Parallax

3 August, 1492

Columbus sails from Palos

Three small ships left a minor Andalusian port before sunrise to reach Asia by sailing west. Their commander’s arithmetic was wrong by half the globe, and the mistake joined two worlds that had been apart for thousands of years.

Palos de la Frontera, Spain

Half an hour before sunrise on Friday 3 August 1492, three ships dropped down the Rio Tinto on the ebb tide, crossed the bar of Saltes and stood out into the Atlantic. The largest, the Santa Maria, was a round-bellied cargo ship chartered from her owner, Juan de la Cosa, who sailed in her. The other two were caravels, lighter and handier: the Pinta and the Nina. About ninety men were aboard, most of them from Palos and the neighbouring towns of Moguer and Huelva.

Their commander was a Genoese in his early forties whom the Spaniards called Cristobal Colon. He had spent the better part of a decade asking the crowns of Portugal and then Castile to pay for a voyage westward to the Indies. Royal commissions had examined his figures and found them too small; they were correct. In April 1492, months after the fall of Granada, Isabella and Ferdinand at last agreed, granting him in advance the titles of admiral, viceroy and governor of whatever he found, and a tenth of its profits.

Palos had not volunteered. The town owed the crown a penalty for an earlier offence and was ordered to supply two caravels for a year. Sailors were slow to sign on with a foreigner bound for nowhere known. What changed that was the support of Martin Alonso Pinzon, the leading shipowner of the port, who took command of the Pinta and put his brother Vicente Yanez in the Nina. A few men accepted a royal pardon in exchange for sailing. Also aboard was Luis de Torres, a convert from Judaism who knew Hebrew and some Arabic, brought along to speak to the Great Khan.

Columbus did not head west. He ran south-west for the Canary Islands, the last Castilian territory, to pick up the steady easterly winds he knew from earlier voyages. Three days out the Pinta’s rudder jumped its fastenings, and nearly a month went on repairs and on re-rigging the Nina with square sails. The fleet finally left La Gomera on 6 September.

Thirty-six days later, at two in the morning on 12 October, a lookout on the Pinta sighted a white cliff in the moonlight. The island was called Guanahani by the Lucayan Taino who lived there. Columbus named it San Salvador, took possession for Castile in front of people who did not know what he was doing, and wrote that they would make good servants. He believed, and went on believing, that he was off the coast of Asia.

How it came to this

Educated Europeans in 1492 knew the earth was round. The question was its size and how much of it was ocean. Columbus combined the smallest ancient estimate of the globe with the largest estimate of Asia’s eastward extent, misread Arab miles as shorter Italian ones, and concluded that Japan lay about 2,400 nautical miles west of the Canaries. The true figure is more than four times that. The scholars who doubted him were right that no ship of the time could carry food and water for such a crossing; none of them knew a continent lay in the way.

Castile’s interest came from rivalry. Portugal had spent seventy years working down the African coast, and in 1488 Bartolomeu Dias rounded the Cape of Good Hope, opening a sea road to India that a treaty closed to Castilians. The conquest of Granada in January 1492 freed money and attention. That same spring the monarchs ordered all Jews to convert or leave their kingdoms; the deadline fell in the days before the fleet sailed, and Columbus mentions the expulsion in the opening lines of his journal.

How each side saw it

The Taino

The people who met the ships left no written account. Their side survives in what Columbus chose to record, in the work of Ramon Pane, a friar who lived among the Taino of Hispaniola and wrote down their beliefs in the 1490s, and in archaeology. Columbus’s own journal describes people who swam out with parrots and cotton thread, and notes within two days where a fort could be built and how easily they could be subjugated. On Hispaniola, forced labour, violence, famine and then epidemic disease reduced a population of several hundred thousand, on cautious estimates, to a few thousand within about forty years.

Bartolome de las Casas

The Dominican friar who preserved the journal is also its first critic. Las Casas came to Hispaniola in 1502, held Indian labourers himself, then renounced them and spent fifty years denouncing the conquest. In his History of the Indies he treats Columbus as an instrument of providence chosen to open the way for the gospel, and in the same pages condemns him for beginning the enslavement of the islanders and holds that God punished him for it. Much of what later became the ‘Black Legend’ of Spanish cruelty was drawn by Spain’s rivals from this Spanish source.

The Pinzon family and Palos

In the long lawsuits between the crown and Columbus’s heirs, begun in 1508, sailors from Palos testified that Martin Alonso Pinzon had been the real maker of the voyage: that he found the crews, steadied Columbus when he wanted to turn back, and urged the change of course that led to land. The witnesses were called by a crown keen to shrink the Columbus family’s hereditary rights, and Pinzon had died within weeks of returning, so the claim cannot be tested. In Andalusia the Pinzon brothers are still honoured as co-discoverers.

Modern historians and Indigenous critics

For Samuel Eliot Morison, writing in 1942 after retracing the route under sail, Columbus was above all a superb navigator. Since the 1970s the emphasis has moved to consequences: Alfred Crosby’s ‘Columbian exchange’ of crops, animals and diseases, and the demographic collapse that followed. Indigenous writers and activists across the Americas reject the word ‘discovery’ for lands already inhabited by millions and mark the anniversary as the start of invasion. Felipe Fernandez-Armesto and others caution against both the saint and the monster, and describe an ambitious, self-taught, socially insecure man of his time.

