Parallax

19 August, AD 14

Augustus dies at Nola, and the rumours begin

Rome’s first emperor asked his friends whether he had played his part well, kissed his wife and died. Within a generation historians were asking whether she had helped him on his way.

Nola, Campania, Italy

In the summer of AD 14 Augustus was 75 and had been master of the Roman world for more than four decades. He left Rome to accompany his stepson and adopted heir, Tiberius, part of the way towards a command in Illyricum. On the voyage down the coast he caught a chill and developed a stomach complaint. He rested for four days on Capri, where, Suetonius says, he was in excellent spirits, handing out togas and Greek cloaks and making Romans and Greeks swap dress and language. He then sat through an athletic contest held in his honour at Naples, saw Tiberius off at Beneventum, and turned for home.

He got as far as Nola, a town near Vesuvius where his family owned a house. It was the house, and by tradition the very room, in which his father Gaius Octavius had died 72 years before. Messengers were sent to recall Tiberius.

Suetonius, writing about a century later with access to the imperial archives, gives the death in detail. On his last day Augustus asked repeatedly whether there was any disturbance outside on his account. He called for a mirror, had his hair combed and his slack jaw set straight, and asked the friends he admitted whether he had played the comedy of life fittingly, adding a tag in Greek of the kind actors used when they came forward at the end of a play: if it has pleased you, applaud. Then he sent them out. He died suddenly in the arms of his wife Livia, telling her to live mindful of their marriage, and farewell. It was the ninth hour of the day, 19 August, in the month the Senate had renamed after him.

What happened next gave the rumour-mongers their material. Livia had the house and the surrounding roads sealed by guards, and bulletins continued to say that the emperor was holding his own. Only when Tiberius had arrived was it announced, in a single statement, that Augustus was dead and Tiberius in control. Almost at once a centurion killed Agrippa Postumus, Augustus’s last surviving grandson, on the island where he had been exiled.

The body was carried to Rome by night, to avoid the heat, on the shoulders of the town councillors of each place along the road. After two funeral speeches it was burned on the Campus Martius. A former praetor swore on oath that he had seen the emperor’s form rising to heaven, and on 17 September the Senate declared Augustus a god.

How it came to this

He was born Gaius Octavius in 63 BC, into a wealthy family from Velitrae that was new to the Senate. His great-uncle Julius Caesar adopted him by will, and at eighteen, on Caesar’s murder in 44 BC, he took the name and raised an army with his own money. With Mark Antony and Lepidus he formed a three-man dictatorship that put some 300 senators and 2,000 men of the equestrian class on death lists, Cicero among them. The partners destroyed Caesar’s assassins at Philippi and then turned on each other. The defeat of Antony and Cleopatra at Actium in 31 BC left him without a rival.

In 27 BC he handed his powers back to the Senate and received most of them again, with the new name Augustus. He called himself princeps, first citizen, and kept the forms of the republic while controlling the armies, the richest provinces and the treasury. The weakness of the arrangement was succession. His nephew Marcellus, his friend and son-in-law Agrippa, and his grandsons Gaius and Lucius all died before him. That left Tiberius, Livia’s son by her first marriage, adopted without enthusiasm in AD 4.

How each side saw it

Augustus in his own words

He left an account of himself to be cut in bronze outside his mausoleum, the Res Gestae, which survives because a copy was inscribed on a temple wall at Ankara. In it he says that at nineteen he raised an army and restored liberty to a republic oppressed by a faction; that he avenged his father; that he refused every office contrary to ancestral custom; that he excelled all in influence but held no more power than his colleagues. It lists the money he gave, the temples he restored, the kings who sought his friendship. The proscriptions are not mentioned and Antony is never named.

The critics at the funeral

Tacitus opens his Annals with the talk at Augustus’s funeral, setting two verdicts side by side. Admirers said civil war had forced his hand and that he had given the world peace and law. Others said that duty to his father was a pretext, that he had bribed soldiers, tricked the Senate, betrayed each ally in turn, and that the peace was real but bloodstained. Tacitus, a senator writing under Trajan, plainly leans to the second view. He is also the one who notes that some suspected foul play by the emperor’s wife.

Livia

Livia Drusilla was married to Augustus for 51 years and left no account of her own; none of her many letters survives. She is known through male writers who distrusted a woman with influence. Tacitus calls her a burden to the state as a mother and to the house of the Caesars as a stepmother, and hints that every death that cleared Tiberius’s path was her doing. Cassius Dio reports the story that she smeared poison on figs still growing on the tree. Anthony Barrett and most modern biographers find no evidence against her beyond the pattern of the accusations.

What is disputed

The poisoning. Tacitus mentions it as a suspicion and Dio as something people said, linked to a rumoured secret visit by Augustus to the exiled Agrippa Postumus. Suetonius, who enjoyed scandal, does not mention it at all, and an intestinal illness in a man of 75 needs no further explanation. The deathbed scene itself may have been shaped by Augustus or by tradition. Who ordered the killing of Agrippa Postumus, whether Augustus in advance, Livia or Tiberius, was disputed in antiquity and remains so. How long he ‘ruled’ depends on whether one counts from Actium or from 27 BC.

