Parallax

9 August, 48 BC

Caesar breaks Pompey on the plain of Thessaly

Outnumbered two to one and close to starving, Julius Caesar won the Roman civil war in a single morning with six hidden cohorts. Looking at the dead, he said they had asked for it.

Near Pharsalus, Thessaly, Greece

For several mornings in the summer of 48 BC Julius Caesar drew up his army on the plain of Thessaly and offered battle, and for several mornings Pompey kept his own much larger army on the slopes below his camp and declined. Pompey’s plan was sound. Caesar had been beaten at Dyrrhachium on the Adriatic coast a few weeks earlier, his men were living on what they could strip from a hostile countryside, and time and hunger could finish him without risk. On the morning Caesar gave up and ordered his tents struck, he saw that the enemy line had at last come down on to level ground.

Pompey had been pushed into it. His camp was full of senators who had left Rome with him, and they were tired of waiting. They called him Agamemnon, king of kings, and hinted that he was prolonging the war because he enjoyed commanding former consuls. According to Caesar, who is not a neutral witness, they were already quarrelling over who would inherit his office of chief priest.

The numbers favoured Pompey. Caesar gives himself 22,000 legionaries and 1,000 horsemen against 45,000 infantry and 7,000 cavalry. Pompey anchored his right on the river Enipeus and massed nearly all his cavalry on the left under Titus Labienus, who had been Caesar’s best officer in Gaul. They were to sweep away Caesar’s few horsemen and come in behind his line. Caesar saw the danger and took six cohorts out of his third line to form a fourth, hidden behind his right wing, with orders to use their javelins as stabbing spears rather than throw them.

Pompey told his infantry to stand and receive the charge, hoping the Caesarians would arrive out of breath. Caesar’s veterans, running forward and seeing that nobody came to meet them, halted of their own accord, recovered and dressed their ranks, then went in. A veteran centurion named Crastinus led the first rush after promising Caesar that he would earn his thanks that day, alive or dead; he was killed by a sword thrust through the mouth. On the flank Labienus’s cavalry drove Caesar’s horse back as planned, and then ran into the fourth line. The horsemen broke and fled for the hills. The six cohorts cut down the archers and slingers left behind and swung into the rear of Pompey’s left. Caesar sent in his fresh third line at the same moment.

Pompey did not wait for the end. He rode back to camp and sat in his tent until the enemy were on the rampart, then changed his general’s cloak for plain clothes and left by the rear gate for Larissa and the coast. Caesar’s men found the camp prepared for a victory dinner, with tables laid, silver plate set out and tents shaded with ivy. Looking over the dead, Caesar is reported by an officer who was there, Asinius Pollio, to have said: ‘They would have it so. After all I had achieved, I, Gaius Caesar, would have been condemned in the courts if I had not asked my army for help.’

How it came to this

Caesar and Pompey had been partners for a decade. With Crassus they had formed the private alliance later called the First Triumvirate in 60 BC, and Pompey had married Caesar’s daughter Julia. Julia died in 54 BC and Crassus was killed fighting the Parthians at Carrhae the following year. While Caesar spent nine years conquering Gaul and growing rich and popular, Pompey drifted towards the conservative senators around Cato, who were determined to prosecute Caesar the moment he laid down his command and lost his legal immunity.

In January 49 BC the Senate ordered Caesar to disband his army. He crossed the Rubicon, the boundary of his province, with a single legion instead. Pompey abandoned Italy for Greece, where he could draw on the money, ships and client kings of the East. Caesar first disposed of Pompey’s legions in Spain, then crossed the Adriatic in midwinter with too few ships and tried to pen Pompey against the sea at Dyrrhachium. Pompey broke the siege lines in July 48 BC, and Caesar withdrew inland to Thessaly with Pompey following.

How each side saw it

Caesar, in his own account

Almost everything known about the battle goes back to Caesar’s Civil War, written within a few years as a defence of his conduct. In it he is the reluctant combatant who offered peace repeatedly and was refused by a clique of arrogant nobles. His enemies are greedy and overconfident, his soldiers disciplined, his own losses 200 men and thirty centurions against 15,000 Pompeian dead. He stresses the mercy he showed to those who surrendered, and later writers add that he burned Pompey’s captured letters unread. Modern readers treat the tactical narrative as broadly reliable and the politics and the figures as advocacy.

The senators in Pompey’s camp, through Cicero

Cicero had followed Pompey to Greece out of loyalty and was at Dyrrhachium, unwell, during the battle. His letters to Atticus and others in the following months are the nearest thing to a view from inside the losing side, and it is not flattering. He believed the Republic’s cause was the lawful one and Caesar a criminal, yet he was appalled by his own party: by the talk of confiscations and lists of the condemned, and by threats against anyone who had stayed neutral in Italy. Whoever won, he concluded, the result would be a master. He went home and accepted Caesar’s pardon.

Republican memory: Lucan

Under the emperor Nero, a century later, the young poet Lucan wrote an epic on the civil war, often called the Pharsalia, in which the battle is the day Roman liberty died. Caesar is a force of destruction who feasts within sight of the unburied dead, Pompey a faded great man, Cato the only hero. Lucan was forced to kill himself in AD 65 after joining a plot against Nero. His poem carried the republican reading through the Middle Ages and into the political thought of the English, American and French revolutions, where Caesar served as the pattern of a tyrant.

The Greeks on whose land it was fought

The war was Roman, but it was fought across Greek farmland by armies that ate what they found. Days before the battle Caesar’s troops stormed and sacked Gomphi, a Thessalian town that had shut its gates to him, as a deliberate warning; the next town opened its gates on hearing the news. Pompey’s army included contingents levied from Greece, Asia Minor, Syria and the client kingdoms, whose losses nobody counted. No account from the Greek cities survives. We know of Gomphi from Caesar himself and from Plutarch and Appian, Greeks writing under Roman rule long afterwards from Roman sources.

