Parallax

28 August, 1749

Goethe is born at noon in Frankfurt

By his own account he arrived apparently lifeless and had to be revived. He went on to write the most famous German novel of his century and the most famous German play of any, to help govern a small state for fifty years, and to quarrel with Isaac Newton about light.

Frankfurt am Main, Holy Roman Empire

Johann Wolfgang Goethe was born on 28 August 1749 in his family’s house on the Grosser Hirschgraben in Frankfurt, as the clocks struck twelve. That, at least, is how he opens his autobiography, written sixty years later, with a mock-solemn horoscope: the sun in Virgo, Jupiter and Venus friendly, the moon obstructive. Through the midwife’s clumsiness, he says, he came into the world as if dead, and only after much effort was he brought to see the light. His grandfather, the city’s chief magistrate, was moved by the scare to arrange proper training for Frankfurt’s midwives.

His father, Johann Caspar, was a wealthy lawyer with a bought imperial title and no occupation, who poured his energy into educating his children. His mother, Catharina Elisabeth, was eighteen when her first child was born and told stories. Of the children who followed only a sister, Cornelia, lived to grow up. The boy learned Latin, Greek, French, Italian and English, staged plays with a puppet theatre, and at six, he later claimed, had his faith in a kindly providence shaken by news of the Lisbon earthquake.

He was sent to study law at Leipzig and then Strasbourg, where he met the critic Herder and discovered Shakespeare, folk song and Gothic architecture. At twenty-five he published The Sorrows of Young Werther, a short novel in letters about a young man who shoots himself over a woman engaged to someone else. It made him famous across Europe within a year. Young men dressed in Werther’s blue coat and yellow waistcoat; clergy denounced the book and several cities banned it.

In 1775 the eighteen-year-old Duke Karl August invited him to Weimar, a town of about six thousand people. Goethe stayed for the rest of his life. He sat on the privy council, oversaw mines, roads and the tiny army, directed the court theatre, and was ennobled as von Goethe. A two-year escape to Italy in 1786 remade him as a classicist. He studied bones, plants, rocks and clouds, and spent two decades on a theory of colour that he valued above all his poetry.

He worked on Faust for some sixty years. The first part appeared in 1808; he sealed the manuscript of the second in 1831 and left instructions that it be published after his death. He died in his armchair in Weimar on 22 March 1832, aged eighty-two.

How it came to this

Germany in 1749 was not a country but several hundred territories under the loose roof of the Holy Roman Empire. Frankfurt was one of its free cities, a Lutheran merchant republic where emperors were crowned, and Goethe as a boy watched the coronation of Joseph II. There was no capital, no national theatre and, in the eyes of educated Europeans, not much of a literature. German courts spoke French; Frederick the Great of Prussia wrote in it and thought his own language barbarous.

The generation born around mid-century changed that in about thirty years. Lessing, Herder, Goethe and Schiller, with Kant in philosophy, made German a language in which the continent’s most ambitious writing was being done. The movement began in rebellion, the Sturm und Drang of the 1770s, with its cult of feeling and genius, and settled into what was later called Weimar Classicism. It happened in small princely towns, under patronage, at the moment the French Revolution and then Napoleon were breaking the old Empire apart. Goethe lived through all of it and distrusted most of it.

How each side saw it

Christiane Vulpius and the Weimar court

In 1788 Goethe took into his house Christiane Vulpius, a twenty-three-year-old who made artificial flowers in a workshop. They lived together for eighteen years before he married her in 1806, days after she had faced down French soldiers looting the house. Five children were born; one survived. Court society, including his old friend Charlotte von Stein, refused to receive her and wrote of her with contempt as fat, vulgar and fond of drink. Her own letters to him survive, cheerful and practical and unconcerned with literature. Sigrid Damm’s biography of 1998 was the first to treat her as more than an embarrassment.

German patriots and radicals

To many younger Germans the old man in Weimar was a disappointment. He admired Napoleon, who received him at Erfurt in 1808, wore the Legion of Honour, and refused to write war songs against the French in 1813, telling Eckermann later that he could not hate a nation to which he owed so much of his culture. The radical journalist Ludwig Borne called him a servant of princes who had never once spoken for the oppressed; the critic Wolfgang Menzel attacked him as immoral and unpatriotic. The nationalist cult of Goethe came after his death and required forgetting this.

Johanna Hohn and the critics of the minister

In 1783 a servant named Johanna Catharina Hohn was beheaded in Weimar for killing her newborn child. The duke had asked his privy council whether the death penalty for infanticide should be kept. Goethe, who had already drafted the scenes in which Faust’s abandoned Gretchen is condemned for the same act, gave his written opinion that it would be more advisable to retain it. The American scholar W. Daniel Wilson made this, and Goethe’s part in press-ganging and surveillance, the centre of a critical reassessment in the 1990s. Defenders answer that his vote was one of three and that the duke decided.

The physicists

Goethe believed Newton had gone wrong by forcing light through a slit in a dark room, and that colour arises where light and darkness meet. His Theory of Colours of 1810 attacks Newton at length. Physicists rejected it then and since; Hermann von Helmholtz, in a lecture of 1853, said that the poet had mistaken a study of perception for a refutation of optics. As a description of how colours are seen, of after-images, coloured shadows and contrast, the book has kept admirers, among them the painter Turner, and later Wittgenstein, who thought it was not a theory at all.

