Parallax

17 August, 1786

Frederick the Great dies in his armchair

The king who turned a second-rank German state into a great power died propped upright in a chair at Sanssouci, and Berlin did not weep. It took 205 years for him to be buried where he had asked.

Sanssouci, Potsdam, Prussia

By the summer of 1786 Frederick II of Prussia could no longer lie down. Dropsy had swollen his legs and body, asthma choked him when he was horizontal, and he spent his nights as well as his days in an armchair in his small summer palace above Potsdam. He was 74, toothless, stooped, dressed in a snuff-stained blue uniform coat, and still running the state himself. His cabinet secretaries were summoned at four or five in the morning, and he went on dictating orders about drainage schemes, garrison postings and tax returns until two days before the end.

In June he had sent to Hanover for Johann Georg Zimmermann, one of the most fashionable physicians in Germany. Zimmermann stayed a little over two weeks, prescribed dandelion extract, and found his patient impossible: the king dismissed medical advice and went on eating eel pie, heavily spiced soups and Italian polenta thick with cheese and garlic. Zimmermann went home and later published their conversations, which sold well.

On 15 August Frederick woke unusually late, around eleven, and worked through his papers in a weak voice. The next day he could not manage it. He drifted in and out of consciousness, and when the general who came each day for the parole stood waiting, the king was unable to give the word. During the night of the 16th a hussar valet named Strutzki knelt and held the king upright against his own body for hours so that he could breathe. At about twenty past two in the morning of 17 August, Frederick died in his arms. Only his doctor, two valets and a minister were in the room.

The stories told about his final hours are of the kind that attach to famous deaths. He is supposed to have noticed one of his Italian greyhounds shivering and ordered a quilt thrown over it, and, after a coughing fit eased, to have said that the mountain was passed and things would go better. Both come from accounts by his attendants set down afterwards.

His instructions for his burial were clear and had been repeated in successive wills. He wanted to be laid, at night, without ceremony, in a vault he had built on the top terrace of Sanssouci, next to the graves of his dogs. His nephew and successor, Frederick William II, thought this unfitting for a king and had him placed in the Garrison Church in Potsdam beside the father Frederick had hated. The French agent Mirabeau, in Berlin at the time, reported that the capital was gloomy but that nobody was sad: he saw no regret, heard no praise, and thought people were simply tired of him.

How it came to this

Frederick was born in 1712, the son of Frederick William I, a pious, violent drillmaster of a king who despised his heir’s taste for French verse and the flute. In 1730 the eighteen-year-old prince tried to escape to England. He was caught, imprisoned at Kustrin, and made to watch from a window as his friend and accomplice, Lieutenant Hans Hermann von Katte, was beheaded. He submitted, married a wife he ignored for the rest of his life, and waited.

He became king in May 1740 and within seven months had invaded Silesia, a rich Habsburg province to which Prussia had a thin legal claim, taking advantage of the accession of the young Maria Theresa. Holding it cost him three wars. In the last, the Seven Years’ War of 1756-63, he fought Austria, France and Russia at once, saw Berlin raided and his army nearly destroyed, and survived largely because the Empress Elizabeth of Russia died in 1762 and her successor changed sides. In 1772 he joined Russia and Austria in the first partition of Poland. At home he corresponded with Voltaire, abolished judicial torture, tolerated every religion, and called himself the first servant of the state.

How each side saw it

Maria Theresa and Vienna

To the Habsburg court Frederick was a robber. He had guaranteed Maria Theresa’s inheritance and then invaded it weeks after her father’s death, while she was 23 and pregnant. In her letters she calls him the monster and the evil man of Sans Souci, and she never accepted the loss of Silesia, telling her ministers she would sooner sell her last petticoat. She regarded his philosophy as a mask for irreligion and bad faith. Her son Joseph II, by contrast, admired him and sought him out in 1769, which she thought a dangerous infatuation.

Poland and Saxony

Polish historians remember Frederick as an architect of the partitions. During the Seven Years’ War he had debased Polish coin struck from captured Saxon dies, damaging the Commonwealth’s economy, and in 1772 he took Royal Prussia, joining his scattered lands. His own letters compare the Poles of his new province to the Iroquois of Canada. Saxony, which he invaded without declaration in 1756, saw its army forcibly drafted into Prussian regiments and Dresden bombarded in 1760. In both countries the title ‘the Great’ has never been used without irony.

Later German traditions

Nineteenth-century Prussian historians such as Droysen and Treitschke made Frederick the founder of Germany’s destiny. The Nazis took this further: Hitler staged the opening of the Reichstag at Frederick’s tomb in Potsdam in March 1933 and kept his portrait in the Berlin bunker. After 1945 the Allies abolished Prussia as a bearer of militarism, and East Germany removed his equestrian statue from Unter den Linden in 1950. The same regime put it back in 1980, having decided that parts of the Prussian past were usable after all.

What is disputed

The deathbed sayings rest on attendants’ recollections and cannot be checked. A larger argument concerns his private life: Tim Blanning argues from contemporary gossip, Voltaire’s malicious memoirs and Frederick’s own verse that he was homosexual, something older German biographers passed over or denied; others think the evidence proves only indifference to women. Historians also disagree about how enlightened his rule was, since serfdom remained and the nobility’s grip on the officer corps tightened. The idea of a straight line from Frederick to Hitler, popular in Allied wartime writing, is rejected by Christopher Clark and most recent scholars.

