Parallax

13 August, 1704

Marlborough and Eugene destroy a French army on the Danube

A general of fifty-four who had never commanded in a great battle marched an army across Europe in secret and, in one August afternoon, ended forty years of French invincibility.

Blindheim (Blenheim), Bavaria

At two in the morning on 13 August 1704 some 52,000 men in nine columns began to move west along the north bank of the Danube through a ground mist. They were Danes, Hessians, Prussians, Hanoverians, Dutch and Austrians; fewer than a quarter came from the British Isles. Their commander, John Churchill, Duke of Marlborough, was fifty-four and had never fought a great battle as commander-in-chief. Beside him rode Prince Eugene of Savoy, the emperor’s best general, who had.

A few miles ahead, the army of Marshal Tallard and the Elector of Bavaria, about 56,000 French and Bavarians, lay in camp behind a marshy stream called the Nebel, its right resting on the Danube at the village of Blindheim. Tallard thought the position so strong that when the columns appeared at dawn he took them for an army moving off to the north. He was finishing a letter to Louis XIV saying so when the guns began.

It took Eugene until past midday to work his wing through woods and broken ground to face the Elector and Marshal Marsin on the far flank. Marlborough’s men lay down under cannon fire for hours while they waited, and the Duke had divine service read and rode along the line. At about half past twelve Lord Cutts led the English brigades against Blindheim. They were thrown back from the palisades with heavy loss. But the attack did what was needed. The French officer in charge of the village, the Marquis de Clerambault, took alarm and pulled in the reserve infantry behind it until twenty-seven battalions, some 12,000 men, were crammed into the streets and gardens, too tightly packed to use their muskets.

That left Tallard’s centre, nearly a mile of open stubble, held mostly by cavalry. Through the afternoon Marlborough passed his own centre across the Nebel on bundles of brushwood and pontoon bridges, horse and foot interleaved, beating off charges that at one moment nearly broke him; Eugene, hard pressed himself, sent a brigade of heavy cavalry at once when asked. A little after five the Duke ordered the whole line forward at a trot. The French cavalry fired from the saddle, wavered and broke. Thousands were driven over the steep bank into the Danube and drowned. Tallard, who was short-sighted, rode into a Hessian squadron and was taken.

Marlborough borrowed a pencil and wrote to his wife Sarah on the back of a tavern bill: ‘I have not time to say more, but to beg you will give my duty to the Queen, and let her know her army has had a glorious victory.’ The troops shut up in Blindheim held out until nine that night and then surrendered, some regiments burning their colours first. The Franco-Bavarian army had lost well over 30,000 men, around 14,000 of them prisoners; the allies about 12,000 killed and wounded.

How it came to this

Charles II of Spain died childless in 1700 and left his whole empire to Philip of Anjou, grandson of Louis XIV. England, the Dutch Republic and the Austrian Habsburgs, who had their own claimant in the Archduke Charles, went to war to prevent Bourbon control of Spain, the southern Netherlands and Italy. For two years the war in Flanders was one of sieges. Then Bavaria’s Elector, Max Emanuel, sided with France, and a Franco-Bavarian army on the upper Danube threatened Vienna, which was also facing a Hungarian revolt. If Vienna fell, the alliance would collapse.

Marlborough, captain-general of the English and Dutch forces, decided to march his army 250 miles from the Low Countries to the Danube. He concealed the destination from the Dutch government, which would have forbidden it, and from the French, who expected an attack on the Moselle. The march took five weeks, with supplies and new shoes waiting at prepared depots. On 2 July he stormed the Schellenberg heights at Donauworth at great cost, crossed into Bavaria, and set about forcing the Elector either to change sides or to fight.

How each side saw it

The French

Tallard, taken to England and held for seven years at Nottingham, blamed the Bavarians, the poor state of his cavalry and Clerambault, who rode into the Danube and drowned rather than answer for the infantry lost in the village. At Versailles nobody wanted to tell Louis XIV; Madame de Maintenon is said to have broken the news. The Duke of Saint-Simon’s memoirs record the court’s disbelief that a French army had laid down its arms, and treat the day as the end of an assumption, two generations old, that French armies did not lose battles. French historians call it the battle of Hochstadt.

The Bavarians

Bavaria’s experience began before the battle. In July 1704 Marlborough, unable to bring the Elector to terms, sent cavalry to burn the countryside between the Danube and Munich. He wrote to his wife that the work was contrary to his nature and that the people were suffering for their master’s ambition. Local tradition counts several hundred villages and farms destroyed. After the defeat the Elector fled to the Netherlands, and Bavaria was occupied, taxed and conscripted by Austria. A peasant rising against the occupation was crushed at Sendling outside Munich on Christmas Day 1705, with around a thousand dead, an event commemorated in Bavaria far more than the battle.

The Dutch and the English Tories

Not everyone on the winning side approved. The Dutch States-General had not agreed to risk their army so far from home and learned of it when it was too late to object. In England, Tory politicians who favoured a cheap naval war resented a general allied to the Whigs, and before the news arrived some talked of calling him to account if the march failed. Jonathan Swift’s pamphlet The Conduct of the Allies, in 1711, argued that England was bleeding and paying for Dutch and Austrian interests while the Duke prolonged the war for profit. He was dismissed at the end of that year.

The Austrian and German tradition

German and Austrian accounts give Prince Eugene at least equal credit. With the smaller wing he held down the larger part of the enemy army all afternoon in repeated costly attacks, reportedly shooting two of his own fleeing troopers, and released his heavy cavalry to save Marlborough’s centre at the critical moment. In the English-speaking world, shaped above all by the Duke’s descendant Winston Churchill in the 1930s, it is Marlborough’s battle. The two men themselves never quarrelled over it. Eugene’s dispatches and Marlborough’s letters each praise the other, which is rare among allied commanders.