What is disputed

The original journal is lost; we have only the abstract Las Casas made from a copy, part quotation and part summary, and scholars argue over how far he shaped it. It says Columbus kept a second, shorter reckoning of distance to reassure the crew, which some historians think is a misunderstanding of two units of measure. Which island was Guanahani is unsettled: Watling Island is the usual answer, Samana Cay the main challenger. His Genoese birth is supported by notarial documents and accepted by most specialists, though Catalan, Portuguese and Jewish origins have all been proposed, most recently on the basis of DNA claims announced in 2024 and not yet published in full.

What followed

Columbus returned in March 1493 with gold ornaments, parrots and several captive islanders, and sailed again that autumn with seventeen ships and settlers. Pope Alexander VI and then the Treaty of Tordesillas in 1494 divided the non-Christian world between Castile and Portugal. Within fifty years the Aztec and Inca states had been overthrown, and the labour shortage caused by the death of Indigenous peoples was being filled by enslaved Africans. Maize, potatoes and tobacco crossed one way; horses, wheat, sugar and smallpox the other. Several American countries have replaced Columbus Day with commemorations of Indigenous peoples.

Read further

  • Oliver Dunn and James E. Kelley Jr (eds), The Diario of Christopher Columbus’s First Voyage to America, 1492-1493 (1989)
  • Samuel Eliot Morison, Admiral of the Ocean Sea: A Life of Christopher Columbus (1942)
  • Felipe Fernandez-Armesto, Columbus (1991)
  • William D. Phillips and Carla Rahn Phillips, The Worlds of Christopher Columbus (1992)
  • Alfred W. Crosby, The Columbian Exchange: Biological and Cultural Consequences of 1492 (1972)

Same day, other years

1795

The Treaty of Greenville

Fort Greenville, Ohio countryThe Americas

For a decade a confederacy of Shawnee, Miami, Delaware, Wyandot and other nations had fought to hold the Ohio River as the boundary of the United States, and in 1791 it inflicted on an American army the heaviest defeat any Native force ever dealt one. In August 1794 General Anthony Wayne beat the confederacy at Fallen Timbers, and its British allies shut their fort gates against the retreating warriors. A year later, after weeks of council, more than ninety chiefs put their marks to a treaty giving up most of what is now Ohio in return for goods worth 20,000 dollars and small annual payments. Settlers poured in, and Ohio became a state within eight years.

Seen from elsewhere. The Miami leader Little Turtle argued the boundary in council before signing last. A young Shawnee, Tecumseh, stayed away and never accepted it. He later held that the land belonged to all the nations in common and that no group of chiefs could sell it, the principle behind the confederacy he built before 1812.

1916

Roger Casement is hanged

Pentonville Prison, LondonEurope

As a British consul, Roger Casement had documented the mutilation and killing of rubber workers in King Leopold’s Congo in 1904 and, later, of Indigenous people in the Putumayo region of the Amazon. He was knighted for it in 1911. By then he was an Irish nationalist. When war came he went to Germany to seek arms and recruit Irish prisoners of war, was put ashore from a submarine in County Kerry three days before the Easter Rising, and was arrested within hours. Tried in London under the Treason Act of 1351, he was convicted and hanged. While appeals for clemency were being gathered, officials showed journalists and diplomats pages from diaries recording his sexual encounters with men.

Seen from elsewhere. To the government he was a servant of the crown who had joined the enemy in wartime. Irish nationalists long insisted the ‘Black Diaries’ were forged to blacken a patriot. A forensic examination in 2002 judged them genuine, which most historians accept, though some still dissent. His remains were returned to Ireland in 1965 and given a state funeral.

1959

The Pidjiguiti dock massacre

Bissau, Portuguese GuineaAfrica

Dockers and boatmen at the Pidjiguiti quay in Bissau, the capital of Portuguese Guinea, stopped work to demand better pay from the trading company that dominated the colony’s commerce. In the afternoon armed police moved to clear the docks and opened fire. Men were shot on the quay and in the water as they tried to reach their boats. About fifty were killed and many more wounded, by the count that became accepted after independence. The following month leaders of the small nationalist party, the PAIGC, met in secret under Amilcar Cabral and decided that peaceful protest in the towns was finished. They would organise the peasantry and prepare for war, which began in 1963.

Seen from elsewhere. The colonial authorities treated the event as a riot put down by the police, and the Lisbon press, under censorship, said little. The death toll rests largely on survivors’ and nationalist accounts. Historians also debate how far the PAIGC organised the strike, as it later said, or adopted a workers’ dispute it had not led.

2014

The attack on the Yazidis of Sinjar

Sinjar, northern IraqMiddle East

Before dawn, fighters of the group calling itself Islamic State advanced on the towns and villages around Mount Sinjar, home to most of the world’s Yazidis, followers of an ancient religion of the region. Kurdish forces responsible for the area withdrew. Tens of thousands of people fled up the bare mountain, where many died of thirst before an air and land corridor was opened. Those caught below were separated. Men and older boys who refused to convert were shot and buried in mass graves; women and children were taken away and distributed or sold. United Nations investigators estimate that around 5,000 people were killed and more than 6,000 abducted, and concluded in 2016 that the crime was genocide.

Seen from elsewhere. The perpetrators did not deny it: the group’s magazine defended the enslavement of Yazidi women on religious grounds, calling them pagans. Yazidis count the attack as the seventy-fourth campaign of extermination in their history. Many blame the Kurdish withdrawal, which Kurdish officials attribute to being outgunned. Some 2,600 people remain missing.

Also on 3 August