Parallax

10 August, 1557

A victory on St Lawrence’s day, repaid in granite

Philip II of Spain was twenty miles away when his army wrecked the French at Saint-Quentin. He declined to march on Paris and built a monastery instead.

Saint-Quentin, Picardy, France

Philip II of Spain had been king for a year and a half, and he was not at the battle that made his reputation. On 10 August 1557 he was at Cambrai, some twenty miles off, dealing with paperwork and waiting for English reinforcements. His army in the field, a mixed force of Spaniards, Germans, Walloons and Italians, was commanded by his cousin Emmanuel Philibert, the dispossessed Duke of Savoy, who had his own reasons to fight the French: they had occupied his duchy for twenty years.

Savoy had feinted towards Champagne and then turned on Saint-Quentin, a weakly held town on the Somme that covered the road to Paris. Gaspard de Coligny, Admiral of France, slipped inside with a few hundred men on the night of 2 August and held the crumbling walls. The Constable of France, Anne de Montmorency, sixty-four years old and the most powerful man in the kingdom after the king, marched to relieve him with an army roughly half the size of Savoy’s.

Montmorency’s plan for St Lawrence’s day was to ferry reinforcements into the town across the marshes of the Somme while his main body stood by. The boats were too few and stuck in the mud, and only a few hundred men got in. Meanwhile he had left a ford on his flank lightly watched. Savoy sent his cavalry across it under Lamoral, Count of Egmont. The Constable, seeing the danger late, ordered a retreat across open country towards the woods. Egmont’s horsemen caught the column and pinned it, and the infantry and guns came up and broke it.

It was over in a few hours. French dead are put at anywhere from 3,000 to 6,000 or more, with thousands of prisoners. Montmorency was taken with a pistol ball in the hip, along with a marshal of France, several dukes and most of the army’s standards. Savoy’s losses were a few hundred. Coligny held the town for another seventeen days. It was stormed on 27 August and sacked so thoroughly that Philip, who had by then arrived in camp, ordered the women and children escorted to safety.

Paris lay open, and Savoy wanted to march on it. Philip, short of money to pay his troops and cautious by nature, declined. His father, the retired emperor Charles V, is said to have asked on hearing the news whether his son was in Paris yet. What Philip did instead was make a vow. The battle had been won on the feast of the martyr Lawrence, by tradition a Spaniard, and tradition adds that the king’s guns had ruined a church of the saint during the siege. He resolved to found a monastery in Lawrence’s name. In 1563 the first stone was laid at El Escorial, in the mountains north-west of Madrid.

How it came to this

The war was the last round of a contest between the Habsburgs and the Valois kings of France that had run since 1494, fought mostly over Italy. Charles V, worn out, had abdicated in 1555-56 and divided his inheritance: the imperial title and Austria to his brother Ferdinand, and Spain, the Netherlands, Milan, Naples and the Americas to his son Philip. A truce made at Vaucelles in 1556 lasted months. Pope Paul IV, a Neapolitan who loathed Spanish rule in Italy, drew Henry II of France into a new attack, and Henry sent his best general, the Duke of Guise, south with the pick of his army.

That left the northern frontier thin. Philip was also king consort of England through his marriage to Mary Tudor, and in June 1557 he persuaded a reluctant English council to declare war on France. Both crowns were close to bankruptcy; Philip had suspended payments to his bankers that same year. A quick, cheap victory in Picardy was what he needed, and it was what Savoy gave him.

How each side saw it

The French

For France the day was a disaster to rank with Pavia. Contemporary memoirists, among them Francois de Rabutin, who served in the campaign, blamed the Constable’s overconfidence and the unguarded ford. Coligny wrote his own account of the siege while a prisoner, defending his decision to hold a town he knew could not be saved in order to buy time for Paris. That time was used: Henry II recalled Guise from Italy, and in January 1558 Guise took Calais from the English, an event French tradition remembers far more warmly than the defeat that made it necessary.

The English

About 7,000 Englishmen under the Earl of Pembroke reached the army after the battle and took part in the storming of the town. In England the war was unpopular from the start, seen as a Spanish quarrel into which the queen’s husband had dragged the country. When Calais, held since 1347, fell five months later, the blame settled on Mary and Philip. The Protestant tradition shaped by John Foxe treated the loss as a judgement on her reign. The saying that ‘Calais’ would be found written on her heart was first printed in Holinshed’s chronicle a generation later and cannot be verified.

The people of Saint-Quentin

The townspeople left no chronicle of their own. What happened to them is known from the letters of the victors and from Coligny. After the assault on 27 August the town was given over to pillage, in which German mercenaries were especially blamed; houses were burned, men killed or held for ransom, and the surviving inhabitants driven out. Philip had relics removed from the collegiate church for safekeeping and wrote of his distress at the disorder. The town stayed in Spanish hands, half empty, until it was returned to France under the peace of 1559.

The Escorial’s admirers and its critics

The Hieronymite friar Jose de Siguenza, librarian of the Escorial and its first historian, presented the building in 1605 as an act of piety and thanksgiving, an eighth wonder of the world. Outside Spain it became the emblem of something else. Protestant and later liberal writers made it the stone image of the ‘Black Legend’: a king shut in a cell beside a church, ruling half the world by memorandum and the Inquisition. Historians of the past century, among them Geoffrey Parker and Henry Kamen, have argued over how much of that portrait is polemic.