What followed

Tiberius succeeded without a civil war, which was the real test of what Augustus had built, and the system he devised lasted in recognisable form for two centuries. His name became a title borne by every later emperor. Later ages have used him as they needed: as the prince of peace under whom Christ was born, as a model for monarchs, and in 1937 as the centrepiece of Mussolini’s celebrations of the two thousandth anniversary of his birth. Ronald Syme’s The Roman Revolution, published two years later, portrayed him as a party boss who came to power through a coup.

Read further

  • Suetonius, The Twelve Caesars: Augustus
  • Tacitus, Annals, Book 1
  • Cassius Dio, Roman History, Book 56
  • Ronald Syme, The Roman Revolution (1939)
  • Anthony A. Barrett, Livia: First Lady of Imperial Rome (2002)

Same day, other years

1692

Five are hanged at Salem, among them a minister

Salem, MassachusettsThe Americas

On this day a cart carried five people convicted of witchcraft to the gallows at Salem: John Proctor, a farmer who had denounced the accusing girls as frauds; John Willard, a constable who had refused to make further arrests; George Jacobs, a man of about eighty; Martha Carrier of Andover; and George Burroughs, a former minister of Salem Village. On the ladder Burroughs recited the Lord’s Prayer without a slip, which a witch was thought unable to do, and the crowd wavered. Cotton Mather, on horseback, reminded them that the devil could appear as an angel of light, and the hangings went ahead. Proctor’s wife Elizabeth, also condemned, was spared because she was pregnant.

Seen from elsewhere. The judges believed they were defending a godly colony and accepted ‘spectral evidence’, the testimony of the afflicted about what the accused’s spirits did to them. In October Increase Mather argued against it and the trials collapsed. Judge Samuel Sewall publicly asked forgiveness in 1697, and the accuser Ann Putnam in 1706. Nineteen people were hanged in all, and the colony reversed the convictions in 1711.

1942

The Dieppe raid ends in nine hours

Dieppe, FranceEurope

Just before dawn about 6,100 troops, nearly 5,000 of them Canadian, landed at and around the Channel port of Dieppe in the largest raid of the war. The plan was to seize the town, hold it for a few hours and withdraw. Surprise was lost when the flotilla ran into a German convoy, the preliminary bombardment was light, and the tanks that got ashore could not climb the shingle or pass the sea wall. Men were cut down on open beaches under the cliffs. By early afternoon it was over. Of the Canadians, more than 900 were dead and some 1,900 were prisoners. The RAF lost over a hundred aircraft.

Seen from elsewhere. Lord Mountbatten, whose headquarters planned it, always maintained that Dieppe taught lessons that saved many lives in Normandy. Canadian historians have been unpersuaded; Brian Loring Villa argued that Mountbatten revived the raid without proper authority, and David O’Keefe that its hidden purpose was to capture German naval cipher material. German propaganda presented it as a failed invasion.

1953

A coup overthrows Mosaddegh in Iran

Tehran, IranMiddle East

Mohammad Mosaddegh, Iran’s elected prime minister, had nationalised the British-owned Anglo-Iranian Oil Company in 1951 and been met with a blockade that crippled the economy. In August 1953 the American CIA and British intelligence put into action a plan to remove him. A first attempt on the night of 15 August failed, and the Shah fled to Baghdad and then Rome. Four days later crowds, some of them paid, marched into central Tehran; army units loyal to General Fazlollah Zahedi joined them, and tanks shelled Mosaddegh’s house. Some 200 to 300 people died in the fighting. The Shah flew home. Mosaddegh was tried, imprisoned for three years and confined to his village until his death in 1967.

Seen from elsewhere. The Shah’s supporters called the day a national uprising and say the monarchy still had genuine backing, including from senior clerics who feared communism. Historians such as Ervand Abrahamian put the foreign agencies at the centre; others, including Darioush Bayandor, argue that Iranians decided the outcome. The CIA formally acknowledged its role in documents released in 2013.

2003

A truck bomb destroys the UN headquarters in Baghdad

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Late in the afternoon a lorry packed with explosives was driven down an access road beside the Canal Hotel, the United Nations base in Baghdad, and detonated beneath the office of the secretary-general’s special representative, Sergio Vieira de Mello. Twenty-two people were killed and more than a hundred injured. Vieira de Mello, a Brazilian who had run the UN administration in East Timor, was trapped in the rubble for hours, conscious and speaking to rescuers, and died before he could be freed. After a second bombing in September the UN withdrew most of its international staff from Iraq. The date is now marked as World Humanitarian Day.

Seen from elsewhere. The attack was claimed by the network of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, which cited the UN’s part in separating East Timor from Muslim Indonesia. Many Iraqis associated the organisation with the sanctions of the 1990s and saw it as an arm of the occupation. An independent panel under Martti Ahtisaari found the UN’s own security arrangements dysfunctional.

Also on 19 August