What is disputed

The birth scene is Goethe’s own, in a memoir titled Poetry and Truth, and he chose the title carefully. His reported last words, ‘More light’, come from accounts by people not in the room; another version has him asking for a shutter to be opened, and another has him speaking to his daughter-in-law. His claim to have discovered the intermaxillary bone in humans in 1784 overlaps with work by the French anatomist Vicq d’Azyr. The label ‘universal genius’ is contested: he directed a theatre and wrote on science, but his standing as a scientist remains a matter of argument.

What followed

Goethe’s name was claimed by every later Germany. The republic founded in 1919 drew up its constitution in Weimar partly to borrow his prestige. The Nazi state celebrated him selectively, and in 1937 built Buchenwald concentration camp on the Ettersberg, the hill above Weimar where he used to walk, leaving one oak standing inside the fence that prisoners called Goethe’s oak. Both post-war German states marked his bicentenary in 1949. His phrase ‘world literature’, coined in 1827, and his late poems in dialogue with the Persian poet Hafez are now read as an early argument against literary nationalism.

Read further

  • Nicholas Boyle, Goethe: The Poet and the Age, 2 vols (1991, 2000)
  • Rudiger Safranski, Goethe: Life as a Work of Art (2017)
  • Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Poetry and Truth (Dichtung und Wahrheit)
  • Johann Peter Eckermann, Conversations with Goethe (1836)
  • W. Daniel Wilson, Das Goethe-Tabu (1999)

Same day, other years

AD 430

Augustine dies in a besieged city

Hippo Regius (Annaba, Algeria)Africa

Augustine had been bishop of the North African port of Hippo for thirty-five years when an army of Vandals under Gaiseric, crossing from Spain, reached its walls in the spring of 430. He was seventy-five. Refugees filled the town, among them his future biographer Possidius, who records that in the third month of the siege the old man took a fever, had the penitential psalms copied out and hung on the wall where he could read them from bed, and asked to be left alone to pray. He died on 28 August. The city fell the following year. His library, with the Confessions and The City of God, was saved.

Seen from elsewhere. The Vandals were Christians too, of the Arian confession Augustine counted heretical. So, in their own eyes, were the Donatists, the rigorist African church he had spent decades fighting and whose suppression by imperial force he came to justify with the Gospel phrase ‘compel them to come in’. Later persecutors quoted him.

1833

Britain’s Slavery Abolition Act becomes law

London, and the British CaribbeanThe Americas

The Act that received royal assent on 28 August 1833 declared that from 1 August 1834 slavery would cease in most British colonies, affecting some 800,000 people in the Caribbean, Mauritius and the Cape. It did not free them outright. Those over six became ‘apprentices’ bound to work unpaid for their former owners for most of the week, for up to six years; the scheme was abandoned in 1838 after protest. Parliament voted twenty million pounds, roughly forty per cent of a year’s government spending, as compensation. All of it went to the owners. Territories of the East India Company were excluded.

Seen from elsewhere. British tradition credits Wilberforce and the humanitarian campaign. Caribbean historians, following Eric Williams, stress declining sugar profits and above all the enslaved themselves: the Jamaican rising of 1831-32 led by Samuel Sharpe convinced London that slavery could not be held. The compensation loan was finally paid off in 2015; Caribbean governments now seek reparations.

1879

The Zulu king Cetshwayo is captured

Ngome forest, Zululand (South Africa)Africa

The British invasion of the Zulu kingdom had begun in January with an ultimatum that the high commissioner, Sir Bartle Frere, issued without London’s approval and knew could not be met. After the Zulu victory at Isandlwana and the British one at Ulundi in July, King Cetshwayo kaMpande was a fugitive. A patrol of dragoons found him on 28 August in a homestead in the Ngome forest. He was shipped to Cape Town and held in the castle. Sir Garnet Wolseley divided Zululand among thirteen appointed chiefs, an arrangement that produced civil war. Cetshwayo was allowed back to a reduced kingdom in 1883 and died the next year.

Seen from elsewhere. Cetshwayo dictated his own account in captivity: he had not wanted war and had forbidden his men to cross into Natal. Bishop John Colenso and his daughters argued his case, and in London in 1882 he met Queen Victoria. Natal officials had portrayed him as a bloodthirsty despot; most historians now see a manufactured war.

1963

A quarter of a million people march on Washington

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

The March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom was the idea of the veteran labour leader A. Philip Randolph and was organised in eight weeks by Bayard Rustin. About 250,000 people, perhaps a fifth of them white, walked from the Washington Monument to the Lincoln Memorial to demand a civil rights law, desegregated schools, a public works programme and a higher minimum wage. Martin Luther King spoke last. Partway through his prepared text he set it aside and began the passage about a dream that he had used in earlier speeches; several who were there recall the singer Mahalia Jackson calling out to him to tell them about the dream.

Seen from elsewhere. Malcolm X called it the Farce on Washington, a protest tamed by its white sponsors. No woman was given a full speech, to the anger of organisers such as Anna Arnold Hedgeman, and John Lewis was made to soften his. Two days later an FBI memorandum named King the most dangerous Negro in the country.

Also on 28 August