What is disputed

The date 9 August comes from Roman calendar inscriptions, but the republican calendar had drifted badly and the battle probably fell in June by the solar year; reconstructions differ by weeks. Caesar never names the place. Later writers say Pharsalus or ‘Old Pharsalus’, and scholars still argue over whether the armies fought north or south of the Enipeus. The casualty figures are Caesar’s; Asinius Pollio, who fought there, put the Pompeian dead at 6,000. Caesar’s order to spare fellow citizens is in Suetonius and Appian but not in his own narrative. Whether Pompey chose to fight or was bullied into it rests largely on hostile testimony.

What followed

Pompey sailed to Egypt hoping for help from the young Ptolemy XIII and was stabbed to death as he stepped ashore near Pelusium on 28 September. Caesar, arriving days later, was shown his head and signet ring. The war went on in Africa and Spain until 45 BC, and Caesar was murdered a year after that by men who included Brutus, pardoned after Pharsalus. The settlement that finally emerged under his heir Octavian kept the forms of the Republic and ended its substance. Pharsalus became the standard example of the day a free state was lost, or rescued from a corrupt oligarchy, depending on the writer.

Read further

  • Julius Caesar, The Civil War, translated by John Carter (1997)
  • Plutarch, Life of Pompey and Life of Caesar
  • Lucan, Civil War, translated by Susanna Braund (1992)
  • Adrian Goldsworthy, Caesar: The Life of a Colossus (2006)
  • Robin Seager, Pompey the Great: A Political Biography (2002)

Same day, other years

AD 378

The Goths destroy a Roman army at Adrianople

Adrianople (Edirne), ThraceEurope

Two years earlier the emperor Valens had allowed Gothic refugees fleeing the Huns to cross the Danube, and Roman officials had then starved and cheated them into revolt. On a hot afternoon outside Adrianople, Valens attacked the Gothic wagon camp without waiting for the western army under his nephew Gratian, which was only days away. The Gothic cavalry, absent foraging when the fight began, returned in the middle of it and struck the Roman flank. The infantry were pressed together so tightly that men could not raise their swords. Valens died on the field with perhaps two thirds of his army, and his body was never identified.

Seen from elsewhere. The Goths left no account. The story is told by Ammianus Marcellinus, a former Roman officer who blamed corrupt officials and an emperor jealous of his nephew. Nicene Christians such as Ambrose saw divine punishment of an Arian ruler. Historians disagree about the scale of the losses and now reject the old idea that the day proved cavalry superior to infantry.

1814

The Creek nation signs away 23 million acres

Fort Jackson, AlabamaThe Americas

After crushing the Red Stick faction of the Creek nation at Horseshoe Bend in March 1814, General Andrew Jackson summoned Creek leaders to a fort near the Coosa River in what is now Alabama and dictated terms. The treaty took some 23 million acres, about half of all Creek land, across Alabama and southern Georgia. Almost all the chiefs who signed belonged to the Creek towns that had fought beside Jackson against the Red Sticks, and much of the land taken was theirs. Jackson told them the cession was the price of a war their nation had started. The territory was soon opened to cotton planters and the enslaved people they brought with them.

Seen from elsewhere. The allied chiefs, led by Big Warrior, protested that they were being punished for their loyalty, and signed because they saw no alternative. Jackson and frontier settlers regarded the cession as security against British and Spanish intrigue. Within a generation the remaining Creeks were removed west of the Mississippi.

1945

The second atomic bomb falls on Nagasaki

Nagasaki, JapanAsia

The second atomic bomb was meant for the arsenal city of Kokura. Finding it hidden by smoke and haze, the B-29 Bockscar, short of fuel, flew on to its secondary target and released a plutonium bomb through a gap in the cloud at 11.02 am. It exploded over the Urakami valley, north of the city centre, close to the Mitsubishi arms works and to the cathedral of Japan’s largest Catholic community. Estimates of the dead by the end of 1945 range from about 40,000 to more than 70,000, among them Korean forced labourers and Allied prisoners of war. The Soviet Union had invaded Japanese-held Manchuria hours earlier. Japan surrendered six days later.

Seen from elsewhere. American leaders held that the bombs ended the war and spared an invasion. Critics ask why a second city was destroyed three days after the first, before Tokyo had absorbed the news; Tsuyoshi Hasegawa and others argue that Soviet entry weighed more with Japan’s leaders. Survivors, the hibakusha, have campaigned for abolition ever since.

1965

Singapore leaves Malaysia

Singapore and Kuala LumpurAsia

Singapore had joined the new federation of Malaysia in 1963, and the union lasted less than two years. Lee Kuan Yew’s People’s Action Party campaigned for a ‘Malaysian Malaysia’ with equal standing for all races; the ruling Malay party in Kuala Lumpur saw this as an attack on the constitutional position of the Malays. Communal riots in Singapore in 1964 killed dozens. On 9 August 1965 the Malaysian parliament voted 126 to nil to separate the island, with Singapore’s members absent, and Lee announced independence on television, breaking off in tears. The new state had no hinterland, almost no army and drew much of its water from Malaysia.

Seen from elsewhere. The Malaysian prime minister, Tunku Abdul Rahman, said he had cut Singapore loose to prevent bloodshed. For decades the event was described as an expulsion. Papers and memoirs released since show that Lee’s ministers, led by Goh Keng Swee, negotiated the break in secret with their Malaysian counterparts.

Also on 9 August