What followed

Twenty years after his death the army he had built was destroyed by Napoleon at Jena, and Napoleon, visiting the tomb, is said to have told his officers that they would not be there if Frederick were alive. In 1943 the coffin was moved for safety, ending up in a salt mine in Thuringia, where American soldiers found it in 1945. It rested in Marburg and then at Hohenzollern Castle until 17 August 1991, when, after German reunification, he was finally buried at night on the terrace at Sanssouci. Visitors leave potatoes on the slab, for the crop he pressed on his peasants.

Read further

  • Tim Blanning, Frederick the Great: King of Prussia (2015)
  • Christopher Clark, Iron Kingdom: The Rise and Downfall of Prussia, 1600-1947 (2006)
  • Theodor Schieder, Frederick the Great, translated by Sabina Berkeley and H. M. Scott (2000)
  • Giles MacDonogh, Frederick the Great: A Life in Deed and Letters (1999)
  • Comte de Mirabeau, The Secret History of the Court of Berlin (1789)

Same day, other years

1862

The Dakota War begins in Minnesota

Acton, Minnesota, United StatesThe Americas

On a Sunday afternoon four young Dakota men, returning hungry from an unsuccessful hunt, killed five white settlers at Acton after a quarrel over some hens’ eggs. That night the leaders of the Mdewakanton Dakota met at the house of Taoyateduta, known as Little Crow. Annuity payments promised by treaty were months late, the harvest had failed, traders were refusing credit, and people were starving on a narrow reservation along the Minnesota River. Little Crow warned that the Americans were as many as locusts, and then agreed to lead. The attack on the Lower Sioux Agency began the next morning. In six weeks several hundred settlers were killed. On 26 December, 38 Dakota men were hanged together at Mankato, the largest mass execution in United States history.

Seen from elsewhere. Settler accounts called it the Sioux Massacre. Dakota oral histories, and narratives such as that of Big Eagle recorded in 1894, describe a people cheated of land and food and divided over the war; many Dakota protected white neighbours. Military trials lasted minutes each. Afterwards about 1,600 non-combatants were interned at Fort Snelling and the Dakota were expelled from Minnesota.

1945

Sukarno proclaims Indonesian independence

Jakarta, IndonesiaAsia

Two days after Japan’s surrender, at ten in the morning, Sukarno stood on the porch of his house at Pegangsaan Timur 56 and read two sentences declaring Indonesia independent. Mohammad Hatta stood beside him. The text had been drafted overnight at the home of a sympathetic Japanese admiral, Maeda Tadashi, after impatient young nationalists had kidnapped both leaders and taken them to the garrison town of Rengasdengklok to stop them waiting for Japanese approval. A red and white flag sewn by Sukarno’s wife Fatmawati was raised on a bamboo pole. The Netherlands, which had ruled the islands for more than three centuries, sent troops to recover them, and four years of war and negotiation followed before the transfer of sovereignty in December 1949.

Seen from elsewhere. The Dutch government regarded Sukarno as a Japanese collaborator and the republic as a Japanese creation, and called its two major offensives ‘police actions’. A state-funded Dutch study published in 2022 concluded that its forces had used extreme violence systematically. The Netherlands long dated Indonesian independence from 1949, and accepted 17 August 1945 politically only in 2005.

1962

Peter Fechter bleeds to death at the Berlin Wall

Berlin, GermanyEurope

Peter Fechter was an eighteen-year-old bricklayer from East Berlin. A year and four days after the Wall went up, he and a workmate, Helmut Kulbeik, hid in a workshop on Zimmerstrasse near Checkpoint Charlie, jumped from a window and ran for the barrier. Kulbeik got over. Fechter was hit in the pelvis by a border guard’s bullet and fell back on the eastern side, where he lay calling for help for about fifty minutes, in full view of a growing western crowd, photographers and American soldiers. West Berlin police threw him bandages he could not reach. Nobody from either side went to him until he was dead or dying, when East German guards carried the body away.

Seen from elsewhere. The East German guards said they feared being shot from the western side if they entered the strip; a border guard had been killed days earlier. The American garrison had orders not to cross. West Berliners turned on both, shouting ‘murderers’ at one and stoning the vehicles of the other. In 1997 two former guards were convicted of manslaughter and given suspended sentences.

1988

General Zia dies in an unexplained air crash

Bahawalpur, PakistanAsia

Minutes after taking off from Bahawalpur, where President Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq had watched a demonstration of an American tank, his C-130 transport pitched up and down and dived into the ground. Everyone on board died, around thirty people, among them the chairman of the joint chiefs, General Akhtar Abdur Rahman, and the United States ambassador, Arnold Raphel. Zia had seized power in 1977, hanged the prime minister he overthrew, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, in 1979, pushed through an Islamisation of law and public life, and made Pakistan the channel for American and Saudi support to the Afghan mujahideen. Elections that November brought Bhutto’s daughter Benazir to office.

Seen from elsewhere. A Pakistani board of inquiry concluded that sabotage was the most probable cause; American investigators leaned towards mechanical failure, and no full criminal investigation followed. Theories have blamed the Soviet KGB, Afghan intelligence, Indian agents, the Bhutto family’s avengers, rival generals and the CIA. None has been proved.

Also on 17 August