What is disputed

The famous claim that the Escorial was laid out as a gridiron, in memory of the instrument on which St Lawrence was roasted, appears in early descriptions but not in Philip’s foundation charter. George Kubler and others have argued that the grid plan derives from hospital and palace design and from reconstructions of Solomon’s Temple. The charter gives the victory as one motive among several, the chief being a burial place for Charles V. Casualty figures for the battle vary widely between Spanish and French accounts. Whether Philip threw away a chance to end the war by not marching on Paris has been debated since the week it happened.

What followed

The victory brought no quick peace. Both sides ran out of money, and the Treaty of Cateau-Cambresis in April 1559 confirmed Spanish dominance in Italy for a century and a half and gave Savoy back his duchy. Henry II died that summer of a jousting wound received at the celebrations. Coligny, who had read scripture in captivity, emerged as leader of the French Protestants. Egmont, the hero of the charge, was beheaded in Brussels in 1568 by Philip’s governor, the Duke of Alba. The Escorial was finished in 1584. Philip died there in 1598, and most Spanish monarchs since lie in its vault.

Read further

  • Geoffrey Parker, Imprudent King: A New Life of Philip II (2014)
  • Henry Kamen, The Escorial: Art and Power in the Renaissance (2010)
  • George Kubler, Building the Escorial (1982)
  • Jose de Siguenza, Historia de la Orden de San Jeronimo, part three (1605)
  • Frederic J. Baumgartner, Henry II, King of France 1547-1559 (1988)

Same day, other years

1680

The Pueblo towns rise against Spain

Upper Rio Grande, New MexicoThe Americas

For eighty years Spanish governors and Franciscan friars had ruled the Pueblo towns of the upper Rio Grande, taking tribute in maize and cloth, demanding labour and suppressing the kachina dances. In 1675 a governor had forty-seven Pueblo religious leaders arrested for sorcery; some were hanged and the rest flogged. One of the flogged, Po’pay of Ohkay Owingeh, spent the next five years organising from Taos. Runners carried knotted cords to dozens of towns, speaking several languages, to count down the days. When two runners were caught, the rising was brought forward to 10 August. About 400 colonists and 21 of the province’s 33 friars were killed. The survivors abandoned Santa Fe and retreated south to El Paso.

Seen from elsewhere. Spanish reports called it apostasy inspired by the devil. The written record consists almost entirely of Spanish interrogations of captured Pueblo men; the Pueblo account survives in oral tradition. Spain returned in 1692 but never restored the old system of forced labour, and historians debate how united the towns remained in between.

1741

Travancore defeats the Dutch at Colachel

Colachel, southern IndiaAsia

The Dutch East India Company controlled the pepper trade of the Malabar coast through treaties with small kingdoms, and Marthanda Varma, the young ruler of Travancore, was swallowing those kingdoms one by one. In 1741 the Company landed a force from Ceylon at the port of Colachel, near the southern tip of India, and fortified it. Travancore’s army besieged the position through the monsoon, and after a fire in the Dutch powder store the garrison surrendered. Among the prisoners was Eustachius de Lannoy, who took service with the raja, reorganised his army on European lines and commanded it for decades. The Company did not challenge Travancore again, and in 1753 signed a treaty abandoning its local allies.

Seen from elsewhere. In India the battle is often called the first defeat of a European power by an Asian state, which overlooks earlier cases and the small numbers involved. Dutch records treat it as a local reverse in a trade already in decline. The date given varies between sources; 10 August is the one commemorated.

1792

The Tuileries palace is stormed

Paris, FranceEurope

Since June 1791, when Louis XVI had tried to flee the country, many Parisians had doubted his loyalty to the constitution. War with Austria and Prussia went badly, and at the start of August 1792 the city learned of the Duke of Brunswick’s manifesto threatening Paris with destruction if the royal family were harmed. On the morning of 10 August the city’s radical districts and volunteer battalions from Marseille and Brittany marched on the Tuileries. The king and his family walked to the Legislative Assembly for protection. Fighting then broke out between the attackers and the Swiss Guards. Some 600 of the Swiss died, many of them killed after the king sent an order to cease fire. The monarchy was suspended that day.

Seen from elsewhere. To revolutionaries this was a second revolution against a king in league with the invader, and they said the Swiss had fired on men who came to fraternise. Royalists remembered a massacre of soldiers who kept their oath; the Lion of Lucerne commemorates them. Several hundred of the attackers also died.

1920

The Ottoman Empire is partitioned on paper at Sevres

Sevres, FranceMiddle East

The peace imposed on the Ottoman Empire after the First World War was signed in the showroom of a porcelain factory outside Paris by delegates of Sultan Mehmed VI. It left the sultan Istanbul and part of Anatolia. Eastern Thrace and the region of Smyrna went to Greece, an independent Armenia was recognised in the east, the Kurds were promised autonomy with a possible path to statehood, and the Arab provinces passed to British and French mandates. The Straits were placed under an international commission and Ottoman finances under Allied control. The nationalist assembly in Ankara, led by Mustafa Kemal, had already rejected the terms and declared the signatories traitors. The treaty was never ratified.

Seen from elsewhere. Turkish forces overturned the settlement by arms, and the Treaty of Lausanne replaced it in 1923. For Armenians and Kurds, Sevres is the promise that was withdrawn; Lausanne mentions neither. In Turkey the word still stands for a fear of partition by foreign powers, sometimes called the Sevres syndrome.

Also on 10 August