courtyards, and before dawn on the 6th tanks were brought in to shell the Akal Takht, the seat of Sikh temporal authority. Bhindranwale was found dead in its ruins.

Seen from elsewhere. The government counted 493 militants and civilians and 83 soldiers killed; Sikh organisations and independent observers put the civilian dead in the thousands. Most Sikhs, including many who opposed Bhindranwale, saw a desecration. That October Mrs Gandhi was shot by two Sikh bodyguards, and mobs killed about 3,000 Sikhs in Delhi.

Also on 6 June