What is disputed

England still used the old calendar, so the battle was fought on 2 August by English reckoning and 13 August by the calendar of the armies. Strengths and losses differ between sources: French casualties are given as anywhere from 30,000 to 40,000 including prisoners and stragglers. Historians dispute how far the victory was planned and how far Tallard and Clerambault handed it over. The devastation of Bavaria is defended by some as normal practice for the age and condemned by others. Robert Southey’s poem After Blenheim, of 1798, asked what good the famous victory did, a fair question of a war that lasted nine more years.

What followed

Blenheim saved Vienna, knocked Bavaria out of the war and broke the reputation of French arms. Marlborough went on to win at Ramillies, Oudenarde and Malplaquet, the last at appalling cost. The peace of Utrecht in 1713 left Philip on the Spanish throne but barred union with France, and gave Britain Gibraltar, Minorca and the contract to supply enslaved Africans to Spanish America. Queen Anne gave the Duke the royal manor of Woodstock, and public money was promised for a palace there, named after the battle. Payments stopped when the Marlboroughs fell from favour, and they finished it themselves. Winston Churchill was born in it in 1874.

Read further

  • Winston S. Churchill, Marlborough: His Life and Times (1933-38)
  • David Chandler, Marlborough as Military Commander (1973)
  • Charles Spencer, Blenheim: Battle for Europe (2004)
  • Richard Holmes, Marlborough: England’s Fragile Genius (2008)
  • Derek McKay, Prince Eugene of Savoy (1977)

Same day, other years

1521

Tenochtitlan falls

Tenochtitlan (Mexico City)The Americas

After a siege of almost three months, the island city of Tenochtitlan fell on 13 August 1521 when its young ruler Cuauhtemoc was captured in a canoe on the lake. Hernan Cortes commanded about a thousand Spaniards; the great bulk of the besieging army, numbering in the tens of thousands, was made up of Tlaxcalans, Texcocans and other Nahua peoples with their own scores to settle with the Mexica. Thirteen small warships built for the purpose cut the city off by water. Smallpox, brought the previous year, had already killed the ruler Cuitlahuac and a large part of the population. The defenders were starved and pushed back street by street, and the city was levelled as it was taken.

Seen from elsewhere. Nahua accounts collected within a generation, in the Florentine Codex and the Annals of Tlatelolco, describe famine, fouled water and the killing of people leaving the city. Tlaxcalan records present the victory as their own. Matthew Restall and other historians now describe an Indigenous civil war that Spaniards exploited and then claimed.

1898

The arranged battle of Manila

Manila, PhilippinesAsia

By August 1898 Filipino revolutionary forces under Emilio Aguinaldo, who had declared independence on 12 June, held most of Luzon and had the Spanish garrison of Manila surrounded by land. An American squadron under George Dewey held the bay. The Spanish governor, Fermin Jaudenes, let it be known that he would surrender to the Americans after a show of resistance to satisfy honour, provided the Filipinos were kept out of the city. On 13 August the arranged attack took place, and a number of men died where the script broke down. American troops occupied the walled city and barred Aguinaldo’s army from it. Nobody in Manila knew that an armistice had been signed in Washington the day before.

Seen from elsewhere. Filipinos saw allies turn into occupiers; Aguinaldo said he had been promised independence, which Dewey denied. American officers argued that they had prevented a sack. Spain ceded the islands for 20 million dollars in December, and the war that followed between Americans and Filipinos killed several hundred thousand people, most of them civilians.

1937

The battle of Shanghai begins

Shanghai, ChinaAsia

Full-scale war between China and Japan had begun near Beijing in July 1937. On 13 August fighting broke out in Shanghai, where Chiang Kai-shek had chosen to commit his best German-trained divisions against the Japanese naval garrison, in a city full of foreign witnesses. The next day Chinese aircraft aiming at a Japanese cruiser dropped bombs on crowded streets in the foreign concessions and killed more than a thousand civilians. Japan landed reinforcements, and for three months the two armies fought house to house and across the creeks north of the city. China lost perhaps 200,000 men or more, including many of its trained junior officers, and Japan over 40,000. The Chinese line broke in November, and the pursuit ended at Nanjing.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan called the fighting an incident provoked by China, citing the shooting of a naval officer near a Chinese airfield days before. Historians dispute Chiang’s choice: some say it wasted his best troops in an unwinnable position, others that it wrecked Japan’s plan for a short war and won China foreign sympathy.

1961

Berlin is divided overnight

Berlin, GermanyEurope

In the early hours of Sunday 13 August 1961 East German police, border troops and factory militia strung barbed wire along the line dividing the Soviet sector of Berlin from the three western ones, tore up streets and shut the underground and overhead railway links. Concrete blocks followed within days. Around three million people had left East Germany since 1949, many of them young and skilled, most by simply crossing the open city, and the state was running out of workers. The party leader Walter Ulbricht had said in June that nobody intended to build a wall. Families, workplaces and streets were divided overnight. At least 140 people died at the Berlin Wall before it opened in 1989.

Seen from elsewhere. East Germany called it the Anti-Fascist Protection Rampart, a defence against Western subversion and economic sabotage. Western governments protested but did not act; President Kennedy remarked privately that a wall was a great deal better than a war. Hope Harrison has shown that Ulbricht pressed a hesitant Khrushchev to allow it.

Also on 13 August